LCCC ENGLISH DAILY
NEWS BULLETIN
February 19/15
Bible Quotation for Today/Do Not be a hypocrite whenever
you give alms
Matthew 06/01-04: "‘Beware of practising your piety before others
in order to be seen by them; for then you have no reward from your Father in
heaven. ‘So whenever you give alms, do not sound a trumpet before you, as the
hypocrites do in the synagogues and in the streets, so that they may be praised
by others. Truly I tell you, they have received their reward. But when you give
alms, do not let your left hand know what your right hand is doing, so that your
alms may be done in secret; and your Father who sees in secret will reward you."
Letter to the Romans 15,14-21.
"I myself feel confident about you, my brothers and sisters, that you yourselves
are full of goodness, filled with all knowledge, and able to instruct one
another. Nevertheless, on some points I have written to you rather boldly by way
of reminder, because of the grace given me by God to be a minister of Christ
Jesus to the Gentiles in the priestly service of the gospel of God, so that the
offering of the Gentiles may be acceptable, sanctified by the Holy Spirit. In
Christ Jesus, then, I have reason to boast of my work for God. For I will not
venture to speak of anything except what Christ has accomplished through me to
win obedience from the Gentiles, by word and deed, by the power of signs and
wonders, by the power of the Spirit of God, so that from Jerusalem and as far
around as Illyricum I have fully proclaimed the good news of Christ. Thus I make
it my ambition to proclaim the good news, not where Christ has already been
named, so that I do not build on someone else’s foundation, but as it is
written, ‘Those who have never been told of him shall see, and those who have
never heard of him shall understand.’"
Latest analysis, editorials from miscellaneous sources published on February
18-19/15
Information about the US-Iranian nuclear dialogue is no longer “sensitive.” For
Obama it’s a done deal/DEBKAfile/February 18/15
Kirkuk is just one question mark for the Kurds/David Ignatius/The Daily
Star/February 18/15
Iran faces an uphill battle in Yemen/Tariq Alhomayed/Asharq Al Awsat/February
18/15
New partners in struggle against terrorism/Yohanan Plesner/Ynetnews/February
18/15
Lebanese Related
News published on
February 18-19/15
Lebanese Parliament fails to elect president again, session postponed to March
11.
Geagea: State must control anti-terror strategy.
Mustaqbal, Hizbullah Begin Discussions on 'National Anti-Terror Strategy'
Salam, Bassil meet EU delegation.
Best Friends: Geagea, Aoun trade birthday tweets.
Berri urges accord ahead of void in Cabinet.
Hariri, UN official discuss Lebanon, region.
Aoun Meets Hariri over Dinner at Center House
Hezbollah demands France release Georges Abdallah.
Jumblatt sticks to Nusra stance after Nasrallah call out.
March 14: Participation in Anti-IS Coalition Proves State Alone Responsible for
Protecting Lebanon.
Suleiman Responding to Aoun: Electing President Fastest Way to Withdraw
Confidence from Minister.
'Dangerous' Gang that Robbed Churches Arrested.
Berri Says It's Time to Steer Clear of Speeches and Take Decisions.
Beirut Port Basin Filling Stops after Truckers Issue Warning.
Hariri and Aoun Could Meet Soon.
U.S. Downplays Lebanon's Boycott of Washington Conference
Mashnouq Says Extension of High-Ranking Officers Part of Ongoing Glitches.
Bilal Deqmaq Deported from Turkey, Arrested at Beirut Airport.
Abou Faour Says Unified Prescription Form to Create Qualitative Change.
Visiting EU Delegation Voices Solidarity with Lebanon.
Joint Security Force in Bekaa Arrests Syrians, Confiscates Illegal Items.
Report: Lebanese Authorities Reject Obtaining Russian TOS-1 Systems.
Miscellaneous
Reports And News published on
February 18-19/15
Yemen’s Houthis buying off local tribes: sources .
Iran's Khamenei threatens world gas supply .
Obama view of Arab world role faces challenges .
Killers of Copts were “foreign nationals”: Libyan ex-minister .
Egyptians mourn Coptic Christians beheaded by ISIS.
Sisi tours border with Libya after bombing ISIS.
Street cleaner killed by Cairo bomb: official.
Italy: ISIS poses ‘evident risk’ in Libya.
Egypt drops U.N. bid for Libya military intervention: ministry
Street cleaner killed by Cairo bomb: official.
Russia the warlord.
Saudi King receives Qatari Emir in Riyadh .
Syria willing to suspend Aleppo strikes 6 weeks: UN envoy .
Over 100 killed in regime’s Aleppo offensive.
Battles leave more than 150 as rebels make gains near Aleppo.
Arab states to ask UN to ease Libya arms embargo.
Netanyahu: Tzipi Livni is a danger to Israel .
Herzog: As PM, I will not negotiate with Hamas .
UN tells donors to make good on Gaza pledges.
Israel court quashes election ban for Arab MP.
Jordanian rapper sues Netanyahu over campaign clip.
Tunisia says 4 policemen killed in Al-Qaeda attack.
Airstrike on Niger village kills up to 30.
Bosnian police arrests alleged supporters of ISIS.
Gay Catholic group gets VIP treatment at Vatican.
Nigeria claims over 300 Boko Haram fighters killed in town recapture
Jihad Watch Site Latest Reports
Obama: “Many Muslim Americans across our country are worried and afraid”
UK: Muslim teacher fined for posting pro-Hitler image on FB aimed at Jews
Copenhagen imam day before jihad murder at synagogue: Muhammad didn’t dialogue
with Jews, he fought them
Muslim stabs non-Muslims; WaPo: “Man stabs two at a bus stop after asking them
if they’re Muslim”.
Mehdi Hasan blames Muslim attack on non-Muslims on “anti-Muslim hate speech”.
White House touts Boston’s success in “countering violent extremism”.
Sudan President: CIA, Mossad behind Boko Haram, Islamic State.
Holder: “Radical Islam, Islamic extremism – you know, I’m not sure an awful lot
is gained by saying that”.
Muslim cleric rejects that Earth revolves around the Sun.
The Atlantic: “The Islamic State is Islamic. Very Islamic.”
Video: Walking in Paris while Jewish
Egyptians mourn Coptic Christians
beheaded by ISIS
By ARIEL COHEN/J.Post/02/18/2015
The Egyptian government knew of the disappearance of the victims 45 days before
their death, but refrained from taking action to rescue them. Hundreds of
Christians gathered at a Coptic mass at Saint Mark's Coptic Orthodox Cathedral
in Cairo on Tuesday evening.
Families of the victims also gathered in the church. Of the 21 men executed by
Islamic State, all were Christian. The Copts were taken hostage by the Islamic
State last month while residing in Surt, Libya. In the video produced by Islamic
State media, “A Message Signed with Blood to the Nation of the Cross,” the Copts
were beheaded by the militants. In the video, militants suggested that these
killings were in response to both the death of Osama bin Laden as well as a
five-year-old dispute over the disappearance of a Coptic Christian woman.
The Egyptian government knew of the disappearance of the victims 45 days before
their death, but refrained from taking action to rescue them, according to a
statement from the Mapsero Youth Movement. Furthermore, they claim that even
though the families of the victims repeatedly begged the government to
intervene, they choose silence over action. On Sunday, Egyptian President Abdel
Fatah el-Sisi announced seven days of national mourning in reaction to the
killings. In a televised address he said that Egypt would take necessary action
to avenge the deaths. On Monday morning Egypt announced that it had carried out
airstrikes against Islamic State targets in Libya. Egyptian Prime Minister
Ibrahim Mehleb announced in an official statement that the families of the
victims will be granted "martyr privileges," including pensions from the
Ministry of Social Solidarity as well as a new church to be built in Al-Minya,
in honor of the victims.
Lebanese Parliament fails to elect president again, session
postponed to March 11
The Daily Star/Feb. 18, 2015/BEIRUT: Speaker Nabih Berri postponed a
parliamentary session to elect a new president of the republic to March 11,
after the 19th attempt to break the nine-month-long presidential deadlock failed
Wednesday. Like previous attempts, the 19th session to elect a head of state was
doomed to fail over a lack of quorum, owing to the absence of an accord between
the rival factions on a consensus candidate. Some 56 lawmakers representing the
March 14 coalition attended parliament for Wednesday's session. There have been
19 sessions over the past nine months that have aborted due to ack of a quorum,
raising fears of a prolonged vacancy in the country’s top Christian post.
Lawmakers from MP Michel Aoun’s parliamentary Change and Reform bloc,
Hezbollah’s bloc and its March 8 allies have thwarted a quorum since April 2014
by consistently boycotting parliamentary sessions, demanding an agreement
beforehand with their March 14 rivals over a consensus candidate. The failure to
pick a successor to former President Michel Sleiman, whose six-year tenure came
to an end May 25, has plunged the country into a presidential impasse that has
paralyzed Parliament and is threatening to cripple much the government's work.
Aoun Meets Hariri over Dinner at
Center House
Naharnet/Free Patriotic Movement leader MP Michel Aoun held talks Wednesday
evening with al-Mustaqbal movement chief ex-PM Saad Hariri at the Center House
in downtown Beirut, in the first public meeting between the two leaders since at
least five years.
Future TV said Aoun was accompanied by his son-in-law, Foreign Minister Jebran
Bassil, and that talks were expected to continue over a dinner banquet. For its
part, Hariri's press office said the talks were also attended by the ex-PM's
adviser former MP Ghattas Khoury.
The discussions tackled “the general political situations in the country and the
latest regional developments,” Hariri's office said. Hariri then threw a dinner
banquet in Aoun's honor, the office added. The meeting comes after Bassil
attended on Saturday a rally commemorating the 10th anniversary of the
assassination of Hariri's father, former Prime Minister Rafik Hariri. Al-Akhbar
newspaper reported Wednesday that Bassil represented the FPM after al-Mustaqbal
invited the movement as a positive step towards rapprochement between two sides.
Al-Mustaqbal is already engaged in talks with the FPM's top ally Hizbullah since
December. The representatives of the two parties are discussing ways to limit
sectarian tension and possible ways to resolve the presidential crisis. Bassil
and ex-MP Khoury have held a series of contacts to set the stage for the
meeting, the daily said.
Geagea: Anti-terror strategy must be
in state’s hand
The Daily Star/Feb. 18, 2015
BEIRUT: Lebanese Forces leader Samir Geagea Wednesday agreed with Hezbollah
chief Sayyed Hasan Nasrallah that Lebanon should develop a national strategy to
fight terrorism, but stressed that the power of decision-making must be in the
hands of the government.
"Nasrallah called for the establishment of a national strategy to counter
terrorism, but it must include all parties and the [final] decision should be in
the hands of the state,” Geagea told a news conference. “This strategy should
not mean that Hezbollah will take a decision and then all the Lebanese bear the
consequences,” he added. “Therefore, we hope to reach a national strategy that
does not put us in another place."Geagea said he agrees with Nasrallah that
“terrorism” and “Israel” are Lebanon’s enemy, “but we disagree on who takes the
decision to confront Israel, where? and how?”Geagea also said preliminary talks
between representatives of the Lebanese Forces and Michel Aoun’s Free Patriotic
Movement have come a long way. “There is progress, but we are still looking into
the presidential issue and other issues, too,” he said. “We are now preparing
the basic principles.” "We are working to overcome all the obstacles that some
are trying to create,” Geagea added. “And we will exert every effort to make
this dialogue a success, but so far we have not reached a clear vision on the
presidential election.”Lebanon has been without a president since Michel
Sleiman’s term ended in May with lawmakers failing to elect a successor over
lack of consensus.
Mustaqbal, Hizbullah Begin Discussions
on 'National Anti-Terror Strategy'
NaharnetظAl-Mustaqbal movement and Hizbullah announced Wednesday after their
sixth dialogue session that they explored means to find a “national anti-terror
strategy,” amid a continued dispute between them over the state's role in such a
plan of action. The conferees “discussed the mutual calls for finding a national
anti-terror strategy and the debate was launched over its mechanisms,” the two
parties said in a joint statement. The dialogue session comes in the wake of al-Mustaqbal
movement leader ex-PM Saad Hariri's return to Beirut to take part in a rally
commemorating the tenth anniversary of the assassination of his father, former
premier Rafik Hariri. Although Hariri delivered a sharp-toned speech on the
occasion, he affirmed that dialogue with Hizbullah will continue in order to
“protect Lebanon.”
Hizbullah chief Sayyed Hassan Nasrallah for his part stressed commitment to
dialogue during a speech on Monday, endorsing Hariri's call for devising an
anti-terror strategy. Nasrallah, however, responded to Hariri's demand that
Hizbullah withdraw its fighters from Syria by calling on all Lebanese to “go
together to Syria and Iraq” to combat “the threat of terrorism.” In an interview
on Future TV, Interior Minister Nouhad al-Mashnouq said discussions over the
sought strategy consumed three hours of the sixth dialogue session.
“It is necessary to find a national anti-terror strategy under the sponsorship
of the state, and we must exert efforts to combat terrorism on the basis of
national consensus, away from some parties' regional alliances and commitments,”
Mashnouq, who took part in the session, told the TV network. Meanwhile, the
joint statement said the two parties “positively evaluated the Bekaa's security
plan and the steps that occurred to remove flags and pictures from various
regions.”The conferees also called on the political forces and leaders to
contribute to the efforts aimed at curbing celebratory gunfire “during all
occasions.”Dialogue between the two parties had kicked off on December 23, 2014.
In previous sessions, the conferees agreed to remove political flags and banners
from the streets to “defuse sectarian tensions,” speaking of “clear progress
that might contribute to consolidating national stability.”
Beirut Port Basin Filling Stops after Truckers Issue
Warning
Naharnet/The head of the truckers syndicate warned on Wednesday that the drivers
will take action after claiming workers resumed filling the controversial fourth
basin at Beirut Port in violation of an agreement that they had reached with
Prime Minister Tammam Salam. The warning of Naim Sawaya prompted work to stop,
Education Minister Elias Bou Saab said. Earlier this month, the drivers
suspended their open-ended strike and work in the basin was halted after Salam
promised to find a solution to the row over the filling in agreement with all
parties, including Christian religious figures. But Sawaya, who heads the
syndicate, told Voice of Lebanon radio (93.3) that the filling resumed on
Wednesday. “We are heading towards escalatory measures,” he said. Bou Saab, who
had previously mediated in the case, told LBCI that he contacted Salam, who said
he had no knowledge about the resumption of activity on the basin. Bou Saab said
the PM confirmed to him that all works would stop until a solution is found. The
truckers syndicate claims that the filling of the basin would end the role of
Beirut Port and harm the economy. Port Officials argue, however, that the
project will give more space to store containers. But there are fears that the
move would direct large vessels to the Port of Tripoli because the fourth basin
will no longer be able to accept big cargo ships. This will allegedly cause
hundreds of Beirut Port employees, mostly truckers, to lose their jobs. The
rival Christian parties back the truckers. Another controversial issue linked to
the filing of the basin is the scrutiny on the manner in which Abdul Rahman
Hourie Company was awarded the $123 million worth contract to carry out the
work.
Berri urges accord ahead of void in
Cabinet
The Daily Star/Feb. 18, 2015 /BEIRUT: Parties must reach an agreement on a
formula to replace the current decision-making mechanism in order to allow for
Cabinet to resume its sessions, Speaker Nabih Berri told his visitors Wednesday.
Three days after Prime Minister Tammam Salam said he would not call for a
Cabinet session until an agreement is reached, Berri told his visitors that
relevant parties must achieve an accord in order to enable government to resume
its work and avoid the negative repercussions caused by the current deadlock. A
weekly Cabinet session scheduled for Thursday has been canceled due to the
aforementioned disagreement over a new decision-making formula. After President
Michel Sleiman’s term ended last May, Cabinet adopted a system which requires
unanimous backing among all 24 ministers to approve decisions. With the
presidential seat still vacant, the government is still exercising the powers of
the president. The current system, not stipulated in the Constitution, allows
any minister to veto a decision, which has led to a political impasse. The
speaker also expressed his concern over the ongoing paralysis of state
institutions, urging a solution to tackle hindrances to the government’s work.
Best of friends: Geagea, Aoun trade birthday tweets
The Daily Star/Feb. 18, 2015 /BEIRUT: Political rivalry did not stop Lebanese
Forces leader Samir Geagea from extending his heartfelt wishes to Free Patriotic
Movement chief Michel Aoun, who celebrated his 80th birthday Tuesday. “I hope
that we will have achieved [a] full agreement before your next birthday” Geagea
said to Aoun on his official Twitter page. The FPM leader responded by
thanking Geagea for his greetings and expressed a tinge of birthday optimism by
anticipating that an accord would be reached before next year. “I hope our
agreement will be achieved by the end of the fasting period so that we present
it as a gift to the Lebanese,” Aoun tweeted in reference the Lenten fast which
ends on April 5. Aoun and Geagea are the country's two main presidential
candidates, but neither currently has enough support in Lebanon's divided
Parliament to win the election. Preparations are currently underway for talks
between the two rival politicians that aim to achieve Christian rapprochement to
end the presidential election impasse. Though the two have yet to meet, an
agenda for dialogue sessions has been set and preliminary talks are being
carried out in anticipation for the meeting.
U.S. Downplays Lebanon's Boycott of
Washington Conference
Naharnet/A U.S. diplomat underestimated Lebanon's decision to boycott a
conference expected to be held in Washington after Beirut claimed that it cannot
take part in a meeting to confront terrorism with the Jewish state's
participation. “Cooperation between the Lebanese and U.S. security agencies is
ongoing,” the diplomatic source said in comments published in al-Liwaa newspaper
on Wednesday. Washington, according to the daily, informed Lebanon its regret
that Foreign Minister Jebran Bassil will not take part in the conference.
However, the diplomat pointed out that Interior Minister Nouhad Mashnouq will
head to Washington in March upon a formal invitation. Media reports said that
Washington received an official apology from Lebanon on its participation in the
“White House conference on efforts to counter violent extremism,” as Beirut
argued it cannot be a “partner with Israel in confronting terrorism.” More than
60 countries, including 14 Arab nations and Israel, are expected to take part in
the summit slated on February 18 at the White House and presided by U.S.
President Barack Obama. The White House planned the conference in light of the
recent shootings in France and earlier attacks in Canada and Australia. The
meetings are expected to continue the next day where the foreign ministers will
meet at the headquarters of the U.S. State Department, headed by Secretary of
State John Kerry. The third day is devoted to meetings of experts and
specialized committees in Washington. Bassil has apologized for the
participation in the conference after consultations with Prime Minister Tammam
Salam.
The Islamic State controls several areas in Syria and Iraq and aims to spread to
Lebanon as its fighters position in the outskirts of Bekaa towns bordering Syria
and the Lebanese army is in adamant efforts to stop their efforts to infiltrate
the country.
Gay Catholic group gets VIP treatment at Vatican for first
time
Philip Pullella| Reuters/Feb. 18, 2015
VATICAN CITY: A prominent American Catholic gay rights group was given VIP
treatment for the first time at an audience with Pope Francis Wednesday, a move
members saw as a sign of change in the Roman Catholic Church. "This is a sign of
movement that's due to the Francis effect," said Sister Jeannine Gramick,
co-founder of New Ways Ministry, which ministers to homosexual Catholics and
promotes gay rights in the 1.2 billion-member Church. Gramick and executive
director Francis DeBernardo led a pilgrimage of 50 homosexual Catholics to the
audience in St. Peter's Square. They told Reuters in an interview afterwards
that when the group came to Rome on Catholic pilgrimages during the papacies of
Francis's predecessors John Paul and Benedict, "they just ignored us." This
time, a U.S. bishop and a top Vatican official backed their request and they sat
in a front section with dignitaries and special Catholic groups. As the pope
passed, they sang "All Are Welcome," a hymn symbolizing their desire for a more
inclusive Church. A list of participants released by the Vatican listed "a group
of lay people accompanied by a sister" but did not mention that they were a gay
rights organization. "What this says is that there is movement in our Church,
movement to welcome people from the outside closer to the inside," Gramick said
in St. Peter's Square.
Several months after his election, Francis made his now-famous remark about how
he could not judge gay people who are have good will and are seeking God. But he
so far shown no sign the Church will change its teaching that while
homosexuality is not sinful, homosexual acts are. Last October, bishops from
around the world meeting in Rome to debate questions concerning family issued an
interim report calling for greater acceptance of gays in the Church. That
passage was watered down in the final version of the report after conservative
bishops complained. A second and final meeting on family issues is scheduled for
October. DeBernardo said Catholic gay and lesbian couples and other
non-traditional families should be invited to the meeting, known as a synod, to
speak to the bishops about their faith and their sexuality
Hariri, UN official discuss Lebanon, region
The Daily Star/Feb. 18, 2015/BEIRUT: Former Prime Minister Saad Hariri met with
U.N. Special Coordinator for Lebanon Sigrid Kaag to discuss the presidential
election stalemate, the Syrian refugee crisis, as well as other developments in
the region. “It is natural that the meeting dealt with the situation in Lebanon
and the region, with a particular focus on security and stability,” Kaag said
following the meeting at Hariri’s Downtown Beirut residence, according to a
statement from Hariri’s office. She said the meeting also tackled important
issues such as the presidential deadlock and the social and economic impact of
the Syrian crisis on Lebanon. “We discussed the necessary support needed for the
[Syrian] refugees ... in addition to the need for continued support for all
efforts made by the [Lebanese] government and Lebanese partners to maintain
Lebanon’s stability and isolate it from any dangers and threats,” Kaag added.
She also underlined the importance of respecting U.N. Security Council
Resolution 1701, while pledging support for the government of Prime Minister
Tammam Salam. The statement said Hariri also held separate meetings with Economy
Minister Alain Hakim and a Kataeb Party delegation composed of MPs Elie Marouni,
Nadim Gemayel, Samer Saadeh and Fadi Habr.
Jumblatt sticks to Nusra stance after
Nasrallah call out
The Daily Star/Feb. 17, 2015/BEIRUT: Progressive Socialist Party leader Walid
Jumblatt defended Tuesday his refusal to classify the Nusra Front as a terrorist
organization, one day after Hezbollah chief Sayyed Hasan Nasrallah called him
out over his stance. In a televised speech Monday, Nasrallah insisted that no
distinction should be made between ISIS and the Nusra Front, Al-Qaeda's
affiliate in Syria. Without addressing him by name, Nasrallah called on Walid
Jumblatt to explain his logic behind distinguishing between the two.
“As long as there is a single Syrian fighting Bashar Assad’s terrorist regime,
then I am with this Syrian,” the PSP chief wrote in a post on his Twitter
account after several users questioned his logic. “This is my opinion, I know it
won’t change many of the equations being drawn up for the region, but my
conscience is clear,” he added. Jumblatt has in the past noted that Nusra is
made up of Syrians, whereas ISIS includes jihadis from all over the world. But
he has never explicitly said that he supports the Nusra Front, which was behind
several car bombs and suicide attacks in Lebanon, in addition to the killing of
two Lebanese captive servicemen on the outskirts of Arsal.
Hezbollah demands France release Georges Abdallah
The Daily Star/Feb. 17, 2015/BEIRUT: Hezbollah deputy chief Naim Qassem Tuesday
condemned France's ongoing imprisonment of leftist militant Georges Ibrahim
Abdallah. “We call on France to release Georges Abdallah as soon as possible,
and we consider his continued detention to be a blatant violation of human
rights,” Qassem said in a statement released by the Hezbollah media office after
meeting with representatives from the International Campaign for the Release of
Georges Ibrahim Abdallah. The remarks were the first by a ranking official
in Hezbollah to demand the release of Abdallah, but the party in 2013 released a
statement of support. Abdallah was arrested in Lyon in October 1984 and
condemned three years later to life in prison for alleged involvement in the
killing of an Israeli diplomat and an American military attache in Paris in
1982.
Abdallah has maintained his innocence.
Abdallah should have been freed in 1999 by virtue of France's penal code, but
Paris has rejected nine appeals for his release. His supporters have accused the
United States and Israel of lobbying to keep Abdallah behind bars. Under the
French judicial system, a life sentence means 15 years in prison, after which
the prisoner has the right to demand his release. In 2013, French courts
accepted a request to release Abdallah, and within the 24-hour deadline, no
appeals were made. His supporters in Lebanon were preparing his reception and
the date of his return was set. But then-Interior Minister of France Manuel
Valls denied the deportation order. Hezbollah had maintained a low profile in
supporting his release, with party official Ghaleb Abu Zeinab once explaining
that the party did not want its support to be negatively exploited.But on
Tuesday Qassem openly denounced French authorities over the delay in releasing
Abdallah, accusing the United States of exerting pressure on France to keep him
behind bars.
“Is American pressure... more important than France’s dignity?” he asked.
Kirkuk is just one question mark for
the Kurds
David Ignatius/The Daily Star
Feb. 17, 2015
From the roof of his office, Gov. Najmaldin Karim can see multiethnic Kirkuk
laid out below. He points toward the Sunni suburb of Huwija about 24 kilometers
west, which is controlled by ISIS. Two weeks ago, the extremists staged a
ferocious assault there that almost broke through the defense lines. “ISIS has
its eyes on Kirkuk. It is the big prize for them,” Karim says. This very
morning, a gray day when poor visibility favored the attackers, ISIS launched an
artillery and mortar strike in a Sunni suburb called Daquq, south of the city.
Coalition airstrikes have pounded ISIS targets in Kirkuk twice this week.Kirkuk
sits uneasily on the fault line between Kurdistan to the east, the Shiite-led
Baghdad government to the south, and Sunni regions to the west. Karim is a Kurd
himself, and a member of one of its big political parties, the Patriotic Union
of Kurdistan. But “as governor, I’m governor of everybody,” he insists.Kirkuk
illustrates the dilemmas facing the Kurdish regional government in Irbil, about
an hour’s drive north.
The Kurds regard Kirkuk as part of their ancestral homeland, and the Iraqi
constitution calls for a referendum in which the city’s Kurdish majority could
vote to leave the orbit of Baghdad and become part of Kurdistan.But can the
Kurds swallow Kirkuk without choking on the other groups that live here? Karim
reckons that Kurds make up a little over 50 percent of the Kirkuk population,
while Sunnis account for 32 percent to 35 percent and Turkmen 13 percent to 14
percent. It’s a microcosm of the larger Iraqi ethnic puzzle.For now, the common
enemy of ISIS seems to be bringing Iraqis together in the city. The Kurdish
peshmerga rings Kirkuk and provides the most important security force. But
inside the city, security is managed by a local police force that Karim says is
roughly 39 percent Arab, 36 percent Kurd and 26 percent Turkmen. “If they say
it’s only the Kurds who are keeping order in the city, that’s not true,” Karim
argues. Karim says he favors a special status for Kirkuk within Kurdistan, like
what Quebec has in Canada. But Falah Mustafa Bakir, Kurdistan’s minister for
foreign affairs, rejects this formula. “We have waited too long,” he says in an
interview in his office in Irbil. “We don’t want to continue with transition and
delay.
”Kirkuk is just one of the question marks for a Kurdistan that, in many ways,
has been the great Iraqi success story. The region has security, jobs and most
of all, the dynamism of a homogenous population where nearly everyone shares the
same dream of eventual Kurdish independence.But Kurdistan also has some mundane
problems, starting with corruption. The territory is run by traditional
political parties dominated by the Barzani and Talabani clans, who have
historically controlled the Kurdish Democratic Party and the PUK, respectively.
Having the right connections, and greasing them with some cash, has become a way
of life here.It’s “absolutely right” that Kurdistan has been weakened by
corruption, concedes Masrour Barzani, the chief of the regional security council
who oversees all intelligence activities. “We don’t claim perfection,” Bakir
agrees, but he argues that corruption in Kurdistan is far less than the circus
of thievery in Baghdad.
The ruling KDP government gave a smaller reform party known as “Change” control
of the Finance Ministry and oversight of the peshmerga. But when asked if these
reforms have removed payoffs and nepotism, a prominent local businessman just
rolls his eyes.Even the Kurds’ beloved peshmerga had its troubles in the first
days of the war against ISIS last August. “The pesh had been dormant for a long
time,” Barzani explains. Some inexperienced commanders buckled, and grizzled
veterans had to be mobilized. Since August, they’ve lost more than 1,000 killed
in action and over 4,500 wounded. The Kurds still want their own country
someday, but for now they are still Iraqis.Kurdistan’s problems are manageable,
if leaders take them seriously. The danger is that corruption and political
tension could weaken the foundations of the Kurdish region, just as they have
the rest of Iraq. For now, the Kurds maintain the strongest platform in the
region – and they’ve done the best job in battling ISIS. But nothing lasts
forever. Kurdistan must solve the problems of success as well as it did those of
centuries of isolation and betrayal.
**David Ignatius is published twice weekly by THE DAILY STAR.
Iran faces an uphill battle in Yemen
Tariq Alhomayed/Asharq Al Awsat
Tuesday, 17 Feb, 2015
The Yemeni crisis has reached a critical moment of truth. The Gulf and the
international community have both declared their opposition to the Houthi coup,
with these stances resulting in the subsequent closure of several foreign
embassies in Sana’a, leaving the Houthi coup without international cover bar
Iran’s support. By “critical” above I mean that five regions in Yemen oppose the
Houthis coup, with the remaining one accepting it only partially through
coercion, oppression and violence.
Well, what is the mood in the Gulf right now, particularly since it is the party
that is now communicating with the international community and explaining what
should be done in Yemen?
According to reports I have personally heard from several well-informed Gulf
sources, the Gulf Cooperation Council (GCC)—which launched the main initiative
that led to Ali Abdullah Saleh’s departure from power in 2012—has resolved its
position on the issue and will not tolerate any laxity here.
“Yemen has changed, and we have to think in a different way devoid of emotions,”
one source said.
According to another source, what happened in Yemen was “a full-fledged coup and
will not be accepted by the international community or neighboring countries.”
“No country keen about its security can accept the presence of a militia armed
with weapons coming from countries with whom it shares its borders,” the source
added.
“The Houthi coup and efforts to legitimize it provide a recipe for a sectarian
civil war. No peaceful solution can be reached without things returning to
normal, and weapons, particularly the medium and heavy ones, being returned to
the state, as well as dialogue being resumed,” he said.
Of course, the Gulf’s view of this dialogue has changed drastically. Gulf states
are seeking genuine dialogue with guarantees, particularly since the Houthis,
according to the source, previously signed “more than 65 agreements without
complying with any of them, instead using these agreements as a way to catch
their breath before continuing their march towards the other regions.”
As such, GCC countries believe the next agreement, if it ever takes place, will,
naturally enough, differ from the previous ones. This is a natural result,
particularly after Iran’s involvement in the Houthi coup became apparent to
everyone. It was therefore remarkable that this week’s UN resolution on Yemen,
unanimously adopted by the Security Council, called for an end to foreign
intervention in the country—by Iran of course.
So, in case a future agreement on Yemen is reached, will the Gulf again fall
victim to Saleh and the Houthis’ machinations? And how will Iran be dealt with?
What I heard was remarkable: reports suggest that Saleh and the Houthis have
sent several messages, all with the same content: “Rest assured.”
Another Gulf source told me: “We are confident and reassured as to our ability
to maintain our security and [protect] our borders, and the ones who should be
sent messages of assurance are the Yemeni people, from across the spectrum. The
Yemenis are fed up with Saleh’s ploys and the Houthis’ treachery.”
But it was what one source said about Iran that particularly stood out: “Those
who think that the bisht of Qom can protect against the Yemeni thorns should
reassess their calculations quickly.”
The bisht, a cloak worn by clerics from the Iranian city of Qom, indeed cannot
protect Iran from the pricks of the Yemeni thorns. And we should not forget
either that Tehran is yet to get a taste of the Yemeni dagger.
Information about the US-Iranian nuclear dialogue is no longer “sensitive.” For
Obama it’s a done deal
DEBKAfile Special Report February 17, 2015
Some US and Israeli media have reported that the Obama administration reduced
the exchange with Israel of sensitive information about its nuclear negotiations
with Iran - because Binyamin Netanyahu has leaked “details of the US position to
the media.”
This is a skewed account of the situation. The fact is that US President Barack
Obama and Iran’s President Hassan Rouhani have agreed on the final draft of a
comprehensive nuclear accord. Its terms are therefore an open secret. The deal
would be in the bag if Iran’s paramount leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei could be
brought round to endorsing it.
For now, Washington and Tehran are using media spin tactics in an effort to
persuade him. Those tactics were dismissed as “unprofessional media games,” by
Iranian Foreign Minister spokeswoman Marzieh Afkham Sunday, Feb. 15, when she
denied a Wall Street Journal report that Khamenei had answered a letter from the
US president.
"There has been no new letter from Iran's side," she asserted in reference to a
letter from Obama to Khamenei last October which, according to the US press,
suggested cooperation with Iran in fighting the Islamic State.
No reference was made to the nuclear issue in her remarks. The Iranian leader
preserves a sphinx-like silence, which has nothing to do with Binyamin
Netanyahu, but does in fact refute Obama’s propaganda game that pins the blame
on the Israeli prime minister.
For five years, Obama ran a back-channel dialogue with Iran. Then too he kept
its content secret not just from Israel but from other closely affected allies,
Saudi Arabia and certain Gulf emirates. Israel at times offered Washington
relevant intelligence on Iran, but was rebuffed.
The Israeli opposition campaigning against Netanyahu and his Likud party for the
March 17 election has seized on this dispute to accuse him of jeopardizing the
country’s strong ties of friendship with the United States - when in fact it is
a one-on-one brawl with the US president.
Relations would be seriously harmed only if Obama went all the way and cut off
military and intelligence ties, a step that would hurt America’s strategic
interests no less than Israel’s.
And indeed, Philip Gordon, the Middle East director for President Obama’s
National Security Council, arrived in Israel Monday, Feb. 16 for meetings with
Israeli national security adviser Yossi Cohen and Intelligence Minister Yuval
Steinitz.
Only last week, Washington had to admit that US intelligence had been taken by
surprise by the fall of the pro-American regime in Yemen and Sanaa’s takeover by
the Iranian-backed rebel Houthis. While reluctant to admit as much, the
administration was deeply disappointed by this act of deceit by Tehran, on which
the White House counts heavily for military and intelligence cooperation as a
trusted ally in the future war against the Islamic State.
Out of Obama’s intelligence loop on Iran, Israel may be equally reluctant to
share its intelligence data on Yemen or even on the situation in Syria and Iraq.
Israel’s Netanyahu is not the only Middle East stand-out against Obama’s Iranian
policy. Other leaders are in even worse relations with Washington. The Obama
administration and Egyptian President Abdel-Fatteh El-Sisi are not even on
talking terms, much like the late Saudi monarch Abdullah who died last month.
His successor, King Salman has yet to make his intentions towards the United
States known.
New partners in struggle against terrorism
Yohanan Plesner/Ynetnews
Published: 02.18.15
Op-ed: We in Israel join our Danish friends as they mourn terrible incident, but
we also call on them to join us in helping to lead Europe and West in an
uncompromising war on terrorism.
If there is anything we should avoid saying right now, when the Danish people
are grieving over the terrorist attack and mourning its victims, it is remarks
of the sort that have often been typical of us Israelis: “Now you’ll finally
understand what we have been going through all these years, what we are
experiencing, and why we must combat terrorism.”
At such a time, Israel's leadership should be transmitting a different message,
one that is less confrontational and more inclusive: a message of partnership
among democracies battling terrorism without sacrificing their democratic
values. Such a campaign requires striking a balance between competing values,
and steps that will minimize the violation of fundamental rights while guarding
national security.
Denmark has already shown that it knows how to take drastic measures to
safeguard its security. During the last decade, under its previous two prime
ministers, Lars Løkke Rasmussen and his predecessor Anders Fogh Rasmussen,
Denmark's immigration regulations have been amended and made more stringent
several times over. Cameras and inspectors have been stationed at its borders,
restricting the free movement of migrants who do not have a residency permit.
During his tenure, Lars Løkke Rasmussen was assailed for this by other members
of the European Union, on the grounds that he is harming the vision of a “Europe
without borders.” But he has remained firm, justifying his actions on national
security grounds.
The Danish people must now serve as an example to Europe in another way: Denmark
must encourage all the countries of the EU, and in fact the entire Western
world, to establish a set of clear cut rules for democratic countries involved
in the war on terror. In Israel we have been doing this for years, because we
understand that military operations alone will never defeat terrorism.
An effective war against terrorism cannot be fought without a legal and moral
defense, which is essential both for internal justification and to protect
against external charges and suits that may be filed—and indeed are already
being filed—with international tribunals such as the International Criminal
Court in The Hague.
A democracy that delves deeply into these issues and tries to clarify them for
itself encounters many dilemmas: Is administrative detention—also known as
preventive detention—a legitimate tool? Israel employs this measure occasionally
in the areas that may one day be part of a Palestinian state; but ought it also
be exercised in sovereign territories?
Is it acceptable to deviate from regular procedures when the security services
deem it essential? If so, to what extent? Can detention be extended beyond its
normal duration?
When the conflict spirals into actual hostilities, the dilemmas that we know all
too well become even more challenging: Should possible harm to innocent
bystanders rule out military action? Is it legitimate to raid religious sites
that are suspected of harboring terrorists or of serving as hotbeds of
incitement?
Israel has been dealing with these questions for many years. Now France,
Denmark, Britain, and Sweden are beginning to face the very same issues. The
last Knesset made progress in drafting a comprehensive anti-terrorism law that
includes guidelines for dealing with “supporting organizations”; however, it was
not passed into law. The new Knesset will have to complete this legislation.
At the same time, the Knesset would be well advised to engage in a joint effort
with our friends in Europe to enact laws and define norms that will meet
international standards and that perhaps will be adopted by other countries as
well.
We in Israel join in sympathy with our Danish friends as they mourn this
terrible incident. But we also call on them to join us in helping to lead Europe
and the West in an uncompromising war on terrorism, while holding on dearly to
our most cherished, democratic values.
**Yohanan Plesner is the president of the Israel Democracy Institute, home of
the Center for National Security and Democracy, and the chairman of the
Association of Friends of Denmark in Israel.