LCCC NEWS
BULLETIN
JULY 24/2006
News from the Daily Star
for 24/07/06
Israeli bombardment leaves telecom infrastructure in tatters
Syria offers to play peacemaker as top diplomats meet
in Israel
Olmert tells Cabinet he expects campaign to 'take a very long time'
Southern villagers run gauntlet in search of refuge
Hizbullah gives government negotiation power
Salloukh says captured Israeli soldiers are 'in good health'
Pope urges immediate cease-fire, delivery of aid
World media returns to Beirut - for the usual reason
Sidon overflows with desperate evacuees
50 years after Nasser's gambit, Suez Canal means more to Egypt than ever
'There are children dying' - UN humanitarian boss
Cyprus braces for 10,000 new arrivals as evacuation approaches completion
Beirut bands hold benefit for internally displaced
With supplies already low, evacuees settled outside Jbeil hope to wait it out
Car bombs kill 60 in Iraq ahead of PM's visits to America, Britain
Exhibition looks back on Beirut's violent past, now made cruelly present
News from miscellaneous
sources for 24/07/06
Hezbollah rocket attacks not
subsiding-AP
Israel Ready to Accept a NATO-Led International Force as
Killing Rages On
US: We won't hold direct talks with Syria-Ynetnews
Peretz: Israel supports deployment of multi-national force-Ha'aretz
Saad Hariri: "We Will Rebuild Every Bridge"TIME - USA
Israel's Olmert says Lebanon crisis will last a long time-Life Style Extra
IDF: Syria Continues to Arm Hezbollah; Worries About Wider -Arutz Sheva
UN observer seriously wounded by Hizbullah gunfire in Lebanon-Jerusalem Post
2 key Americans see 1982 in Lebanon '06-Seattle Post Intelligencer
US pushes Syria for peace-The Australian
Israel
says would accept NATO-led force-Ap
Syria says will urge Mideast
cease-fire-AP
Captured Israeli soldiers safe: Lebanon’s foreign minister-Khaleej
Times
Israeli military seizes Lebanese town-CNN
International
Israel expands ground operation-NDTV.com
Next, war on Syria?Aljazeera.com -
London,UK
US trying to sabotage alliance between Syria, Iran?Ynetnews
Israeli warplanes kill 3 fleeing Lebanese-AP
Israel and Lebanon under fire-Reuters.uk
Peretz OKs NATO Force in South Lebanon-Arutz
Sheva
BOMBS CRASH THE PARTY: Tourists' exodus deprives Lebanon-Detroit
Free Press
Thousands flee southern Lebanon as Israeli forces mass at border-Canada.com
UK and Israel in talks on Lebanon-BBC
News - UK
ANALYSIS-Reluctant Bush may need Syria to end Lebanon war-Reuters
NY Times: US Sees Syria as Key in Hizbullah War-Arutz
Sheva
Diplomatic flurry in Israel over Lebanon war-Washington
Post
Israeli Soldiers Push Deeper Into Lebanon, Seize Village-Los
Angeles Times
With the Spotlight on Lebanon, Gaza Feels Left in Dark-Los
Angeles Times
Proportionality in the war in Lebanon-Ha'aretz
Fear, chaos precede US evacuations in Lebanon-Houston
Chronicle
Lebanon: We'll sue Israel for damages-Ynetnews
- Israel
Israel builds detention center for Lebanon captives-People's Daily Online
Israeli tanks cross border as Lebanon awaits invasion-Telegraph.co.uk
Latest
News From miscellaneous sources 24/07/06
Israel strikes Lebanon religious building-Houston Chronicle
Israel Will Accept a Disarmed Hezbollah-Washington Post
Israel waits as Lebanon burns-Sunday Business Post
Israeli Troops Battling Hezbollah Gunmen in Lebanese Village-Bloomberg
Analysis / A road map for Lebanon studded with mines-Ha'aretz
Hezbollah rockets land in open areas in northern Israeli city-People's Daily
Online
Bush slams Syria, Iran over Hezbollah-CNN
Jordanian king again calls for immediate ceasefire in Lebanon-People's Daily
Online
MI5 fears Hezbollah terror attacks in Britain-Daily Mail
French FM condemns both Israel and Hezbollah-People's Daily Online
Israeli military base attacked by Hezbollah guerillas-People's Daily Online
Hezbollah base seized: Israel-Sydney Morning Herald
Whom Hezbollah, Israel battling for indeed?-People's Daily Online
Israel seizes a village from Hezbollah-AP
For Hezbollah, survival may mean victory-AP
Plots underway to deploy NATO troops in south Lebanon:
analyst-MehrNews.com - Tehran,Iran
U.N. warns of 'disaster' as Lebanese flee-AP
Israel hastily musters its citizen-AP
Israeli bombardment leaves
telecom infrastructure in tatters
By Osama Habib -Daily Star staff
Monday, July 24, 2006
BEIRUT: Lebanon's mobile networks and satellite antennas are being targeted by
Israeli warplanes, causing at least $10 to $15 million in material damage and a
drop in the revenues of the telecom sector, Telecommunications Minister Marwan
Hamade said on Sunday. "We are still assessing the damages but we estimate the
material losses are close to $15 million so far," Hamade told The Daily Star
over the telephone.
Israeli warplanes have hit transmitters, relay stations and satellite stations
in Beirut, the South, the North and the Bekaa Valley since the war started 12
days ago. Israeli warplanes bombarded a satellite and antenna station in
Kesrouan on Saturday, killing an employee of the Lebanese Broadcasting
Corporation and destroying the television antenna. The strikes targeted
transmission towers for a number of private television stations, including LBCI
and Future, as well as a number of private radios in Fatqa and further up on
mount Sannine, police said.
In Fatqa, television footage showed a cloud of thick black smoke billowing into
the sky from the towers which were engulfed in flames. A truck was also seen
burning. Transmission towers for television stations, including Hizbullah's Al-Manar
and the privately run New TV, as well as mobile telephone networks were also
destroyed in Terbol in Nor-thern Lebanon, police added.
Observers say that the Israeli forces want to cut all communication links
between Lebanon and the outside world and to sever mobile communication lines
among the Lebanese.
Hamade said teams from the ministry are repairing some of the damage in
different areas. But the minister declined to give more details about the
repairs in some areas, fearing that the Israeli forces may target these stations
and satellites. "I don't want to identify the areas in which technical teams are
working because the Israelis might bombard them," he said. Some Lebanese said
the mobile lines in some parts of the North and South of the country were
inoperative due to the intense bombardment. Hamade said that the
Telecommunication Ministry has instructed the two mobile operators in Lebanon,
MTC Touch and Alfa, to extend the duration of the pre-paid cards to ease the
pressure on residents.
"This will of course affect the revenues from telecoms, which is the main source
of income for the government."Total revenues from the telecom sector are more
than $1.3 billion a year, including the mobile and land-line networks. But the
minister said all the land-line services are still intact.
The government was hoping to privatize the telecom sector this year as part of
efforts to reduce the $40 billion public debt.
Hundreds of Iranian Troops Fighting in Lebanon
BY IRA STOLL - Staff Reporter of the Sun
July 19, 2006
URL: http://www.nysun.com/article/36326
Hundreds of Iranian Revolutionary Guard personnel are on the ground in Lebanon
fighting Israel, security sources say.
"I have no doubt whatsoever that they are there and operating some of the
equipment," an Arab diplomatic source told The New York Sun yesterday.
Another foreign source, based in Washington, said the Islamic Revolutionary
Guard Corps contingent in Lebanon is based in Beirut and in the Bekaa Valley. He
said the troops usually number a few dozen, but that the size of the force
increased in connection with the hostilities that have broken out between Israel
and Iran's proxy, Hezbollah, over the past week.
The sources said the Iranians had directly operated a radar-guided C–802 missile
that Iran acquired from Communist China and that hit an Israeli navy missile
boat off the coast of Lebanon on Friday, killing four Israeli seamen.
"This was a direct message to the Israelis that we are fighting the Iranians
here," the Arab diplomatic source said.
The Iranian Revolutionary Guard's mission in Lebanon includes keeping custody of
Zalzal missiles and drones, or unmanned aerial vehicles. A report by an
Israel-based research group, the Intelligence & Terrorism Information Center,
identifies the units of Iran's Revolutionary Guard "deployed and active in
Lebanon" as the "Al-Quds Force." The Lebanon-based Iranian force "provides
military guidance and support for terrorist attacks against Israel," the report
says.
President Bush has openly blamed Iran, along with Syria, for sponsoring
Hezbollah, but he has stopped short of identifying the presence of Iranian
troops in Lebanon. Tomorrow, a senior National Security aide to Mr. Bush,
Elliott Abrams, and the undersecretary of state, Nicholas Burns, will chair a
meeting at the White House for at least 10 Iranian opposition organizations. The
White House has hinted to those invited that President Bush may stop by.
The Iranian government has cheered Hezbollah's actions while at the same time
publicly denying the presence of Revolutionary Guards in Iran.
Clearing the Iranian Revolutionary Guard from Lebanon has emerged as an
unstated, but significant, Israeli war aim. Israelis also are hoping for tougher
American and international sanctions on Iran and Syria as punishment for the
Iranian and Syrian roles in Hezbollah's kidnapping of Israeli soldiers and
raining of missiles on Israeli cities.
The Arab diplomatic source described the leader of Hezbollah, Hassan Nasrallah,
as "totally subservient" to Iran. "How more forceful can I put it?" he said.
In New York on Monday, Senator McCain, a Republican of Arizona who sits on the
Armed Services Committee, said the Iranians had supplied Hezbollah with arms,
equipment, training, and 10,000 rockets. He said he did not see how Hezbollah
would have captured Israeli soldiers without "the tacit agreement and maybe
support of the Iranians." And Mr. McCain said Iranians have "very heavily
penetrated" southern Iraq, "including sending in terrorists" and equipment for
the bombs known as improvised explosive devices.
The Hezbollah offensive against Israel followed a summit in Damascus. Reports
vary on whether the meeting was attended by Sheik Nasrallah himself or by one of
his top political aides, Sheik Hussein Khalil. Others said to be present include
the head of Syrian military intelligence, Assef Shawkat, and the Iranian
national security adviser, Ali Larijani, who is one of the many high-ranking
Iranian officials who have been shuttling between Damascus and Tehran.
The president of the Reform Party of Syria, Farid Ghadry, who opposes the regime
in Damascus, said there are indications that Hezbollah and the Iranians and
Syrians recently attacked a Lebanese army base, signaling they are expanding
their campaign beyond Israeli targets.
Israel seizes a village from Hezbollah
By BENJAMIN HARVEY, Associated Press Writer
ON THE ISRAEL-LEBANON BORDER - Israeli tanks, bulldozers and armored personnel
carriers knocked down a fence and barreled over the Lebanese border Saturday as
forces seized a village from the Hezbollah guerrilla group.
The soldiers battled militants throughout the day and raided the large village
of Maroun al-Ras in several waves before finally taking control, military
officials said. Tens of thousands of Lebanese fleeing north packed into the port
of Sidon to escape the fighting as the United Nations warned of a growing
humanitarian "disaster."
Early Sunday, warplanes for the first time hit inside the port city of Sidon,
currently swollen with refugees, destroying a religious complex that the Israeli
military said was used by Hezbollah. Hospital officials said four people were
wounded.
A series of large explosions reverberated through Beirut in the early hours
Sunday as Israeli aircraft again pounded Hezbollah's stronghold in the south.
Warplanes also hit targets in eastern Bekaa Valley, firing missiles in the
cities of Hermel and Baalbek, witnesses said. There was no immediate word on
casualties in either strike.
The growing use of ground forces, 11 days into the fighting, signaled Israeli
recognition that airstrikes alone were not enough to force Hezbollah out of
southern Lebanon. But a ground offensive carries greater risks to Israel, which
already has lost 18 soldiers in the recent fighting. It also threatens to
exacerbate already trying conditions for Lebanese civilians in the area.
Israeli military officials have said they want to push Hezbollah beyond the
Litani River, about 20 miles north of the border, with the Lebanese army
deploying in the border zone. An Israeli radio station that broadcasts to
southern Lebanon warned residents of 13 villages to flee north by Saturday
afternoon. The villages form a corridor about 4 miles wide and 11 miles deep.
With Lebanese fearing an escalation in the battle, international officials
worked to end the conflict.
Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice was set to arrive in the Middle East on
Sunday, though she ruled out a quick cease-fire as a "false promise."
President Bush said his administration's diplomatic efforts would focus on
finding a strategy for confronting Hezbollah and its Syrian and Iranian backers.
"Secretary Rice will make it clear that resolving the crisis demands confronting
the terrorist group that launched the attacks and the nations that support it,"
Bush said in his weekly radio address.
Italy, which has been trying to mediate an end to the fighting, said it would
hold a conference Wednesday to work out the basis for a truce agreement. U.N.
Secretary-General Kofi Annan has proposed a beefed-up U.N. force along the
Lebanese border, but Israel has called for the Lebanese army to take control of
the area.
Annan said the conflict had displaced at least 700,000 Lebanese so far, and
Israel's destruction of bridges and roads has made access to them difficult.
"I'm afraid of a major humanitarian disaster," he told CNN.
U.N. humanitarian chief Jan Egeland said it would take more than $100 million to
help the displaced. He said he would make an appeal "urging, begging" the
international community for contributions.
As part of an effort to avert such a crisis, Israel eased its blockade of
Lebanon's ports to allow the first shiploads of aid to arrive. It remained
unclear how that aid would get to the isolated towns and villages where the
fighting has been centered.
Israel has attacked mostly with airstrikes, but small units have crossed the
border in recent days and fought with Hezbollah fighters.
A far larger force of about 2,000 troops entered the area Saturday trying to
root out Hezbollah bunkers and destroy hidden rocket launchers.
The troops, backed by tanks and armored vehicles, raced past a U.N. outpost and
headed into Maroun al-Ras. Gunfire could be heard coming from the village, and
artillery batteries in Israel also fired into the area.
"The forces have completed, more or less, their control of the area of the
village, Maroun al-Ras, and made lots of hits against terrorists," said Maj.
Gen. Benny Gantz, chief of Israel's ground forces. "It was a difficult fight
that continued for not a short time."
Dozens of Hezbollah fighters were injured or killed in the battle, Gantz said.
Hezbollah said two of its fighters were killed Saturday, bringing the total
number of acknowledged Hezbollah fighters killed to eight. Israel accuses the
group of vastly underreporting its casualties.
The village was strategically important because it overlooked an area where
Hezbollah had command posts, Gantz said. The forces seized a cache of weapons
and rockets in a village mosque, he added. The village is believed to be a
launching point for the rocket attacks on northern Israel.
At one point, a half-ton bomb was dropped on a Hezbollah outpost, about 500
yards from the border and near the village. Other positions were bombarded by
Israeli gunboats off the coast.
About 32 residents took refuge at the U.N. observers post. Nearly the entire
remaining population of the village — which numbered about 2,300 before the
crisis broke out — were believed to have fled, Lebanese security officials said.
Some of the invading forces returned to Israel during the day. U.N. peacekeepers
and witnesses said Israel also briefly held the nearby village of Marwaheen
before pulling back.
About 35,000 fleeing Lebanese filled Sidon as they searched for a place to stay
or a way to get farther north.
"I'm afraid a disaster is going to happen with all these refugees. There's no
aid, not from other nations, not from Lebanon," Mayor Abdul-Rahman al-Bizri
said.
More than 200,000 Lebanese fled to Syria, according to the Syrian Red Crescent.
A steady stream of foreign nationals boarded ships and planes Saturday to take
them away. U.S. officials said more than 7,500 Americans had been evacuated from
Lebanon by Saturday night.
"Everybody's crying and kissing and wishing you well, and you have to turn and
leave. We have the chance to get out, but they don't," said Susan Abu Hamdan,
44, of Northville, Mich., who was visiting her siblings in Beirut.
The Israeli army said it wanted to completely destroy all Hezbollah
infrastructure in an area between a half-mile and two miles from the border, but
it had no intention of going deeper into Lebanon.
"We really want to knock out Hezbollah in this area," said Capt. Jacob Dallal,
an army spokesman. "We want to wipe them out, and we don't intend for them to
ever be there again."
A senior Israeli military official confirmed that Israel did not plan to
reoccupy southern Lebanon as it did in 1982-2000 to create a buffer zone to
protect northern Israel.
Israel's current offensive began July 12 when Hezbollah guerrillas captured two
Israeli soldiers and killed three others in a cross-border raid.
Israeli airstrikes on Saturday blasted communications and television
transmission towers in the central and northern Lebanese mountains, knocking the
Lebanese Broadcasting Corp. off the air and killing one person at the station.
The death toll in Lebanon rose to at least 372, Lebanese authorities said.
Over the past 11 days, Hezbollah has launched nearly 1,000 rockets into Israel,
killing 15 civilians and sending hundreds of thousands of others fleeing into
bunkers. At least 132 rockets landed in Israel on Saturday, wounding 20 people,
three seriously, rescue officials said.
A total of 19 Israeli troops have been killed in the fighting so far.
Hezbollah also fired at the army base of Nurit in Israel, wounding one soldier,
the army said.
Israel's call for Lebanese to leave much of the area south of the Litani River
caused many to fear that a far deeper Israeli ground incursion was being
planned, an offensive that would almost certainly lead to far higher casualties.
More than 400,000 people live south of the Litani. Though tens of thousands have
left, many are believed still there, trapped by the damaged roads or by fear of
being caught in an airstrike.
Survival may equal victory for Hezbollah
By HAMZA HENDAWI, Associated Press Writer
BEIRUT, Lebanon - Hezbollah leader Sheik Hassan Nasrallah acknowledges that
Israeli troops can sweep across south Lebanon. But if he and his militants can
survive and keep fighting, he will cement his image as the unlikely new hero of
Arab nationalism.
Israeli troops backed by tanks fought their way into southern Lebanon Saturday
at the start of a ground assault to drive the Islamic guerrilla group away from
the border and put Israeli cities beyond the reach of its rockets.
"I don't want to raise expectations. I never said that the Israelis cannot reach
any place in southern Lebanon," says Nasrallah, a black-turbaned Shiite cleric
whom Israel has tried repeatedly to kill.
"Our dogma and strategy is when the Israelis come, they must pay a high price.
This is what we promise and this is what we will achieve, God willing."
The fighting was sparked by Hezbollah's July 12 capture of two Israeli soldiers
and the killing of eight others in a cross-border raid. A massive Israeli
offensive followed and Hezbollah responded by firing hundreds of rockets at
Israel.
More than 370 people have been killed in Lebanon over the past 11 days,
authorities said. In Israel, 34 have died.
Anticipating the ground assault, Nasrallah sought to ensure his group's survival
and safeguard its widening base of support in Lebanon and abroad by lowering the
bar for what would constitute victory.
In a television interview broadcast Friday, he defined victory as a successful
defense.
And he acknowledges the gravity of defeat.
"A defeat in Lebanon will end the region's resistance movements, the Palestinian
cause and impose Israel's conditions for a settlement," he warned.
His previous warnings were even more dire.
"If Israel is able to defeat the resistance in Palestine and Lebanon, God
forbid, then the Arab world, governments and peoples will drown in eternal
humiliation from which they will have no way out."
Hezbollah's chances of victory lie as much in its guerrilla capability as in
Nasrallah's leadership. He has led the group since 1992, taking over after his
predecessor was killed in an Israeli helicopter attack.
A fiery orator who deftly mixes threats with lighthearted comments, Nasrallah
lost his 18-year-old son, Hadi, during a fight with Israeli troops in 1997. He
refused to receive mourners, praised God's "ultimate grace and kindness" for
choosing a family member as a martyr and allowed another son, Jawad, to join the
guerrillas.
"We love martyrdom," he said on Friday. "But we take precautions to deny the
enemy an easy victory."
On paper, Hezbollah's chances of surviving a military setback and regrouping to
fight again are good. Most of its estimated 5,000-6,000 fighters are hardened by
years of combat against Israel during its 18-year control of a border strip in
southern Lebanon.
The Iranian- and Syrian-backed organization, listed as a terrorist group by the
United States, has a typical guerrilla arsenal that includes assault rifles,
mines, light artillery, mortars and — most importantly — missiles with ranges of
up to 45 miles.
It enjoys popular support in southern and eastern Lebanon.
Victory or defeat, Nasrallah already has a place in the hearts of millions of
Arabs angered and ashamed by their governments' perceived acquiescence to
Israeli and U.S. policies.
A defeat on the battlefield is unlikely to change that so long as Hezbollah is
seen to have put up a good fight. In fact, it could give the 46-year-old,
mid-ranking cleric hero status.
Nasrallah's rise to Arab stardom, said Ibrahim Bayram of Beirut's respected An-Nahar
daily, was owed in part to his tireless attempts to rise above the Shiite-Sunni
divide by forging close ties with Sunni Muslims — who are the overwhelming
majority of the world's Arabs.
"He has ambitions to become a leader of the Muslim world," said Bayram.
Charismatic, sharp and media savvy, Nasrallah seems aware of respect and
admiration he and his organization enjoy. He speaks with a confidence that
sometimes borders on arrogance.
He also taunts his critics in the Arab world, led by key U.S. allies Saudi
Arabia, Egypt and Jordan.
"I say to Arab leaders: I don't want your swords and I don't want your hearts
... Leave us alone."
Such undiplomatic talk resonates with many Arabs. His fiery rhetoric harkens
back to Gamal Abdel-Nasser, Egypt's late president who led his nation to
disastrous military defeat by Israel in 1967. But Nasser's political resilience
and charisma made him a respected Arab nationalist leader until his death in
1970.
"Nasrallah is doing what Arab governments are unwilling or incapable of doing —
fighting Israel. He is embarrassing them," said Vali Nasr, an expert on Shiites
who lectures on national security affairs at the U.S. Naval Postgraduate School
in Monterrey, Calif.
"Many people in the Middle East reward courage, not wisdom," said Nasr.
Israel strikes Lebanon religious building 2 hours, 22
minutes ago
BEIRUT, Lebanon - Israeli warplanes struck Sidon early Sunday, targeting a
religious building run by a Shiite Muslim cleric close to Hezbollah in their
first hit inside the southern port city, currently swollen with refugees from
fighting further south.
Also early Sunday, a huge explosion reverberated across Beirut, apparently
caused by an Israeli air raid on the capital's southern suburbs.
At least four people were wounded in the airstrike that targeted Sidon for the
first time since Israel launched its massive military offensive against Lebanon
and Hezbollah guerrillas July 12, hospital officials said.
Strikes early in Israel's campaign hit bridges outside the city of 100,000,
where 35,000 refugees are also now residing.
Witnesses said the Israeli jets fired two missiles that directly hit the
four-story Sayyed al-Zahraa compound in Sidon. The compound, which contains a
mosque, a religious library and a seminary, was entirely destroyed but was
believed to be empty at the time of the strike, they said.
A man and his wife in a nearby house were lightly wounded from broken glass,
while two other people strolling near the compound were also hit by shrapnel,
hospital officials said.
The compound is run by Sheik Afif Naboulsi, a Shiite Muslim cleric close to Iran
and the militant Hezbollah group.
Minutes earlier, two other blasts also shook Beirut also caused by an Israeli
airstrike on the southern suburbs where Hezbollah headquarters, including the
residence of Hezbollah leader Sheik Hassan Nasrallah have been flattened by
repeated Israeli bombing.
Israeli warplanes also hit targets in eastern Lebanon's Bekaa Valley firing
missiles in the cities of Hermel and Baalbek at around 11 p.m. Saturday,
witnesses said. There was no immediate word on casualties in either strike.
From : Joseph Gebeily <jgebeily@licus.org>
Sent : July 22, 2006 11:56:07 PM
To : "Joseph Gebeily" <jgebeily@licus.org>
Subject : The Hezbollah myth
Friends,
Allow me to share with you some of what I said about Hezbollah yesterday on
Voice Of America-On The Line with Host Eric Felten . Below it, you will find the
full transcript of the show.
Host: Joseph Gebeily, these Hezbollah rockets and missiles are not held in
depots or military installations but are rather held in Southern Lebanon and in
homes and in civilian areas. How does rooting out Hezbollah -- whether it's
Israel or the international community coming up with some kind of U-N force -–
how does this happen without causing so much death and destruction in Lebanon
that seems to part of what Hezbollah wants to have happened?
Gebeily: First, I want to challenge the idea of the “resistance movement” that
Hezbollah has gotten over the years. Hezbollah is a militia that formed in the
late seventies-early eighties, and it was formed after the Iranian revolutionary
guard moved into Lebanon through Syria. It had nothing to do originally with the
Israeli invasion of Lebanon. The Hezbollah agenda is to transform Lebanon into a
radical Shiite regime modeled after the Iranian theocracy. And over the years,
although the Israeli invasion of Lebanon had extended to Beirut, Hezbollah never
attacked the Israelis. They never resisted or hurt the invaders in any way,
shape or form. Then,at the end of the Lebanese civil war in 1989, there was an
agreement for all militias to disarm including Hezbollah. And the only reason
they kept their weapons is because the Syrians wanted that. So then they came up
with this excuse that they are fighting the Israelis and they remembered that
the Israelis were still in a small security zone in Southern Lebanon, and they
needed to chase them out. Later and after the Israeli withdrawal in 2000, they
remembered the Shebaa farm which was never mentioned before.And now they are
talking about the lebanese prisoners in Israel. They were always finding an
excuse, a "raison d'etre" if you want to call it, to present it to the Lebanese
to keep their militia and their areas of control. And at some point Hassan
Nasrallah, in his last statement said: “we are fighting the war of the ummah,
and we're fighting the war of the whole Muslim world.” So here is another Bin
Laden. The idea of Hezbollah being a Lebanese resistance movement is totally
wrong.
Now, back to the rockets; it is very hard to be able to get rid of the Hezbollah
armament without a ground troop operation. Let's face it, bombings and air
strikes etc, could hit here and there. But Hezbollah doesn't care, they don't
care about loss of civilian life. They are going to hide, all their rockets,
ammunitions, etc. among the Lebanese population. It's the Lebanese who are
suffering, the Lebanese who are being killed, the Lebanese civilians. Hezbollah
has lost only eight members so far and that's nothing. And the Lebanese losses
are in the hundreds but Hezbollah don't care. They are still so outrageous in
saying: we are going to continue the war and we are not going to stop -- the
Hezbollah leaders.
Full Transcript:
On The Line: Iran And Syria's Proxy War
http://www.voanews.com/uspolicy/ontheline/
21 July 2006
Iran And Syria's Proxy War (MP3) audio clip
Iran And Syria's Proxy War (Real Player) - Download audio clip
Listen to Iran And Syria's Proxy War (Real Player) audio clip
Transcript
Host: Israel's assault on the radical Islamic Hezbollah has been viewed by many
as a legitimate act of self-defense. Based in southern Lebanon, Hezbollah has
the declared goal of destroying Israel. The terrorist group has launched missile
attacks on Israeli towns and cities. Hezbollah created the latest crisis when it
sent fighters across the border to attack and kidnap Israeli soldiers. Officials
of Lebanon's democratically elected government have blamed Syria for
orchestrating Hezbollah's attacks. Lebanese communications minister Marwan
Hamada said, "Syrian Vice President Faruq al-Shara gives the commands, Hezbollah
carries them out, and Lebanon is the hostage." President George W. Bush had this
comment:
President Bush: "The root cause of that current instability is terrorism and
terrorist attacks on a democratic country. And part of those terrorist attacks
are inspired by nation states, like Syria and Iran. And in order to be able to
deal with this crisis, the world must deal with Hezbollah, with Syria and to
continue to work to isolate Iran."
Host: Mr. Bush said that "Sometimes it requires tragic situations to help bring
clarity in the international community":
President Bush: "It is now clear for all to see that there are terrorist
elements who want to destroy our democratic friends and allies, and the world
must work to prevent them from doing so."
Host: The Group of Eight industrial nations issued a statement saying, "The
immediate crisis results from efforts by extremist forces to destabilize the
region and to frustrate the aspirations of the Palestinian, Israeli and Lebanese
people for democracy and peace." The G-8 statement continued: "These extremist
elements and those that support them cannot be allowed to plunge the Middle East
into chaos and provoke a wider conflict." Officials of Arab governments have
also criticized Hezbollah. Saudi foreign minister Saud al-Faisal denounced
Hezbollah's "irresponsible acts."
What are Iran and Syria up to in Lebanon? And is U.S. policy in the region
working? I'll ask my guests: Farid Ghadry, President of the Reform Party of
Syria; Dr. Joseph Gebeily, President of the American Lebanese Coalition and Mark
Dubowitz, Chief Operating Officer of The Foundation for the Defense of
Democracies. Welcome and thanks for joining us today.
Farid Ghadry, what role does Syria and Iran have in this current crisis?
Ghadry: It's a very important role. We know for a fact that about three weeks
ago there was a secret meeting inside Damascus, where an envoy from Hezbollah --
we believe [Iran’s Ali] Larijani was there as well as Assef Shawkat, the head of
the [Syrian] military intelligence. In that meeting the plot was hatched to
actually do what Hezbollah has done in Southern Lebanon, which is encroach into
Israeli territories and the killing of Israeli soldiers. Syria has a lot to do
with what is happening. In fact it is leading the effort in bringing about
Hezbollah to do what it is doing. It is funding Hezbollah -- it is helping the
funding of Hezbelloh, and also helping arm Hezbelloh. And Iran as well has a
very important role in all of this. When the [U-S] president says Syria and Iran
are involved in all of this they know exactly what they are talking about. And I
think Syria and Iran are not trying to hide it out. They are trying to show they
are doing what they are doing, in fact, because they've lobbed threats in the
past on Israel and on the Lebanese as well. Especially when Bashar al-Assad
said, I'm going to break Lebanon apart if I'm forced to leave, which is exactly
what he's doing today.
Host: Joseph Gebeily, is Syria trying to break Lebanon apart?
Gebeily: Absolutely. This is not new. It has been going on this way, for many,
many years. Syria never considered Lebanon as being a sovereign and independent
country. There's no diplomatic relations, there's no recognition of Lebanon, and
there are these slogans sometimes from Syrian officials that, "We’re one people,
and it's the imperialistic nations which divided us, so we should go back to
being one.” And over the years, Syrian officials or Syrian governments, have
sent troops into Lebanon, weapons, fighters, stirred trouble, and done
assassinations. Over the years, definitely Syria is after trouble in Lebanon.
Host: Mark Dubowitz, what is Syria trying to accomplish here?
Dubowitz: It's clear that both Lebanon and Gaza for that matter are both Syrian
and Iranian occupied territory today. Both Syria and Iran have a very complex
agenda. It's essential to undermine American power in the area. It is for the
destruction of the State of Israel and it is to destroy the embers of democratic
reform, that were taking place in Lebanon after the Cedar Revolution. And we are
starting to see a rise [of democracy] throughout the Middle East that is a
direct threat to the Syrian and Iranian regimes. And they will do everything
they can to destroy that.
Host: Farid Ghadry --
Ghadry: More than that Eric, I think Mark is very right about this. Iran and
Syria have seen success in the theater in Iraq, whereby they disturbed the
process of democratization in Iraq. And now they are so bold they are saying,
not only did they disturb that process, but we're going to try and destroy any
democracy in the Middle East. And the first one is Israel. Their goal is not
only to stop democracy, but now their goal is so bold they are going to try and
destroy any democracy in the Middle East. They look like the policy of the U-S
is not for the good of the Middle East, and they look like the winners after all
in their battles against U-S interests in the Middle East.
Host: Joseph Gebeily, how powerful are Iran and Syria together at this point in
the region?
Gebeily: We have to realize that the main power today is Iran. The Syrian regime
has been weakened from its exit out of Lebanon and its isolation from the
international community. U-N Security Council resolutions, one after the other,
are asking Syria to leave Lebanon and condemning Syrian support for the
militias. Arab isolation even [affects Syria] because the Syrian government does
not have a lot of friends even among the Arab community and it's relying a lot
on Iran. That's why [there was] the defense agreement recently; that's why
there's financial support from Iran. A lot of people feel these days, and Farid
can correct me if I'm wrong, that it's Iran making the decisions. Syria now is a
minor player in the hands of Iran.
Host: Mark Dubowitz, is Syria a minor player, and to what extent does the
territory that Syria occupies relate to what Iran is able to do in the region?
Dubowitz: That's exactly right: Iran is the major player. It's the major threat.
Iran clearly has, both regional and I would say, worldwide ambitions to spread
radical Khomeini Shiism. There's an opportunity to do that first in Lebanon,
certainly in Iraq, and to use Syria as a proxy. Syria is, in fact, a strange
country, because it's brittle [and] it's weak. It has a very weak military; it
has a very complex political structure where the younger al-Assad today is not
like the old man al-Assad. He doesn't have the power and he certainly doesn't
have the savvy. But he is isolated. He's been isolated by his Arab brethren;
he's been isolated by the international community. And certainly, the
international community has made it very, very clear under Fifteen-Fifty-Nine,
the [U-N] Security Council resolution, Syria must get out of Lebanon. Syria
today is not out of Lebanon. Syrian intelligence agents are all over Lebanon.
The Syrian President is backed by -- the Lebanese is backed by Syria. It's
critical that first and foremost, Syria must be removed from the region. And
secondly, we must understand this is Iranian regional ambitions. And we have to
target those.
Host: Farid Ghadry, a lot of commentators have noted that given the weakness
that Mark Dubowitz describes of Syria, that Israel is making a mistake by
targeting Lebanon here, which is being held hostage by Syria, rather than
attacking the Syrian regime which is controlling Hezbollah. Do you think that
Israel should be looking at Syria rather than at Lebanon?
Ghadry: As a Syrian native, as a Syrian-American, I'm opposed to any military
activity against Syria, because eventually that will bear onto the people of
Syria. And that's not something we all want. Plus we know that the government is
pretty savvy about these issues. They will use that to bring support on the
street against Israel. Not only against Israel, but against the opposition who’s
working very hard to bring the regime down. However, we're not opposing, we do
not oppose the issue of regime change. Because we believe the regime has been
weakened so much that if the United States decides they want to -– that this is
time for a regime change in Syria -- in and by itself that act will bring about
the coalition, the coalescing of the opposition, the weakening of the regime
from within. The people will be empowered inside Syria and realize that this is
the last few days of that regime. And that, in and by itself should bring about,
the coalescing of forces to break down that regime peacefully from within. I'm
more supportive of the regime being broken down from within than actual military
theater, or military operations against Syria today. With one exception, that if
Israel decides it wants to take out the military headquarters of the Syrian
military intelligence, or pinpoint targets, one, two, or three: I don’t think it
would be such a bad idea to do that. But overall a blanket operation against
Syria today is not in the best interest of the Syrians nor is it in the best
interests of the opposition. I just want to bring up the other issue. Syria is
very important. It is weak militarily, but it's not weak, when it comes to as a
chess player in the Middle East. And the reason being, Syria has been able to
gain the confidence of Hamas, which is a Muslim Sunni entity and gain confidence
of Hezbollah, which is a Shia entity. And both of them, Syria controls both of
them in a very, very clever way. Something has not been done in the Middle East,
so while Iran plays the big ogre in the Middle East, Syria has a very important
role as an Arab entity. Bringing other Arab entities together under the same
wing and under the specter of Iran.
Host: Joseph Gebeily, Shimon Peres who’s currently the Vice Premier of Israel,
has said that, "We [Israel] will leave Iran to the world community and Syria as
well [and] it's very important to understand that we are not instilling world
order." What is there for the world community to do here, if this is being
directed by Syria and Iran?
Gebeily: As everybody agrees here, the main player is Iran, and then there are
proxies. The Syrian regime being one, and then the local players: the non-state
actors in Lebanon, Hezbollah, the Palestinian militia supported by Syria, and
some very minor Lebanese groups. All these have been working with the Syrian
regime for years. They're well armed. They've committed acts of assassinations,
terrorism, etc., within Lebanon. And short of hitting the Iranian regime, of
getting rid of the Iranian evil in the Middle East, there's of course the Syrian
regime, and if not, their proxies within Lebanon. The international community
has the plan for that. They have the road map. There are now several United
Nations Security Council resolutions, starting with Fifteen-Fifty-Nine that is
the main one. Which said basically Syria should be out, militias should be
disarmed. But what's happening now is that though the Syrians are theoretically
out, there's still the intelligence [agents]. But again, weapons, ammunitions,
and fighters, are still getting into Lebanon. If you look back at the history,
that's how the Lebanese civil war started in the seventies. Syria -- the Syrian
army- was not within Lebanon at the time, but they were arming all these
militias -- Palestinians and others -- within Lebanon. Then, the war started and
then they found an excuse to come in. We should control the border. It is
extremely important that the borders of Lebanon will be controlled. South and
eastern borders. [In the] South, the government should take with the help of the
United Nations, should take control of the Southern border, so Hezbollah cannot
play a role in there and the Eastern border should be extremely well controlled,
so the Syrians cannot keep sending fighters and weapons and ammunition, and
bombs into Lebanon.
Host: Mark Dubowitz, what would it take for a secure border in Lebanon?
Dubowitz: Both Joseph and Farid have put it very well. Which is, I think, the
destruction of Hezbollah. Let's remember, we talk a lot about Iran and Syria as
these grandmasters and Hezbollah as a proxy. But Hezbollah is a global terrorist
organization, which is very sophisticated and very deadly. It has killed more
Americans than any terrorist organization with the exception of al-Qaida. It has
worldwide reach. It has terrorist cells in America, South America, in Australia,
and in East Asia. It is a deadly terrorist organization and in the global war on
terror it is incumbent on the United States and its allies to deal a deadly blow
to these terrorist organizations with global reach. We should acknowledge that
Hezbollah is a dangerous player on its own. In terms of securing the border,
it's clear that Hezbollah as been there for now twenty-three years. Since 2000,
since the Israelis actually left southern Lebanon there have been one hundred
and fifty-one missile attacks against Israeli towns. There have seventeen
Israelis who've have been killed. There have been fifty-two that have been
injured. We forget the crisis didn't begin three days ago or three weeks ago. It
began fifty-eight years ago, certainly. But it began in 2000 when the Israelis
pulled out of Southern Lebanon and were met with missile attacks, deadly
attacks, against their citizens and their civilians. It began a year ago when
the Israelis pulled out of Gaza, and over a thousand rockets have been lobbed in
by Hamas and other Palestinian terrorist groups, into Israeli towns, killing and
maiming Israeli citizens. So, the response has to be clear and it has to be
direct. Ultimately Israel needs to have the time in the next couple weeks to do
as much damage to Hezbollah's military capability [as possible] and to go after
the ten to thirteen thousand rockets that are currently sitting on the Lebanese
border. By the way, rockets which have been primarily provided, financed, and
are currently being run out of southern Lebanon by Iranian and Syrian
intelligence agents and troops.
Host: Farid Ghadry, let's talk about those missiles. People seem to have been
surprised by the sophistication of the missiles that are now at Hezbollah's
disposal, not only ones that can reach as far as Haifa, but then the use of a
variation on the Chinese silk worm missile that had gone to Iran, used to hit an
Israeli warship off of Lebanon. What does this tell us about the current state
of missile technology proliferation in the region?
Ghadry: Politically, it tells us that Hezbollah has been planning for this day
for a long time. Because when Israel got out of Lebanon in May of 2000, that
should have closed the issue of Israel being on Lebanese territories and that
should have given reason to Hezbollah to exit to the scene as a struggling or as
a resistance movement. But the fact that they have those missiles tells us that
Hezbollah, Iran, and Syria have been planning for this day and they have been
instigating, and they have been prodding Israel for a fight, and they've been
eager to get a fight. Now, in terms of the technology, this is very worrisome.
In fact these are exactly the kind of things we do not want in the Middle East.
Simple reason: the Middle East, the whole area, is very backward. We need to pay
attention to our people, we need democracies, we need to give them freedom. We
need to lift ourselves from the darkness, from the dark ages that we've been
living in for the last one-hundred years. And in order for us to do that, we
need to become peaceful people. We need to bring about peaceful change to our
societies and allow the people to grow and allow the people to prosper from
within. Spending money on missiles rather than spending money on schools is
counterproductive to any Arab thought and to our development as a people. And
that, in and by itself, is a crime. And I believe that the Iranians and the
Syrians, and everybody that supports this kind of activity or missile technology
or offensive technology in the Middle East is simply calling for more
destruction and more havoc. In the Middle East, countries have been or are
living in the dark ages. We should fight this as Arabs. We should fight it with
all our hearts, and try and conquer that issue with every ounce of our energy.
It's not in the best interest of the Arab countries.
Host: Joseph Gebeily, these rockets and missiles are not held in depots or
military installations but are rather held in Southern Lebanon and in homes and
in civilian areas. How does rooting out Hezbollah -- whether it's Israel or the
international community coming up with some kind of U-N force -– how does this
happen without causing so much death and destruction in Lebanon that seems to
part of what Hezbollah wants to have happened?
Gebeily: I want to challenge the idea of the “resistance movement” that
Hezbollah has gotten over the years. Hezbollah is a militia that formed in the
late seventies-early eighties, and it was formed after the Iranian revolutionary
guard moved into Lebanon through Syria. It had nothing to do originally with the
invasion of Israeli invasion of Lebanon.
The Hezbollah agenda is transforming
Lebanon into a radical Shiite regime modeled after Iranian theocracy. And over
the years, although the Israeli invasion of Lebanon had extended to Beirut,
Hezbollah never attacked the Israelis. They were always finding an excuse, if
you want to call it, to present it to the Lebanese. And in the end of the
Lebanese civil war in 1999, there was an agreement for all militias to disarm
including Hezbollah. And the only reason they kept their weapons is because the
Syrians wanted them to. And then they come up with this excuse that they are
fighting the Israelis and they remembered that the Israelis were still in a
small security zone in Southern Lebanon, and after that, after the Israeli
withdrawal in 2000. Remember the Sheba farm that was never mentioned before and
now they are talking about the prisoners. And at some point Hassan Nasrallah, in
his last statement said: “we are fighting the war of the ummah, and we're
fighting the war of the whole Muslim world.” We're hearing now another Bin
Laden. The idea of localized Lebanese resistance movement is totally wrong. Now,
back to the rockets; it is very hard to be able to get rid of the Hezbollah
armament without a ground troop operation. Let's face it, bombings and air
strikes etc, could hit here and there.
But they don't care, Hezbollah doesn't
care, about loss of civilian life. They are going to hide, all their rockets,
ammunitions, etc. among the Lebanese population. It's the Lebanese who are
suffering, the Lebanese who are being killed, the Lebanese civilians. Hezbollah
has lost only eight members so far and that's nothing. And the Lebanese losses
are in the hundreds but they don't care. They are still so outrageous in saying;
we are going to continue the war and we are not going to stop -- the Hezbollah
leaders.
Host: I'm afraid that's all the time we have for today, but I'd like to thank my
guests: Farid Ghadry of the Reform Party of Syria; Dr. Joseph Gebeily of the
American Lebanese Coalition and Mark Dubowitz of The Foundation for the Defense
of Democracies. Before we go, I'd like to invite you to send us your questions
or comments. You can reach us through our web site at
w-w-w-dot-v-o-a-news-dot-com-slash-ontheline. For On the Line, I'm Eric Felten.
Israeli warplanes kill 3 fleeing Lebanese
By SAM F. GHATTAS, Associated Press Writer
BEIRUT, Lebanon - Israeli warplanes struck a minibus carrying people fleeing the
fighting Sunday in southern Lebanon, killing three people, Lebanese security
officials said, and Israel said it would accept a NATO-led international force
to keep the peace along the border.
Hezbollah rockets killed two civilians in northern Israel, and a member of the
U.N. observer team in south Lebanon was seriously wounded by guerrilla fire.
The top U.N. humanitarian official, touring Beirut, said billions of dollars
will be needed to repair damage from 12 days of warfare.
Israeli troops continued to hold a Lebanese border village that they battled
their way into the day before, but did not appear to be advancing, Lebanese
security officials said. Its warplanes and artillery, meanwhile, were battering
areas across the south.
Israeli Defense Minister Amir Peretz told the Cabinet that the current offensive
is not an invasion of Lebanon, but rather a series of limited raids into the
area.
Peretz also said that Israel would accept a temporary international force,
preferably headed by NATO, deployed along the Lebanese border to keep Hezbollah
guerrillas away from Israel, according to officials in Peretz's office.
Israel also hit the southern port of Sidon for the first time in its campaign,
destroying a religious complex linked to Hezbollah and wounding four people.
More than 35,000 people streaming north from the heart of the war zone had
swamped the city, which is teetering under the weight of refugees.
Israel also bombed a textile factory in the border town of al-Manara, killing
one person and wounding two, Mayor Ali Rahal told The Associated Press.
The stricken minibus was carrying 16 people fleeing the village of Tairi,
working their way through the mountains for the southern port city of Tyre. A
missile hit the bus near the village of Yaatar, killing three and wounding the
rest, security officials said. The wounded were taken to hospitals in Tyre.
On Saturday, the Israeli military told residents of Taire and 12 other nearby
villages to evacuate by 4 p.m.
At least four other people were killed by strikes in the south, Lebanese
television said, but the deaths were not confirmed by security officials. About
45 people were wounded in Israeli air raids that targeted villages and towns
around Tyre, security and hospital officials said.
The three deaths in the minibus brought to at least 375 the official death toll
provided by Lebanese authorities. Israel's death toll stands at 36, with 17
people killed by Hezbollah rockets and 19 soldiers killed in fighting.
A U.N. observer was seriously wounded by Hezbollah gunfire during fighting with
Israeli troops in south Lebanon, said U.N. spokesman Milos Strugar. The Italian
chiefs of staff office identified the wounded U.N. official as Italian Capt.
Roberto Punzo, saying he was flown by helicopter to an civilian hospital in
Haifa.
He was the second member of the U.N. monitoring team injured in 12 days of
fighting. Several U.N. positions on the border have taken hits from Israeli
shells, and Israel said earlier this week that a U.N. post on its side was hit
by a Hezbollah missile — although the observer team said it was a stray Israeli
shell.
Israeli warplanes and helicopters bombed Nabi Sheet, near the eastern Bekaa
Valley town of Baalbek, wounding five people, witnesses said. In Baalbek,
strikes leveled an agricultural compound belonging to Hezbollah. Raids also
targeted a factory producing prefabricated houses near the main highway linking
Beirut to the Syrian capital of Damascus, witnesses said.
Two civilians died in early morning air raids on border villages, witnesses
said. A 15-year-old boy was killed at Meis al-Jabal, and a man was killed at
Blida.
Hezbollah rockets badly damaged a house and slammed into a major road in Haifa,
Israel's third-largest city, killing two people, and at least 13 others were
wounded across northern Israel.
Peretz said the 12-day-old offensive in Lebanon would continue as Israel tries
to push Hezbollah guerrillas away from the border.
"The army's ground operation in Lebanon is focused on limited entrances, and we
are not talking about an invasion of Lebanon. We are beginning to see the army's
successes opposite Hezbollah," he told the Cabinet, according to a participant
in the meeting.
Peretz also met with German Foreign Minister Frank-Walter Steinmeier, one of a
series of diplomatic meetings aimed at ending the fighting. French Foreign
Minister Philippe Douste-Blazy was also scheduled to meet with Israeli
officials, and Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice was headed to the region as
well.
"The goal is to create a situation in which we have as broad a space for
diplomatic movement as possible," Peretz said after meeting Steinmeier. "The
goals we set for ourselves will be achieved. We certainly see a combination of a
military operation that is fulfilling its role plus broad international activity
to complete the process."
In Iran, President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad said Israel had "pushed the button of its
own destruction" by attacking Iranian-backed Hezbollah guerrillas in Lebanon.
Ahmadinejad didn't elaborate, but suggested Islamic nations and others could
somehow isolate Israel and its main backers led by the United States. On
Saturday, the chairman of Iran's armed forced joint chiefs, Maj. Gen. Sayyed
Hassan Firuzabadi, said Iran would never join the current Middle East fighting.
U.N. humanitarian chief Jan Egeland, meanwhile, inspected the destruction
wrought by Israeli air raids on south Beirut as he began a relief mission to
Lebanon.
Making his way around piles of rubble, he stressed the need for a halt to the
hostilities.
"If it continues like this, there will be more and more civilian casualties," he
told reporters.
Egeland also planned to travel to Israel for further coordination on opening aid
corridors. The number of displaced people has grown to 600,000, according to the
World Health Organization.
Egeland said Saturday it would take more than $100 million to help the
displaced. He said he would make an appeal "urging, begging" the international
community for aid.
Evacuees in Sidon were stretching supplies of fuel, food and some medicines that
already were tight for its own population of 100,000 and nearly impossible to
replenish.
"There are no supplies reaching us, not from other nations, nor from the
Lebanese government," said Mayor Abdul-Rahman al-Bizri, whose city was so packed
that Palestinian refugees were taking in Lebanese refugees.
Sidon was only one face of the mounting humanitarian crisis across Lebanon amid
an Israeli blockade and bombardment that has made roads unusable or too
dangerous to distribute supplies to the south.
The Israeli military has announced that humanitarian aid could enter through
Beirut's port and determined a coastal to Tripoli as a land corridor for aid.
But it did not define a safe passage route to the south — where the bombardment
is heaviest.
Aid supplies arrived Friday and Saturday on ships carrying Europeans fleeing the
country. The exodus of foreigners continues, with tens of thousands — including
7,500 Americans — taken out by sea the past week.
Rallies across Canada denounce Middle East conflict
Published: Sunday, July 23, 2006
Shannon Proudfoot, CanWest News Service
Published: Sunday, July 23, 2006
OTTAWA -- Thousands of Canadians took to the streets Saturday in cities across
the country to protest against the continuing conflict in Lebanon and Israel,
which has resulted in the deaths of numerous civilians, and against Canada's
response to the situation.
Prime Minister Stephen Harper was the major target of criticism in Ottawa and
elsewhere. Thousands of protesters gathered on Parliament Hill to denounce the
government's response to the burgeoning violence in Lebanon.
The Ottawa demonstration, organized by the Coalition of Arab Canadian
Professionals and Community Associations (CAPCA), attracted about 2,500 members
of the Lebanese community, labour unions and other supporters. Many waved
Canadian, Lebanese or Palestinian flags, while others carried placards reading
"We need a Prime Minister, not a puppet" and "Mr. Harper ... we hold you
responsible for Israeli murder of Canadians."
Bahija Reghao, president of CAPCA, said the demonstration was a show of
solidarity among all those who disagree with Harper's recent statements calling
Israel's attacks on Lebanon a "measured response." Reghao hoped the protest
would move the prime minister to "read the real facts" and alter his position.
"It's not an Arab issue, it's not a Muslim issue it's a Canadian issue. We're
talking about Canadian values," she said.
Omar Diab sat with his wife, Hoda, and their sons, Hassan, 8, and Abdul, 3,
alongside dozens of other young families in Ottawa. Diab was there because he
felt it was time to "take a stand" and demand an end to the violence, and he was
hopeful the government would take heed of the protesters.
"We're Lebanese-Canadians. Our country is being bombed, we have lots of family
there. We have to show solidarity with them, that we feel what they feel," he
said.
In Montreal, home to Canada's largest community of Lebanese descent, roughly
1,000 protesters made their way through downtown streets as part of the
International Day of Action against Israeli Aggression. They, too, expressed
anger at Canada's prime minister, calling out "Harper, you are an accomplice."
"A `measured response' would have been to take out Hezbollah," Tarek El-Onsi
said in reference to Harper's remark, while hoisting a giant Canadian flag over
his head.
"Don't go after Lebanese civilians and infrastructure," added his brother,
Ghassan El-Onsi, who was born in Lebanon but has lived most his life in Saudi
Arabia and Canada.
Ghassan bemoaned the destruction of a country he says was just starting to
thrive after years of civil war.
"We rebuilt it all in 15 years, and in 10 to 15 days half of the city is
destroyed."
While some protesters could be seen wearing T-shirts bearing the likeness of
Sheik Hassan Nasrallah, Hezbollah's leader, the overwhelming number of Montreal
protesters were not concerned with questions of a political nature, but rather
the human toll of this conflict.
"The whole focus is on innocent civilians," said Danielle Frank who was marching
behind a banner that read "Israeli terrorism is not Jewish Value."
Frank was one of many Jews marching with protesters against escalating Israeli
aggression in Lebanon.
Further west, about 150 people gathered in the main courtyard at Winnipeg's city
hall.
They called for an immediate ceasefire to the hostilities and vented their anger
at Harper.
Israel began its attacks on Lebanon after Hezbollah crossed into Israel and
captured the two soldiers on July 12.
Many demonstrators carried placards, including some which read ``End Israeli
Terror.''
About 30 pro-Israel demonstrators also turned up at the Winnipeg rally.
Some argued that agreeing to a ceasefire would be supporting terrorism. Others,
like Ken McGhie, waved Israeli flags.
"We need to stand with Israel," said McGhie. "Israel has a right to defend
itself."
There were a couple of heated conversations between the opposing groups, but for
the most part it was a peaceful rally.
Ottawa Citizen, with files from Montreal Gazette, Winnipeg Free Press
© CanWest News Service 2006
Civilian deaths mount in Mideast violence
By SAM F. GHATTAS, Associated Press Writers
BEIRUT, Lebanon - Israeli warplanes struck a minibus carrying people fleeing the
fighting Sunday in southern Lebanon, killing three people, Lebanese security
officials said, and Hezbollah rockets killed two civilians in northern Israel.
Syria, one of Hezbollah's main backers, said it will press for a cease-fire to
end the fighting — but only in the framework of a broader Middle East peace
initiative that would include the return of the Golan Heights. Israel was
unlikely to accept such terms but the remarks were the first indication of
Syria's willingness to be involved in international efforts to defuse the
Lebanese crisis.
Israel said it would accept a NATO-led international force to keep the peace
along the border.
The top U.N. humanitarian official, touring Beirut, said billions of dollars
will be needed to repair damage from the 12-day offensive, which began July 12
when Hezbollah guerrillas captured two Israeli soldiers and killed three others
in a cross-border raid.
A member of the U.N. observer team in south Lebanon was wounded by guerrilla
fire and a Lebanese photographer became the first journalist to die in the
fighting when an Israeli missile hit near her taxi in southern Lebanon.
Israeli troops continued to hold a Lebanese border village that they battled
into on Saturday, but did not appear to be advancing, Lebanese security
officials said. Its warplanes and artillery, meanwhile, battered areas across
the south.
In talking about a cease-fire, Damascus warned that it will not stand by if the
Israelis step up their offensive in Lebanon.
"Syria and Spain are working to achieve a cease-fire, a prisoners' swap and to
start a peace process as one package," Syrian Information Minister Mohsen Bilal
was quoted as saying by the Spanish daily newspaper ABC.
Bilal said Damascus would cooperate only within a broader peace initiative that
would include a return of the Golan Heights, captured by Israel in 1967.
Asked about the comments from Syria, U.S. Ambassador to the United Nations John
Bolton said, "It's hard to see."
"Syria doesn't need dialogue to know what they need to do," Bolton told "Fox
News Sunday." "They need to lean on Hezbollah to get them to release the two
captured Israeli soldiers and stop the launch of rockets against innocent
Israeli civilians.
Israeli Defense Minister Amir Peretz told the Cabinet that the current offensive
is not an invasion of Lebanon, but rather a series of limited raids into the
area.
Peretz also said that Israel would accept a temporary international force,
preferably headed by NATO, deployed along the Lebanese border to keep Hezbollah
guerrillas away from Israel, according to officials in his office.
Israel hit the southern port of Sidon for the first time, destroying a religious
complex linked to Hezbollah and wounding four people. More than 35,000 people
streaming north from the heart of the war zone had swamped the city, which is
teetering under the weight of refugees.
Israel also bombed a textile factory in the border town of al-Manara, killing
one person and wounding two, Mayor Ali Rahal told The Associated Press.
The stricken minibus was carrying 16 people fleeing the village of Tairi,
heading through the mountains for the southern port city of Tyre. A missile hit
the bus near the village of Yaatar, killing three and wounding the rest,
security officials said.
On Saturday, the Israeli military told residents of Taire and 12 other nearby
villages to evacuate by 4 p.m.
In other violence, an 8-year-old boy was killed in a strike on a village in the
mountains above Tyre, and another missile hit a vehicle right outside the Najem
hospital, wounding eight, a hospital official said.
Hezbollah said three of its guerrillas were killed in fighting.
At least four other people were killed by strikes in the south, Lebanese
television said, but the deaths were not confirmed by security officials. About
45 people were wounded in Israeli air raids that targeted villages and towns
around Tyre, security and hospital officials said.
The deaths brought to at least 380 the official death toll provided by Lebanese
authorities. Israel's death toll stands at 36, with 17 people killed by
Hezbollah rockets and 19 soldiers killed in fighting.
A photographer working for a Lebanese magazine was killed when an Israeli
missile exploded near her taxi, security officials said on condition of
anonymity because they were not authorized to speak to the media. Layal Nejim,
23, worked for the Lebanese magazine Al-Jaras, the officials said. Her driver
survived.
A U.N. observer was wounded by Hezbollah gunfire during fighting with Israeli
troops in south Lebanon, said U.N. spokesman Milos Strugar. The Italian chiefs
of staff office identified the wounded U.N. official as Italian Capt. Roberto
Punzo, adding he was flown by helicopter to a hospital in Haifa and that his
life was not in danger.
He was the second member of the U.N. monitoring team injured in 12 days of
fighting.
Israeli warplanes and helicopters bombed Nabi Sheet, near the eastern Bekaa
Valley town of Baalbek, wounding five people, witnesses said. In Baalbek,
strikes leveled an agricultural compound belonging to Hezbollah. Raids also
targeted a factory producing prefabricated houses near the main highway linking
Beirut to the Syrian capital of Damascus, witnesses said.
Two civilians died in early morning air raids on border villages, witnesses
said. A 15-year-old boy was killed at Meis al-Jabal, and a man was killed at
Blida.
Hezbollah rockets badly damaged a house and slammed into a major road in Haifa,
Israel's third-largest city, killing two people and wounding five. Across
northern Israel, the militants' rockets wounded at least 13 others.
Peretz said the 12-day-old offensive in Lebanon would continue as Israel tries
to push Hezbollah guerrillas away from the border.
"The army's ground operation in Lebanon is focused on limited entrances, and we
are not talking about an invasion of Lebanon. We are beginning to see the army's
successes opposite Hezbollah," he told the Cabinet, according to a participant
in the meeting.
Peretz also met with German Foreign Minister Frank-Walter Steinmeier, one of a
series of diplomatic meetings aimed at ending the fighting. French Foreign
Minister Philippe Douste-Blazy was also on the schedule, and Secretary of State
Condoleezza Rice was headed to the region as well.
"The goal is to create a situation in which we have as broad a space for
diplomatic movement as possible," Peretz said after meeting Steinmeier. "The
goals we set for ourselves will be achieved. We certainly see a combination of a
military operation that is fulfilling its role plus broad international activity
to complete the process." In Iran, President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad said Israel had
"pushed the button of its own destruction" by attacking Iranian-backed Hezbollah
guerrillas in Lebanon.
He didn't elaborate, but suggested Islamic nations and others could somehow
isolate Israel and its main backers led by the United States.
U.N. humanitarian chief Jan Egeland, meanwhile, inspected the destruction from
Israeli air raids on south Beirut and he stressed need for a halt to the
hostilities. "It's terrible, I see a lot of children wounded, homeless,
suffering. This is a war where civilians pay a disproportionate price in Lebanon
and northern Israel. I hadn't believed it would be block by block leveled to the
ground," he said.
He said the "disproportionate response by Israel is a violation of international
humanitarian law."
On Monday, the United Nations will release and international appeal for "more
than $100 million" in aid for Lebanon, Egeland said.
He told AP the long-term cost of rebuilding the infrastructure would be "in the
billions."
Egeland also planned to travel to Israel for further coordination on opening aid
corridors. The number of displaced people has grown to 600,000, according to the
World Health Organization. Hours after he left, three heavy blasts were heard
and smoke rose over Dahiyah, the southern Beirut neighborhood that has been hit
heavily. Some 35,000 refugees have swamped Sidon, which says it has yet to
receive any aid shipments. The refugees were stretching supplies of fuel, food
and medicines that already were tight for Sidon's own population of 100,000.
The Israeli military has said humanitarian aid could enter Lebanon through
Beirut's port and determined a coastal route to Tripoli as a land corridor. But
it did not define a safe passage route to the south — where the bombardment is
heaviest.
Aid supplies arrived Friday and Saturday on ships carrying Europeans fleeing the
country. The exodus of foreigners continues, with tens of thousands — including
7,500 Americans — taken out by sea the past week.
Civilian deaths mount in Mideast violence
By SAM F. GHATTAS, Associated Press Writers
BEIRUT, Lebanon - Israeli warplanes struck a minibus carrying people fleeing the
fighting Sunday in southern Lebanon, killing three people, Lebanese security
officials said, and Hezbollah rockets killed two civilians in northern Israel.
Syria, one of Hezbollah's main backers, said it will press for a cease-fire to
end the fighting — but only in the framework of a broader Middle East peace
initiative that would include the return of the Golan Heights. Israel was
unlikely to accept such terms but the remarks were the first indication of
Syria's willingness to be involved in international efforts to defuse the
Lebanese crisis.
Israel said it would accept a NATO-led international force to keep the peace
along the border.
The top U.N. humanitarian official, touring Beirut, said billions of dollars
will be needed to repair damage from the 12-day offensive, which began July 12
when Hezbollah guerrillas captured two Israeli soldiers and killed three others
in a cross-border raid.
A member of the U.N. observer team in south Lebanon was wounded by guerrilla
fire and a Lebanese photographer became the first journalist to die in the
fighting when an Israeli missile hit near her taxi in southern Lebanon.
Israeli troops continued to hold a Lebanese border village that they battled
into on Saturday, but did not appear to be advancing, Lebanese security
officials said. Its warplanes and artillery, meanwhile, battered areas across
the south.
In talking about a cease-fire, Damascus warned that it will not stand by if the
Israelis step up their offensive in Lebanon.
"Syria and Spain are working to achieve a cease-fire, a prisoners' swap and to
start a peace process as one package," Syrian Information Minister Mohsen Bilal
was quoted as saying by the Spanish daily newspaper ABC.
Bilal said Damascus would cooperate only within a broader peace initiative that
would include a return of the Golan Heights, captured by Israel in 1967.
Asked about the comments from Syria, U.S. Ambassador to the United Nations John
Bolton said, "It's hard to see."
"Syria doesn't need dialogue to know what they need to do," Bolton told "Fox
News Sunday." "They need to lean on Hezbollah to get them to release the two
captured Israeli soldiers and stop the launch of rockets against innocent
Israeli civilians.
Israeli Defense Minister Amir Peretz told the Cabinet that the current offensive
is not an invasion of Lebanon, but rather a series of limited raids into the
area.
Peretz also said that Israel would accept a temporary international force,
preferably headed by NATO, deployed along the Lebanese border to keep Hezbollah
guerrillas away from Israel, according to officials in his office.
Israel hit the southern port of Sidon for the first time, destroying a religious
complex linked to Hezbollah and wounding four people. More than 35,000 people
streaming north from the heart of the war zone had swamped the city, which is
teetering under the weight of refugees.
Israel also bombed a textile factory in the border town of al-Manara, killing
one person and wounding two, Mayor Ali Rahal told The Associated Press.
The stricken minibus was carrying 16 people fleeing the village of Tairi,
heading through the mountains for the southern port city of Tyre. A missile hit
the bus near the village of Yaatar, killing three and wounding the rest,
security officials said.
On Saturday, the Israeli military told residents of Taire and 12 other nearby
villages to evacuate by 4 p.m.
In other violence, an 8-year-old boy was killed in a strike on a village in the
mountains above Tyre, and another missile hit a vehicle right outside the Najem
hospital, wounding eight, a hospital official said.
Hezbollah said three of its guerrillas were killed in fighting.
At least four other people were killed by strikes in the south, Lebanese
television said, but the deaths were not confirmed by security officials. About
45 people were wounded in Israeli air raids that targeted villages and towns
around Tyre, security and hospital officials said.
The deaths brought to at least 380 the official death toll provided by Lebanese
authorities. Israel's death toll stands at 36, with 17 people killed by
Hezbollah rockets and 19 soldiers killed in fighting.
A photographer working for a Lebanese magazine was killed when an Israeli
missile exploded near her taxi, security officials said on condition of
anonymity because they were not authorized to speak to the media. Layal Nejim,
23, worked for the Lebanese magazine Al-Jaras, the officials said. Her driver
survived.
A U.N. observer was wounded by Hezbollah gunfire during fighting with Israeli
troops in south Lebanon, said U.N. spokesman Milos Strugar. The Italian chiefs
of staff office identified the wounded U.N. official as Italian Capt. Roberto
Punzo, adding he was flown by helicopter to a hospital in Haifa and that his
life was not in danger.
He was the second member of the U.N. monitoring team injured in 12 days of
fighting.
Israeli warplanes and helicopters bombed Nabi Sheet, near the eastern Bekaa
Valley town of Baalbek, wounding five people, witnesses said. In Baalbek,
strikes leveled an agricultural compound belonging to Hezbollah. Raids also
targeted a factory producing prefabricated houses near the main highway linking
Beirut to the Syrian capital of Damascus, witnesses said.
Two civilians died in early morning air raids on border villages, witnesses
said. A 15-year-old boy was killed at Meis al-Jabal, and a man was killed at
Blida.
Hezbollah rockets badly damaged a house and slammed into a major road in Haifa,
Israel's third-largest city, killing two people and wounding five. Across
northern Israel, the militants' rockets wounded at least 13 others.
Peretz said the 12-day-old offensive in Lebanon would continue as Israel tries
to push Hezbollah guerrillas away from the border.
"The army's ground operation in Lebanon is focused on limited entrances, and we
are not talking about an invasion of Lebanon. We are beginning to see the army's
successes opposite Hezbollah," he told the Cabinet, according to a participant
in the meeting.
Peretz also met with German Foreign Minister Frank-Walter Steinmeier, one of a
series of diplomatic meetings aimed at ending the fighting. French Foreign
Minister Philippe Douste-Blazy was also on the schedule, and Secretary of State
Condoleezza Rice was headed to the region as well.
"The goal is to create a situation in which we have as broad a space for
diplomatic movement as possible," Peretz said after meeting Steinmeier. "The
goals we set for ourselves will be achieved. We certainly see a combination of a
military operation that is fulfilling its role plus broad international activity
to complete the process."
In Iran, President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad said Israel had "pushed the button of its
own destruction" by attacking Iranian-backed Hezbollah guerrillas in Lebanon.
He didn't elaborate, but suggested Islamic nations and others could somehow
isolate Israel and its main backers led by the United States.
U.N. humanitarian chief Jan Egeland, meanwhile, inspected the destruction from
Israeli air raids on south Beirut and he stressed need for a halt to the
hostilities.
"It's terrible, I see a lot of children wounded, homeless, suffering. This is a
war where civilians pay a disproportionate price in Lebanon and northern Israel.
I hadn't believed it would be block by block leveled to the ground," he said.
He said the "disproportionate response by Israel is a violation of international
humanitarian law."
On Monday, the United Nations will release and international appeal for "more
than $100 million" in aid for Lebanon, Egeland said.
He told AP the long-term cost of rebuilding the infrastructure would be "in the
billions."
Egeland also planned to travel to Israel for further coordination on opening aid
corridors. The number of displaced people has grown to 600,000, according to the
World Health Organization.
Hours after he left, three heavy blasts were heard and smoke rose over Dahiyah,
the southern Beirut neighborhood that has been hit heavily.
Some 35,000 refugees have swamped Sidon, which says it has yet to receive any
aid shipments. The refugees were stretching supplies of fuel, food and medicines
that already were tight for Sidon's own population of 100,000.
The Israeli military has said humanitarian aid could enter Lebanon through
Beirut's port and determined a coastal route to Tripoli as a land corridor. But
it did not define a safe passage route to the south — where the bombardment is
heaviest.
Aid supplies arrived Friday and Saturday on ships carrying Europeans fleeing the
country. The exodus of foreigners continues, with tens of thousands — including
7,500 Americans — taken out by sea the past week.