LCCC ENGLISH DAILY
NEWS BULLETIN
June 25/2013
Bible Quotation for
today/Victory through Christ
02 Corinthians02/14/17: "But thanks be to
God! For in union with Christ we are always led by God as prisoners in
Christ's victory procession. God uses us to make the knowledge about
Christ spread everywhere like a sweet fragrance. For we are like a
sweet-smelling incense offered by Christ to God, which spreads among
those who are being saved and those who are being lost. For those who
are being lost, it is a deadly stench that kills; but for those who are
being saved, it is a fragrance that brings life. Who, then, is capable
for such a task? We are not like so many others, who handle God's
message as if it were cheap merchandise; but because God has sent us, we
speak with sincerity in his presence, as servants of Christ."
Latest analysis, editorials, studies, reports, letters & Releases from miscellaneous sources
Women’s rights and the
threat of Islamism/By: Iqbal Al-Ahmad/Asharq
Alawsat/June 25/13
Opinion: The Muslim
Brotherhood has failed in Egypt/Tariq Alhomayed/Asharq
Alawsat/June 25/13
Latest News Reports From Miscellaneous Sources for June 25/13
Lebanese Army Storms Asir's
Security Zone, Cleric Disappears after 16 Troops
Martyred
Lebanese Army Command Stresses
Keenness on Places of Worship, Vows to 'Suppress
Sedition'
Miqati, Salam, ex-PMs Reject
Attacks on Army, Urge Closure of 'All Security
Apartments, Zones'
Hariri: We Will Remain with
Army, Every Outlaw Must be Dealt with in Same Manner
Hizbullah Condemns Sidon
Clashes: Army Guarantor for Civil Peace in Lebanon
Geagea Meets Suleiman: Asir
Phenomenon Product of Hizbullah Phenomenon
Al-Rahi Lashes out at
'Executioners,' Says Attack on Institutions is 'High
Treason'
Mouawad Contacts Qahwaji:
Persistence of Illegitimate Arms Paves Way for Strife
Sami Gemayel Calls for Curfew
in Sidon, Beirut, Tripoli to Avert More Unrest
Fadel Shaker’s Brother Killed
in Abra Clashes
Aoun Links Sidon Clashes to
Uncontrolled Flow of Syrian Refugees into Lebanon
France Expresses ‘Great
Concern’ over Sidon Clashes
Plumbly Stresses Need to
Cooperate with Suleiman, State Institutions to Ensure
Stability in Lebanon
Arab League Warns of Severity
of Targeting Lebanese Army
Riyadh Voices Concern over
Sidon Clashes, Urges End to Fighting for Stability's
Sake
Abbas Rejects ‘All
Interference’ in Lebanese Affairs in Phone Call with
Suleiman
Syria Says Assad Won't Cede
Power at Geneva Meet
Washington Urges Russia to
Return Snowden to U.S.
Egypt PM Condemns 'Heinous'
Attack on 4 Shiites
As Egypt lurches into civil
strife, local militias raise their heads. Obama keeps
faith with Brotherhood
France Expresses ‘Great Concern’ over
Sidon Clashes
Naharnet/France on Monday expressed “great concern” over the violence in the
southern city of Sidon, condemning attacks against the military
institution.“France strongly condemns the attacks targeting the army that have
resulted in the death or injury of several troops,” foreign ministry spokesman
Philippe Lalliot said.He added: “We support efforts made by President Michel
Suleiman to safeguard security and draw an end to provocations whatever was
their source.”“We call on the political parties to work for civil peace and
stability in the country.”Sidon’s clashes between the army and supporters of
Salafist cleric Sheikh Ahmed al-Asir have resulted in the death of at least 16
troops.The southern city’s clashes are one of the most intense bouts of violence
in Lebanon linked to the conflict in Syria.
SourceAgence France Presse
Plumbly Stresses Need to Cooperate with Suleiman, State Institutions to Ensure
Stability in Lebanon
Naharnet/United Nations Special Coordinator for Lebanon Derek Plumbly condemned
on Monday the clashes in the southern city of Sidon, extending his sympathy to
Army Commander General Jean Qahwaji and to the families of those who have been
killed in the fighting. He said: “We are at one in our support for President
Michel Suleiman, for the institutions of the state and for the security forces,
and in particular the army, at this difficult juncture.”“We stress the need for
all concerned throughout the country to work with them to ensure the security
and stability Lebanon’s people deserve, and to keep Lebanon safe from conflict,”
he added. He made his remarks after a meeting with the five ambassadors of the
permanent members of the U.N. Security Council to discuss recent developments
with regard both to U.N. Security Council resolution 1701, on which U.N.
Secretary General Ban Ki-moon will soon issue a further report, and to the
situation in Lebanon.
Plumbly continued: “I would like again to emphasize the important role played by
the Lebanese security and armed forces in sustaining Lebanon’s national unity
and sovereignty.”“I and the ambassadors were unanimous in deploring the recent
challenge to the rule of law in Sidon, and attacks on the Lebanese armed forces
there and elsewhere,” he stated. “We stress the importance of the protection of
civilians and look forward to the early restoration of order in the city,” said
the U.N. official.Clashes broke out on Sunday between the army and supporters of
Salafist cleric Sheikh Ahmed al-Asir in the southern city of Sidon.The military
command said the number of troops killed in the fighting rose to 12. There were
also more than 50 injuries among the ranks of the soldiers, but it was not clear
how many fighters were killed in the unrest.
The clashes erupted when al-Asir's supporters surrounded an army checkpoint in
the area, where a vehicle transporting other supporters of the cleric had been
stopped.
After the armed men attacked the troops with gunfire, the army fired back.Later
on Monday, U.S. Ambassador to Lebanon Maura Connelly met with Prime
Minister-designate Tammam Salam to address the latest developments in Lebanon.
Connelly expressed the United States’ strong condemnation of the violent clashes
in Sidon and conveyed her country’s deepest sympathies and condolences for the
deaths and injury of Lebanese army members and innocent civilians. She called on
all parties “to exercise restraint and respect for Lebanon’s stability and
security as well as the safety of civilians.”She further praised the efforts of
the army and Internal Security Forces in working with political leaders to
maintain peace and stability, underscoring the United States’ commitment to
continue providing training and equipment to assist security forces in their
critical role of preserving Lebanon’s unity. Connelly reiterated the United
States position that government formation is a Lebanese process and that the
Lebanese people deserve a government that reflects their aspirations and that
strengthens Lebanon's stability, sovereignty, and independence while fulfilling
its international obligations. The ambassador renewed the commitment of the
United States to a stable, sovereign, and independent Lebanon.
Riyadh Voices Concern over Sidon Clashes, Urges End to
Fighting for Stability's Sake
Naharnet/Saudi Arabia on Monday voiced “extreme concern” over the
deadly clashes in the southern port city of Sidon between the Lebanese army and
gunmen loyal to Islamist cleric Sheikh Ahmed al-Asir.
In a statement recited by Saudi Culture and Information Minister Abdul Aziz
Khoja – the former ambassador to Lebanon – after cabinet's weekly meeting under
the chairmanship of King Abdullah, Riyadh “expressed extreme concern over the
development of the situations in southern Lebanon and the clashes in the city of
Sidon.”It also urged all parties to “halt the fighting and not to escalate the
situation in order to preserve the security and stability of brotherly
Lebanon.”Sixteen troops have been killed and more than 50 wounded in the
clashes, the army said in a statement.A source close to Asir said at least five
of his supporters had also been killed.
Abbas Rejects ‘All Interference’ in Lebanese Affairs in Phone Call with Suleiman
Naharnet /Mahmoud Abbas on Sunday stated his rejection of "any interference" in
Lebanese affairs.“We stress the rejection of the Palestinian factions of any
interference in Lebanese affairs,” Abbas said in a phone call with President
Michel Suleiman. He added: “We support the steps taken by the Lebanese state to
prevent sedition and preserve stability and security in (the southern city of)
Sidon.” Sidon’s clashes between the supporters of Salafist cleric Sheikh Ahmed
al-Asir and the army spilled over to the Palestinian refugee camp of Ain el-Helweh
where army checkpoints repeatedly came under fire.LBCI television also noted
that “intense fighting” took place in the area of Taamir Ain el-Hilweh between
the army and Fatah al-Islam and Jund al-Sham militants. The clashes in the
southern city, which are one of the most intense bouts of violence in Lebanon
linked to the conflict in Syria, resulted in the death of at least 16 troops.
Arab League Warns of Severity of Targeting Lebanese Army
Naharnet/The Arab League condemned on Monday the attack against the Lebanese
army by supporters of Salafist cleric Sheikh Ahmed al-Asir in the southern city
of Sidon on Sunday, calling on all Lebanese powers to exert efforts to avert
strife.Arab League chief Nabil al-Arabi warned of the “dangerousness of
targeting the army,” demanding that the assailants be arrested and brought to
justice.“Supporting the army will help it perform its national duties seeing as
it is the symbol of Lebanon's unity, security, and stability,” he said. He also
called on all political and religious leaderships to tackle the deteriorating
security situation in Sidon in order to protect the people.Sixteen soldiers have
been killed in the clashes, the army said Monday, in violence tied to rising
sectarian tensions fanned by the Syria conflict. The fighting began on Sunday on
the outskirts of Sidon and intensified on Monday.The security cabinet pledged
the military would fight until it "finishes with" al-Asir. A military judge
issued a warrant for the controversial cleric's arrest, a judicial source
said.The violence is among the worst in Lebanon since the start of the Syrian
conflict, which has inflamed sectarian tensions in the country, particularly
between Shiite supporters of the Damascus regime and Sunni backers of the
uprising.
Army Storms Asir's Security Zone, Cleric Disappears after 16 Troops Martyred
Naharnet/..The army on Monday stormed the security zone of Sheikh Ahmed al-Asir's
mosque in the Sidon suburb of Abra and arrested a number of gunmen as the
Islamist cleric fled to an unknown destination, following clashes that left 16
troops martyred. Several local TV networks aired live footage showing army
troops advancing into Asir's security zone and arresting a number of his gunmen.
Volleys of machinegun fire were being heard in Abra as the army scoured the
security zone, while smoke could be seen billowing from some buildings in the
area. "The army has arrested gunmen of Arab nationalities in al-Asir's security
zone," al-Manar television reported.
A security source confirmed to OTV that al-Asir was not found in the security
zone. Voice of Lebanon radio (93.3) said al-Asir and his close aide Fadel Shaker
"managed to flee the security zone in Abra around 4:00 pm with the help of armed
groups." MTV said al-Asir and Shaker fled the mosque through its backdoor and
headed to the Ain el-Hilweh Palestinian refugee camp, where they have hardline
Islamist allies.
"The army is saying that al-Asir is not among the captives, the wounded or the
dead," LBCI television reported.
But later on Monday, Free Syrian Army political adviser Bassam al-Dada told LBCI
that "al-Asir is in the custody of the FSA and he is now inside Syria." Earlier,
reports said al-Asir was entrenched in the mosque while sources said he managed
to escape in an ambulance to an unknown location. LBCI also said that the
Lebanese Red Cross transported more than 20 bodies of gunmen from the security
zone in Abra.As they closed in on al-Asir's complex in Abra in the morning
hours, army units came under sniper fire from his gunmen, who sought to push the
soldiers back. Snipers from high-rise buildings helped the fighters in their
quest to defend the mosque. Earlier, scores of employees at Sidon's Serail, that
lies near Abra, escaped to safety after the building was hit with gunfire.
Gunmen also blocked the road near Sidon's Sea Castle. But the military later
reopened it.
Many people living on high floors came down or fled to safer areas, while others
were seen running away from fighting areas carrying children. Others remained
locked up in their homes or shops, fearing getting caught in the crossfire. Gray
smoke billowed over parts of the city. The city has come to a standstill as the
military continued to evacuate the residents of the buildings near the mosque.
In parts of the city, drivers waved white sheets from their car windows as they
moved in a bid to protect themselves from sniper fire. State Commissioner to the
Military Court Judge Saqr Saqr issued search and investigation warrants against
al-Asir and 123 others including his brother and Salafist-turned singer Fadel
Shaker. Earlier, al-Asir appealed to his supporters through his Twitter account
in other parts of Lebanon to rise to his help, threatening to widen the scale of
clashes. The military command said the number of troops killed in the fighting
that erupted at noon Sunday rose to 16. There were also more than 50 injuries
among the ranks of the soldiers.
Caretaker Prime Minister Najib Miqati announced a day of mourning on Tuesday,
calling in a memo for a work halt from 12:00 pm till 1:00 pm
Meanwhile, the fighting in Taamir near the Palestinian refugee camp of Ain el-Hilweh
stopped after militants from different nationalities belonging to Jund al-Sham
and Fatah al-Islam clashed with the army to ease the pressure on al-Asir's
gunmen. The fighting also reached the city's markets after masked gunmen began
appearing there. But the army clamped down on them, preventing the clashes from
spiraling out of control. Abra's clashes erupted when al-Asir's supporters
surrounded an army checkpoint in the area, where a vehicle transporting other
supporters of the cleric had been stopped. After the armed men attacked the
troops with gunfire, the army fired back.
The military command vowed on Sunday to "strike back with an iron fist anyone
who... spills the blood of the army.”
It urged political leaders in Sidon to choose sides and to stand either
alongside the army, or with "those who promote strife and the killing of
troops."The clashes in the southern city are one of the most intense bouts of
violence in Lebanon linked to the conflict in Syria. Al-Asir, who is anti-Hizbullah,
supports rebels fighting to oust Syrian President Bashar Assad.
Army Command Stresses Keenness on Places of Worship, Vows to 'Suppress Sedition'
Naharnet /The Army Command on Monday stressed its "keenness on places of
worship" after its troops closed in on Sheikh Ahmed al-Asir's gunmen who
entrenched themselves in the Bilal bin Rabah Mosque in Abra.
"Army units continue their military operations in the city of Sidon and the area
of Abra to stamp down armed activities, arrest those who attacked army positions
and restore security and stability,” the Command said in a statement. “A lot of
gunmen fired sniper shots at army troops while using religious centers as
barricades, in addition to turning innocent civilians into human shields to
avoid direct confrontation with army forces,” the statement added. The Army
Command stressed its “total keenness on places of worship and the lives of
citizens,” while calling on “the gunmen who attacked army positions and citizens
… to surrender their weapons and turn themselves in immediately to army forces
to avoid further bloodshed.”The Command noted that it knows the identities of
the aforementioned gunmen “one by one.”
It stressed that “the army will press on with its efforts to suppress strife,”
adding that its units “will not halt their military operations until security is
fully restored in the city and its surroundings and until everyone abides by law
and order.” The Command also called on citizens, “especially those present in
the conflict zone or inside al-Asir's complex and its surroundings, who are
facing security problems, to contact the Army Command's Operations Directorate
on the phone numbers 1701 and 01422245 in order to address these problems as
soon as possible and evacuate them if necessary.”
In a previous statement, the Command said the number of troops killed in the
fighting that erupted at noon Sunday rose to 16. There were also more than 50
injuries among the ranks of the soldiers.
A source close to Asir said at least five of his supporters had also been
killed.
Fadel Shaker’s Brother Killed in Abra Clashes
Naharnet /The brother of former singer Fadel Shaker was killed on Monday during
the clashes between the army and the gunmen of Salafist cleric Sheikh Ahmed al-Asir
in Abra neighborhood of the southern city of Sidon.
“Abu Abed Shmandour was killed in Monday’s clashes with the army in Abra,” the
state-run National News Agency reported. “Six gunmen were also arrested during
the army’s raids, among them is Abu Abed Shmandour’s son, who was disguised as
veiled woman.”Meanwhile, MTV said that Fadel Shaker fled the Bilal bin Rabah
mosque through its backdoor and headed to the Ain el-Helweh camp.
Radio Voice of Lebanon (93.3) said both men managed to flee the mosque with the
help of armed groups around 4:00 p.m.LBCI television also revealed that the army
seized control of the houses and offices that were occupied by Asir's group,
confiscating quantities of arms, equipment, uniforms and al-Nusra Front flags.
Sidon’s clashes between the army and supporters of Salafist cleric Sheikh Ahmed
al-Asir have resulted in the death of at least 16 troops.The southern city’s
clashes are one of the most intense bouts of violence in Lebanon linked to the
conflict in Syria.
Miqati, Salam, ex-PMs Reject Attacks on Army, Urge Closure of 'All Security
Apartments, Zones'
Naharnet /Caretaker Prime Minister Najib Miqati, Premier-designate Tammam Salam
and the former prime ministers on Monday condemned "any attack on the army,
whichever side it may come from," while demanding the closure of "all security
zones."In a statement issued after a meeting at the Grand Serail, the conferees
"stressed their condemnation and rejection of any attack on the army or any
security institution, whichever side it may come from, because the army is the
shield of the country in the face of disintegration and the undermining of
Lebanon's image and independence.”
And as they stressed their commitment to "the state and its institutions, topped
by the military and security institutions," they called for "putting an end to
futile attempts to put the army in a confrontation with the Sunni sect, while
they are the advocates of the state and law.""We voice our solidarity with our
people in all the regions who are feeling that the law is only being imposed on
them, while it should be imposed on everyone because the state must be
responsible for everyone without selectivity," said the statement which was
recited by Miqati.
The conferees called on the army to "shoulder its responsibilities in a full
manner," urging the Sunni community to "pay attention to the trap that is being
set for them and for the army with the aim of stirring discord between them and
the army."They also called for “implementing a security plan that prevents armed
activities in a comprehensive manner and targets all security zones and security
apartments.”
The prime ministers stressed the importance of “arresting those who attacked the
army and holding them accountable” after conducting an “instant probe.”
And as they warned against being dragged into “the trap of sedition and
divisions,” the conferees underlined the importance of “clinging on to
coexistence and preserving civil peace.”They also emphasized the importance of
dissociation from the Syrian crisis and of abiding by the Baabda Declaration in
order to protect the Lebanese from “regional conflicts.”The prime ministers
called for forming a new cabinet as soon as possible “so that it can shoulder
its responsibilities amid these difficult circumstances.”
Sixteen troops were killed and more than 50 wounded in clashes between the army
and gunmen loyal to Islamist cleric Sheikh Ahmed al-Asir on Sunday and Monday.
A source close to Asir said at least five of his supporters had also been
killed. On Monday afternoon, the army stormed Asir's security zone in the Sidon
suburb of Abra and arrested a number of gunmen as the Islamist cleric fled to an
unknown destination. Abra's clashes erupted when al-Asir's supporters surrounded
an army checkpoint in the area, where a vehicle transporting other supporters of
the cleric had been stopped. After the armed men attacked the troops with
gunfire, the army fired back.Abra is home to a mosque where Asir used to lead
the main weekly prayers on Fridays. The sheikh had claimed that Hizbullah uses
apartments in Abra to keep him under surveillance.He also said the Lebanese army
has provided cover to Hizbullah, whose members are fighting alongside Syrian
President Bashar Assad's troops against rebels.
Hariri: We Will Remain with Army, Every Outlaw Must be Dealt with in Same Manner
Naharnet /Former Prime Minister Saad Hariri on Monday stressed that al-Mustaqbal
movement “will remain with the army,” saying the military institution did the
right thing by confronting Islamist cleric Sheikh Ahmed al-Asir.
“The army offered major sacrifices and we must all embrace it,” Hariri said in
an interview on Future TV.
“We in the al-Mustaqbal movement will remain with the army, no matter what they
are saying and no matter how much they try and our project will remain the
state,” he stressed. “Let no one try to remove us from this path and we will
remain firm and steadfast in this direction,” he went on to say. Hariri revealed
that he has been communicating with Army Commander General Jean Qahwaji “amid
this difficult situation” and saluted President Michel Suleiman “who followed up
continuously on matters,” noting that “his sovereign stances protect Lebanon and
the Lebanese.”
“The main problem in Lebanon is the proliferation of weapons in the hands of
armed groups and this problem will lead to confrontations in the country,”
Hariri pointed out.
“We will continue to say that arms are the main problem in the country,” he
added.Addressing protesters who took to the streets in solidarity with al-Asir,
Hariri said: “Some people are seeking problems and when they block the roads
they are blocking their own roads and this is not a solution.”“The solution is
not in forming groups such as Asir's group to confront the state,” he stressed.
“Perhaps the method (of dealing with al-Asir) was harsh but anything against the
state must be dealt with in the same manner and no one is bigger than his
country, and if anyone believes the opposite, a day will come and they will ask
the state for help and protection,” Hariri noted.“Today, the army made major
sacrifices and it's about time we extended the the mandate of the army commander
and to do something for the army instead of only praising it,” he said. He
called on Sidon's residents to be “patient,” hoping the southern city will
restore its position. Sixteen troops were killed and more than 50 wounded in
clashes between the army and gunmen loyal to Islamist cleric Sheikh Ahmed al-Asir
on Sunday and Monday. A source close to Asir said at least five of his
supporters had also been killed. On Monday afternoon, the army stormed Asir's
security zone in the Sidon suburb of Abra and arrested a number of gunmen as the
Islamist cleric fled to an unknown destination.
Abra's clashes erupted when al-Asir's supporters surrounded an army checkpoint
in the area, where a vehicle transporting other supporters of the cleric had
been stopped.
After the armed men attacked the troops with gunfire, the army fired back. Abra
is home to a mosque where Asir used to lead the main weekly prayers on Fridays.
The sheikh had claimed that Hizbullah uses apartments in Abra to keep him under
surveillance.He also said the Lebanese army has provided cover to Hizbullah,
whose members are fighting alongside Syrian President Bashar Assad's troops
against rebels.
Syria Says Assad Won't Cede Power at Geneva Meet
Naharnet/Syrian President Bashar Assad will not step down at a proposed peace
conference in Geneva but will only discuss the formation of a national unity
government, the foreign minister said on Monday.
Speaking at a press conference in Damascus, Foreign Minister Walid al-Muallem
also slammed a decision by supporters of the Syrian opposition to arm the
rebels, saying it would only prolong a conflict already in its 28th
month."President Bashar Assad will not resign. If your condition (for talks at
Geneva) is President Assad's resignation, don't bother coming," he said."We will
head to Geneva not to hand over power to the other side... We will go to Geneva
in order to set up a real partnership and a broad national unity
government."Despite supporting opposing sides in the conflict, Russia and the
United States have spearheaded an initiative to hold a peace conference in
Geneva.But prospects for the conference appear dim, and it has already been
pushed back from a mooted June date until July at the earliest.
The opposition has said that any solution to the conflict must involve Assad's
departure, something the regime has repeatedly ruled out.
The opposition has also set other conditions for its attendance, including the
withdrawal of Hizbullah fighters from neighboring Lebanon who have intervened in
support of the Assad regime.The Syrian government has said it will attend the
conference, but has made clear it has no plans to cede power. Muallem also
lashed out against a decision by the Friends of Syria group of Arab and Western
governments that back the opposition to step up their assistance to the
rebels."Two days ago a conference (of the Friends of Syria group) was held in
Doha. They emerged with a clear decision to arm the opposition... This will only
prolong the crisis," Muallem said. Qatar said the Friends of Syria group had
agreed on a "secret" plan to ramp up assistance to the rebels.U.S. Secretary of
State John Kerry pledged additional support for the rebels to end an "imbalance"
in Assad's favor. "Who decides when the balance needs to be restored?" asked
Muallem. "They say the restoration of balance is aimed at forcing the Syrian
government to attend the Geneva talks. We said we are ready to attend -- but
what about the other side?" he asked. The Friends of Syria group "said they are
acting for the sake of the Syrian people. Does killing the Syrian people achieve
that goal?" Muallem warned that any arms provided to the opposition would end up
in the hands of Al-Nusra Front, a rebel group that has openly proclaimed its
allegiance to Al-Qaida and is on Washington's terror blacklist."Why don't they
(the Friends of Syria) see how they are contributing to terrorism? "I only want
to say that what was decided in Doha is dangerous because it aims at prolonging
the violence, and it encourages terrorism," he said."Arming the opposition will
be an obstacle to the Geneva conference and will kill more of our people."Source/Agence
France Presse.
Geagea Meets Suleiman: Asir Phenomenon Product of Hizbullah Phenomenon
Naharnet/Lebanese Forces leader Samir Geagea noted on Monday that the
“phenomenon” of Sheikh Ahmed al-Asir is a product of local conditions in
Lebanon, calling on all Lebanese to support the army and state given the clashes
in the southern city of Sidon.He told Free Lebanon radio: “The phenomenon of
Hizbullah produced several other phenomenons, including that of al-Asir.”
“We are all citizens who enjoy the same rights and duties, but when one citizen
sees that another enjoys superiority over him regarding these rights, then he is
bound to react against this reality,” he said.
“Hizbullah has violated all laws and state institutions seeing as it revolts
against any political issue that it opposes, which was demonstrated during the
May 7, 2008, clashes,” Geagea continued.“We believe that the army's tackling of
the situation in Sidon marks the beginning of addressing the possession of
illegitimate arms and the presence of 'statelets' in Lebanon,” he noted.
“When a portion of Lebanese believe that they have the right to form an armed
group independent of the state, then other Lebanese will follow suit,” he
explained.
“This is the mistake that al-Asir committed and the only way to end this reality
lies in resorting to state institutions, starting with the army,” he remarked.
“We can no longer tolerate illegitimate arms, whether they are in al-Asir's
possession or Hizbullah's,” he said.
Moreover, Geagea added that the demand to eliminate al-Asir's phenomenon should
continue to include the arrest of those who killed Hashem al-Salman in front of
the Iranian Embassy in Beirut on June 9.
“Tackling one phenomenon and not the other will not end the current situation in
Lebanon, because similar armed groups will emerge in the country in the future,”
he explained.
“The bigger problem lies in the presence of Hizbullah because failure to tackle
this problem will create future one and we will continue to move from one bad
situation to a worse one,” noted the LF leader.
“From now on, we will demand that the state perform its duties until the end,
which goes beyond ending the unrest in Sidon,” he said. “Where are Salman's
murderers?” he wondered. Lebanese Option Party member Hashem Salman was killed
and at least eleven others were wounded in a scuffle between supporters of
Hizbullah and protesters near the Iranian Embassy in Beirut.
The demonstrators were holding a sit-in near the embassy to protest Hizbullah's
involvement in the war raging in Syria.
Geagea stressed that the state cannot choose to assume its full responsibilities
at certain instances, while at others, it only perform part of them. “Officials
cannot remain in power if some regions remain outside the state's control for
unknown reasons,” he added. On Sunday, Geagea had held talks with President
Michel Suleiman at the Baabda Palace.
He said that the visit was scheduled before the eruption of the Sidon clashes.
He revealed that the discussions focused on the unrest and the security
situation in Lebanon.
He later contacted Army Commander General Jean Qahwaji, MP Bahia al-Hariri, and
head of the Mustaqbal bloc MP Fouad Saniora to discuss the latest security
developments. Clashes broke out on Sunday between the army and supporters of
Salafist cleric Sheikh Ahmed al-Asir in the southern city of Sidon.
The military command said the number of troops killed in the fighting rose to
12. There were also more than 50 injuries among the ranks of the soldiers, but
it was not clear how many fighters were killed in the unrest.
The clashes erupted when al-Asir's supporters surrounded an army checkpoint in
the area, where a vehicle transporting other supporters of the cleric had been
stopped.
After the armed men attacked the troops with gunfire, the army fired back.
Aoun Links Sidon Clashes to Uncontrolled Flow of Syrian Refugees into Lebanon
Naharnet/Free Patriotic Movement leader MP Michel Aoun condemned on Monday the
clashes in the southern city of Sidon, linking the unrest to the “uncontrolled”
flow of Syrian refugees into Lebanon.
He said during a press conference: “We had repeatedly stressed the need to pay
attention to the flow of refugees in order to prevent their transformation into
rebels who may combat the army.” “The government is not controlling the
situation and we have repeatedly warned of this development, but no security
measure was taken to monitor the flow of refugees,” added the MP. Asked who is
responsible for the unrest, he responded: “Some sides responsible for the
country's security have neglected their duties towards the army, their nation,
and citizens.”“Those responsible for the security must assume their duties. Who
allowed armed groups to gain power?” he wondered.Moreover, Aoun praised the army
for its crackdown on the unrest in Sidon, hoping that its efforts will mark the
beginning of “the liberation of Lebanon of criminal gunmen.”
Clashes broke out on Sunday between the army and supporters of Salafist cleric
Sheikh Ahmed al-Asir in the southern city of Sidon. The military command said
the number of troops killed in the fighting rose to 12. There were also more
than 50 injuries among the ranks of the soldiers, but it was not clear how many
fighters were killed in the unrest. The clashes erupted when al-Asir's
supporters surrounded an army checkpoint in the area, where a vehicle
transporting other supporters of the cleric had been stopped.After the armed men
attacked the troops with gunfire, the army fired back.
Mouawad Contacts Qahwaji: Persistence of Illegitimate Arms Paves Way for Strife
Naharnet/Independence Movement leader Michel Mouawad condemned on Monday the
clashes in the southern city of Sidon and the attack against the army, stressing
his support for the state. He said: “The developments in Sidon demonstrate that
ignoring the spread of illegitimate arms, regardless of the identity of their
sectarian owners, poses a danger to the army, state, stability, and entire
Lebanese entity.” He made his remarks after contacting Army Commander General
Jean Qahwaji to condole him over the victims of the army during the Sidon
unrest.Mouawad demanded that all sides “grant the army complete cover to defend
itself,” rejecting the concept of imposing “security through the appeasement of
all powers.”“The state with its political and military agencies are the sole
guarantors of stability and security,” he remarked.
“Any arms outside the legitimacy of the state pose a threat to us all,” he
warned. In addition, he voiced his support to the initiative of Mustaqbal bloc
leader MP Fouad Saniora, who demanded that an end be made to Hizbullah's armed
presence in Sidon, “which is the main reason for the spread of illegitimate arms
in the city.” Clashes broke out on Sunday between the army and supporters of
Salafist cleric Sheikh Ahmed al-Asir in the southern city of Sidon.The military
command said the number of troops killed in the fighting rose to 12. There were
also more than 50 injuries among the ranks of the soldiers, but it was not clear
how many fighters were killed in the unrest.
The clashes erupted when al-Asir's supporters surrounded an army checkpoint in
the area, where a vehicle transporting other supporters of the cleric had been
stopped.
After the armed men attacked the troops with gunfire, the army fired back.
Sami Gemayel Calls for Curfew in Sidon, Beirut, Tripoli to Avert More Unrest
Naharnet/Phalange Party MP Sami Gemayel condemned on Monday the clashes in the
southern city of Sidon, voicing the party's support for the army's efforts to
crackdown on the gunmen.
He said after the party's weekly politburo meeting: “A curfew should be imposed
in all the regions that are witnessing tensions.”He explained that a curfew
should be imposed in Beirut and the northern city of Tripoli in order to avert
unrest that may erupt there. “We have taken too long to give the army the green
light to crackdown on gunmen in Lebanon,” he lamented. “Lebanon stands by the
army in its efforts to restore the authority of the state,” he declared.“This
requires that they perform their duty objectively and not in a selective
manner,” explained the MP.He added that no one, regardless of their sectarian
affiliations, should be allowed to carry arms in Lebanon.Moreover, he hinted
that the presence of Syrian and Palestinian refugees in Lebanon helped
contribute to the current unrest in the country, stressing that the party had
longed warned of the possible threat they may present to Lebanon's internal
security. “All sides must assume their responsibilities in preventing unrest in
Lebanon,” he demanded. In addition, Gemayel said that the unrest in Sidon was a
product of the concept of imposing security in Lebanon through the appeasement
of all sides.“It is time to impose real security in Lebanon without compromise,”
he declared. Being lenient with gunmen will only worsen the problem and embolden
gunmen,” he explained. Furthermore, he said that the army is paying the price of
imposing security through appeasement and “it is time to restore authority to
the state, which requires supporting the army and standing against all who
consider themselves above the law.”“No one should be led to believe that they
can control Lebanon through force or the use of arms,” he stated.“We will not
surrender Lebanon to armed groups and militias because that would mean the end
of the country,” Gemayel said. In addition, he noted the government's failure to
convene in order to address the situation in Sidon, “which is sign of its
absence.”He therefore demanded that President Michel Suleiman take matters into
his own hands, head to the Defense Ministry, and impose a curfew in the areas
that have witnessed clashes and tensions. Clashes broke out on Sunday between
the army and supporters of Salafist cleric Sheikh Ahmed al-Asir in the southern
city of Sidon.The military command said the number of troops killed in the
fighting rose to 12. There were also more than 50 injuries among the ranks of
the soldiers, but it was not clear how many fighters were killed in the
unrest.The clashes erupted when al-Asir's supporters surrounded an army
checkpoint in the area, where a vehicle transporting other supporters of the
cleric had been stopped.
After the armed men attacked the troops with gunfire, the army fired back.
Tensions have since been high in numerous regions in Lebanon, especially in
Beirut and Tripoli.
In Tripoli, army positions came under threat of gunmen, but then tensions have
so far not escalated into violence.
Hizbullah Condemns Sidon Clashes: Army Guarantor for Civil
Peace in Lebanon
Naharnet/Hizbullah slammed on Monday the attack against the army
by supporters of Salafist cleric Sheikh Ahmed al-Asir in the southern city of
Sidon on Sunday.Its said in a statement: “The army is the guarantor of civil
peace in Lebanon and any attack against it is tantamount to an attack against
the entire nation.”“The attack against the army on Sunday is an attack against
all the Lebanese and their security, present, and future,” it declared.It
highlighted the dangerousness of the attack since it targeted a “main state
institution that guarantees Lebanon's civil peace.” The attack should stand as
an opportunity for the Lebanese, regardless of their affiliations, to support
the army, continued the statement. Hizbullah also demanded that “all measures be
taken to put a complete stop to such assaults against the army and bring the
assailants to justice.” Sixteen soldiers have been killed in the clashes, the
army said Monday, in violence tied to rising sectarian tensions fanned by the
Syria conflict.The fighting began on Sunday on the outskirts of Sidon and
intensified on Monday.The security cabinet pledged the military would fight
until it "finishes with" al-Asir.A military judge issued a warrant for the
controversial cleric's arrest, a judicial source said.The violence is among the
worst in Lebanon since the start of the Syrian conflict, which has inflamed
sectarian tensions in the country, particularly between Shiite supporters of the
Damascus regime and Sunni backers of the uprising.
Qabbani Rejects Army Defection Calls, Warns Sidon Incident
Boosts Sedition
Naharnet /Grand Mufti Sheikh Mohammed Rashid Qabbani rejected on
Monday calls on Sunnis to defect the army, saying they promote sedition and
leads to chaos.“It's not allowed to engage in battles with the army under any
pretexts,” Qabbani said in a statement.He appealed in a televised speech on the
Lebanese to hold on to the army, stressing that “those who were responsible for
the assault on the army should be held accountable.”
Qabbani said that the “security chaos in (the southern city of) Sidon and the
(northern city of) Tripoli aims at distracting the army from its main duty along
the border.”At least twelve Lebanese soldiers were killed in less than 24 hours
in clashes with supporters of Salafist cleric Sheikh Ahmed al-Asir in the Sidon
suburb of Abra.Asir had appealed to his supporters through his Twitter account
in other parts of Lebanon to rise to his help, threatening to widen the scale of
clashes.Abra is home to a mosque, Bilal bin Rabah, where Asir leads the main
weekly prayers on Fridays. The sheikh believes Hizbullah uses apartments in Abra
to keep him under surveillance. He also says the Lebanese army has provided
cover to Hizbullah, whose members are fighting alongside Syrian President Bashar
Assad's troops against rebels. Asir was unknown until around two years ago, when
he gained prominence for his opposition to Hizbullah and its ally Assad. The
military urged political leaders in Sidon to choose sides and to stand either
alongside the army, or with "those who promote strife and the killing of
troops".
The Sidon clashes spilled over other Lebanese regions on Sunday, as roads were
blocked in the North, Bekaa and Beirut. On Monday, gunmen have been roaming the
streets of Tripoli in a show of support to al-Asir, reported the National News
Agency.
Al-Rahi Lashes out at 'Executioners,' Says Attack on Institutions is 'High
Treason'
Naharnet/Maronite Patriarch Beshara al-Rahi described on Monday as
“executioners” all parties that use illegitimate arms against the Lebanese
people, saying the country was paying the price of their actions.
“When we use illegitimate arms against the people of our nation we all become
executioners,” al-Rahi said during a ceremony in Adma, north of Beirut. “There
is only one victim that is Lebanon,” he said. “They are all executioners!” he
added about the March 8 and 14 alliances whom he blamed for the deteriorating
security situation in Lebanon.He said the attack on the army in the southern
city of Sidon is an assault on the state, the dignity of the people and the
nation's self-esteem.He also described the attack on state institutions as “a
crime against the people and high treason.”At least 12 soldiers have been killed
in less than 24 hours of clashes with supporters of Salafist cleric Sheikh Ahmed
al-Asir in Sidon. The fighting intensified on Monday, a day after the violence
began, when al-Asir's supporters opened fire on an army checkpoint in Abra where
the cleric's Bilal Bin Rabah mosque lies. Al-Rahi condemned “all those covering
up for the crimes, including politicians,” saying they were as guilty as those
committing the crimes.He urged the judiciary to arrest Sidon's gunmen and give
them the ultimate punishment “although some politicians, who are professionals
in covering up for crimes, might pressure it.”The patriarch said Sidon's
fighting and similar cases in different regions in addition to the involvement
in Syria's war came despite the Baabda declaration in which different parties
had pledged to distance Lebanon from the region's crises. “They are the results
of the persistence to paralyze state institutions and dismantle them,” he said.
Washington Urges Russia to Return Snowden to U.S.
Naharnet /The White House said early Monday it expected cooperation from Russia
on returning fugitive intelligence leaker Edward Snowden back to the United
States to face espionage charges.
"Given our intensified cooperation after the Boston Marathon bombings and our
history of working with Russia on law enforcement matters -- including returning
numerous high-level criminals back to Russia at the request of the Russian
government -- we expect the Russian government to look at all options available
to expel Mr. Snowden back to the U.S. to face justice for the crimes with which
he is charged," said National Security Council spokesperson Caitlin
Hayden.Hayden also expressed disappointment with Hong Kong for allowing Snowden
to leave "despite the legally valid U.S. request to arrest him for purposes of
his extradition under the U.S.-Hong Kong Surrender Agreement."We have registered
our strong objections to the authorities in Hong Kong as well as to the Chinese
government through diplomatic channels and noted that such behavior is
detrimental to U.S.-Hong Kong and U.S.-China bilateral relations," she
said.Snowden, a 30-year-old former intelligence contractor, is wanted by the
United States on espionage charges, after he quit his job with the National
Security Agency and fled to Hong Kong with a cache of secret documents.On
Sunday, Snowden left Hong Kong for Moscow, despite Washington having requested
his arrest and extradition. Hong Kong officials said the documentation
supporting the extradition request had been incomplete.An Ecuadorian minister
said Monday that Ecuador is analyzing an asylum request from Snowden."We are
analyzing it with a lot of responsibility," Foreign Minister Ricardo Patino told
reporters through a translator at a hotel in Hanoi, Vietnam. He says the asylum
request "has to do with freedom of expression and with the security of citizens
around the world." Patino spoke briefly to reporters on his way to a meeting
with Vietnam's foreign minister. He did not say how long it would take Ecuador
to decide.SourceAssociated PressAgence France Presse.
Egypt PM Condemns 'Heinous' Attack on 4 Shiites
Naharnet/Egypt's prime minister, Hesham Qandil, on Monday condemned the
"heinous" attack against Shiites in a village south of Cairo which left four
dead and several injured, the cabinet said in a statement.
Qandil "strongly condemns the ugly incident ... which resulted in the death of
four Egyptian citizens," the cabinet said. "This heinous crime is incompatible
with the principles and teachings of all heavenly religions, and contrary to the
nature of religious tolerance in Egypt," he said.On Sunday, four Egyptian Shiite
Muslims were killed when they were attacked by a hostile mob in the village of
Abu Mussalem in the Giza province.
A house where the minority Shiites were meeting was surrounded by residents who
told them to get out.When they refused, a crowd of several hundred people
stormed the building and killed four Shiites and injured several others.The
attack comes following weeks of toxic anti-Shiite rhetoric in the media and from
Sunni Islamist leaders.Qandil expressed his "categorical rejection of hate
speech and incitement to violence" and said investigations were underway and
that those responsible would be held accountable.He said authorities would
"ensure that the perpetrators be brought to justice to serve as an example to
deter anyone thinking of tampering with the fabric of society."Shiites are
estimated as a tiny fraction of Egypt's population of 84-million, most of them
Sunni Muslim.SourceAgence France Presse.
As Egypt lurches into civil strife, local militias raise their heads. Obama keeps faith with Brotherhood
DEBKAfile Special Report June 24, 2013/After weeks of
mounting anti-government turmoil across Egypt, army chief Abdel-Fattah al-Sissi
finally spoke up Sunday, June 23, to warn that the Egyptian army would “not
watch the country descend into uncontrollable conflict” ahead of the planned
June 30 mass opposition rallies” or allow “an attack on the will of the people.”
Meanwhile, Egypt lurches day by day closer to what US and Israeli intelligence
diagnose as “low intensity civil war.” In outlying towns, law and order is
breaking down as armed gangs attack governors and burn emblems of government,
while the ruling Muslim Brotherhood deploys armed men strike back at government
opponents. The police are not intervening in the disorder - any more than the
army has to date.
DEBKAfile‘s military sources note that Defense Minister al-Sissi avoided
defining which side the generals regarded as representing the “will of the
people” – President Mohamed Morsi who pushed them off the national stage, or the
myriad opposition groups sworn to overthrow him on the first anniversary of his
rise to power. They aim to replace him with a high presidential council headed
by a Supreme Court judge. A number of opposition groups say they have collected
15 million signatures in support of their demand.
If they succeed in their high-stake bid, Egypt would undergo its third
revolution in three years. The first in 2011 ousted President Hosni Mubarak,
whose successor, the Supreme Military Council, was itself unseated in 2012 by
the Muslim Brotherhood.
The popular voice, heartened by the middle class clamor rising in Istanbul’s
Taksim Square and Rio de Janeiro, speaks with greater confidence in its power to
put Mohamed Morsi’s head on the block and get rid of Islamist rule - especially
since he has also fallen out with his own Muslim Brotherhood.
For the Egyptian opposition, the 16 provincial governors the president approved
this month were the last straw which shut the door to any possible conciliation
and dialogue with the incumbent rulers. Morsi was considered as going too far by
his appointment as governor of Luxor, Adel Khayat, a member of the extremist Al-Gamaa
Al-Islamiyya, al Qaeda’s Egyptian branch.
The president has been wooing for the favor of extremist Salafist and pro-al
Qaeda circles for help in standing up to Muslim Brotherhood leaders. Realizing
he was the symbol of rising discord, Khayat stood down Sunday, June 23, “for the
sake of Egypt.”
From the start of his presidency, Morsi’s Brotherhood masters expect Morsi to
bow obediently to their authority and perform their will. His continuing
independence has confronted him with his own Islamic camp as the fifth adversary
bent on his ouster, in addition to –
1. The secular and liberal groups for whom Islamic rule is anathema:
2. Religious minorities, led by the largest, the indigenous Christian Copts;
3. Sections of the Egyptian army;
4. Despairing elements of the population, who see their country disintegrating
into chaos and corruption, with no hope of personal security for Egypt’s masses
and many of them facing starvation.
There is no reliable estimate of the size and strength of any of those five
groups, excepting the Muslim Brotherhood, or their chances of coming together –
either to overthrow the president, or to back him against fellow opponents.
These evaluations are further complicated by the wide reporting gap between the
state of affairs in Egypt’s main cities and the bulk of the population in the
rural areas. Most accounts focus on Cairo and Alexandria or, at most, the Canal
towns of Suez and Ismailia, or the urban areas of the Delta, which have veered
completed out of the central government’s security control. The rest of the
country might as well be on the other side of the moon.
According to DEBKAfile’s intelligence sources, local armed militias are
springing up in the Suez and Delta cities and certain rural areas. Their
political hues and plans of action are hard to pin down.
Two more imponderables further befog the direction in which Egypt may be headed:
How the Obama administration views the mayhem touched off by the anti-Mubarak
revolution it fostered, and the intentions of al-Qaeda’s Salafi allies in Sinai.
According to our Washington sources, the US has pulled away from President Morsi
in disapproval, while at the same time staying close to the Muslim Brotherhood.
This orientation is manifested by the coming appointment of Anne Woods
Patterson, former US ambassador to Cairo, as Under Secretary for the Near East.
She has been Obama’s point person for cultivating good rapport with the Muslim
Brotherhood, which he counts on as a reliable and steady hand at the helm of
rule in Cairo. Washington also maintains a good relationship with the Egyptian
army, which is judged as the only organized power system in the country, as well
as the steadfast guardian of the historic Egyptian-Israeli peace treaty. Lawless
Sinai falls through the cracks between the US, the Muslim Brothers and the
military. Its destabilizing influence reaches into the Palestinian Gaza Strip
and along the Egyptian-Israeli border running down eastern Sinai. The army is
willing to combat arms smuggling through Sinai to the Palestinian Hamas in the
Gaza Strip, but refuses to take on the mutinous Bedouin of the al-Qaeda-linked
Salafi cells who roam freely through the peninsula’s wastelands.To step into the
gap, the Obama administration last week decided to assign another 400 US
soldiers to the 13-nation Multinational Observer peacekeeping force posted in
Sinai to monitor the 1979 Egyptian-Israeli peace accord.
Women’s rights and the threat of Islamism
Iqbal Al-Ahmad/Asharq Alawsat
When ideological extremism of any kind turns into an attack on freedoms and
rights, and terrorism takes away all rights—intellectual or otherwise—and seeks
to eliminate all previous gains and advances, it becomes a nightmare.
In the Arab world, the impact of the recent period of rapid upheaval, or “Arab
Spring,” soon became the “Women’s Autumn.” Many of the gains that were attained
over many years as the result of a treacherous and difficult journey have been
lost.
There is a consensus that Arab women were the first victims of the ascension of
Islamists to power in countries such as Egypt and Tunisia. Extremism in the
religious sphere often permeates into other areas, such as the intellectual,
political, cultural and social. Because of this, the rights that had been gained
in the 1960s and 1970s began to be threatened.
Following Muhammad Mursi’s victory in the presidential elections, the Egyptian
Islamic leader Hazim Abu Ismail declared that Islamic ideology was now dominant.
He summarized the reasons for women to fear political Islam when he said: “We
want to implement Shari’a law and end cabarets, alcohol, adultery and topless
women in films, at public squares and on beaches.”
According to Abu Ismail, if we look for the common factor in cases where the
rules of Islam are broken, women are to be found. Cabarets, adultery and
stripteases are all matters that concern women, and implementing Shari’a would,
in this case, prevent women from spreading corruption and immorality.
Today, the achievements made by Egyptian women in all areas are threatened by
parties controlled by radical religious ideology, which considers women
primarily as a form of entertainment, after which their place is at home.
The Convention on the Elimination of Discrimination Against Women (CEDAW)
published a report after the arrival of the first elected civilian president
following the January 25 revolution. It stated that “Egyptian women, in the new
political system, are experiencing a lot of systematic violence … and have
little freedoms and human dignity.”
I talk about the Egyptian experience because it is today’s reality. We see with
our own eyes how the radical religious leadership represents the ideological
changes taking place. Egyptian women have lost a lot since the Brotherhood’s
rise to power, which reduced the number of women ministers from four to only
one.
The phenomenon of sexual harassment against Egyptian women that took place in
Egyptian squares during the recent changes, and their subsequent elimination of
freedom of expression, was merely heaping insult upon insult. Harassment took
place for purely political reasons—this was published clearly in many reports—in
order to prevent women expressing themselves. It caused women to be fearful, and
those who did not want to experience any harassment simply stayed at home; the
opposition in the streets to Muslim Brotherhood rule went on without women’s
voices.
Those who have been observing a variety of the Islamic leaderships in the Arab
world have noted the absence of women from religious interpretations. Based on
these, there has been a refusal to adopt numerous women’s rights. This indicates
that the marginalization of women’s rights is a part of political Islam’s
projects—the features of which began in the Arab world.
In democratic states, responsibility is collective. Despite this, the state also
takes charge of various institutions and authorities.
In Kuwait, I have lived with this reality for many years. Women’s political
rights have been refused by the National Assembly on account of external
religious reasons, which postponed the presence of women in parliament—despite
Kuwaiti women being among the most qualified Arab women for such
responsibilities.
Unfortunately, the same principles can still be found among some of those
occupying senior leadership positions. If it were not for an open government
that is appreciative of women’s achievements, women would occupy no such
positions. The late Emir, Sheikh Jaber Al-Ahmad, set out to grant political
rights, but was brought down in the National Assembly when it was discussed
within a purely religious framework. The issue later returned to the Assembly
and, with difficulty, after lengthy discussions, it was approved.
Opinion: The Muslim Brotherhood has failed in Egypt
Tariq Alhomayed/Asharq Alawsat
Regardless of what 30 June protests bring about,
reality shows that the Muslim Brotherhood have failed in Egypt and the region
Regardless of the results of the forthcoming 30 June demonstrations in Egypt,
and whether the opposition succeeds in toppling the president or not, reality
says the Muslim Brotherhood’s project in Egypt has failed, and that the
Brotherhood will suffer from this failure for many years, in Egypt and the
region.
When former President Mubarak resigned, the Brotherhood gave endless promises
for democracy, but their promises were empty. The way the Brotherhood has dealt
with every crisis in Egypt was tinged with attempts to insult the intelligence
of others and exclude them, and by applying the principle of divide and rule,
which divided everything in the country.
The Muslim Brotherhood tried to exclude the military, and the time for that was
suitable for that, because both revolutionaries and opposition agreed. Then the
exclusion of the military became a plan to exclude all; from Azhar and the
judiciary, to the media, even the opposition itself; not to mention trying to
monopolize the constitution and try to pass it hurriedly, with the exclusion of
others.
All this took place during a frightening economic downturn which threatened the
Egyptian state as a whole.
What is stunning about each directive or resolution from the ruling authority–or
the Brotherhood one can say–is that they clashed with the public and the
institutions, causing more division internally, and raising confusion and
concern externally.
With regards to the external side, the Brotherhood’s chaotic rule was also
stunning in most issues, from the Iranian issue to the Renaissance Dam
(Ethiopia), to the Syrian issue. Yet, that was not enough for the organization;
with efforts increasing in Egypt to prepare for the 30 June protests, which aim
to topple the president, the Brotherhood resorted to methods which implicated
them further. Instead of giving political concessions, or try to make
reconciliation efforts, they resorted to escalation on the street, and labeling
others as infidels and traitors, and threatening to crush their political
opponents.
The fact is, If Mubarak and his aides were three days late in their dealing with
the 25 January revolution, as we wrote at the time, the Brotherhood today are
years late in dealing with reality. One must ask the question: Where are the
sensible men of the Brotherhood? Does the Brotherhood want to spill blood in
Egypt to be like Assad and Gaddafi? Or do they want to lead Egypt a state to
ruin? Did the alleged Brotherhood democracy only mean reaching power, followed
by the Khomeini exclusionary approach, which was adopted by the Iranian
revolution, and dress that approach with an Islamic cover to guarantee staying
in power?
In summary, what history is going to remember is that the failure of the Muslim
Brotherhood in Egypt was caused by the Muslim Brotherhood themselves, not their
enemies, internally and externally, especially when the Brotherhood decided to
rule Egypt with a group mentality, and governed it like an opposition, not a
political authority, which applies the principle of good governance, brings
together not divides; a principle which gives the impression that the ruler
believes in sharing authority, not monopolizing it, and also believes in the
sanctity of preventing bloodshed, and not dealing softly with those who label
others as infidels and traitors, and threaten the social security of the country
as a whole.
Therefore, and regardless of what the 30 June demonstrations produce, reality
says the Muslim Brotherhood plan in Egypt and the region has failed, and this is
what a small number of sensible people had warned against.