LCCC ENGLISH DAILY
NEWS BULLETIN
August 12/2013
Bible/Faith/Quotation for today/Paul's
Prayer
Ephesians 01 /15-23: "For this reason, ever
since I heard of your faith in the Lord Jesus and your love for all of
God's people, I have not stopped giving thanks to God for you. I
remember you in my prayers and ask the God of our Lord Jesus
Christ, the glorious Father, to give you the Spirit, who will make you
wise and reveal God to you, so that you will know him. I ask that
your minds may be opened to see his light, so that you will know what is
the hope to which he has called you, how rich are the wonderful
blessings he promises his people, and how very great is his power
at work in us who believe. This power working in us is the same as the
mighty strength which he used when he raised Christ from death and
seated him at his right side in the heavenly world. Christ rules
there above all heavenly rulers, authorities, powers, and lords; he has
a title superior to all titles of authority in this world and in the
next. God put all things under Christ's feet and gave him to the church
as supreme Lord over all things. The church is Christ's body, the
completion of him who himself completes all things everywhere.
Latest analysis, editorials, studies, reports, letters & Releases from miscellaneous sources
Seven Pillars of Fiction/By: Efraim Karsh/The Wall Street Journal/August 12/13
When McCain Visits us/By: Mostafa Zein/Al Hayat/August 12/13
Latest News Reports From Miscellaneous Sources/August 12/13
Pope asks Muslims, Christians to promote respect
Ambush in east Lebanon kills two, wounds Arsal mayor
Arsal Mayor Hurt, Companion Killed as Convoy Attacked
after Hostage Swap
Hariri Calls for Preventing Strife after al-Labweh Ambush
Report: Army Thwarts Suicide Attack at Arsal Checkpoint
Suleiman, Miqati, Salam Urge Arrest of Hujairi's Convoy Attackers
Aazaz Hostage Relative Held over Alleged Links to Kidnappers of Turks
Report: Turkish Pilots' Kidnappers Professionals, Not Relatives of Aazaz Abductees
Al-Rahi Slams 'Disgraceful' Abduction of Turks, Urges Release of Aazaz Pilgrims
Charbel Pledges Positive News on Turkish Pilots in
Upcoming Days: They are Doing Well
Sheikh Abbas Zgheib: Relatives of Aazaz Pilgrims Entitled
to Take Escalatory Steps against Turkish Interests
Canada Condemns Eid al-Fitr Bombing in Iraq
Bahrain blocks Hezbollah’s al-Manar TV website
Will Hezbollah wage terror campaign against UNIFIL?
Syria rivals engage in propaganda warfare
Syria Rebels Pass on 13 Kidnapped Kurds to Jihadists
Syria: Barzani pledges to defend Syrian Kurds against Al-Qaeda
Egypt’s Muslim Brotherhood goes underground, hides command
structure in Gaza
Morsi Loyalists Rally in Cairo as Crackdown Looms
Egypt: Sinai Jihadist group says it was targeted by Israeli drone
US
seeks Libyan permission for drone attacks, says source
Al-Azhar calls for reconciliation in Egypt
The Muslim Brotherhood is vulnerable to internal strife
The Muslim Brotherhood is not likely to suffer internal strife
At Least 8 Militants Killed in Egypt's Sinai Air Raids
Some U.S. Embassies Reopen after Security Alert Closure
Netanyahu Recovering after Hernia Operation
U.S. Condemns Iraq Attackers as 'Enemies of Islam'
Morocco: The King and the Frankness Approach
Pope asks Muslims, Christians to promote respect
August 11, 2013/Daily Star /VATICAN CITY: Pope Francis
expressed hope Sunday that Muslims can work together
with Christians to promote mutual respect. The pope
spoke from his studio window overlooking St. Peter's
Square during his traditional Sunday appearance. He said
that "our brothers" the Muslims had just concluded their
holy month of Ramadan, dedicated to fasting, prayer and
alms-giving. Tens of thousands of Romans and tourists
turned out in the square in blistering heat for the
papal appearance and blessing. Francis has decided to
spend summer at the Vatican instead of at the customary
papal villa in Castel Gandolfo, a hill town southeast of
Rome where the weather is usually cooler, especially on
summer evenings.
Aazaz Hostage Relative Held over Alleged Links to
Kidnappers of Turks
Naharnet/Mohammed Saleh, a relative of one of the Aazaz
abductees, was arrested on Sunday on charges of having
links to the kidnappers of the two Turkish pilots.
“The (Internal Security Forces') Intelligence Bureau
managed to identify all the kidnappers of the two Turks
and it arrested Mohammed Saleh on suspicion that he's
involved in the operation,” Future TV reported.
Earlier on Sunday, al-Jadeed television said Saleh was
arrested after authorities “intercepted phone calls
proving his links to the abductors of the Turks.”
“The families of the Aazaz abductees have given security
agencies a one-hour deadline to release Mohammed Saleh,
threatening to obstruct aviation at the Beirut airport,”
al-Jadeed added.
But Adham Zgheib, another relative of one of the
Lebanese abductees, told Voice of Lebanon radio (93.3)
that the families have no intention to block the road
leading to and from the Rafik Hariri International
Airport and that they will rather stage a sit-in outside
the headquarters of the ISF. Meanwhile, Sheikh Abbas
Zgheib, who has been tasked by the Higher Islamic Shiite
Council to follow up the case of the abducted pilgrims,
said a Lebanese security agency had arrested Saleh
between 6:00-7:00 p.m. and that he was in a car with his
family.
“Why was Saleh arrested and what are the legal grounds
for his detention? If he was arrested over claims that
phone calls were intercepted in the case of the abducted
Turks, then they have to arrest all the honorable people
in Lebanon,” said Zgheib in an interview with the
National News Agency. He noted that the families of the
abductees were threatening to escalate their protests
although he denied that they have set a specific
deadline and said he was trying to pacify their anger.
Referring to the case of Salafist activist Shadi al-Mawlawi,
Zgheib said: “All hell broke loose in the past over the
arrest of a terror suspect and ministers and prime
ministers were mobilized to release him and transport
him in their cars, so what is the justification for the
arrest of a person whose crime is that his relative was
abducted more than a year ago amid total negligence (by
Lebanese officials)?”
Later on Sunday, Zgheib told NNA that the abductees'
families will not make any escalatory steps and that
they will give a chance to mediations.
A Turkish pilot and co-pilot were kidnapped by gunmen on
Friday on the airport road.
The attack prompted Turkey to issue a travel warning
urging its citizens to avoid unnecessary travel to
Lebanon and those already present in the country to
leave.
The relatives of the pilgrims held in Aazaz were quick
to deny having any links to the abduction.
Eleven pilgrims were kidnapped in Syria's Aleppo region
in May 2012 as they were making their way back to
Lebanon by land from pilgrimage in Iran.
Two of them have since been released, while the rest
remain in Aazaz. Their relatives have held Turkey
responsible for their ongoing abduction.
They have repeatedly vowed to take action against
Turkish interests in Lebanon in order to pressure Ankara
to release the captives.
Sheikh Abbas Zgheib: Relatives of
Aazaz Pilgrims Entitled to Take Escalatory Steps against
Turkish Interests
Naharnet /Sheikh Abbas Zgheib, who has
been tasked by the Higher Islamic Shiite Council to
follow up the case of the abducted Lebanese pilgrims in
Syria, defended the right of the relatives of the
captives to target Turkish interests in Lebanon in order
to pressure Ankara to release them, reported the Kuwaiti
daily al-Anbaa on Sunday. He said: “The relatives have
every right to take any appropriate escalatory measure
they see fit to harm Turkish interests in Lebanon.” “Any
action they take to that end will be legitimate and
just,” he stressed. On the abduction of two Turkish
pilots in Lebanon on Friday, he said: “The Lebanese
state has the right to intervene to resolve this issue,
but it should in return fairly deal with this issue and
not simply seek to appease Turkey.”The lack of any
decisive official Lebanese position on the pilgrims'
abduction prompted the kidnapping of the pilots by the
Zuwar al-Imam Rida group,” Zgheib explained. “The group
cannot be blamed if its goal was to ensure the release
of the pilgrims,” he stressed.
“The Turkish state is the only side that should be
blamed and condemned for its attempts to stall the
release of the captives,” he added. He also said that
the March 14 forces should be blamed as well because its
positions have only encouraged the Turkish stances.
Asked if the pilots' abduction will harm General
Security chief Abbas Ibrahim's efforts to release the
pilgrims, Zgheib replied: “The members of the follow up
committee on the pilgrims' kidnapping understand the
good intentions of the Zuwar al-Imam Rida group.” “The
group realized that the approach of negotiations to
resolve the case will not yield any results and it
therefore abducted the pilots believing that a
counter-kidnapping may pressure the captors to release
the pilgrims,” he noted. A Turkish pilot and co-pilot
kidnapped by gunmen on Friday. Six gunmen intercepted a
van carrying the Turkish Airlines employees from Rafik
Hariri International Airport to a hotel in the Ain
Mreisseh seafront at dawn Friday, kidnapping the two
pilots - Murat Akpinar and Murat Agca - but leaving the
four other crew members behind. The attack prompted
Turkey to issue a travel warning urging its citizens to
avoid unnecessary travel to Lebanon and those already
present in the country to leave. The relatives of the
pilgrims held in Aazaz were quick to deny having any
links to the abduction.
Eleven pilgrims were kidnapped in Syria's Aleppo region
in May 2012 as they were making their way back to
Lebanon by land from pilgrimage in Iran. Two of them
have since been released, while the rest remain in Aazaz.
Their relatives have held Turkey responsible for their
ongoing abduction. They have repeatedly vowed to take
action against Turkish interests in Lebanon in order to
pressure Ankara to release the captives.
Al-Rahi Slams 'Disgraceful' Abduction of Turks, Urges
Release of Aazaz Pilgrims
Naharnet/Maronite Patriarch Beshara al-Rahi on Sunday
condemned as “disgraceful” the abduction of two Turkish
pilots near Beirut's Rafik Hariri International Airport,
saying they were kidnapped in a prearranged and
“professional” manner amid “the absence of the state's
security authorities.” Al-Rahi warned that the operation
will harm Lebanon's image, urging state officials to
stop being “reckless concerning security and people's
interests.”
“Enough with your personal disputes at the expense of
Lebanon and its institutions and people,” the patriarch
added, urging the release of the pilots as soon as
possible.
“We reiterate our call for the release of the Lebanese
abductees in (Syria's) Aazaz as well as the two bishops
Boulos Yazigi and Youhanna Ibrahim and the three priests
who were kidnapped in Syria and we pray for this to
happen,” al-Rahi said. He also blasted Lebanese
officials over the delay in “forming a new cabinet;
holding the parliamentary polls; drafting a fair and
just electoral law; finalizing the administrative
appointments, executive decrees and legislation;
resolving the judicial issues; confronting the economic
and social challenges; and fending off the security
threats created by the repercussions of the war in Syria
and the refugee influx.”
Charbel Pledges Positive News on Turkish Pilots in
Upcoming Days: They are Doing Well
Naharnet/Caretaker Interior Minister Marwan Charbel
stressed on Sunday that investigations are “on track” to
determine the fate of the abducted Turkish pilots and
ensure their release, reported Voice of Lebanon radio
(93.3).
He told the radio: “The pilots are doing well and we
hope to have positive news in the case in upcoming
days.”“We are employing all possible means to find
them,” he added. “The most important thing is that we
find their location, make sure they are safe, and ensure
their release,” stated the minister. Furthermore, he
urged the media to refrain from analyses that may harm
the investigations. “All sides are being cooperative in
investigating the abduction of the pilots,” he said in
response to whether Hizbullah was contributing to these
efforts.A Turkish pilot and co-pilot kidnapped by gunmen
on Friday. Six gunmen intercepted a van carrying the
Turkish Airlines employees from Rafik Hariri
International Airport to a hotel in the Ain Mreisseh
seafront at dawn Friday, kidnapping the two pilots -
Murat Akpinar and Murat Agca - but leaving the four
other crew members behind. The attack prompted Turkey to
issue a travel warning urging its citizens to avoid
unnecessary travel to Lebanon and those already present
in the country to leave.
Suleiman, Miqati, Salam Urge Arrest of Hujairi's Convoy
Attackers
Naharnet/President Michel Suleiman on Sunday held talks
with the security officials over the deadly al-Labweh
incident that happened earlier in the day, urging
“utmost efforts to contain the situation and arrest the
perpetrators and refer them to the relevant judicial
authorities.” “Resorting to such methods, amid the
breakthrough in the issue of the abductees, will further
complicate things and create new problems,” Suleiman
said.
Arsal municipal chief Ali al-Hujairi and two of his
companions were wounded while a man was killed when
their convoy came under fire in the Bekaa town of al-Labweh
earlier on Sunday, shortly after they took part in a
hostage swap that took place in Ras Baalbek. A military
source told Agence France Presse that the ambush comes
in retaliation to a deadly attack on four young men near
Arsal in June and that it was carried out by members of
the Jaafar and Amhaz families as the car passed the town
of al-Labweh. For his part, caretaker Prime Minister
Najib Miqati contacted caretaker Defense Minister Fayez
Ghosn, caretaker Interior Minister Marwan Charbel, army
Chief of Staff Maj. Gen. Walid Salman and the
dignitaries of Arsal. Miqati stressed the importance of
“cooperation among all the residents of the region to
address the repercussions of the incident and thwart any
attempt to stir strife among their ranks.” The premier
noted that security agencies are “performing their
duties to apprehend the culprits and refer them to the
judiciary.”
Meanwhile, PM-designate Tammam Salam contacted the
interior minister to inquire about the circumstances of
the attack, urging the army and security forces to “deal
with this act with utmost firmness in order to arrest
the perpetrators and bring them to justice.” Salam said
the incident highlights “the volatile and critical
situation in the Bekaa region and the urgent need for
joint efforts from all the political parties and
residents to confront all attempts at stirring strife
and undermining stability and civil peace.”
Report: Turkish Pilots' Kidnappers Professionals, Not
Relatives of Aazaz Abductees
Naharnet /Initial reports in the kidnapping of the two
Turkish pilots have found out that the abductors are
professionals and not amateurs, reported the daily An
Nahar on Sunday. It explained that the high level of
professionalism in the operation indicates that the
captors are not relatives of the Lebanese pilgrims held
in Syria's Aazaz region. The kidnapping raised questions
over the efficiency of the security measures taken at
the airport seeing as the Turkish Airlines pilots were
abducted at a distance of less than 200 meters from
Rafik Hariri International Airport. The kidnappers would
have had to monitor the arrival time of the pilots'
plane and set up the ambush in the busy airport area
without being detected, added the daily. Observers
questioned how the assailants set up the fake
checkpoint, changed the course of traffic along the
airport highway, and carried out the abduction out in
the open, reported An Nahar. “How is that the kidnappers
knew the complete details of the Turkish Airlines flight
and the exact time that its crew needed to arrive at the
airport, leave the premises, and get to the ambush?”
they asked.
Investigations are so far focusing on the telephone
calls conducted before the landing of the plane, it
stated. A Turkish pilot and co-pilot kidnapped by gunmen
on Friday. Six gunmen intercepted a van carrying the
Turkish Airlines employees from Rafik Hariri
International Airport to a hotel in the Ain Mreisseh
seafront at dawn Friday, kidnapping the two pilots -
Murat Akpinar and Murat Agca - but leaving the four
other crew members behind.
The attack prompted Turkey to issue a travel warning
urging its citizens to avoid unnecessary travel to
Lebanon and those already present in the country to
leave. The relatives of the pilgrims held in Aazaz were
quick to deny having any links to the abduction. Eleven
pilgrims were kidnapped in Syria's Aleppo region in May
2012 as they were making their way back to Lebanon by
land from pilgrimage in Iran.
Two of them have since been released, while the rest
remain in Aazaz. Their relatives have held Turkey
responsible for their ongoing abduction. They have
repeatedly vowed to take action against Turkish
interests in Lebanon in order to pressure Ankara to
release the captives.
Hariri Calls for Preventing Strife after al-Labweh
Ambush
Naharnet/Former Prime Minister Saad Hariri on Sunday
telephoned Army Commander General Jean Qahwaji and
discussed with him the attack that targeted the convoy
of Arsal municipal chief Ali al-Hujairi earlier in the
day, the ex-PM's office said. "Hariri stressed the need
to take the measures necessary to pursue the
perpetrators, noting that this incident is part of the
nonstop attempts to drag the country into further
tensions,” the office added.
The former premier also telephoned al-Hujairi, who
briefed him on the circumstances of the attack. During
his talks with the municipal chief, Hariri condemned the
incident and warned against being dragged into the plots
of “those who are trying to ignite sedition,” said a
statement issued by the ex-PM's office. Al-Hujairi and
two other people were wounded while a man was killed
when their convoy came under fire in the Bekaa town of
al-Labweh earlier on Sunday, shortly after they took
part in a hostage swap that took place in Ras Baalbek,
state-run National News Agency reported. A military
source told Agence France Presse that the ambush comes
in retaliation to a deadly attack on four young men near
Arsal in June and that it was carried out by members of
the Jaafar family as the car passed the town of al-Labweh.
Report: Army Thwarts Suicide Attack at Arsal Checkpoint
Naharnet/The army succeeded on Friday night in thwarting
a suicide bomb attack against a checkpoint in the Bekaa
region of Arsal, reported An Nahar daily on Sunday. It
revealed that soldiers had halted the attack shortly
after it stopped a Syrian, a Palestinian, and Danish
citizen of Palestinian origins at the Hmeid checkpoint
on the outskirts of Arsal. They were traveling from
Syria in a Mitsubishi vehicle without license plates or
identification cards. Upon halting the vehicle, one of
the Palestinians, wearing an explosive belt, stepped out
of the car and attempted to blow himself up. The
soldiers however shot and killed him before he would
carry out his attack.
His two companions have since been arrested. A
Kalashnikov rifle and another explosive belt attacked to
a hand grenade was found in their possession.
The Army Command had initially revealed the attack in a
statement on Friday night, saying that it had arrested
three gunmen as they attempted to infiltrate Lebanon
from Syria earlier that day. On July 14, the army
arrested a number of individuals for transporting
weapons in Arsal. The Beirut-based, pan-Arab television
al-Mayadeen said those arrested were two Syrians, a
Lebanese and two Palestinians who were carrying "suicide
vests."
Border areas in the North and East have been struck by
frequent cross-border shelling and clashes linked to the
Syrian crisis, while the Syrian regime has told Lebanon
to better control its porous border to prevent the
smuggling of fighters and arms. Lebanon is sharply
divided over the war in Syria and Arsal is a particular
flashpoint as refugees from the uprising and fighters
and smugglers hostile to the regime of Syrian President
Bashar Assad traverse the border.
Arsal Mayor Hurt, Companion Killed as Convoy Attacked
after Hostage Swap
Naharnet/Arsal municipal chief Ali al-Hujairi was
wounded and his companion Mohammed Hasan al-Hujairi was
killed when their convoy came under fire in the Bekaa
town of al-Labweh on Sunday, shortly after a hostage
swap that took place in Ras Baalbek, state-run National
News Agency reported.
Two other companions of the municipal chief were also
injured in the attack, NNA said, noting that Mohammed's
body was transported to Dar al-Amal Hospital in Douris.
Ali al-Hujairi “was on his way back from a hostage swap
that saw the exchange of Youssef al-Meqdad for several
abductees who hail from Arsal when he fell into an armed
ambush on the road between al-Labweh and al-Nabi
Othman,” the agency reported. The ambush was staged by
“gunmen who were in four cars: a Cherokee and a Yukon
SUVs and two Mercedes cars,” NNA said, adding that
Hujairi was lightly wounded in the head while Ahmed
Khaled al-Hujairi, aka al-Qatsheh, was critically
injured. “Ali al-Fliti, aka Ali Zahwi, received light
injuries to his hand and he left hospital together with
the municipal chief after they received the necessary
treatment,” the agency added.As soon as the news of the
ambush broke out, tensions soared in Arsal and a number
of men fired their weapons in the air to condemn the
attack, NNA said.
In the Bekaa town of Saadnayel, protesters blocked roads
in condemnation of the attack as gunmen deployed on the
streets, according to al-Mayadeen television.
Earlier, OTV said “al-Nusra Front militant” Abou Khaled
al-Qatshi, who hails from Arsal, was killed in the
ambush. But NNA said it received phone calls from a
number of Arsal residents who denied that one of the
wounded is a Nusra member. Military sources told LBCI
television that the armed group that staged the attack
also kidnapped Syrian national Mohammed Abbas.
Later on Sunday, the army heavily deployed in al-Labweh's
square and on the road leading to Arsal, according to
OTV.
A group calling itself “The Brigades of the Four
Martyrs” has claimed the attack, Voice of Lebanon radio
(93.3) said. Later on Sunday, the army issued a
statement confirming the casualties and saying the
gunmen also abducted two Syrians who were in the convoy.
"Army units deployed in all Bekaa regions, especially in
northern Bekaa, have taken extraordinary measures to
prevent any escalation,” it said. Troops are also
conducting “a major search and investigation operation
to identify and arrest the perpetrators and refer them
to the relevant judicial authorities,” the statement
added. A military source told Agence France Presse that
the incident comes in retaliation to a deadly attack on
four young men near Arsal in June. He said the
attack was carried out by members of the Jaafar and
Amhaz families as the car passed the town of al-Labweh.
The four men were killed on June 15 as they smuggled
fuel in the region, a security source said at the time.
Members of the Jaafar family, to which two of the slain
men belonged, responded furiously and the Lebanese army
called for calm in the area, which is home to both
Shiite and Sunni towns.
While the deaths were believed to be linked to control
of the lucrative smuggling trade in the region, they
came amid tensions between Lebanon's Sunni and Shiites
communities sparked by the conflict in neighboring
Syria.
Morsi Loyalists Rally in Cairo as Crackdown Looms
Naharnet/Supporters of ousted Egyptian president
Mohammed Morsi rallied on Sunday to demand his
reinstatement, amid last ditch efforts for
reconciliation ahead of a threatened crackdown on
protests.
A large convoy of cars carrying pictures of the deposed
president beeped their horns as they drove through a
neighborhood in east Cairo.
Hundreds at a women's march in central Cairo chanted
against army chief Abdel Fattah al-Sisi who was behind
Morsi's overthrow, shouting: "Sisi is a traitor, Sisi is
a killer."Morsi loyalists, led by the Muslim
Brotherhood, have kept up two huge camps in Cairo to
protest against the Islamist president's ouster by the
military on July 3, with regular demonstrations around
the country.
They say nothing short of his reinstatement will
persuade them to disperse, despite several warnings by
the interim leaders that the camps will be dismantled
after the Eid al-Fitr holiday which was to end on
Sunday.
In a sign of the mounting tensions, a brief overnight
power cut at the main sit-in outside the Rabaa al-Adawiya
mosque struck panic among the pro-Morsi demonstrators,
with some taking to social media to announce the assault
had begun. Protest organizers told Agence France Presse
that as the electricity went out, they reinforced their
barricades, added sandbags to the entrances of the
protest site, and sent volunteers to find out what was
happening, only to be told it was a false alarm.
The main coalition of Morsi supporters, the Anti-Coup
Alliance, said 10 marches would take off from various
parts of the capital on Sunday "to defend the electoral
legitimacy" of Egypt's first freely elected president.
The fresh rallies came as Al-Azhar, Sunni Islam's
highest seat of learning, called for reconciliation
talks in the latest of a string of attempts to find a
peaceful solution to the political deadlock.
Al-Azhar's Grand Imam, Ahmed al-Tayyeb, is to begin
contacts with political factions on Monday aimed at
convincing them to sit down to talks later this week,
state media reported.
"Al-Azhar has been studying all the proposals for
reconciliation put forward by political and intellectual
figures... to come up with a compromise formula for all
Egyptians," Tayyeb's adviser, Mahmoud Azab, told the
state-owned Al-Ahram newspaper. But the Muslim
Brotherhood is unlikely to accept such an invitation
after Al-Azhar sided with the military over Morsi's
ouster.
Tayyeb appeared with army chief Sisi when he announced
on July 3 that Morsi had been deposed and laid out a
political roadmap for Egypt's transition which provides
for new elections in 2014.
Morsi's turbulent single year in power polarized
Egyptians and his ouster by the military only deepened
divisions.
The Islamist leader was widely criticized for
concentrating power in Brotherhood hands and under his
tenure Egypt saw political divisions spill out onto the
streets in deadly clashes while the economy tumbled.
On June 30, millions took to the streets to demand
Morsi's ouster, openly calling on the army to remove
him.
The interim leadership is now under immense pressure at
home to crack down on the pro-Morsi protests, and
immense pressure from the international community to
avoid bloodshed.
Senior U.S., EU and Arab envoys flew into Cairo in
recent weeks to try to persuade the two sides to find a
peaceful way out of the crisis. But the government vowed
on Wednesday to clear the Islamist protest camps, saying
foreign mediation had failed. More than 250 people have
been killed in clashes since Morsi's ouster, following
days of mass rallies demanding his resignation.
The government had already ordered police to end the
pro-Morsi protests, which it described as a "national
security threat." Meanwhile, the army pursued a campaign
against militants in the lawless Sinai peninsula, with
the latest air strikes leaving 25 people dead and
injured, the military said. In the town of Touma,
witnesses confirmed eight people were killed, with their
funerals held Sunday.
Militants based mainly in north Sinai near Israel's
border have escalated attacks on security forces and
other targets since Morsi's ouster.SourceAgence France
Presse.
Egypt’s Muslim Brotherhood goes underground, hides
command structure in Gaza
DEBKAfile Exclusive Report August 11, 2013/On July 22,
debkafile revealed that a group of six Muslim
Brotherhood officials escaped from Egypt after the July
3 overthrow of president Mohamed Morsi in a military
coup and smuggled themselves into the Gaza Strip to lead
an uprising against the military. The group was headed
by Mahmud Izzat Ibrahim, known as the Brotherhood’s
“iron man” and fourth in rank in its hierarchy after
Supreme Guide Muhammed Badie. The fugitives set up a
command post at the Gaza Beach Hotel for operations
against Egyptian military and security targets in
collaboration with Hamas and armed Al Qaeda-linked
Salafist Bedouin in Sinai. The group planned their
revolt to spread quickly out from Sinai to Egypt proper
and topple the interim rulers in Cairo.
Western intelligence agencies following the inner
workings of the Muslim Brotherhood have since discovered
that the Brotherhood’s plans are a good deal more
high-powered than first thought.
According to debkafile’s intelligence sources, the
movement never dismantled its clandestine paramilitary
underground. Its hidden commanders manipulated front
politicians from the shadows under three Egyptian
presidents and continued to do so after the Brotherhood
was elected to power in Cairo in 2012. At all
times since then, the Brothers stood ready to step in
should their Freedom and Justice Party leaders be ousted
and sent back to prison. “Supreme Guide,” Mohammed Badie
was therefore no more than an obedient front for the
Muslim Brotherhood’s real leader, who was until now Mr.
X. It now transpires that he is none other than Mahmoud
Izzat Ibrahim, who is firmly at the helm and running the
show both in Sinai and Cairo from the Gaza Beach Hotel,
under the auspices of the Palestinian Hamas rulers. He
plans to confront with violence every action ordered
against the Brotherhood by Defense Minister, Gen.
Abdel-Fattah El-Sisi.
While conducting a war of terror against military
targets in Sinai, Izzat Ibrahim’s orders keep thousands
of followers maintaining their sit-in protests in Cairo
for their president's reinstatement. They are determined
to leave the military no option but to use force to
disperse them. Ibrahim's goal is to lead his movement
into a bloody confrontation with the military. Gen. El-Sisi,
for his part, knows that the Brotherhood’s underground
command center in the Gaza Beach Hotel must be destroyed
in order to beat its war of resistance. For effective
action in the Gaza Strip, the Egyptian military needs
help from Israel’s Defense Forces, just as the IDF needs
the Egyptian army to counteract the al Qaeda and other
Islamic terrorists in Sinai who are dedicated to
attacking Israel as well as Egypt.
This tacit interdependence and the interchanges against
a shared enemy shot into prominence over two incidents.
The first was the two-hour closure Thursday, Aug. 8 of
Eilat airport at Israel’s southernmost tip, following an
Egyptian intelligence tip-off over a missile threat from
Sinai. Then Friday, Aug. 9, foreign sources reported
that two missiles fired by an Israeli drone in North
Sinai destroyed a missile launcher and killed four or
five terrorists at Ajarah. Israel never confirmed this
attack. The impression it made was quickly overlaid with
conflicting reports. Egyptian officials initially
attributed the Israeli drone attack to intelligence
cooperation between the two armies. An Al-Qaeda group in
Sinai, Ansar Beit al-Maqdis, accused Israel of killing
four of its members by a drone strike and vowed
vengeance. debkafile reported that the attack may not
have been conducted by Israel but Egyptian authorities,
which preferred to disavow an operation carried out on
the Muslim festival of Eid al-Fitr.
Finally, Sunday, the Egyptian military reported that its
operation against armed groups in the Sinai believed to
have been plotting attacks on security forces and other
targets was ongoing. At least seven people were killed
over night and six arrested in a raid. The Egyptian
military statement went on to report that the raid
followed an air strike by the Egyptian military on
Friday, which saw at least four people killed. The
assault on Saturday happened when Apache helicopters hit
areas south of Sheikh Zuwaid in north Sinai, according
to Egyptian state media. Israel’s Defense minister
commented: “The Egyptian army is fighting first and
foremost to defend Egyptian citizens and sovereignty. We
will not let rumors and speculation impair the peace
relations between our countries.”
Morocco: The King and the Frankness Approach
Mohammad el-Ashab/Al Hayat
Could the case of Spanish prisoner Daniel Galvan have
taken the dimensions it did, had his crimes not featured
the raping and violation of the dignity of children?
Pardon, which is a prerogative held by the head of the
state, affected people accused and pursued on the
judicial level against the backdrop of many files. The
street, however, was shaken by the provocative character
of the acts attributed to Galvan. This means that
societies accept tolerance and forgiveness – even some
forms of arbitrary injustices prohibited by law – but
like any other body, strongly reject extraneous
behavior.
However, the controversy was not caused by Galvan’s
pardoning, which was soon recanted by Moroccan Monarch
Mohammed VI, once he realized that a grave mistake had
been committed, when the name of the accused was
included in the amnesty lists. Indeed, the measures
linked to the pardon decision revealed the possible
insertion of names or inclusion of people pursued by the
judiciary on these lists, although they do not meet the
required conditions. While this coincides with the
ongoing debate over the reform of the judiciary system
to guarantee efficiency, fairness and the quick
settlement of the files, it reveals that the legal
arsenal – no matter how accurate, sound and in line it
is with advanced international laws – is not enough on
its' own to ensure the soundness of the sentences. It is
therefore the power of conscience that spares judicial
sentences from any possible flaws.
If by pardoning Galvan, the book of amnesty is open,
namely with the dismissal of the high commissioner who
administrated prisons, whose involvement in this fault
has been proved, thanks to investigations, then the
reform of the judicial system has become a must, at
least on two levels, the first being the laws adaptation
so they become adequate to change, while the second
would have to do with the integrity of conscience, which
grants the judge the power to evaluate. The position
adopted by the Moroccan monarch will unlikely go without
repercussions, at least because this is the first time
that he recants a decision he had adopted and is not
informed about the acts of one of the people included in
the pardon. This precedent paves the way before the
enforcement of the agreements related to the retrieving
of wanted elements, in case they are foreigners or
living in foreign countries. In reality, and just like
any other people, the Moroccans are not interested in
keeping their prisons full. They are rather interested
in seeing justice done, when dealing with those who
committed rape crimes against children. As for King
Mohammed VI’s reception of the families of the victims,
it had a major impact in restoring consideration.
The paradox is that through the pardon initiative,
Morocco wanted to respond to the demands of its Spanish
neighbor. However, it fell in the trap of a pardon that
lacked the necessary judgment required in such cases,
and just like civil organizations and dignitaries
rebelled, when a minor committed suicide after she was
forced to marry the man who raped her, the pardoning of
the children’s rapist provoked angry reactions. This
means that the Moroccan street is practicing a more
stringent monitoring role towards the government than
all the parliamentary blocs, and that this role is no
longer limited to the opposition of unfair policies.
Indeed, it now affects any decisions or commitments that
are provocative and immoral. People can put up with
nature’s injustice, but they cannot succumb to that of
topical laws.
Namely in moral issues, disputes dissipate and
viewpoints converge and merge. Hence, it is out of the
question for any country – no matter how tolerant it is
– to accept seeing outlaws running loose, which is why
the ball that started rolling in the Moroccan court
reached Spain, which authorized the pursuit of Daniel
Galvan, against the backdrop of the acts attributed to
him. By doing so, Spain helped end the Moroccan
neighbor’s embarrassment, which saw how a misplaced
“reward” not only reached the wrong address, but also
provoked a wave of overwhelming anger. This reveals that
the world is still fine, as long as the people are still
upholding their moral values.
The situation provoked some sort of an aftershock. Yet,
the speed with which the Moroccan monarch dealt with it
reflected the ongoing respect of the pulse of the
street, as he went far in his honesty vis-à-vis his
people, when he said that no side was informed, at any
point and in any way, about the nature of the crimes
committed by Spanish national Galvan. In reality, when
it comes to the pardoning of thousands of people, it is
impossible for the king to look at all the papers and
information. It is thus the responsibility of the
parties included in the amnesty committee to be more
thorough and to realize the size of the responsibility
on their shoulders. However, the other side of the
picture reveals that many cases are not presented as
they truly are or are twisted, whether out of neglect or
fear. The experience which was overcome by Morocco -
despite its limited character – showed that concealing
facts from the ruler might not be beneficial, and might
even implicate him in predicaments. Honesty is a key
pillar in any wise authority, whether at the level of
strategic issues or the regular practices that might
have completely reverse results if they miss the
address.
Mediators Versus Egypt
Jihad el-Khazen/Al Hayat
I had hoped that General Abdel-Fattah Al-Sisi had
refused to receive Senators John McCain and Lindsey
Graham, the war and evil duo. I had hoped that the
interim president, Adly Mansour, and the prime minister,
Hazem Al-Beblawi, had rejected all of the foreign
efforts undertaken by people who claimed they wanted a
solution to Egypt's domestic crisis.
The two Republican Senators have supported every war
against Arabs and Muslims; the blood of Iraqi children
is on their hands. Even so, they had the nerve to claim
that they had come to Egypt as part of an effort to see
an Egyptian solution to an Egyptian problem. In fact, we
should say that their efforts were Israeli. They had
asked for a halt to American assistance to Egypt, on the
pretext that a coup had taken place. They refused to see
the millions of Egyptians demonstrating for the ouster
of President Mohamed Morsi and decided, while visiting
Egypt, that it was a failed state, or on its way to
being one - they actually hope for this, just as McCain
warned a coming bloodbath, which he would also like to
see.
As for other "gentlemen" mediators, they are either
working for the interests of their countries, as one
would suppose, or for the interest of Israel. In any
case, the interest of Egypt and its people is the last
thing they think about. The best solution should be
Egyptian, with Egyptians responsible for this solution,
perhaps helped by Arab mediation. As for the others, we
and Egypt have had enough of them, and they should keep
their distance. I cannot hide the fact that they have
deceived others. They were received by Foreign Minister
Nabil Fahmy, whose father Ismail was a wise patriot who
did not deceive, or become deceived.
I could also mention here Tawakul Karman, a dear Yemeni
woman who won the Nobel Peace Prize and was banned from
entering Egypt after she came to support Morsi. I say to
her that she should pay attention to her own country,
which has become a headquarters for al-Qaeda in the
Arabian Peninsula, i.e., a headquarters of criminal
terror, and the target of American drones, which are
killing civilians.
The situation in Egypt can tolerate no interpretations
or justifications. During the one year of Muslim
Brotherhood rule, the economy was destroyed, or nearly
destroyed. The country's reserves vanished and the
budget deficit rose by 11 percent, while in June, when
the Egyptians rose up, inflation was at 9.8 percent,
along with record levels of unemployment. The Muslim
Brotherhood's supporters demonstrated, held sit-ins and
blocked roads, bridges and tunnels to sabotage their own
country. The Egyptian Army intervened after the people
rose up against the Muslim Brotherhood regime. There was
a revolution that was bigger than the one witnessed in
2011, and it aimed at preventing acts of violence and
the collapse of security. Yet. McCain and Graham talked
about a coup after they turned their backs on the
Egyptian people. I was surprised that Senator Rand Paul
insisted that a coup took place, and asked that the $1.5
billion in US assistance be spent on America's own inner
cities. At least Paul had good intentions, even if he is
inexperienced. If he had only done the same with regard
to Israeli assistance, which is much larger than what
Egypt gets, to help revive American cities suffering
from the ongoing financial crisis; even Detroit has
declared bankruptcy. I read an editorial deserving of
mention in The Washington Post, that great liberal
newspaper. Recently, a Jewish man bought it and its
information is always correct. Its editorial page
contains fair liberal Jews and also extremist Likudniks
who put Israel's interest over that of America's.
The editorial, written by the pro-Likud types, said that
soldiers removed an elected president from power; it did
not say that millions of Egyptians did so. It did not
doubt the soundness of his election, and the figures are
there. The editorial did not take note of the millions
of Egyptians who demonstrated against a president from
the Muslim Brotherhood; it rejected the statement by US
Secretary of State John Kerry in Pakistan, when he said
the Egyptian Army intervened to restore democracy, and
insisted that the Army ousted an elected president. The
newspaper did not see that the "elected president" and
his gang tried to make Egypt into the Muslim
Brotherhood, and that the terrorist Ayman Al-Zawahiri
called for armed resistance, forgetting democracy. It
did not see that the leader of the Brotherhood, Mohamed
Badie, and his advisors faced accusations of inciting
the protestors to kill. Egypt will be saved by its
people, and the Brotherhood is a part of Egypt. It
should have a role in the coming democratic system; the
supporters of Israel, meanwhile, are enemies of God and
His people.
When McCain Visits us
Mostafa Zein/Al Hayat
The Arabs are never very optimistic about the
appearances of Senator John McCain. The former pilot has
not laid down his arms, ever since the time he was
bombing the Vietnamese people. Crimes against humanity
in Vietnam made him stronger. He still sees the United
States as the savior of mankind, whose mission is to
spread democratic values, even if forced to exterminate
savage peoples to do so. American values are more
important than human beings, especially if they serve
Washington’s interests. John McCain flares up to rescue
allies. He does not avoid going to dangerous places –
from Libya, where he supported the rebels, to north
Lebanon, where he inspected practical preparations to
storm Syria. From there, he moved to northern Syria,
where he offered his support to the groups of armed
fighters – groups affiliated to Al-Qaeda, the Al-Nusra
Front, the Free Syrian Army (FSA) and dozens of other
names. He pledged to all of them that he would pressure
the White House to establish a buffer zone “to protect
the rebels and turn it into a base for attacks towards
Damascus, so as to topple the dictatorship and establish
a just national democratic state”. It is not one of
McCain’s habits to abandon allies during crises. Here he
is, flaring up to rescue the Muslim Brotherhood in
Egypt, this time bringing along his fellow Senator,
Lindsey Graham. The two men are not interfering in
Egypt’s affairs, but they informed the leader of the
“coup”, Abdel Fattah Al-Sisi, that they had prevented
the decision to cut off military aid to the Egyptian
army from being taken. Their threat was a clear one: he
must either agree to the return of the Muslim
Brotherhood and hand power over to the people, or see
American aid cut off. To make themselves even clearer,
in case anyone had failed to understand, they added that
they represented the US Congress, but that their visit
to Cairo had taken place in coordination with the White
House. In other words, the US administration, not just
the US Congress, stands with the Muslim Brotherhood
against the army.
McCain’s argument is that the people have chosen the
Muslim Brotherhood, and that their will must be
respected. This would be a sound democratic argument if
one were to reduce democracy to merely the ballot box.
But what about the will of the tens of millions of
people, who protested against the practices engaged in
by the Brotherhood during its year in power, accusing it
of “Brotherhoodizing” great and small institutions? And
what about the Muslim Brotherhood’s foreign policy, in
continuity with the policies adopted by Egypt’s former
regime? The fact of the matter is that democracy and the
will of peoples are the least of Washington’s concerns.
This is what events have confirmed, from Latin America
to the Middle East, without forgetting Africa and Asia.
John McCain represents the finest example of such a
direction, which he seeks to embody every time he has a
chance to. Indeed, the “Arab Spring” has provided him
with a golden opportunity he simply cannot miss.
Let no Arab forget, whether they support or oppose
American policy, that the White House and the US
Congress’s main concern in the Middle East is ensuring
the security of Israel. This is no prediction or
analysis, as every statement by an American official
confirms it, and every “mediation” effort engaged in by
Senators from Congress or by the White House drives
towards it. There is no difference between Democrats and
Republicans. Anyone who departs from such a rule becomes
an outcast. It is no coincidence for Secretary of State
John Kerry to have chosen Ambassador Martin Indyk as his
aid, for reviving negotiations between the Palestinians
and the Israelis. Indeed, the man has dedicated his
entire life to the service of Zionism and Israel, and
the story of the lobby and of how he obtained American
citizenship, to be later appointed as Ambassador in Tel
Aviv under Clinton is known to everyone. John McCain is
no less of a prominent figure in this respect. He was
among the staunchest supporters of the destruction of
Iraq, the most enthusiastic about destroying Libya. He
was also of those who have called for attacking Syria
and who have incited an Israeli invasion of Lebanon. He
clings to Jerusalem as the capital of the Jewish State
and his mediation in Egypt does not depart from such a
course. However, he has failed and the more he fails,
the more he clings to his stances.
In his visit to Cairo and his defense of the toppled
president, McCain has brought suspicion on the Muslim
Brotherhood of coordinating with Israel. Is it then mere
suspicion?
Canada Condemns Eid al-Fitr Bombing in Iraq
August 10, 2013 - Canada's Foreign Affairs Minister John
Baird today issued the following statement:
“Canada unequivocally condemns the abhorrent attacks
that killed scores of people and injured more than one
hundred in mainly Shi’ite areas in Baghdad.
“Our thoughts go out to the families and friends of the
victims of this senseless violence. We also wish a
speedy recovery to those injured.
“Today’s attacks come while Muslims around the world
observe Eid al-Fitr, which marks the end of the holy
month of Ramadan. These despicable attacks appear to
have targeted Iraqi Shi’ites celebrating this Muslim
holiday.
“Canada urges Iraqi authorities to bring those
responsible to justice, and to protect those who seek to
build a more prosperous and peaceful Iraq.”
Media Relations Office
Foreign Affairs, Trade and Development Canada
613-995-1874
media@international.gc.ca
Follow us on Twitter: @DFATDCanada
Seven Pillars of Fiction
by Efraim Karsh/The Wall Street Journal
http://www.meforum.org/3577/lawrence-of-arabia-fiction
The modern Middle East was born when the European powers
exploited the declining Ottoman Empire's entry into
World War I to gobble up its lands. They did so by
duping naive Arab nationalists to rise against their
Ottoman suzerain and then cheated the Arabs of the
fruits of their uprising.
So goes the popular narrative about the origins of the
region's troubles. It's an emotionally gripping tale,
but it's also the inverse of truth. It wasn't British
officials but a Meccan potentate, Sharif Hussein ibn Ali
of the Hashemite family, who in the summer of 1915
hatched the idea of overthrowing the Ottoman Empire.
Impressed by Hussein's promises to raise the Ottomans'
Arab subjects in revolt, Sir Arthur Henry McMahon, the
British high commissioner in Egypt, tentatively accepted
Hussein's vision of an Arab successor empire and
facilitated the revolt that began in June 1916.
Hussein never came close to fulfilling his end of the
bargain. Most of the Arabic-speaking population remained
loyal to the Turks until the bitter end, viewing the
Hashemite insurrection with disdain. Even in his
hometown of Mecca the sharif didn't command absolute
loyalty. Had he not been armed and fed by Britain (and,
to a lesser extent, France) and provided with troops,
military guidance and lavish shipments of gold to buy
Bedouin loyalty, Hussein would have never been able to
launch his uprising, let alone sustain it.
This act of insubordination in a secondary theater of
the Great War played a negligible part in the fall of
the Ottoman Empire. Yet it was instantly immortalized as
the "Great Arab Revolt," winning the Hashemites
territories several times the size of the British Isles
after the war: The emirate of Transjordan (later to be
known as the Kingdom of Jordan) was established in 1921
to satisfy the ambitions of Hussein's second son,
Abdullah, while in the same year the modern state of
Iraq was created at the instigation of Abdullah's
younger brother Faisal. Hussein himself became king of
the Hijaz, Islam's birthplace, only to be evicted a few
years later by Abdul Aziz ibn Saud, the founding father
of Saudi Arabia.
It was a young British participant, Thomas Edward
Lawrence (1888-1935), who single-handedly produced this
extraordinary feat of historical deception. Though aware
that the revolt was but "a sideshow of a sideshow," as
he wrote in his cleverly titled 1922 memoir, "Seven
Pillars of Wisdom: A Triumph," Lawrence had no qualms
about mythologizing it in grand style. In the process he
catapulted himself to fame as "Lawrence of Arabia" and
became perhaps the first mega-celebrity of modern times.
His legend was amplified by generations of acolytes,
including Lowell Thomas, whose "The Last Crusade"
lectures about Lawrence played to full houses in New
York and London in 1919; the British director David
Lean, who gave us the Oscar-winning 1962 epic "Lawrence
of Arabia"; and a lengthy string of fawning biographers.
The illegitimate son of a disgraced Anglo-Irish
aristocrat and his children's governess, Lawrence
studied archaeology at Oxford and spent the prewar years
working on digs in Syria and Palestine. When the
Ottomans made their catastrophic decision to enter World
War I on the side of the Triple Alliance in November
1914, Lawrence was recruited to a new intelligence unit
in Cairo, the headquarters of Britain's war effort in
the Middle East. Two years later, in October 1916, he
accompanied a senior British official to the Hijaz to
inspect the state of the Hashemite insurrection that had
begun a few months earlier. Staying behind to report on
the situation, he endeared himself to Faisal, and the
road from there to his creation of the myth of the
revolt was short.
How did an archaeologist with no military education
successfully brand himself a world authority on
guerrilla warfare with considerable impact on the future
shape of the Middle East? The answer offered by Scott
Anderson's beautifully crafted but ultimately flawed
account of the desert revolt is that "Lawrence was able
to become 'Lawrence of Arabia' because no one was paying
much attention." As Lawrence's superiors saw it, the
author says, permitting a daring young operator to lead
the Arabs in distracting the Turks from the much
bloodier and consequential European front was a
low-cost, high-return investment.
The problem with this theory is that London did actually
commit massive resources and serious efforts to the
Middle East during the war. These ranged from the
disastrous 1915 Gallipoli landing, to the tortuous but
successful Mesopotamian campaign (1915-16), to the
conquest of the Levant (1917-18) by the Egyptian
Expeditionary Force headed by Gen. Edmund Allenby. By
the time fighting came to an end in 1918, no fewer than
one million British and Commonwealth troops had been
deployed in the region—hardly a reflection of "the low
regard with which British war strategists viewed events
in the Middle East," as Mr. Anderson claims.
The Hashemite uprising was indeed a minor sideshow in
the grand order of things, yet it was never the
free-ranging operation suggested by the author. Rather
it was an integral part of the Anglo-French war
effort—Paris sent a military mission to the revolt
commanded by a colonel—that was led by a string of
seasoned officers, such as Col. Cyril Wilson and Lt.
Col. Pierce Joyce, but never by Lawrence. As Lawrence
himself put it, "I never had any office among the Arabs:
was never in charge of the British mission with them.
Wilson, Joyce, Newcombe, Dawnay and Davenport were all
over my head."
Mr. Anderson recounts Lawrence's life in chronological
fashion, drawing on some contemporary sources, official
correspondence and the like. Yet he is too willing to
take his subject at his word, even as he acknowledges
that "earlier than most, Lawrence seemed to embrace the
modern concept that history was malleable, that truth
was what people were willing to believe."
To substantiate Lawrence's largely fictionalized version
of his exploits, Mr. Anderson juxtaposes them with those
of three contemporaries, freelancers who the author
thinks lived parallel lives to Lawrence's. Throughout
the book, the stories of these other men are interwoven
with the central narrative concerning Lawrence: William
Yale, a young oil man "who, as the only American field
intelligence officer in the Middle East during World War
I, would strongly influence his nation's postwar policy
in the region"; Curt Prüfer, a German antiquities
scholar "who, donning the camouflage of Arab robes,
would seek to foment an Islamic jihad against the
Western colonial powers"; and Aaron Aaronsohn, "a Jewish
scientist who, under the cover of working for the
Ottoman government, would establish an elaborate
anti-Ottoman spy ring and play a crucial role in
creating a Jewish homeland in Palestine."
Putting a human face on historical events is an
appealing technique that makes "Lawrence in Arabia" a
gripping read. Yet eloquence and color can't
authenticate a flawed historical argument. Prüfer is
little more than a curiosity, notable only for his
future Nazi sympathies. Yale was in no position to
affect the outcome of a war that his country joined at
the 12th hour and even then took no part in the Middle
Eastern fighting. Yale's minor advisory role at the
postwar Paris conference made no difference whatsoever
and, as Mr. Anderson writes, he "resigned from the
American peace delegation in disgust and sailed back to
New York." As for Aaronsohn, he did indeed provide vital
intelligence that facilitated Allenby's rout of the
Ottoman armies in Palestine, but he played no "crucial
role" in the creation of a Jewish homeland in Palestine.
If anything, the exposure of his spy ring in autumn 1917
triggered a draconian Turkish retribution, with the
Levant's Ottoman master, Djemal Pasha, warning Zionist
leaders that should the Turks be driven out of
Palestine, there would be no surviving Jews to welcome
the British forces.
Lawrence did indeed have a considerable impact on the
creation of the modern Middle East, but this had nothing
to do with his real war record. The revolt had been a
complete fiasco. For all the British and French efforts,
the Bedouins remained hopelessly immune to any concept
of orderly warfare. They would break for coffee in the
middle of the fighting and drop off occasionally to see
their families; often a whole clan would tire of
fighting and take a rest. They would attack small and
lightly armed Turkish garrisons but would disperse in
panic when confronted with a significant force, or even
upon hearing artillery. Small wonder that they failed to
vanquish the debilitated Ottoman forces in the Hijaz,
with the strategic (and holy) city of Medina holding out
to the end of the war. It was only in July 1917, more
than a year after the start of the revolt, that the
rebels managed to overcome the meager Ottoman resistance
and capture the small port town of Aqaba, in the extreme
northwest of the Arabian Peninsula. Their subsequent
advances, which would carry them to Damascus at the
war's end, were but a corollary of Allenby's Palestine
offensive, and even these were achieved by the
semiregular forces built by the British from among the
prisoners of war shipped to Arabia.
How Lawrence managed to pass off this sordid power-grab
by a local potentate as a heroic national revolt against
an imperial oppressor Mr. Anderson doesn't tell. He
describes Lawrence as a "painfully shy" and "supremely
private and hidden man" with a "craving for anonymity."
But painfully shy men, especially in the lowest rungs of
strict, disciplinarian hierarchies like the military,
don't treat their superiors as equal or engage in
high-level political machinations, let alone make their
inner feelings known to the entire world via
international best sellers—egomaniacs and compulsive
attention-seekers do.
Lawrence was an exceptionally gifted charlatan with a
keen eye to networking and self-promotion, who
successfully cast his spell on far more senior and
accomplished contemporaries, such as Allenby and Winston
Churchill, who in his capacity as colonial secretary put
the final touches to the post-Ottoman state system. As
Lawrence admitted, tongue in cheek, in a rare moment of
candor in "Seven Pillars": "My proper share was a minor
one, but because of a fluent pen, a free speech, and a
certain adroitness of brain, I took upon myself, as I
describe it, a mock primacy."
**Mr. Karsh is a professor of Middle East and
Mediterranean studies at King's College London and a
senior researcher at the Begin-Sadat Center for
Strategic Studies and at the Middle East Forum. He is
co-author of "Empires of the Sand: The Struggle for
Mastery in the Middle East 1789-1923."