LCCC
ENGLISH DAILY NEWS BULLETIN
ِApril
13/2011
Biblical Event Of The
Day
Luke 13/18-21: " He said,
“What is the Kingdom of God like? To what shall I compare it? 13:19 It is like a
grain of mustard seed, which a man took, and put in his own garden. It grew, and
became a large tree, and the birds of the sky lodged in its branches.” 13:20
Again he said, “To what shall I compare the Kingdom of God? 13:21 It is like
yeast, which a woman took and hid in three measures of flour, until it was all
leavened.”
Latest
analysis, editorials, studies, reports, letters & Releases
from
miscellaneous
sources
Can the US block Iran's drive
for regional hegemony?By: DAN MERIDOR/April
12/11
Latest News Reports From Miscellaneous Sources for April
12/11
Al-Rahi Meets Vatican Foreign
Minister and Cardinal Sandri, Reception Scheduled in his Honor/Naharnet
Bahrain Expels More
Lebanese, No Info on Similar Measures in other GCC Countries/Naharnet
Syrian human rights watchdog: Death
toll in protests reaches 200/Reuters
Chamoun: Hizbullah Never
Represented our Politics as it Wants to Establish Iranian State in Lebanon/Naharnet
Syria's Banias Besieged, Nearby
Village Raked with Gunfire amid Call for New Demos/Naharnet
Saudi Arabia: Second Fukushima if
Iranian Bushehr activated in May/DEBKAfile
Report: Egypt's Mubarak
hospitalized in Red Sea resort/AP
Iran's IRGC 'now occupies Syria'; Civilians killed in protests/World
Tribune
Syrian opposition says 200 killed
in protests/Reuters
Turkey police detain 40 suspected
members of Al-Qaida and Islamist militant group/Haaretz
Syria blocked injured from
medical care, group says/CNN
Student killed after Syria forces attack Damascus University
protest/Haaretz
Rights group: Scores of anti-government activists arrested in Syria/CNN
London, Rome condemn
Syria crackdown/AFP
In Iran, dozens of students attack Saudi embassy with firebombs/WFP
Next 48 hours crucial for Lebanon's Cabinet formation/Daily Star
New Lebanese cabinet expected to be announced
this week/J.Post
Williams Meets Hariri, Renews Appeal for 'Immediate Release' of Estonians/Naharnet
May Chidiac Lectures in
Washington on Lebanese Political Situation, Events in Syria, Region/Naharnet
Berri Threatens to Expose
'Another Kind' of WikiLeaks/Naharnet
Geagea: Each Individual is
Ready to Abuse the State to Fulfill his Party's Goals/Naharnet
Haitham Joumaa: Abidjan
Airport is Secure and Air Traffic Has Returned to Normal/Naharnet
Iraqi Ambassador Slams al-Akhbar
Daily's Alleged Meddling in Iraq's Affairs/Naharnet
2 People Killed in Car
Accident in Jal el-Dib, One Injured in Shooting in Dekwaneh/Naharnet
Iran-Saudi Cold War
Sparked Backlash in Lebanon/Naharnet
Six Years On, No Solution
for Missing Lebanese/Naharnet
Jumblat Questions Purpose
of Launching Debate with Iran: Let us Instead Focus on Ending Internal Tensions/Naharnet
Phalange: One-Sided and
Technocratic Governments Cannot be Formed Given Regional Developments/Naharnet
Williams Meets Baroud,
Hopes New Government Will be Formed in a Few Weeks' Time/Naharnet
On Civil War Anniversary, Suleiman
Slams Division of Shares and Urges Dialogue on Controversial Issues/Naharnet
Cabinet Discussions Reportedly Make
Progress as FPM Dismisses Atmosphere of Optimism/Naharnet
Aoun: I Have No Demands Concerning
New Cabinet, I Am Only Defending Constitution and National Charter/Naharnet
UN rights chief
calls on Syria to halt force on protestors
April 12, 2011 ghts chief on Tuesday called on Syrian authorities to halt the
excessive use of force on peaceful protestors, particularly the use of live
fire. "The High Commissioner has emphasized to the Syrian authorities that the
use of force against peaceful protestors has not quelled discontent anywhere in
the region and to take immediate action to stop the excessive use of force,
particularly the use of live ammunition against peaceful protestors," said
Ravina Shamdasani, spokesperson for the UN High Commissioner for Human Rights.
The spokesperson also highlighted a reported "intensification of killings of
protestors" by Syrian security forces, mass arrests of activists and harassment
of journalists, saying that such action had to stop."A number of journalists,
international and Syrian, as well as Syrian bloggers have reportedly been
arrested and TV signals suspended of at least one private TV station," said
Shamdasani. "Syrian authorities must immediately release journalists detained
for doing their jobs and to respect the right to freedom of expression," she
added. A coalition of six Syrian human rights groups has issued a statement
accusing the Syrian authorities of carrying out "arbitrary arrests" over the
past few days, particularly in the protest hub of Daraa, south of the capital.-AFP/NOW
Lebanon
On Civil War
Anniversary, Suleiman Slams Division of Shares and Urges Dialogue on
Controversial Issues
Naharnet/resident Michel Suleiman urged the country's politicians to fully
implement the Taef Accord lamenting that the constitution was transformed into a
mechanism of division of shares.
"We haven't yet been able to form a modern state that protects itself and
watches over the interests of its citizens," Suleiman told An Nahar daily in
remarks published Tuesday on the eve of the 36th anniversary of the Lebanese
civil war. He regretted that the National Accord reached as part of the Taef
Agreement was not fully implemented. "We deliberately distorted the
constitutional concepts and transformed them into means of division of shares."
"Political parties should continue to implement the Taef Accord with all its
articles and adopt dialogue as the only means to discuss controversial issues,"
Suleiman added. The president told An Nahar that politicians should work on
solving constitutional problems after Lebanon became "solely responsible for its
security, policies and economy without any assistance or interference by a
foreign side." Suleiman reminded politicians that they have a responsibility in
implementing the coexistence article in the constitution, stressing that this
article unlike what some people think that it is aimed at dividing shares among
sects, it urges officials to implement laws and modernize them to form a modern
state. Asked by An Nahar about the formation of the government, Suleiman said:
"We should seek to avoid gaps and not to transform the democracy that we enjoy
into vacuum and chaos." "That's why we should make an immediate initiative to
form the cabinet and … comply with the constitution," he added. Beirut, 12 Apr
11, 09:21
Al-Rahi Meets Vatican Foreign Minister and Cardinal Sandri, Reception Scheduled
in his Honor
Naharnet/Maronite Patriarch Beshara al-Rahi held talks Monday night with the
Vatican Foreign Minister Dominique Mamberti as part of his trip to the European
country, which started on April 11. On Tuesday, the patriarch met with Prefect
of the Congregation for the Oriental Churches, Cardinal Leonardo Sandri. Later
in the day, a reception will be held in al-Rahi's honor by Lebanon's Ambassador
to the Vatican, George Khoury, during which he is also scheduled to meet with
Lebanese expatriates residing in Italy. The patriarch is set to meet with Pope
Benedict XVI on Thursday.He is also scheduled to celebrate mass at St. Peter's
Basilica during which he will express gratitude to the pope for his confidence.
Al-Rahi will return to Beirut at the end of the week. Beirut, 12 Apr 11, 12:45
Geagea: Each Individual is Ready to Abuse the State to Fulfill his Party's Goals
Naharnet/Lebanese Forces leader Samir Geagea noted on Tuesday that a new
Lebanese government will not bolster the Lebanese state, but it will instead
support the March 8 camp "that likes to call itself a Resistance." He said: "We
have not recognized it as a Resistance as no law has been approved in parliament
to officially call it so." The other camp believes that the state answers to it,
he added. "Each one of us has a free opinion towards a party and we don't have
any obligations except towards the Lebanese state's constitutional
institutions," he stressed. "How are we supposed to build a state if each
individual only takes into account his party's interests?" Geagea asked.
Addressing Hizbullah Secretary General Sayyed Hassan Nasrallah's recent
statements on the March 14 camp and the WikiLeaks cables, he said: "People are
free to express their opinions." "Why is the other camp relying on WikiLeaks
while we have been announcing our opinions in the open? We have been demanding
on a daily basis the end of the possession of arms outside the state's
authority," he stressed. Beirut, 12 Apr 11, 17:53
Williams Meets Hariri, Renews Appeal for 'Immediate Release' of Estonians
Naharnet/Caretaker Prime Minister Saad Hariri held talks Tuesday at the Center
House with U.N. Special Coordinator for Lebanon Michael Williams, in the
presence of advisor Mohammed Shatah. Talks tackled "the situation in Lebanon and
also the dramatic developments in the broader Arab region," said Williams after
the meeting. "We agreed on the need to preserve Lebanon's security and stability
at all costs. In this regard, we touched on the events last week in Roumieh
prison, as well as on the abduction of the seven Estonian nationals in the Bekaa
Valley," Williams added. "Hariri updated me on the efforts of the government
under his leadership to address these issues," the U.N. official said. He
renewed his appeal for "the immediate release of the Estonian citizens." Hariri
and Williams also discussed the situation in Ivory Coast and the plight of
thousands of Lebanese who remain in that country. "I assured the Prime Minister
that the United Nations is doing all it can to ensure stability in Côte d'Ivoire
and to help those Lebanese who need the U.N.'s assistance," Williams noted.
Beirut, 12 Apr 11, 19:47
Syria's Banias Besieged, Nearby Village Raked with Gunfire amid Call for New
Demos
Naharnet/Syrian security forces locked down the protest flashpoint town of
Banias and raked the nearby village of Baida with gunfire on Tuesday, witnesses
told Agence France Presse by telephone. "Security forces and armed men are
firing machine guns indiscriminately at the village," a witness said. "The
gunfire against Baida is intense like the rain. At least one person was
injured," another witness told AFP. The army kept a stranglehold on the coastal
town of Banias, 280 kilometers north of Damascus, where residents said they
faced a bread shortage.
"Security forces and the army continue to assault Banias and we know what they
are preparing for us," said Anas al-Shuhri, one of the leaders of anti-regime
protesters.
"There is a shortage of bread in the city, electricity is cut and the majority
of phone lines are too," he added. Several residents of the coastal town,
northwest of Damascus, confirmed al-Shuhri's testimony, particularly the bread
shortage. Abdul Basset, an electrician, told AFP the situation was "extremely
bad".
"The army was redeployed outside the city and the security forces and shabbiha
(regime agents) conducted a number of arrests. The town is dead, shops are
closed," he said.
"Banias is surrounded by tanks, no one can get in or out. It is like a prison,"
said Yasser, a shopkeeper. "We cannot get bread anymore in Banias. Bread
supplies were brought from (the city of) Tartus but that is not enough. The
petrol stations are also closed," he added. Yasser said: "Security forces were
responsible for killing soldiers in Banias because they had refused to attack
the city," an account which differed sharply from the official version of
events. Preacher Sheikh Mohammed said: "Several families evacuated women and
children (to the outskirts of the town), because we are in the Ras al-Nabee
neighborhood which was targeted by gunfire from al-Quz neighborhood. "The bakers
of the town do not have enough bread," he added.
The army has encircled Banias since Sunday, when regime agents opened fired on
residents, particularly those in mosques, killing four people and wounding 17,
according to witnesses.
The official Sana news agency had said nine soldiers, including two officers
were killed on Sunday when their patrol was ambushed outside the coastal town.
Meanwhile, a Facebook group called for fresh protests in Syria on Tuesday to
show "loyalty with the martyrs, wounded and prisoners" after a bloody weekend
crackdown on anti-regime demonstrators. "Today, March 12, is the day of loyalty
towards the martyrs, wounded and prisoners, who are the heroes of the free youth
revolution," said the organizers on Facebook page the Syrian Revolution 2011,
which has played a key role in mobilizing recent protests. "We will shout
slogans despite our wounds and hold peaceful sit-ins until we obtain our
freedom," the group said. "We will not stop, nor backtrack. Our cause is clear.
It is a revolution by the people for the people and the demands are clear. Our
path is peaceful and the objective is freedom." Faced with unrelenting protests
and a rising death toll, Syrian authorities have adopted a sharper tone in
recent days, blaming the violence on "troublemakers" trying to sow discord. The
interior ministry on April 9 warned he would deal harshly with "armed groups"
who "shoot indiscriminately" on "both demonstrators and security forces". State
media on Tuesday slammed "those sowing trouble, disorder and discord when Syria
has already begun to address the problems and pave the road for change and
reform".
The semi-official al-Watan newspaper said youth groups had appealed to the
president, as commander in chief of the army, "to call on the army's reserves to
pursue and arrest those who dare point their weapons on citizens and soldiers".
Syrian students on Monday staged a rally, rare for Damascus, to express
solidarity with protesters who were killed in a bloody weekend crackdown that
left at least 30 civilians dead. Protests erupted in Syria on March 15 calling
for the regime of President Bashar al-Assad, who has been in power since 2000,
to introduce sweeping political reforms.(AFP) Beirut, 12 Apr 11, 17:24
Bahrain Expels More Lebanese, No Info on Similar Measures in other GCC Countries
Naharnet/Bahrain expelled 5 more Lebanese citizens on Monday, As Safir newspaper
said, raising the total number of those asked to leave the kingdom to 24. But
Lebanon's Ambassador to Manama, Aziz al-Qazzi, told LBCI TV network on Tuesday
that only 19 Lebanese have so far been expelled from Bahrain without any
justification. "We have no confirmation whether similar measures have been taken
in the rest of the Gulf Cooperation Council countries," he said. Al-Qazzi told
LBC that he was exerting efforts to prevent more expulsions and trying to urge
the Bahraini authorities to limit entry hardship to the Lebanese. A foreign
ministry source told As Safir that at least 14 of those expelled from Bahrain
are Shiites. Among them are women. The newspaper said that Caretaker Foreign
Minister Ali al-Shami will contact his Bahraini counterpart on Tuesday to
inquire about the reasons behind the expulsions. Some of those expelled told As
Safir that they were summoned by the Bahraini interior ministry's immigration
bureau and were asked to sign a pledge to leave the country within 48 hours. The
officials didn't give any reason for their decision, they said. The news came
after Bahrain's foreign minister accused Hizbullah of backing Shiite protesters
against the Sunni monarchy. Beirut, 12 Apr 11, 11:19
Syrian human rights watchdog: Death toll in
protests reaches 200
The Damascus Declaration group implores the Arab League to sanction the Syrian
government; Human Rights Watch reports security forces prevented wounded
protesters from reaching hospitals./Naharnet
By Reuters/Israel news
Syria's main human rights movement has said the death toll from less than a
month of protests has reached 200 and called on the Arab League to impose
sanctions on the ruling hierarchy.
"Syria's uprising is screaming with 200 martyrs, hundreds of injured and a
similar number of arrests," the Damascus Declaration group said in a letter sent
on Monday to the secretary general of the Arab League. Anti-Syrian government
protester, displays Arabic words on his hands, reading 'Yes for freedom, no to
violence' in Damascus, March 25, 2011.
The letter continued, saying "the regime unleashes its forcers to besiege cities
and terrorize civilians, while protesters across Syria thunder with the same
chant 'peaceful peaceful'."
The group implored the Arab league to "impose political, diplomatic and economic
sanctions on the Syrian regime, which continues to be the faithful guardian of
Hafez al-Assad's legacy," the letter said, referring to the iron-fisted rule of
President Hafez Assad, father of current President Bashar. Bashar, facing
unprecedented protests against his 11-year-old rule, has responded with a
synthesis of force -- his security forces have fired at unarmed protesters,
according to witnesses -- and vague promises to relax bans on freedoms, such as
replacing emergency law with anti-terrorism law. The protests, which erupted in
the southern city of Deraa last month before spreading, have demanded freedom of
expression and assembly and an end to corruption. The authorities have blamed
violence on armed gangs and "infiltrators", saying that soldiers and police also
have been killed. "President Assad has been only giving promises for the last 11
years. Instead of solutions he talks, as the regime usually does, about an
outside conspiracy," the letter said. The Damascus declaration is named for a
document signed in 2005 by prominent civic, Islamist and liberal leaders calling
for the end of 41 years of Assad family rule and its replacement with a
democratic system.
The document demanded the lifting of bans on freedom of speech and assembly and
the abolition of emergency law, under which Syria has been governed since 1963
when the ruling Baath Party took power in a coup and banned all opposition. Most
of its members have spent long periods as political prisoners, including leading
opposition figure Raid al-Turk, who spent more than 17 years in solitary
confinement under Hafez Assad. Fayez Sara, a journalist who was jailed for
two-and-a-half years along with 11 Damascus Declaration members and released in
2010, was arrested again on Sunday, rights activists said. "The secret police
have been rounding up every outspoken figure they can get their hands on. They
either call them in for 'interrogation' and keep them, pick them up from the
street or break into their homes," one of the human rights defenders said. Human
Rights Watch reported Tuesday that Syrian security forces prevented wounded
protesters from reaching hospitals and stopped medical teams from treating them
in two towns during last Friday's demonstrations.
HRW said 27 people were killed in the southern city of Deraa and one other in
the Damascus suburb of Douma on Friday. "To deprive wounded people of critical
and perhaps life-saving medical treatment is both inhumane and illegal," said
Sarah Leah Witson, HRW's Middle East director. She continued, saying "Syria's
leaders talk about political reform, but they meet their people's legitimate
demands for reform with bullets."
Based on witness accounts, HRW said security forces set up a roadblock near a
bridge in Deraa to prevent protesters crossing to the other part of town. One
witness said about 50 soldiers were in front, surrounded by several thousand
uniformed and civilian-clothed members of security services as well as snipers.
When protesters ignored the army's warnings to stop, security forces fired with
Kalashnikovs and snipers opened fire at the same time. A HRW witness said
security forces did not allow ambulances to pick up the wounded and continued
shooting when protesters tried to carry the wounded away. "(The witness) said
that he later saw the bodies of a doctor, a nurse and an ambulance driver, who,
other witnesses told him, were shot when their ambulance tried to reach the
wounded protesters," HRW said in its statement. HRW also documented the accounts
of two witnesses in the Damscus suburb of Harasta who said security forces fired
on protesters trying to help the wounded. Two doctors said they each treated
four wounded protesters with bullet wounds in various parts of their bodies.
Several were children. "The Syrian authorities are responding to protests
against repression with more repression: killings, mass arbitrary arrests,
beatings and torture," Whitson said.
President Assad has said the protests are part of a foreign conspiracy to sow
sectarian strife. His father used similar language when he crushed leftist and
Islamist challenges to his rule in the 1980s, killing thousands. Syrian security
forces sealed off the coastal city of Banias on Monday following pro-democracy
protests and killings by irregulars loyal to Assad, residents said.
Saudi Arabia: Second Fukushima if
Iranian Bushehr activated in May
DEBKAfile Exclusive Report April 12, 2011, 1
Saudi and Kuwait officials have warned the US that if Iran activates its first
nuclear reactor at Bushehr in May as planned, there is a good chance it will
blow up and the entire Gulf region suffer a nuclear disaster on the scale of the
misfortune at Japan's Fukushima and expose millions to radiation contamination.
This issue was urgently raised in recent Saudi-US talks – first on April 4 with
US Defense Secretary Robert Gates and again Monday, April 11, with the National
Security Adviser to the US President Tom Donilon.
The two high-level US official visits to Riyadh in six days attest to the fierce
discord between Saudi King Abdullah and the administration - not just over Iran
and its nuclear activity but the entire gamut of US Middle East policy.
When he met the defense secretary, the king took Gates charged that the White
House ignored Saudi intelligence evidence passed to the CIA that Tehran and
Hizballah were actively fomenting the unrest in Bahrain with a view to igniting
parallel disturbances in the eastern Saudi oil regions among the two million
Shiites living there. Abdullah complained bluntly that no matter what evidence
is put before President Obama, he refuses to budge from his course of engagement
with regard to Iran.
The king declared angrily that the lax American attitude toward Islamic
Republic's nuclear aspirations places the very existence of Saudi Arabia and the
Persian Gulf nations in peril. Washington had twisted
Saudi arms to refrain from challenging the Bushehr nuclear plant when
preparations for its activation were completed last year, despite its harmful
potential for the region. (debkafile reported last August that similar pressure
was applied to Israel.) Even the Iranians, Abdullah told Gates, were scared to
switch it on out of concern for their own people. It
was the first time the Saudi monarch linked the Iranian plant with the Japanese
nuclear calamity. Tuesday, April 12, Japan raised its severity to maximum seven
the same as Chernobyl. Four months ago, on Jan. 26,
Moscow acted outside the rules of conventional diplomacy when Russian ambassador
to NATO Dmitry Rogozin publicly demanded a NATO investigation into the effects
of the Stuxnet malworm on the Bushehr reactor. He repeated a previous warning to
President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad that "The virus attack on a Russian-built nuclear
reactor in Iran could trigger a nuclear disaster on the scale of Chernobyl."
debkafile's intelligence and Russians sources report that Russian
concerns focused on the discovery of the unexplained entry of small pieces of
metal into the cooling system. This told them that the Iranians had not managed
to stop Stuxnet or its impact on the reactor's control systems and there was no
guarantee that more malfunctions capable of causing the plant to blow up had
been were not in store. These warnings were initially heeded: Russian-Iranian
preparations to active the reactor were suspended and it was emptied of nuclear
fuel. But then Friday, April 8, the fuel was reloaded
the fuel. The next day, the head of Iran's Nuclear Energy Commission Fereydoun
Abbasi said: "Even before the earthquake and nuclear contamination crisis in
Japan, Iran had accepted Russian experts' proposal to revise its plant to load
fuel into the core of the Bushehr power plant's reactor."Iran had never before
referred to the Fukushima in relation to Bushehr. Our
sources add that the Abbasi statement clearly held Moscow responsible for any
potential nuclear disaster that may beset the Iranian facility. It also
confirmed the Saudi claim. Riyadh has accordingly demanded that Washington act
without delay and by all means possible to prevent Bushehr going on line next
month according to plan. Such US action would be
diametrically opposed to the Obama administration's Iran policy at present.
However, failure to meet the Saudi demand will deepen the acute crisis in
Saudi-US relations and mistrust sparked by the overthrow of Egyptian President
Hosni Mubarak - with effect on other related issues such as Yemen and even
Pakistan.
Iran's IRGC 'now occupies Syria'; Civilians killed in protests
http://www.worldtribune.com/worldtribune/WTARC/2011/me_syria0417_04_11.asp
WASHINGTON — Iran has deployed 10,000 elite troops in Syria to protect the
regime of President Bashar Assad and has been in effective control of the
country for the past week, the opposition said. The Reform Party of Syria said
Iran has deployed its Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps in Syria to bolster
Syria's defense. The Washington-based opposition group said the IRGC contingent
in Syria contains 10,000 troops, with headquarters in the northern province of
Homs.
"In essence, the IRGC now occupies Syria and has become its de facto ruler," RPS
spokesman Farid Ghadry said. "Syria has become the 32nd province of Iran."
Can the US block Iran’s drive for regional hegemony?
By DAN MERIDOR /J.Post
04/11/2011 01:51
http://www.jpost.com/International/Article.aspx?id=216037
Analysis: Iran has added the religious element to the conflict in a very
detrimental way, playing its hand through the proxies it has in this area.
In the Arab-Israeli conflict, the addition of a religious layer to the conflict
is new. Hamas, Islamic Jihad, and Hezbollah are all religiously-based. When one
speaks and acts for God, there is no compromise.
Iran is a nation of merchants, and it needs the world and its financial system.
This gives leverage to those who want to do something about its nuclear plans.
If there is leadership, resolve, and persistence, with more sanctions, and more
partners in the game, there is a chance that Iran will have to rethink its
policy. Europe can do more. The volume of trade between certain European
countries and Iran remains quite heavy.
In the end, this battle will determine the standing of the United States and its
power and role in the world in the 21st century. I believe that America has
enough power to reinvent itself economically and restore the power that it had,
but the perception that Iran is spreading is just the opposite.
Israel is part of the camp that America has been leading for the last 70 years
in terms of values, way of life, and democracy.
It is important to us that this camp not lose its power in the world, and that
is why a strong America is a very clear Israeli interest, regardless of whether
the Democrats or Republicans are in power.
Compare the United States with its arsenal and al-Qaeda; of course the United
States is much stronger. The Israeli army is much stronger than Hezbollah or
Hamas, but the wars with Hezbollah in 2006 and Hamas in 2009 did not end in
unconditional surrender of the other side. Success does bring deterrence, but
not surrender.
Years ago it was important to know what was happening with your neighbor because
he could attack you, but Manhattan was attacked from Afghanistan. The whole
world becomes a potential enemy or ally. The modern technological era has
reduced the importance of borders for barring information, people, or missiles.
Nations can no longer control the flow of information.
People are much more powerful, while states are less so. This also means that
the bad guys become very potent as well.
This has meant a change in the nature of war. Wars are now fought where
everybody sees them in real time on television.
This puts limits on what you can do in an open world today. The stronger side
becomes weaker because everyone can see what he does, while the weaker side
becomes stronger because everyone can see what is done to him. It does not mean
that the strong side is bad and the weak side is good, but it changes the nature
of war.
The players also now include nonstate actors. Most threatening to some Arab
regimes is the Al-Jazeera television channel. Other important actors that are
not states include the Taliban, al- Qaeda, Islamic Jihad, Hezbollah, and Hamas.
Another new factor is a return to religion in the Muslim world, as in other
parts of the world. If you ask people how they identify themselves, in the past
you would hear many people speak of their Arab identity as their first identity.
Today more people will say that they are first of all Muslim. The Taliban,
Islamic Jihad, al-Qaeda, Hamas, and Hezbollah are all religiously-based.
When one speaks and acts for God, there is no compromise. In the Arab- Israeli
conflict, the addition of this religious layer to the conflict is new.
Egypt’s Nasser never said that he fights for Allah against the Jews, nor did the
Syrians or Jordanians. Now one hears from Iran, Hezbollah, and Hamas that there
cannot be a non-Muslim state here.
The most important conflict that is developing in the world today is the
Iran-America conflict over the nuclearization of Iran. If Iran does go nuclear,
this will have implications for the world order as we know it. First, it may
spell the end of the Nuclear Non- Proliferation Treaty (NPT) regime. Some
countries, such as Egypt, have said that if Iran goes nuclear, they would too.
Others may do it without saying it.
In a world in which more countries are going nuclear, rather than giving up on
nuclear weapons or playing within the rules, the ability of the superpowers to
intervene will be harder and perhaps non-existent.
The alliance between the West and the Arab Gulf area states has been based on
those states giving access to oil – a key element in the world economy. At the
same time, the West/America is leading the defense of those regimes against
radical movements. Those countries have been concerned with Iranian
nuclearization, which would mean Iranian hegemony, coupled with the declared
Iranian policy of exporting its revolution. If America and the West cannot
protect them, they might go along with Iran. Think of a world where Iran and its
allies have such an influence over the price of oil.
Out of the 1.4 billion Muslims, the vast majority want, like every human being,
a good life and stability, although not necessarily democracy. Yet in all these
societies there are minority groups that want to destabilize this way of life
and create something new and more religiously observant, as they understand it.
They are fighting a battle against Western ideas, such as equality of women, and
against basic freedoms, such as freedom of speech. All of them are looking at
the Iran-America conflict to see who will win. A victory for Iran is a victory
for all these groups. Think of how arrogant Hezbollah may become if Iran wins
over America. Think of how arrogant Hamas will be vis-à-vis the PLO.
Iran has added the religious element to the conflict in a very detrimental way,
playing its hand through the proxies it has in this area. Hezbollah is a unique
phenomenon, a Lebanese party that is also Syrian and Iranian. Hezbollah leader
Nasrallah calls himself the personal emissary of Iran’s Supreme Leader. Here you
see more evidence of a change from a national to a religious identification.
Nasrallah is an Arab and Lebanese by nationality, and a close friend and
military ally of a non-Arab, non-Lebanese, Persian Iranian called Ahmadinejad,
fighting against other Arabs and Lebanese. This is because Nasrallah and his
followers are first and foremost Shiites, which is more important to them than
all the other components.
Iran and Syria support Hezbollah with weapons systems, intelligence, training,
and an ideology of delegitimizing and liquidating Israel.
Hezbollah has 50,000 rockets and missiles aimed at Israel from the north, more
than any other country in the world. Hamas and Islamic Jihad in Gaza, which are
Sunni, have more than 5,000 rockets aimed at Israel, some of them from Iran and
Syria.
What is the exact point at which we say that Iran is nuclear? Every day of
enrichment, Iran gets closer to its goal.
Every day in which they build more missiles with which to launch warheads, they
get closer. Every day they proceed with the weaponization process, they get
closer. It has not happened as quickly and as successfully as they wanted it to
happen, but the world needs to act so that the world order is not totally
undermined by an Iranian nuclear capability as well as its possible hegemony
within the Muslim world.
This ongoing battle between America and its allies and Iran is of major
importance to all of us. We should not ask others to fight for us. However, if
there is real world interest in stopping Iranian hegemony and its nuclear
capability, then they may do something about it in time.
As the Iranians continue with their nuclear plans, they defy the West, the UN,
and the International Atomic Energy Agency. Iran is an ancient nation with a
proud history and culture. It is a nation of merchants, and it needs the world
and its financial system. This gives leverage to those who want to do something
about its nuclear plans. Last year we began seeing some steps that were quite
important: UN sanctions, EU sanctions, and US sanctions.
If there is leadership, resolve, and persistence, with more sanctions, and more
partners in the game, there is a chance that Iran will have to rethink its
policy.
The United States has been quite successful in getting the Russians on board for
the UN resolution. Somewhat reluctantly, even the Chinese got on board.
Europe appears determined in declaring the importance of putting an end to the
Iranian attempt to go nuclear, but Europe can do more. The volume of trade
between certain European countries and Iran remains quite heavy. An organized
world has the ability to act in a concerted manner to make it clear to Iran that
it needs to change its policy.
In the end, this battle will determine not only the standing of Iran, but, to a
large extent, the standing of the United States and its power and role in the
world in the 21st century. Iran says that America is an empire of the past, and
that the American economy, the bedrock of American strength, is weak. I believe
that America has enough power to reinvent itself economically and restore its
power, but the perception that Iran is spreading is just the opposite.
Israel did not need WikiLeaks to know what some neighboring regimes think of
Iran. In meetings with an important American politician who was in Israel after
having visited six or seven Arab countries regarding the Palestinian- Israeli
issue, he said that on average each meeting was 10 percent about the Palestinian
issue and 90% about Iran. If the countries which oppose Iran get weaker, it is
better for Iran. Egypt was one of those countries which stood against Iran with
the West. We do not want to see the strengthening of the radical axis and the
weakening of the moderate axis.
The role of the free world is to support the Iranian opposition. Not that
support will immediately bring them victory, but support is the main source of
their confidence in the possibility of victory. Many people who lived in the
Soviet Union and fought against the Soviet regime to let the Jews out have said
that as long as nobody in the world knew about them, from the time of Stalin to
Brezhnev, there was little chance of success. When the world started to know and
react, the Jews knew there was a chance of success and this reinforced their
struggle.
It is important that Iran’s perception does not gain a hold on the thinking of
people in the Middle East and around the world. If America takes an openly
stated, clear lead and coalesces with its natural partners in this campaign,
this can improve America’s role in the world order that all of us want to see.
Even though we all have different state interests, we are part of the camp that
America has been leading for the last 70 years in terms of values, way of life,
and democracy. It is important to us that this camp not lose its power in the
world, and that is why a strong America is a very clear Israeli interest,
regardless of whether the Democrats or Republicans are in power.
Negotiating with Syria? Syria is the main political ally of Iran in the Arab
world. I am one of those few Israelis who think that we should negotiate with
Syria, not that I like what the Syrian regime is doing. Will there be an
agreement in the end? I know what they want from me, but what I want from them
is a full peace, like Jordan and Egypt. They must stop the support of terror
organizations, including Hezbollah, and cut away from the Iranian axis. It is an
open question whether we can get all of this.
It has to do with the strength of America and Iran. There is not just an
Israeli- Syrian closed circle; there is a bigger circle of power relationships
that needs to be taken into account.
**The writer is deputy prime minister and minister of intelligence and atomic
energy. This Jerusalem Issue Brief is based on a recent presentation to the
Institute for Contemporary Affairs at the Jerusalem Center for Public Affairs.