LCCC ENGLISH DAILY
NEWS BULLETIN
January 17/2013
Bible Quotation for today/Who
Is the Greatest?/Temptations to Sin
Matthew18/01-09: "At that time the disciples came to
Jesus, asking, “Who is the greatest in the Kingdom of heaven?” So Jesus called a
child to come and stand in front of them, and said, “I assure you that
unless you change and become like children, you will never enter the Kingdom of
heaven. The greatest in the Kingdom of heaven is the one who humbles
himself and becomes like this child. And whoever welcomes in my name one
such child as this, welcomes me. “If anyone should cause one of these little
ones to lose his faith in me, it would be better for that person to have a large
millstone tied around his neck and be drowned in the deep sea. How
terrible for the world that there are things that make people lose their faith!
Such things will always happen—but how terrible for the one who causes them! “If
your hand or your foot makes you lose your faith, cut it off and throw it away!
It is better for you to enter life without a hand or a foot than to keep both
hands and both feet and be thrown into the eternal fire. And if your eye
makes you lose your faith, take it out and throw it away! It is better for you
to enter life with only one eye than to keep both eyes and be thrown into the
fire of hell.
Latest analysis, editorials, studies,
reports, letters & Releases from miscellaneous sources
Leadership Change in Oil-Rich Saudi Province/By:
Simon Henderson/Washington Institute/January
17/13
Latest News Reports From Miscellaneous
Sources for January 17/13
Rival Lebanese MPs embark on uphill bid for
consensus
Accord on election Lebanese law eludes steadfast
rivals
New Proposals Threaten to Complicate Lebanon's
Electoral Subcommittee Task
Lebanon's PM, Miqati Holds onto Equal Power
Sharing, Says Centrism Defended Lebanon
Geagea: We Support Alternative to Orthodox
Proposal that Enjoys Backing of Majority of Factions
Aoun Restates Orthodox Law Support: We Will Veto
Any Proposal that Does not Assure Equality
Mustaqbal: Orthodox Gathering Law Transforms
People into Sectarian Tribes
UNIFIL denies reports on phone monitoring
Lebanese Army
Lt. Col. Daher Jarjoui
faces death penalty for spying
The Tripoli-based Salafi Sheikh Bilal Deqmaq: There
is no Al-Qaeda in Lebanon
What would a new marina mean for Tripoli?
UNICEF Ambassador Farrow urges more aid for
refugees
Over 80 killed in Aleppo university carnage
U.S. Urges Morsi to Retract Anti-Semitic Remarks
Turkish Planes Attack Kurdish Rebel Targets in
Iraq
Canada to Resettle Up to 5,000 Iranian, Iraqi
Refugees
Push for Syria war crimes probe as 26 children die
US downplays report that Syria used chemical arms
France readies to use armored vehicles in Mali
Likud accuses Obama of 'gross interference' in
elections
UNIFIL denies reports on phone monitoring
January 16, 2013/The Daily Star/BEIRUT: A spokesperson for the
United Nations Interim Force in Lebanon denied recent media reports that
peacekeepers had intercepted phone calls inside a Palestinian refugee camp in a
statement provided to The Daily Star Tuesday. The reports, which appeared in a
number of Lebanese outlets including The Daily Star, attributed the information
to a Lebanese security source who reportedly informed Palestinian officials that
extremist groups in the camp were planning on carrying out terror attacks in
Lebanon. “UNIFIL operates only in the framework of its mandate under U.N.
Security Council Resolution 1701,” the UNIFIL statement read. “UNIFIL’s mandate
and area of operation in south Lebanon are clearly defined in that resolution.
UNIFIL’s deployment and tasks are related to the cessation of hostilities
between Lebanon and Israel; ensuring respect for the Blue Line; preventing
hostile activities or any violation of Resolution 1701 and create an environment
of peace and stability in South of Lebanon,” it explained. The spokesperson
added that UNIFIL’s monitoring activities are limited to the UNIFIL Maritime
Task Force, which assists the Lebanese Navy in tracking maritime traffic, as per
the request of the Lebanese government. “UNIFIL does not monitor land lines and
wireless telecommunications, which is not within its capabilities,” the
statement added.
Rival MPs embark on uphill bid for consensus
January 15, 2013/By Hussein Dakroub/The Daily Star
From left, Lebanon Electricity director general Kamal Hayek, Water and Energy
Minister Jibran Bassil, lawmaker Robert Ghanem and lawmaker Hikmat Dib attend a
parliament session in Beirut, Lebanon. (The Daily Star)
BEIRUT: MPs from the March 8 and March 14 parties will launch attempts Tuesday
to reach a consensus on a new electoral law after five days of deliberations
marked by political differences over which legislation best guarantees fair
representation for all sects.
The announcement, made Monday by MP Robert Ghanem, the chairman of a
parliamentary subcommittee tasked with studying a new electoral law for this
year’s parliamentary polls, came after the rival MPs sealed the results of the
first phase of their discussions before sending them to Speaker Nabih Berri
Tuesday.
“The subcommittee’s agenda contained three points divided into two stages. The
first stage is related to two items: The first one is to discuss the electoral
draft laws and proposals referred by the joint [parliamentary] committees to the
subcommittee, and the second concerns the number of Parliament members,” Ghanem
told reporters after the subcommittee’s three-hour meeting held in Parliament.
He said the second stage was to discuss reaching “a common ground” on a new
electoral law. He added that the subcommittee would meet for this purpose
Tuesday morning.
Ghanem said the subcommittee discussed Monday the draft report on the first
stage of its deliberations, adding that the report would be presented to Berri
Tuesday.
Last week, the MPs from the Hezbollah-led March 8 alliance and the opposition
March 14 coalition examined three conflicting draft electoral laws for this
year’s polls: a controversial proposal by the Orthodox Gathering, which calls
for every sect to elect its own MPs, a draft law presented by the Lebanese
Forces and the Kataeb Party that would divide Lebanon into 50 small districts
under a winner-takes-all system, and the Cabinet’s draft based on a proportional
representation system with 13 medium-sized electoral districts.
They also discussed proposals to increase the number of Parliament members to
allot seats for Lebanese expatriates. Political sources said most of the
subcommittee’s nine members – four March 8 MPs and four March 14 MPs, in
addition to Progressive Socialist Party’s MP Akram Shehayeb – backed a proposal
to increase the number of Parliament members from 128 to 134. Also, six MPs out
of the nine subcommittee members supported the Orthodox electoral proposal,
which has triggered a nationwide heated controversy and has been rejected by
President Michel Sleiman, the Future Movement, PSP leader Walid Jumblatt and
some March 14 Christian politicians who warned that the draft would sharpen
sectarian divisions and encourage the rise of extremists.
Monday’s meeting was attended by Free Patriotic Movement’s MP Alain Aoun, who
suspended his participation in the subcommittee’s talks last week after March 14
lawmakers rejected his demand to refer the Orthodox proposal to a Parliament
vote.
“We approved today the minutes of the eight meetings. We have all agreed to the
sealed minutes and we will present it to Speaker Nabih Berri. We will then
continue discussing the remaining topics in order to reach common denominators,”
Aoun told reporters after the meeting.
He added that the outcome of the subcommittee’s discussions has been written
down and signed. “No one can distance himself from it,” Aoun said.
Hezbollah’s MP Ali Fayyad said the subcommittee’s work in the second stage would
be backed by political parties represented in the subcommittee in order to reach
a common ground on a new electoral law.
MP Shehayeb said: “From now on, serious work will concentrate on common
denominators and this is the most important thing.”
Ghanem, from the March 14 coalition, has also rejected the Orthodox proposal,
which sets Lebanon as a single district based on proportional representation
with each sect electing its own MPs.
The proposal has won an unprecedented Christian consensus by the four rival
Maronite parties: The Lebanese Forces, the Kataeb Party, MP Michel Aoun’s FPM
and Zghorta MP Suleiman Franjieh’s Marada Movement.
The leaders of the four parties have fully supported the Orthodox draft as the
best formula to ensure a true representation of Christians in this year’s
elections, which are scheduled for early June.
Meanwhile, Jumblatt, who has rejected both the Orthodox proposal and the
government’s proportional representation draft law, called for the establishment
of a Lebanese senate as stipulated by the 1989 Taif Accord.
He scoffed at the current heated debate over a new electoral law, saying it was
part of “unprecedented isolationist outbiddings that would leave extremely
negative reverberations at more than one level.”
“Why don’t we cause a positive shock and leap into a Lebanese qualitative
election spring by freeing Parliament from sectarian representation as
stipulated by the Taif Accord and move to establish a senate in which all
Lebanese components are represented?” Jumblatt said in his weekly article to be
published by the PSP’s weekly Al-Anbaa newspaper Tuesday.
He added that among the senate’s main prerogatives would be to address major
national issues and try to allay the concerns and fears of the feuding parties.
Jumblatt called for the adoption of an electoral law that enhances unity, rather
than deepens sectarian divisions.
Implicitly slamming the Orthodox proposal, the PSP leader said: “It is time for
the Lebanese to have an electoral law that brings them together instead of
seeking proposals that increase their sectarian and confessional divisions and
take them back to past centuries.” However, Kataeb MP Sami Gemayel, a member of
the parliamentary subcommittee, defended the Orthodox draft law, but said his
party was open to discussing other electoral proposals.
Speaking at a news conference before attending the subcommittee’s meeting in
Parliament, he said the Christians would no longer accept bring marginalized in
the country’s political decision-making as had happened over the past 23 years.
“We will not accept to be imposed on us after 23 years laws that do not ensure
partnership and equal power sharing and our representation to be as it is
today,” Gemayel said.
“We are open to solutions. We don’t want to impose anything on anyone. But we
will not accept after 23 years laws to be imposed on us that marginalize the
Christians,” he said.
Responding to Jumblatt and other politicians who have criticized the Christian
parties for upholding the Orthodox proposal, Gemayel said: “We wish that Walid
Beik will realize that the current [electoral] law is unjust and instead of
accusing us, let him find a solution to this crisis.”
“We will not accept a return to the zero point ... No one must think that we
will accept for a minute the 1960 law,” Gemayel said.
The 1960 law, which adopts the qada as an electoral district and is based on a
winner-takes-all system, was used in the 2009 parliamentary elections. The law
has been rejected by officials on both sides of the political divide.
Also Monday, independent March 14 Christian lawmakers and politicians reiterated
their rejection of the Orthodox proposal. In a statement issued after their
meeting at the house of Batroun MP Butros Harb, the second in less than a week,
the lawmakers praised the terse statement issued after a meeting of rival
Maronite leaders in Bkirki last Friday in which they called for adopting an
electoral law that provides fair representation for all sects.
“There are several alternatives to the current [1960] other than the Orthodox
proposal that can ensure a true representation and safeguard the unity of
Lebanon and the Lebanese, particularly the unity of Christians,” the March 14
MPs said.
New Proposals Threaten to Complicate Lebanon's Electoral
Subcommittee Task
Naharnet/Several proposals made by rival lawmakers during a meeting of a
parliamentary subcommittee on Tuesday are likely to delay agreement on an
electoral draft-law.
“We continued discussions on all draft-laws and new proposals made by MPs,” said
the chairman of the nine-member subcommittee, MP Robert Ghanem, on the first
round of the second phase of talks aimed at reaching consensus on an electoral
draft-law.
He said discussions will continue in a second session on Tuesday afternoon.
All members called for holding the elections on time and stressed on true
partnership between Muslims and Christians, Ghanem told reporters.
The lawmakers on Monday sealed the results of the first phase of their
discussions on the proposals and the number of parliament members. Ghanem handed
Speaker Nabih Berri the minutes of the meetings during a meeting in Ain el-Tineh.
The second phase which kicked off on Tuesday is aimed at reaching consensus on
the electoral draft-law. But several proposals made by the rival MPs showed that
the different parties are likely to face difficulties in finding converging
ideas.
MP Akram Shehayyeb, who addressed reporters after the subcommittee chairman,
said he proposed for parliament to hold intense meetings pending a decision on a
modern consensual law based on the Taef accord.
Shehayyeb, who is representing MP Walid Jumblat's centrist Progressive Socialist
Party in the meetings, said he also proposed the establishment of a senate and
the adoption of administrative decentralization.
Lawmaker Alain Aoun from MP Michel Aoun's Free Patriotic Movement did not reveal
if he had made any new proposals during Tuesday's meeting. The FPM - part of the
March 8 majority alliance - is a staunch supporter of the so-called Orthodox
Gathering proposal which calls for considering Lebanon a single district and
allowing each sect to elect its own MPs in a propositional representation
system.
“We discussed the electoral draft suggestions again. In spite of what was
achieved in the past days, discussions took their legislative path,” he said,
hinting that the Orthodox proposal would be adopted.
“We should find a solution that combines the rejection to hold the polls based
on the 1960 law … and finding an electoral draft-law that receives the backing
of all parties,” he told reporters.
Phalange MP Sami Gemayel appeared to be critical of Shehayyeb's proposal, saying
he supported discussions on the political system in the country but through
another committee and not the subcommittee whose mission is limited to agreeing
on an electoral draft-law. The opposition March 14 lawmaker said he proposed the
adoption of either a draft-law that divides Lebanon into 50 districts or the
Orthodox Gathering proposal based on a winner-takes-all system and not
proportionality.
“I explained to the subcommittee members that it is easy to implement the
winner-takes-all system in the Orthodox Gathering,” he told reporters. “But
those rejecting it should propose alternatives,” the MP said about the PSP and
al-Mustaqbal movement. Al-Mustaqbal MP Ahmed Fatfat said in response to
Gemayel's suggestion that al-Mustaqbal agreed for proportionality to be
implemented in certain areas “but in other closed regions the winner-takes-all
system should prevail.” “There is a true crisis in the country and we should
find a solution that appeases all sides,” he said.
The Orthodox proposal based on a winner-takes-all system made by Gemayel “needs
further discussions because it was proposed for the first time” on Tuesday, he
said.
As for Shehayyeb's proposal, “it requires that we consult our leaderships,” he
said. “All the proposals could have solutions if there is goodwill.”
Lebanese Forces MP George Adwan, also a member of the March 14 opposition,
criticized the suggestion of Shehayyeb, saying it “goes beyond the discussions
on an electoral draft-law.”
“We can't discuss issues linked to the system because it would change our
mission,” he said about the subcommittee.
While expressing keenness on holding the elections on time, he also said “we
can't discuss about abolishing sectarianism” as time is running fast.
Lebanon's PM, Miqati Holds onto Equal Power Sharing,
Says Centrism Defended Lebanon
Naharnet/Prime Minister Najib Miqati, who is scheduled to visit Saudi Arabia
this month, warned on Tuesday that the so-called Orthodox Gathering electoral
proposal threatens the balance set by the Taef Agreement.
The Orthodox Gathering proposal, which calls for dividing Lebanon into a single
district and allows each sect to elect its own MPs based on a proportional
representation system, leads to “more divisions among the Lebanese and threatens
the balance set by the Taef,” Miqati told As Safir daily.
He expressed fears that the adoption of the proposal in this year's
parliamentary elections could lead the country to the unknown.
“Are its supporters aware of its dangers and consequences?” Miqati asked.
“Aren't they aware that this proposal is an indirect count of the number of
Lebanese and the size of sects in Lebanon?”
Miqati wondered whether it was necessary to take such a “dangerous risk.”
The prime minister reiterated that he holds onto the Muslim-Christian
partnership in the country, countering accusations of calling for a "tripartite
system,” which he said is “not on his agenda.”
Miqati called for the adoption of an electoral draft-law that guarantees the
right representation for all sects and mainly Christian confessions and then the
establishment of a senate based on the Orthodox proposal.
He criticized Energy Minister Jebran Bassil without mentioning him, saying he
was advocating the adoption of the proposal at a time when he had approved a
government bill that calls for dividing Lebanon into 13 districts based on
proportional representation.
“I am surprised that some (officials) have mobilized themselves to defend the
Orthodox proposal at a time when they should defend the government's draft-law,”
Miqati told As Safir.
He accused him of using “double standards” at a time when he was among the first
ministers to adopt the government's bill.
“The problem is that some people are determined to head towards collapse and are
telling us to follow them but we will definitely not do that,” Miqati said.
He defended President Michel Suleiman for criticizing the Orthodox proposal,
saying he is acting out of his respect for his oath to preserve the constitution
and national unity.
“It is natural for the president to stand against the proposal because it is
unconstitutional,” Miqati told As Safir.
Asked about Bassil's criticism of the country's centrists, the PM said: “No one
can deny that centrism warded off dangers from Lebanon and defended it in these
difficult circumstances."
“Who else can defend the country?” he asked. The newspaper said that Miqati is
scheduled to travel to Saudi Arabia before January 21 to participate in an Arab
economic summit.
Highly-informed sources did not rule out meetings between Miqati and several
Saudi officials on the sidelines of the summit.
As Safir said the prime minister will return to Beirut on January 22 to chair a
cabinet session and then travel to the Swiss mountain resort in Davos to
participate in the World Economic Forum.
Future bloc: Proportionality law strengthens Hezbollah
domination
Lebanon’s opposition Future bloc said on Tuesday that adopting
the proportionality electoral law would strengthen Hezbollah’s power over the
country.
“The adoption of the proportionality electoral law at the current political
moment is not a step towards reform, it rather strengthens Hezbollah's
domination and control over the Lebanese state,” the bloc said in a statement
following its weekly meeting.
The Future bloc rejected the “discussion of any electoral draft law that
contradicts the foundations of national coexistence among the Lebanese and
violates the constitution.”
The bloc reiterated its rejection of “the so-called Orthodox Gathering electoral
law proposal because it contributes to transforming the Lebanese people into
rival sectarian tribes.”
Members of a parliamentary sub-committee began early last week their discussions
on different draft laws in order to choose a proposal to replace the 1960
electoral law, with the country’s political circles divided over which law to
adopt despite the cabinet’s approval in September 2012 of a draft law based on
proportionality and 13 electoral districts.
Meanwhile, Lebanon’s four major Christian parties, including the opposition
Lebanese Forces and Kataeb parties, which are the Future bloc’s allies, endorsed
the Orthodox Gathering’s draft law that proposes citizens vote for candidates of
their own sect. However, the Future Movement, the Progressive Socialist Party
and independent March 14 Christian figures rejected this proposal.
Also, the bloc denounced the current government’s adoption of an improvised
policy in handling the issue of Syria refugees.
“The Social Affairs Ministry expects an increase in the numbers of refugees and
this is why we should go back to what the Future bloc had suggested which is
calling for a conference for Arab and international countries and
organizations.”Lebanon is facing difficulties dealing with the increasingly high
number of refugees fleeing Syria’s violence. More than 150,000 refugees are
registered with the UNHCR in Lebanon; some activists, however, say the actual
number is much higher
Lebanese Army officer faces death penalty for spying
January 15, 2013/The Daily Star/BEIRUT: Military Investigative
Judge Imad Zein demanded Tuesday the death penalty for a high-ranking Lebanese
Army defector for spying for Israel, judicial sources told The Daily Star. They
said Zein convicted Lt. Col. Daher Jarjoui for “maintaining contact with the
Israeli enemy and meeting [Israeli] agents between 2005 and 2006.” Zein also
issued an arrest warrant in absentia against Jarjoui. Jarjoui, a resident of the
southern Lebanese village of Qlayaa, served as the Lebanese Army’s liaison with
the Spanish contingent of the U.N. Interim Force in Lebanon. He is said to have
fled to Israel in 2009. Lebanon has arrested dozens of nationals in alleged
Israeli espionage plots.
Accord on election Lebanese law eludes steadfast rivals
January 16, 2013/By Hussein Dakroub/The Daily Star
BEIRUT: Agreement on a new electoral law for this year’s parliamentary polls
appeared as elusive as ever Tuesday as rival political factions stood firm on
their conflicting stances on what served as the best legislation that ensured
fair representation for all sects. The wide split over a new election law also
manifested itself within a parliamentary subcommittee as representatives from
the March 8 and March 14 parties began the second phase of their tough mission
by searching for common ground on the legislation.
The feuding parties represented on the subcommittee traded barbs over
responsibility for the delay in approving a new electoral law to replace the
1960 system, which has been rejected by officials on both sides of the political
divide. The 1960 law, which adopts the qada as an electoral district and is
based on a winner-takes-all system, was used in the 2009 parliamentary polls.
President Michel Sleiman, who has staunchly rejected the Orthodox Gathering’s
controversial electoral proposal, entered the election fray by renewing his
support for the Cabinet’s draft law based on a proportional representation
system with 13 medium-size districts.
In an annual speech at Baabda Palace addressing foreign ambassadors accredited
to Lebanon on the occasion of the new year, Sleiman stressed that the
parliamentary elections, scheduled in early June, would be held on time in line
with “our commitment to our democratic heritage and the principle of peaceful
power rotation.”
He urged the rival factions to discuss the Cabinet’s draft electoral law and
make any amendments needed.
“As long as we are determined on holding the elections, I call for discussing
the draft law put forward by the Cabinet based on proportional representation
and introducing necessary amendments if needed,” Sleiman said.
Despite the March 14 boycott of the government and National Dialogue, Sleiman
said he would continue to prod the Hezbollah-led March 8 alliance and the
opposition March 14 coalition into returning to dialogue aimed at ensuring “a
national consensus at this critical stage through which Lebanon and its environs
are passing.”
He urged internal and external parties to comply with the Baabda Declaration in
order to protect Lebanon against the reverberations of the 22-month-old bloody
conflict in Syria.
“Although some internal parties have slid into the violence as a result of the
bloody conflict in Syria, members of the National Dialogue Committee were able
last year to agree on a statement calling for Lebanon to be neutralized from
regional conflicts,” Sleiman said, referring to recurrent clashes between
supporters and opponents of the Syrian regime in north Lebanon.
The Baabda Declaration, a pact signed by rival political leaders in the March 8
and March coalitions in June 2012, calls for isolating Lebanon from regional
conflicts and rejecting the creation of buffer zones and the flow of weapons and
fighters from Lebanon to Syria.
Meanwhile, rival March 8 and March 14 lawmakers, members of the parliamentary
subcommittee, held two sessions in Parliament Tuesday as they began the second
phase of their quest for common ground on a new electoral legislation. The
lawmakers will meet again Wednesday.
MP Robert Ghanem, chairman of the subcommittee, handed Speaker Nabih Berri the
minutes of last week’s deliberations, which were marked by political differences
over a new vote plan for this year’s polls.
Berri is expected to study the subcommittee’s final report on its discussions
before deciding on whether to call the joint parliamentary committees to debate
and vote on a new electoral proposal reached by the subcommittee.
Speaking to reporters after meeting Berri at his residence in Ain al-Tineh,
Ghanem said Berri was open to any proposal the subcommittee might adopt. He
added that Berri proposed new ideas for the subcommittee to discuss.
Ghanem said Berri emphasized the importance of the subcommittee continuing its
work in an attempt to reach an agreement on an electoral draft law acceptable to
all the parties and ensure a just and true representation.
“I discussed with the speaker a mechanism for the subcommittee’s work. He is
open to any decision the subcommittee takes with regards to the mechanism of its
work,” Ghanem said. “We will rely on God to reach a draft law, that will not be
100 percent fair, but acceptable to all the parties,” he added.
In addition to the Cabinet’s proportional representation draft law, the
subcommittee has examined a controversial proposal by the Orthodox Gathering
which calls for every sect to elect its own MPs, and a draft law presented by
the Lebanese Forces and the Kataeb Party that would divide Lebanon into 50 small
districts under a winner-takes-all system. During last week’s sessions, six MPs
out of the nine subcommittee members supported the Orthodox electoral proposal,
which has triggered a nationwide controversy and has been rejected by Sleiman,
the Future Movement, MP Walid Jumblatt and some March 14 Christian lawmakers,
who warned that the draft would sharpen sectarian divisions and encourage the
rise of extremists.
Earlier Tuesday, LF leader Samir Geagea defended the Orthodox proposal, saying
that it was the only proposal with a parliamentary majority. He urged the
critics of the proposal to come forward with alternatives with sufficient
backing.
“We found only the Orthodox draft law, which has a parliamentary majority, after
[both] the small district draft law and the Cabinet’s draft law failed to secure
a majority,” Geagea told a news conference at his residence in Maarab.
He added that the LF and its March 14 allies had launched talks with various
parties in a bid to garner support for the opposition’s proposal based on small
districts but failed.
However, Geagea’s allies in the parliamentary Future bloc stood firm on their
opposition to the Orthodox proposal, which has been fully supported by the rival
Maronite parties in a rare show of Christian unity: The LF, the FPM, the Kataeb
Party and Zghorta MP Suleiman Franjieh’s Marada Movement.
“The bloc utterly rejects discussing any electoral draft law that runs contrary
to the foundations of coexistence among the Lebanese and contravenes the
preamble of the Constitution,” the bloc said in a statement after its weekly
meeting.
“Therefore, the bloc repeats its absolute rejection of the Orthodox Gathering’s
draft law ... This proposal turns the Lebanese people into feuding sectarian
tribes and deepens divisions among the components of the country,” the statement
said. The bloc reiterated its commitment to the Taif Accord as a basis for any
solution.
For his part, FPM leader Michel Aoun defended the Orthodox proposal, saying the
draft did not contravene the Taif Accord or the Constitution.
“The Orthodox proposal ensures a true and fair representation for all components
of the Lebanese people,” Aoun said in an interview with the FPM’s affiliated OTV
station Tuesday night. He vowed to challenge any electoral law that does not
ensure fair representation.
Aoun complained that under the current political system, the Christians did not
have a say in the country’s political decision-making.
“Executive power is in the hands of the Sunnis and legislative power in the
hands of the Shiites. Where can the Christians influence things?” Aoun said.
“There is an elimination of the Christians’ [role]. There are 450,000
Christians, more than a third of voters, who cannot elect an MP. They are either
deprived or their voice is marginalized,” he added.
UNICEF Ambassador Farrow urges more aid for refugees
January 16, 2013/By Venetia Rainey/The Daily Star
BEIRUT: UNICEF Goodwill Ambassador Mia Farrow has called for an increase in
global humanitarian assistance for Syrian refugees while acknowledging the
efforts of the Lebanese government in an interview with The Daily Star. “I’ve
learned a lot from people who have nothing,” American actress Mia Farrow said,
leaning forward in her chair, her familiar round glasses perched on her nose.
“This Lebanese family we met had taken in five Syrian families. And they had
themselves just a living room, two bedrooms and a kitchen. There were 45 people
living in that small space for almost a year until the UNHCR built their house
up a floor.” But the 67-year-old said in an exclusive interview Tuesday that
what moved her most were the comments from the Syrian families living there.
“They spoke so highly of the [host] family. One grandmother said, with tears
running down her face: ‘They lifted us up.’ I thought that was a beautiful way
of saying it.
“She said never in her life had she thought she would be with nothing. Her
husband had been killed and yet this family took her in. So while she grieves
for what is lost, they lifted her up.”
The actress, who was famously married to director Woody Allen for 12 years,
became the main female protagonist in his movies for several years.
Farrow, who rose to fame as an actress, has become better known for her
humanitarian work, particularly in Sudan, where she has worked tirelessly to
publicize the plight of those affected by the decadelong – and still ongoing –
war in Darfur. “You can’t compare suffering,” she said when asked if there was
anything she had learned there that could be applied in Lebanon. “It’s a very
different situation here.”
But tented communities are starting to form, she added, and although they are
not refugee camps, such an arrangement makes the delivery of food and non-food
items much easier, especially as more and more people continue to arrive. “The
priority is keeping people alive,” she said in her usual soft, measured voice.
“What we can do is get coats, hats and blankets to people. What we can do is
help with tents. How come there aren’t any tents? Where are they?”“That said,
the Lebanese government has apparently been extraordinary. Not every country
would open its borders to so many people, and many of the children are at school
with Lebanese kids.”
Farrow visited Syrian refugees and their host families in Wadi Khaled and the
Bekaa Valley. She was impressed by the hospitality shown to the refugees but
felt more support was needed to alleviate pressure on the host families. “It’s a
huge pressure on Lebanese families because it’s the poorest families who are
taking in the refugees,” Farrow added. “Four million people were in Lebanon
before the influx of refugees, what if a million come? What does that do to the
demographics here and how do people feel about that?”
It is also a huge strain on UNICEF’s resources, thus the global appeal for
assistance. “We don’t have enough of anything: coats, medicine ... it is a
challenge,” Annamaria Laurini, UNICEF’s representative in Lebanon, said Tuesday.
“Funding is short,” added Farrow. “There’s not enough money, basically.”
Appointed a UNICEF goodwill ambassador in 2000, Farrow is on a long list of
celebrities – including footballer Lionel Messi, singer Shakira and actress
Whoopi Goldberg – who use their name to raise awareness of various causes. The
actress-turned-activist, who has 13 living children, nine of whom are adopted,
is an outspoken critic of what she calls “the political part of the U.N.,”
saying that “its state of paralysis serves no one.”
“What really works at the U.N. are the humanitarian agencies. UNICEF works,
UNHCR works, World Food Program works. Are they underfunded? Yes. Do they meet
all the needs? No, not always. Are they in there trying 24 hours a day? Yes.” In
the end, she said, her message is simple: “My plea for the world is: Let’s be a
community. We call ourselves an international community and when innocent people
are suffering to this degree, surely we can all step up.” “I’ll give interviews,
I’ll write, I’ll blog. I’ll do everything I can. And I think everybody of
conscience does what they can. Isn’t that the way we proceed?”
What would a new marina mean for Tripoli?
January 16, 2013/By Brooke Anderson/The Daily Star
TRIPOLI: Depending on whom you ask, a new waterfront development in Tripoli with
high-end restaurants, shops and accommodation will either give a badly needed
boost to an impoverished city, or it will further divide an already fragmented
society.
“Unfortunately for the past 20 years, there has been no plan for the revival of
Tripoli,” MP Robert Fadel, who is facilitating the project, tells The Daily
Star. “People are concerned for very good reasons. They haven’t seen anything of
this magnitude in 20 years.”
Dubbed by some locals as “Tripoli’s Zaitunay Bay” after the Beirut development
near Ain al-Mreisseh, the new project, still in early planning stages and yet to
be given an official name, would cover 1 million square meters, the vast
majority of which would be landfill, and part of which would be on the seaside
promenade, the corniche.
Tripoli Development Holding along with its subsidiary, the Tripoli Seafront
Company, were established last year by 14 of the city’s business leaders for the
execution of the project, which has raised $1 million in seed funding and needs
a total of $300 million. They expect the new marina will boost the local economy
by bringing tourists, residents and around 10,000 new jobs to what has
essentially become a neglected city.
The government will benefit from at least half of the landfill, which the
company plans on developing for state use. This could include infrastructure
such as roads, rehabilitation of the corniche, a public garden and a dry dock at
the cost of $50 million that could generate over a 100 jobs. A percentage of the
generated profits will be divided between the private investors and a
reinvestment fund, which would possibly help establish a technological business
incubator.
“This is a strategy to work together for the good of Tripoli,” says Samir Chreim,
managing partner in Beirut at SCAS, Inc., the financial consulting firm drawing
up the plans for the vast new marina on the southern edge of Lebanon’s second
city.
“If Tripoli’s image is polished, then people will want to visit,” predicts
Chreim, who likens the project to one for which he previously consulted,
Jumeirah, the luxury waterfront development in Dubai, which includes the
man-made palm tree-shaped islands.
Even at this early stage, some residents have already mobilized against the
project, fearing that it will create a cluster of shops and restaurants that
locals cannot afford, harm the coastal environment and intrude on space where
all classes from the destitute city can take a walk along the waterfront.
“Of course I’m against it. It will change the whole peninsula. People come from
poor areas for this million-dollar view,” says Sahar Minkara, an interior
designer and cafe owner in Tripoli, who agrees that her city needs to be
developed, but worries that this will be at the expense of the environment and
regular Tripolitans. She is part of Masha3, a nationwide campaign aimed at
reclaiming Lebanon’s public property. They say that lax enforcement of existing
laws has led to unchecked development along some of Lebanon’s nicest areas of
coastline.
Mira Minkara, Sahar’s cousin and another member of Masha3, wonders if the
developers can live up to their high expectations.
“They say they will create more than 10,000 jobs. I don’t know how realistic or
how economically sustainable it is,” she says. She thinks that developers should
instead revitalize some of the city’s ailing infrastructure, such as the port.
Tripoli resident Jihad Jneid, also a member of the group, says he would support
the project if it were not on the sea, which he says is the only place for poor
people to get away from their basic, cramped housing. Now, he believes, it will
be a place for Tripoli’s wealthy to have an escape from their city’s poverty.
“I don’t think anyone should touch the corniche, even if it improves the face of
Tripoli,” says Jneid. “We need empty spaces where people can go for free and
have coffee. There isn’t anyone from Tripoli that doesn’t go there.”
After learning about the new waterfront project, the members of Masha3 held a
public meeting last month with the Tripoli Holding Group, in which the initial
design plans were discussed. The next scheduled meeting is Friday.
Chreim says he is disappointed with the reaction of some activists, and he
believes that all of their concerns are addressed in the proposed plan. For
example, he says that the area’s flora and fauna have been depleting for years
due to longtime neglect of Tripoli’s coastline. They plan on developing a
hatchery for flora and fauna.
He also questions the logic of the argument that the project will segregate
Tripoli’s social classes, something that he believes is inevitable anywhere.
“There are already different classes in different areas. This happens all over
the world. A Burj Hammoud person won’t live in Ashrafieh. It’s the nature of the
area,” he says, adding that he doesn’t see a problem with a relatively exclusive
area if it results in a greater good for Tripoli’s economy.
Mona Harb disagrees. The urban planning professor at the American University of
Beirut says that economic and class diversity is a normal part of a city’s
“urban fabric” and such projects are a result of “failed urban policies for
decades” in the country’s postwar reconstruction.
“Usually [it’s] when people are busy with politics [that] these projects get
done,” she adds. “I wouldn’t be surprised if the decree [to reclaim public land
along the coast line] were done during intense conflicts in the area.”
The government has yet to issue such a decree.
Indeed, despite the scale of the project, many people in Tripoli, including
those who spend their days on the shore, are still unaware of a new plan for the
waterfront. Fishermen along the corniche voiced surprise upon hearing of it.
“This is the first time I hear about it,” says Mohammad Abdallah sitting on his
boat, scaling a fish. “I hope it happens so that we can have better work.”
Nearby, Ammer Azzedine, a Syrian who has been selling coffee on the corniche for
the past 20 years, says, “They’ve been talking about developing the waterfront
for 20 years. I’ll believe it when I see it.”
Labib Shalak, a longtime resident and software development CEO based in Tripoli,
also says he hasn’t heard of the project, but that he is already skeptical of
the plans.
“To help the economy, we need to have production, not services,” he says. “Maybe
it would create jobs for a couple of years. But after that, what? It could crash
like Dubai.”
Referring to Lebanon’s highly educated workforce which tends to travel abroad
for better opportunities, he says, “Human resources are Lebanon’s biggest asset
– not hotels.” Although he says he would welcome a new hotel, he doesn’t think
it should be a priority.
But some people think that fellow Tripolitans should give the new development a
chance – especially given the economic stagnation of their city, ranked among
the poorest in the Mediterranean basin.
“I don’t have a stand yet,” says Khaled Merheb, sitting at a cafe in Tripoli
with some of his friends who oppose the project. “When I first heard about the
project, they said it would damage Tripoli’s environment and it would prevent
poor people from coming to the corniche. But the corniche is already filled with
litter, and girls can’t walk there alone – so don’t talk about the environment
and poor people.”
He thinks his friends should be open to the new project.
“These are wealthy Tripolitans who want to do something good for the city,” he
says, calling it hypocrisy that people complain about politicians doing nothing
for the city, then try to stop them when they do. “If it’s good for the city,
let them make money. But let my city bloom.”
For Mu’taz Salloum the project can’t come fast enough.
“I’m with the project until I find enough proof that it’s not eco-friendly,”
says Salloum, a film director from Tripoli, noting that the local municipality
already deems the water too polluted for swimming.
“I’m always with any project that brings job opportunities to town. I’m sure if
people from Bab al-Tabbaneh and Jabal Mohsen were offered jobs, they wouldn’t
refuse,” he says, referring to the city’s two most impoverished neighborhoods,
the backdrop to sporadic armed clashes.
“I’d support the project if it created a thousand jobs – or even 10 jobs. People
are dying and starving in Tripoli.”
Meanwhile, Fadel, who for more than two years has been studying the feasibility
and laying the groundwork for the project that he hopes will boost his city’s
economy, says he needs the backing of the local residents.
“The project in the end,” he says, “would require the support of the Tripoli
community.”
Facts on new marina planned for Tripoli
Size: 1 million square meters
Location: on the southern end of the city, near the stadium
Development cost: $300 million
Seed money raised so far: $1 million
Target audience: Lebanese from the area, expatriates, Gulf residents
Possible attractions: a luxury hotel, shopping, water sports
Architects: Dar al-Handasa, Nazih Taleb
Potential contractors: Mouawad-Edde and Khoury Contracting Co.
The Tripoli-based Salafi Sheikh Bilal Deqmaq: There is
no Al-Qaeda in Lebanon
January 15, 2013/By Misbah al-Ali/The Daily Star
TRIPOLI, Lebanon: The Tripoli-based Salafi Sheikh Bilal Deqmaq describes Osama
bin Laden in admiring terms, but says he doesn’t agree with all of Al-Qaeda’s
principles and the group is not active in Lebanon.
In person, Deqmaq – who has been connected to Islamist organizations such as
Al-Qaeda and Fatah al-Islam – is anything but the stereotype of a fiery Salafist
sheikh. He is friendly, dresses in Western clothes and always has a smartphone
nearby.
Called a political panderer and a man ignorant of Islam by some, in a recent
interview with The Daily Star Deqmeq discussed his public persona and what he
truly believes.
To those who call him a fundamentalist, he responds that he is “a fundamentalist
about spreading Islam, fighting polytheists and spreading the word of God.”
“When anything happens in the Arab world or Lebanon that has to do with Sunnis,
all eyes are on me,” the preacher says. “This is why there have been disputes
between myself and others. Maybe some people consider me a competitor.”
Born in Tripoli’s Bab al-Ramel in 1970, Deqmaq embraced Islamist thought at a
young age and become involved in the Islamic Tawheed Movement, dreaming of an
Islamic emirate in Tripoli.
Now the head of the Iqraa Institution for Social Development, the media-friendly
preacher says he manages to straddle various worlds despite the controversy
He cites Fatah al-Islam leader Abu Huraira as a friend, yet Internal Security
Forces head Maj. Gen. Ashraf Rifi also considers him a trusted mediator.
Deqmaq has played a major role in mediating for the release of the Lebanese
pilgrims captured in Syria some seven months ago.
He describes Rifi as “a dear old friend who is respected even by his foes. We
are bound by a strong relationship and he says he is proud of it.”
Although he opposes the Syrian regime, Deqmaq says he has his differences with
the Future Movement, which he criticizes for its secular nature. He also finds
himself at odds with Al-Jamaa al-Islamiya.
Calling bin Laden the “sheikh of mujahideen,” Deqmaq is pleased to say that
“Americans have uncovered some documents that say bin Laden always asked not to
hurt women and children, nor to cut down a tree or hurt Muslims. These are
evidence of the sheikh’s sincerity, may God have mercy on his soul.”
But Deqmaq insists he does not always agree with Al-Qaeda. He defends the Sept.
11, 2001, attacks on the U.S., but not all of their moves.
“I approve of fighting the Jews, the aggressors, and those who fight the Sunni
people. But I disagree with them for the attacks they have launched in Saudi
Arabia and Yemen, except for those that target the [Shiite] Houthis. I also
disagree with their attacks in Egypt.”
Al-Qaeda has no presence in Lebanon, Deqmaq maintains: “If there were Al-Qaeda
in Lebanon, Hezbollah Secretary-General [Sayyed] Hasan Nasrallah would never be
able to squirrel out of his hole.”
Over 80 killed in Aleppo university carnage
January 16, 2013/By Mariam Karouny/Agencies
BEIRUT: Two explosions tore through one of Syria’s biggest universities on the
first day of student exams Tuesday, killing more than 80 people and wounding
dozens, according to the government and an activist group.
Each side in the 22-month-old conflict blamed the other for the blasts at the
University of Aleppo, located in a government-held area of Syria’s most populous
city.
Some activists in Aleppo said a government attack caused the explosions, while
state television accused “terrorists” – a term it uses to describe the rebels –
of firing two rockets at the school. A rebel fighter said the blasts appeared to
have been caused by “ground-to-ground” missiles.
The Syrian Observatory for Human Rights, a Britain-based anti-regime activist
group, said 83 people were killed and dozens wounded, but it could not identify
the source of the blasts.
“Dozens are in critical condition,” the Observatory said in a statement, citing
doctors and students.
State television showed a body lying on the street and several cars burning. One
of the university buildings was damaged.
Video footage showed students carrying books out of the university after one of
the explosions, walking quickly away from rising smoke. The camera then shakes
to the sound of another explosion and people begin to run.
“A cowardly terrorist act targeted the students of Aleppo University as they sat
for their mid-term examinations,” Syria’s United Nations ambassador, Bashar
Jaafari, told the U.N. Security Council in New York.
He said 82 students had died and 162 more were wounded. If confirmed, the
regime’s report of a rocket attack would suggest rebels in the area had been
able to obtain and deploy more powerful weapons than before. The nearest
rebel-controlled area, Bustan al-Qasr, is nearly 2 km from the university.
Activists rejected the suggestion that insurgents were behind the attack,
however, and instead blamed the government.
“The warplanes of this criminal regime do not respect a mosque, a church or a
university,” said a student who gave his name as Abu Taym.
The rebels have been trying to take Aleppo since the summer, but have been
unable to uproot Assad’s better-armed and more organized forces.
After the blasts, Russia said it had suspended operations at its consulate in
Aleppo and advised anyone with consular issues to contact the relevant section
of the Russian Embassy in the capital, Damascus.
Elsewhere, an artillery attack in the central province of Homs killed at least
10 people, according to the Observatory, which added that warplanes launched
airstrikes on multiple rebel bastions across Syria.
The Observatory said five women were among those killed in the shelling of Houla
in Homs province.
“Houla sees daily shelling and daily fighting,” said Observatory director Rami
Abdel-Rahman.
The Syrian Revolution General Commission, a grassroots network of activists,
described the killings in Houla as a “massacre” and added that dozens more were
wounded in the shelling.
In northern Syria, an air raid in the early hours on the rebel-held town of Al-Bab
killed at least eight people, half of them women, said the Observatory.
Air raids struck the rebel-held districts of Jobar and Sultanieh in Homs city,
several of whose districts have been under a suffocating army siege for more
than six months, the Observatory said.
“They have launched an assault on districts under siege,” an anti-regime
activist in the besieged Old City neighborhood of Homs city, who identified
himself as Abu Bilal, told AFP via the Internet. “The army is trying to take
back Homs.”
The violence came one day after 57 countries asked the U.N. Security Council to
refer the conflict in Syria to the International Criminal Court, a move that
Russia’s Foreign Ministry called “ill-timed and counterproductive.”
Russia, which like China and the United States is not an ICC member, said the
referral would not help end the war.
“We believe this initiative is ill-timed and counterproductive to resolving the
main task at this moment: an immediate end to the bloodshed in Syria,” the
Russian Foreign Ministry said in a statement.
Russia’s deputy foreign minister, Mikhail Bogdanov, said Monday that the
Security Council would discuss the Syria crisis before the end of the month, in
a meeting that would likely gather deputy ministers.
Bogdanov also indicated that the U.N. was looking at ways of sending a new
observer mission to Syria.
“It seems as if the need will emerge to send a solid team of international
observers there. I think several options are being discussed,” he said.
Canada to Resettle Up to 5,000 Iranian, Iraqi Refugees
Naharnet /Canada will resettle up to 5,000 mostly Iraqi and
Iranian refugees now in Turkey, Immigration Minister Jason Kenney announced
Tuesday. "With escalating violence in the region, more people are seeking
protection in Turkey, and our commitment to resettle 5,000 mostly Iraqi and
Iranian refugees in Canada will help Turkey deal with this growing pressure,"
Kenney said in a statement. The offer is expected to free up resources for an
influx of Syrians seeking protection in Turkey from the deadly civil war that
the United Nations says has killed more than 60,000 people in nearly two years.
Ottawa has already welcomed 12,000 Iraqi refugees in recent years, mostly out of
war-torn Syria. Canada welcomes one in 10 refugees resettled worldwide.
Agence France Presse
Leadership Change in Oil-Rich Saudi Province
Simon Henderson/Washington Institute
January 14, 2013
The replacement of a long-serving provincial governor is likely related to
security concerns regarding the area's Shiite majority.
The Eastern Province is the largest of Saudi Arabia's thirteen administrative
areas and arguably the most crucial. It contains most of the kingdom's oil
reserves -- the largest in the world -- as well as most of its estimated two
million Shiites, who form a local majority. Additionally, it is the closest
province to Iran (which lies just across the Persian Gulf) and the only one that
borders the kingdom's fellow Gulf Cooperation Council member states, Kuwait,
Bahrain, Qatar, the United Arab Emirates, and Oman.
The outgoing governor, Prince Muhammad bin Fahd, supposedly resigned "upon his
own request," but the immediate speculation is that Riyadh wants a surer pair of
hands to manage burgeoning Shiite protests. Local youths have been regularly
demonstrating in towns near the kingdom's oil export facilities, resulting in
occasional armed clashes with local security forces. Riyadh is no doubt worried
about potential contagion from the near-daily Shiite protests in neighboring
Bahrain, which is connected to the Saudi mainland by a causeway.
The new governor is Prince Saud bin Nayef, the older brother of recently
appointed interior minister Prince Muhammad bin Nayef. Both are sons of the late
crown prince and interior minister Prince Nayef bin Abdulaziz, who died last
year. Their father had a reputation for believing wild conspiracy theories and
distrusting Shiites; although his sons are probably more sophisticated, Saud's
appointment is nevertheless being viewed as a step toward firmer action. (For
his part, Muhammad bin Nayef met with President Obama in the White House today,
a week after visiting London to discuss security cooperation with Prime Minister
David Cameron and other senior British officials.)
In addition, a new governor has been appointed for Medina province: Prince
Faisal bin Salman, who has a doctorate from Oxford University in Saudi-Iranian
relations. He is said to be the most intelligent and favored son of his father,
Crown Prince Salman.
Although the appointments were made in the name of King Abdullah, the monarch
has been mostly out of the public eye since undergoing back surgery in November.
Today's weekly Council of Ministers meeting was chaired by Salman. This was
perhaps surprising because a royal decree announced new members for that
consultative body just last week -- including, for the first time, women, who
will make up twenty percent of the 150 members, an advance that the king is
known to personally favor.
The two announcements illustrate the dichotomy of Saudi policy toward
present-day challenges, so a nuanced U.S. approach is in order. First, the
Eastern Province change reflects the notion that Riyadh's primary worries are
Iran and Shiite loyalty. Despite acknowledging the kingdom's focus on the
security of its oil facilities, Washington is likely concerned that tough
tactics against Shiites demonstrating for more rights could rebound. Second, the
appointment of women to the ministerial council will pass for progress in Saudi
terms and please U.S. officials, but it would be a shame if this modest advance
sets a low bar for future progress.
**Simon Henderson is the Baker fellow and director of the Gulf and Energy Policy
Program at The Washington Institute.