LCCC
ENGLISH DAILY NEWS BULLETIN
ِDecember
30/2010
Bible Of The
Day
Proverbs 20:20: "If one curses his
father or his mother, his lamp will be put out in utter darkness".
Free Opinions, Releases,
letters, Interviews & Special Reports
Saudis urge Lebanon PM
to accept compromise with Hezbollah/By Amos Harel and Avi Issacharoff/December
29/10
Accused spy says Israel
paid their Syrian agent for nuclear information/Haaretz/December 29/10
Latest News Reports From Miscellaneous Sources for December
29/10
Wissam Eid’s parents hope for
justice/Now Lebanon
Saudi-Syrian bid to solve crisis
picks up steam/Daily
Star
Israeli Deputy Prime Minister Moshe
Ya'alon:: West has three years to stop Iran nuclear program/Haaretz/Reuters
Assad: Israel has
extremist gov't not interested in
peace/J.Post
Indictment could be blow to
Lebanon's Hezbollah/AP
Saudi-Syria Compromise based on
Lebanon's Withdrawal from STL before Jan. 15, Report
/Naharnet
King Abdullah to Dispatch Son to
Beirut,
/Naharnet
Berri: Abdullah's Surgery Put
Brakes on Solution to Lebanon Crisis
/Naharnet
Saniora: Bolton's Statements are
Rejected because They are Aimed at Harming Lebanese-Syrian Ties
/Naharnet
Hizbullah Says Indictments of No
Concern but What do Analysts Say?
/Naharnet
Wissam Hasan Fears
Assassination, Report
/Naharnet
Rifi: Security Situation
Excellent
/Naharnet
Qabalan Urges Lebanese to
Cooperate to Safeguard Lebanon
/Naharnet
Mufti Qabbani Prays to Spare
Lebanon Sectarian Strife
/Naharnet
Harb: Lebanon will have a say in
the Saudi-Syrian agreement/Now Lebanon
Jouzo: Sfeir's place in our hearts
remains the same/Daily Star
Wissam Eid’s parents hope for justice
December 29, 2010 /Now Lebanon
As Lebanon braces for a UN court to issue indictments in the Rafik Hariri
murder, the parents of the police officer believed to have cracked the case are
hoping it will also shed light on who killed their son.
Major Wissam Eid, a top communications analyst with the police intelligence
bureau, was assassinated in a January 25, 2008 car bombing outside Beirut.
Three years later, his parents are none the wiser as to who killed him.
They now wait with bated breath news from the UN-backed Special Tribunal for
Lebanon (STL), which is set to issue an accusation in the 2005 Hariri murder,
with the hope that Eid's killers too will be brought to justice.
"We knew he was going to be killed. I expected him to be killed on New Year's
Eve ... But they let me keep him for 25 days," Wissam's mother, Samira, told AFP
at her home in north Lebanon.
"But as soon as I heard news of the bombing that Saturday morning, I knew it was
him," she added, wiping back tears. "I just knew."
The troubled STL is purportedly set to indict high-ranking members of Lebanon's
powerful Shia party Hezbollah over the bombing that killed the five-time Sunni
premier and 22 others in Beirut.
But Hezbollah has warned that any such accusation would have grave repercussions
– a warning that hits home hard in a country that has been plagued for decades
by paralysis, assassinations and all-out war.
Eid's name emerged as the expert who traced the mobile phone networks that
allegedly led to Hezbollah.
He had been liaising with UN investigators looking into the Hariri murder at the
time of his own killing.
The 31-year-old, who built the police force's communications analysis unit, had
been dispatched for years to the country's toughest crimes.
He headed a team tasked with tracing Al-Qaeda-inspired groups and investigating
nine murders of anti-Syrian figures as well as an army general between 2005 and
his own death in 2008.
In the northern village of Deir Ammar, the home of Wissam's parents Mahmoud and
Samira is a shrine dedicated to their son, whose intense gaze greets visitors
from oversized banners hoisted outside the town entrance.
A short walk away, on a hilltop overlooking the Mediterranean, is the young
officer's grave. Family still visit regularly to say a prayer and lay flowers
there.
In the months before his murder, Wissam's parents had been gripped by a feeling
of foreboding. Eid had been receiving threats and his boss, Samir Shehadeh, had
survived an attack on his life in which four of his bodyguards were killed.
"We knew, and knew very well, what Wissam was working on although he never
talked about it," said Eid's mother. "For about a year before Wissam was
murdered, there were always men watching the house."
Wissam himself had twice been the target of bombings. The police force took
extra security measures to protect him, keeping his travel to a minimum and
setting him up in a high-security flat near his office.
Samira, who fondly describes her son as "full of life and a moralist through and
through," concedes that his one flaw was his secretiveness.
"We knew he was threatened. We knew what he was doing was dangerous. We knew he
wouldn't be with us for long," said the elegant, veiled mother of five. "But he
never told us who was after him, although I'm sure he knew who it was.
"And even if he wanted to pull out, it was too late. When you're in over your
head, it's hard to withdraw. They would have killed him anyway. He had the
information."
The STL has been at the center of an escalating deadlock between Hariri's son
and political heir, Saudi-backed Prime Minister Saad Hariri, and the pro-Iranian
Hezbollah.
As the indictment nears, fears that the probe will send the country sliding back
into chaos are spiraling.
But Eid's father, himself a detective with the Internal Security Forces,
maintains the unwavering belief that international justice will take its course.
"We can no longer bury the truth. This is a case in the hands of the
international community, and the lead has been made public," said Mahmoud Eid.
"We must see this through. If forced to choose between peace and justice, we
choose the truth."
General Ashraf Rifi, who commands the police force, first tapped Wissam Eid to
join police intelligence in 2001. Today, he is adamant that the major's death
will not join the list of Lebanon's unsolved murders.
"At the end of the day, I am responsible for my officers," Rifi told AFP at his
office in Beirut. "Wissam Eid was a brilliant, outstanding officer. We lost a
great man.”
"But as I said at the site of the bombing to those who are sending us this
message, that we should cease working, we will not stop. This only increases our
will to continue, to see this through, no matter the costs."
For Major Eid's grieving mother, however, hope for justice is fast fading as the
years go by.
"I know my husband has another opinion, but I don't believe justice will
prevail," she said. "As long as these divisions in the country remain ... I
don't think the truth will ever see the light.
"In all honesty, the only thing that really gives me hope is that God will let
me see him when it is my time to go."
-AFP/NOW Lebanon
King Abdullah to Dispatch Son to Beirut,
Naharnet/Damascus to Finalize Deal on STL, Report/Saudi King Abdullah will
reportedly soon dispatch his son, Prince Abdul Aziz, to Beirut and Damascus to
"finalize the compromise" on the Special Tribunal for Lebanon.Al-Akhbar
newspaper on Wednesday said Abdul Aziz is to hold a series of talks with
high-ranking officials in Beirut before moving to Damascus to put the final
touches on the Saudi-Syria agreement. Beirut, 29 Dec 10, 12:01
Saudi-Syria Compromise based on Lebanon's Withdrawal from STL before Jan. 15,
Report
A Saudi-Syria compromise based on Lebanon's withdrawal from the international
tribunal is likely to be announced by January 15, the daily Al-Akhbar newspaper
said Wednesday.
It said Syrian President Bashar Assad updated President Michel Suleiman during a
Dec. 26 phone call on the content of his conversation with Saudi King Abdullah
and his son Prince Abdul Aziz regarding the Syrian-Saudi compromise "which is
near-completion." Damascus, according to what Assad informed Suleiman, is
waiting for Prince Abdul Aziz's visit to put the final touches on that
settlement, in light of the answers Assad is expecting to hear from King
Abdullah who is recuperating in New York from back surgery.
Damascus reflected the positive impression of visitors to senior Syrian
officials, who said the compromise is likely to be announced "anytime from now
till Jan. 15."
Al-Akhbar said that despite Damascus' insistence that no one could disclose
content of the Saudi-Syria settlement, only three insiders were really
up-to-date with the deal --King Abdullah, Assad and Hizbullah chief Sayyed
Hassan Nasrallah. It said the very little known about the deal – which ought to
be announced before the indictments are issued – maintains that Lebanon
reconsider its position on the STL and take the necessary action to pull out of
the U.N.-backed tribunal in line with legal, security, judicial and financial
obligations stated in the agreement with the United Nations to establish the STL.
The key issue, according to Al-Akhbar, is for Lebanon to "withdraw" from the
tribunal and not call for its annulment.
Berri: Abdullah's Surgery Put Brakes on Solution to Lebanon Crisis
Naharnet/Speaker Nabih Berri said Saudi King Abdullah's back surgery in New York
delayed a solution to the Lebanese crisis but did not obstruct the formulation
of a settlement.
Berri made his remark to Ad-Diyar newspaper in remarks published Wednesday.
He also warned that some people are obstructing the solution.
Meanwhile, sources close to Berri said the calm political atmosphere indicates
that the Lebanese crisis could be solved despite obstruction pressure.
After the resumption of normal political life and Abdullah's recovery "we could
make progress and things could be solved," the sources told al-Liwaa daily.
They advised caution, however, because of what they said "pressure to obstruct a
solution" to the deadlock. The sources told the newspaper that Prime Minister
Saad Hariri's trip to New York to visit Abdullah contributes to the Saudi-Syrian
initiative aimed at ending the crisis.Abdullah's illness "put the brakes on all
issues," they said, adding that former U.S. Ambassador to the U.N. John Bolton's
comments on the international tribunal's indictments delayed a solution. "It is
known by now that the U.S. administration favors a settlement after the release
of the indictment and not before it," the sources added. Beirut, 29 Dec 10,
08:08
Saniora: Bolton's Statements are Rejected because They are Aimed at Harming
Lebanese-Syrian Ties
Naharnet/The head of the Mustaqbal parliamentary bloc MP Fouad Saniora condemned
on Wednesday former U.S. Ambassador to the U.N. John Bolton's recent statements
to al-Hayat daily, saying that they are aimed at creating division among the
Lebanese. He also said that the statements also serve to harm Lebanese-Syrian
ties "that we only wish to see improve.""The remarks only serve Israel's
interest and are an expression of hostility towards Lebanon and Arab interests,"
he concluded. Beirut, 29 Dec 10, 15:54
Moussawi: Our Position from STL is Firm, Desire to Issue Indictment is an
Israeli Aim to Corner Hizbullah
Naharnet/Loyalty to the Resistance bloc MP Nawwaf al-Moussawi stressed on
Wednesday that the Resistance's position towards the Special Tribunal for
Lebanon "is firm as we believe it to be an American tool based on
Israeli-fabricated evidence aimed at targeting Hizbullah."He told NBN: "The
desire to issue the indictment is an Israeli one aimed at cornering the
Resistance."He questioned the "eagerness" to disregard the possibility of Israel
possibly being behind the assassinations that have plagued Lebanon and the
readiness to accept the "idea of fabricated evidence aimed at accusing a
Lebanese group."The MP repeated the opposition's demand that the false witnesses
file be transferred to the justice council.
Beirut, 29 Dec 10, 16:05
Hizbullah Says Indictments of No Concern but What do Analysts Say?
Naharnet/Hizbullah says looming indictments by a U.N. court for the
assassination of former prime minister Rafik Hariri are of no concern to the
group. Hizbullah's leader, in fact, says he is so relaxed he sleeps an extra
hour every night. Behind the veneer of confidence, however, analysts say the
Shiite Lebanese group is deeply worried at the impact of what will likely be
charges against some of its members. At the least, it could be a blow to one of
the movement's most important foundations — its reputation.
For decades, Hizbullah has gained support by depicting itself as a pure
resistance movement, clean of corruption, aimed only at defending Lebanese
against Israel. Instead, indictments would plant a new image in the mind of some
Lebanese: a movement willing to turn its weapons against fellow Lebanese to
carry out a political assassination.
That could weaken Hizbullah's position in sharply divided Lebanon, undermining
one of its main justifications for maintaining its large arsenal, which make it
the most powerful military force in the country. "One of Hizbullah's main
strengths is its reputation in the Arab and Islamic world as a resistance
movement fighting Israeli occupation," said Ibrahim Bayram, an analyst with An-Nahar
newspaper who closely follows Hizbullah affairs. "This will definitely tarnish
its image in the Arab world."
That could turn into more than just an image problem. Hizbullah's enemies may
see the group as weakened and vulnerable. "In the eyes of Israel, America and
the West, Hizbullah will be accused. It will become a rogue entity that is more
easily targeted. This may provide a pretext for others to pounce on it," Bayram
said.
In the worst case scenario, the indictments could cause the collapse of
Lebanon's fragile unity government and spark new fighting between Shiite
Hizbullah and Sunnis.
The Netherlands-based tribunal has not said who it will indict, but Hizbullah
leader Sayyed Hassan Nasrallah has said he has information it will be members of
his group.
Hizbullah has responded by staunchly denying any role in the assassination,
denouncing the court as a conspiracy against it and demanding that its fellow
Lebanese publicly stand by it — something its rivals have so far resisted doing.
Already the impending indictments have paralyzed Lebanon's government, an uneasy
partnership between Hizbullah and factions led by Prime Minister Saad Hariri,
the slain leader's son.
Nasrallah demands the government publicly discredit any findings by the
tribunal, but Hariri has refused to break cooperation with the court. Hizbullah
officials have reportedly said they will not sit on the same table with a prime
minister who accepts an accusation that they were behind the death of his
father.
Hizbullah has also pressed on the case of the "false witnesses" — witnesses who
reportedly gave false information to U.N. investigators to implicate Syria in
the Hariri killing. The case is sensitive because close associates of Saad
Hariri are alleged to have bribed the witnesses to do so.
Hizbullah demands that the Cabinet vote to send the case to the Higher Judicial
Council, which handles political and state security crimes. The lower courts
where Hariri and his supporters want it handled are seen as more under Hariri's
control.
Hizbullah and its allies refuse to attend any Cabinet meeting that does not vote
on the issue, while Hariri has reportedly vowed to walk out of any meeting that
decides to hold a vote. As a result, the Cabinet has met only once since Nov.
10, and that single meeting lasted only a few minutes. State institutions have
been deadlocked.
In a recent speech, Nasrallah denied he was worried, saying, "I have been
sleeping an extra hour each day for the past few months." Talking tough,
Hizbullah has threatened to "cut off the arm" of anyone who tries to arrest any
of its members.
But Bilal Saab, a Middle East expert at the University of Maryland who advises
the U.S. government on Lebanon, said Hizbullah faces hard choices, none of which
are good.
"Right now, Hizbullah is thinking of ways to weather the storm," he said.
He said a violent reaction by the group can throw the country into turmoil and
reawaken the various armed Sunni jihadi groups that are present in Lebanon. A
political reaction that seeks to overthrow the government may buy Hizbullah some
time but is not sustainable in the long term, he said.
Hizbullah and its rivals are now relying on mediation by Syria and Saudi Arabia,
their respective international patrons, to try and reach a settlement that would
allow both camps to step back. "The problem (in Lebanon) is in its total
dependence on the outside and internal inability to carry out any national
role," wrote columnist Rafik Khoury in the daily Al-Anwar.(AP) Beirut, 29 Dec
10, 14:35
Harb: Lebanon will have a say in the Saudi-Syrian agreement
December 29, 2010
“Even if Lebanon does not participate in the Saudi-Syrian talks, it will be
involved when an agreement is reached,” said Minister of Labor Boutros Harb in
an interview on Wednesday.
He also said that certain parties defend the president’s powers but still attack
President Michel Sleiman when he exercises them. “[Sleiman] has the right not to
call for a vote [in the cabinet on the issue of false witnesses],” Harb told the
Voice of Lebanon (100.5) radio. The labor minister commented on Prime Minister
Saad Hariri’s visit to New York, saying the PM went to check on the health of
Saudi King Abdullah bin Abdel Aziz. Sleiman said in an interview with As-Safir
on Wednesday that he rejected being instructed by anyone regarding whether the
issue of “false witnesses” should be put to a vote in the cabinet.Saudi and
Syrian officials have reportedly been communicating in efforts to reach a
compromise that would resolve tensions.
King Abdullah, who is 86 years old, flew to New York on November 22 and was
operated on two days later for a debilitating herniated disc complicated by a
hematoma that put pressure on his spine.-NOW Lebanon
WikiLeaks:
Israeli Troops would Face Leb. Army in Any Conflict with Hizbullah
Naharnet/A document spill by WikiLeaks showed that Israel agreed that moderates
and the Lebanese army must be strengthened, but expressed deep concerns about
ongoing cooperation between Hizbullah and the Lebanese Armed Forces (LAF).
The document sent in July 2009 to Washington from the U.S. embassy in Tel Aviv
said that during a roundtable discussion of Israel's ministry of defense (MOD),
Strategic Division Chief Brigadier General Yossi Heymann acknowledged the
positive results of the Lebanese elections.
However, Heymann feared the outcome did not represent the real power of the
Shiites in Lebanon.
According to the leaked document, Heymann agreed that "moderates and the LAF
must be strengthened, but expressed deep concerns about
ongoing cooperation between Hizbullah and the LAF."
He also said that such aid to Lebanon be paired with efforts to halt
smuggling and directly weaken Hizbullah.
Overall, Heymann was skeptical that these systems would benefit the LAF, and
said the Israeli Government would appreciate a more in-depth conversation
regarding U.S. intentions and overarching strategy with
respect to the LAF.
Heymann suggested further talks to coincide with the August 3rd F-15 technical
discussion in Washington. Assistant Secretary for Political-Military Affairs
Andrew Shapiro offered to take that back to Washington for review.
If it proved too difficult on short notice to bring together interagency experts
to discuss U.S. intentions with the LAF, Shapiro suggested it be included in the
Joint Political Military Group talks later in the fall, according to the
document.
It said the Israeli Government remains concerned about U.S. arms transfers to
the LAF and has requested the opportunity to discuss further U.S. intentions
regarding the LAF.
Shapiro said the results of the Lebanese elections represented a turning point,
and rejection of Hizbullah and its Iranian sponsors. The need to build up
Lebanese institutions, including the army, was now more important than ever, he
argued.
He said the LAF has thus far demonstrated a solid record of accounting for U.S.
systems transferred to Lebanon.
Israeli Ministry of Defense director general Pinhas Buchris, according to the
U.S. embassy cable, acknowledged that the elections in Lebanon were positive,
but countered that Hizbullah's influence remains strong.
He argued that items such as the Cessna Caravan and the Raven unmanned aerial
vehicle (UAV) lack sufficient mitigation measures, which creates the potential
for an incident along the Israel-Lebanese border.
Amos Gilad, an aide to Ehud Barak, said the Israeli Government does not believe
the LAF will attack Israel.
However, given the ties between Hizbullah and the LAF, Gilad was
certain Israeli troops would eventually face the LAF in any conflict
with Hizbullah.
Analysts from the MFA's Center for Policy Research argued there has been no
dramatic change in the political arena despite the March 14 coalition's
significant victory in the elections. They said the fragile political situation
in Lebanon is currently stable, but Hizbullah still possesses an unofficial veto
over policy.
Long term prospects will be tested by the Hariri Tribunal and Hizbullah's desire
for a reprisal to the 2008 Mughniyeh assassination, according to the leaked
cable.
MFA Policy Research analysts further argued that the LAF faces tremendous
pressure following the recent explosion of a Hizbullah arms cache near the
Lebanese-Israeli border.
MFA DG Yossi Gal noted that UNIFIL had been prevented from investigating the
explosion, and raised the recent crossing by Lebanese citizens into Israeli
territory to plant Lebanese and Hizbullah flags. He said French and Italian
delegations had praised the Israeli Government's restraint in these cases.
Shapiro asked if the election results might be the result in part of a backlash
in the Christian community against Hizbullah; the Policy Research analysts
countered that the results were indicative of several factors, including the
influx of Saudi money and an unstable opposition camp.
They agreed that Hizbullah leader Sayyed Hassan Nasrallah "might be a bit
chastened following the elections," as suggested by Shapiro, but that Hizbullah
continues to try and undermine the March 14 coalition. Beirut, 27 Dec 10, 15:28
Wissam Hasan Fears Assassination, Report
Naharnet/Police intelligence chief Maj. Gen. Wissam Hasan fears assassination,
Al-Akhbar newspaper reported Wednesday. It quoted some visitors as saying Hasan
"fears for his personal security and of being assassinated." Hasan spoke at
length about his security and that of his family, which forced him to move out
to live close to the Directorate General of Internal Security Forces in
Ashrafiyeh, Al-Akhbar added. Beirut, 29 Dec 10, 14:08
Rifi: Security Situation Excellent
Naharnet/Police chief Gen. Ashraf Rifi on Wednesday described the security
situation in Lebanon as "excellent."His remarks came after meeting with Maronite
Patriarch Nasrallah Sfeir in Bkiri. Rifi said his visit was to wish Sfeir happy
holidays. Beirut, 29 Dec 10, 13:47
Qabalan Urges Lebanese to Cooperate to Safeguard Lebanon
Naharnet/Vice President of the Higher Islamic Shiite Council Sheikh Abdul Amir
Qabalan on Wednesday called on Lebanon to cooperate to safeguard their nation.
"We are with Lebanon -- a country of coexistence and constructive cooperation,
and we have to protect Lebanon, but not by force ... particularly since we are
living through difficult times which require us to put hand-in-hand to bring
peace to the country," he said. "We also have to cooperate to safeguard Lebanon
from the pitfalls and to protect its people against conspiracies because the
Israeli enemy still lurks out there," Qabalan added. Beirut, 29 Dec 10, 12:51
Israeli
Deputy Prime Minister Moshe Ya'alon:: West has three years to stop Iran nuclear
program
Moshe Ya'alon says Iran remains the government's biggest worry, hopes for
success of U.S.-led actions against Teheran.
By Reuters /The United States and its allies have up to three years to curb
Iran's nuclear program, which has been set back by technical difficulties and
sanctions, Deputy Prime Minister Moshe Ya'alon said on Wednesday. Saying Iran
remained the government's biggest worry, Yaalon did not mention possible
unilateral military strikes by Israel, saying he hoped U.S.-led action against
Tehran would be successful. "I believe that this effort will grow, and will
include areas beyond sanctions, to convince the Iranian regime that,
effectively, it must choose between continuing to seek nuclear capability and
surviving," Ya'alon told Israel Radio. "I don't know if it will happen in 2011
or in 2012, but we are talking in terms of the next three years."
Ya'alon, a former armed forces chief, noted Iran's uranium enrichment plan had
suffered setbacks. Some analysts have seen signs of foreign sabotage in
incidents such as the corruption of Iranian computer networks by a virus. "These
difficulties postpone the timeline, of course. Thus we cannot talk about a
'point of no return'. Iran does not currently have the ability to make a nuclear
bomb on its own," Ya'alon said. "I hope it won't succeed at all and that the
Western world's effort will ultimately deny Iran a nuclear capability."
Ya'alon had previously been hawkish on Iran, saying Israel, believed to have
region's only nuclear arsenal, should attack Iran rather than see it get the
bomb.
Other officials, including Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, have been
tight-lipped about the military option, which would face big tactical and
diplomatic hurdles.
Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad said on Tuesday Iran will retain its right
to pursue nuclear technology. Speaking about next month's planned nuclear talks
with world powers in Istanbul, Ahmadinejad said "We are willing to cooperate
with [them] in Istanbul, but all of them should acknowledge Iran's right to
pursue nuclear technology and know that we will not retreat on inch from these
rights." The six world powers - Britain, China, France, Germany, Russia and the
United States - demand that Iran suspend its controversial uranium enrichment,
in line with five United Nations Security Council resolutions, four of them with
sanctions, designed to make sure the Islamic state is not pursuing a secret
military program.
While denying the existence of military nuclear programs, Tehran has referenced
its right as a Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty signatory and International
Atomic Energy Agency member, saying, like any other country, it has the right to
have civil nuclear projects, including uranium enrichment.
Saudis urge Lebanon PM to accept compromise with Hezbollah
.Haaretz/ 29.12.10/By Amos Harel and Avi Issacharoff
Saudi Arabia is compounding Arab pressure on Lebanese Prime Minister Saad Hariri
to reject an international tribunal investigating the February 2005
assassination of his father, former Prime Minister Rafik Hariri, sources told
Haaretz.
The United Nations-backed tribunal is expected to name Hezbollah, the Iranian-
and Syrian-backed group with a strong presence in Lebanon's political
establishment, as complicit in the Valentine's Day blast which killed Rafik
Hariri as his convoy travelled through Beirut.
In return for Saad Hariri's cooperation, Hezbollah would guarantee that it would
not harm the prime minister. The radical Shi'ite organization would also avoid
any overt military activities and Hariri would be allowed to maintain his own
security apparatus.
The Saudis, considered the Hariri family's patrons, have stepped up pressure on
Hariri to convince him to accept the "compromise" planned by Saudi Arabia and
Syria that aims to defuse Lebanon's political crisis.
The fact that Saudi Arabia has joined Syria in pressuring Hariri suggests that
the chances have increased significantly that the prime minister will accept the
deal.
For the time being, however, Saad Hariri is refusing to make a decision. Last
week, Hariri denied a report in the Lebanese daily Al Diyar that he had agreed
to distance himself from the international tribunal's report "for Lebanon's
interests."
Hariri traveled to New York on Monday for a meeting with Saudi King Abdullah,
after Saudi-Syrian mediation efforts were put on hold because of the king's trip
to the United States for emergency surgery. But now that the king is recovering,
pressure has resumed on Hariri, who is the head of the March 14 alliance,
Hezbollah's rivals in Lebanon, which took power following the assassination.
Haaretz has learned that the proposed compromise involves Hariri relinquishing
the demand that the international tribunal investigate his father's
assassination. He would have to make a statement in which he expresses his
rejection of the tribunal's work.
Hariri would apparently be supported by Hezbollah in efforts to disarm
Palestinian groups operating outside the refugee camps in the country, even
though their numbers are minor compared to those inside the camps. Such a move
would be interpreted as another reassertion of Lebanese sovereignty in line with
the Taif Agreement of 1989, which ended the Lebanese Civil War. In that deal,
government forces disarmed militias; Hezbollah was the only group that refused
to disarm.
On Tuesday, the Al Nahar daily reported that Syrian President Bashar Assad had
told the Saudis that if they are interested in a strong Lebanon, the indictments
that the international tribunal is expected to issue, should be rejected. The
newspaper reported that Assad told the Saudis that "we must act together to stop
the indictments."
The Lebanese daily Al Safir reported earlier this week that Assad had spoken by
phone with the Saudi king, but avoided discussing the compromise proposal,
fearing wiretapping by the Americans. The newspaper said the Syrian leader spoke
in code about the situation in Lebanon and conditioned a future visit to Beirut
with the Saudi king on Hariri's acceptance of the compromise.
The international tribunal is expected to issue indictments in mid-January
against some of the suspects in the assassination, Western sources told Haaretz.
But at this stage there are no plans to release the details or the identities of
the suspects.
The information will be kept under wraps until the judge investigating the
murder completes the evaluation of the information. The details of the
indictments are expected to be made public by April.
Despite efforts to keep things under wraps, it is also expected that information
will leak and the indictments will say senior Hezbollah members had a role in
Rafik Hariri's murder.
Pressure by Hezbollah has included death threats on Saad Hariri, whose security
has been stepped up, according to reports in Lebanon.
Tensions have also been on the rise between Hezbollah and March 14 activists in
Beirut. The latter stay away from neighborhoods controlled by Hezbollah, and a
number of the group's leaders have traveled abroad for "holidays," sources say.
Meanwhile, Lebanese security sources said they had uncovered more equipment,
allegedly belonging to Israeli spies, in the Chouf Mountains. The sources said
Hezbollah helped locate the equipment, which was allegedly used to spy on the
coastal plain and the Bekaa Valley. Ten day ago, the Lebanese Army said it had
uncovered "spying equipment."
Rarity in Region, Lebanese Paper Dares to Provoke
By ROBERT F. WORTH/The New York Times
BEIRUT, Lebanon — Ibrahim al-Amine, the hawk-eyed editorial chairman of Al
Akhbar, describes his newspaper’s founding ambitions this way: “We wanted the
U.S. ambassador to wake up in the morning, read it and get upset.”
Bryan Denton for The New York Times
Ernest Khoury, an editor of Al Akhbar, working beneath a portrait of Karl Marx.
Al Akhbar’s chief owner is an investment banker based in London.
Bryan Denton for The New York Times
A photograph of Joseph Samaha, the founding editor of Al Akhbar who died in
2007, hanging in the newspaper’s offices.
He succeeded. Earlier this month Al Akhbar became the only Arab newspaper to
obtain its own substantial batch of WikiLeaks cables and gleefully cataloged
various embarrassments to the region’s kings, princes and politicians. Soon
afterward, the paper’s popular Web site came under a cyberattack that became a
story in its own right, and provided more free publicity.
It was the latest coup for a five-year-old paper that has become the most
dynamic and daring in Lebanon, and perhaps anywhere in the Arab world. In a
region where the news media are still full of obsequious propaganda, Al Akhbar
is now required reading, even for those who abhor its politics.
They are a remarkable blend: the paper champions gay rights, feminism and other
leftist causes, even as it wholeheartedly supports Hezbollah, the Iranian-backed
Shiite movement. Al Akhbar’s access to Hezbollah allows it to scoop other papers
on Lebanon’s biggest continuing story, but it also publishes muckraking exposés
on the abuse of domestic workers, prison overcrowding and other delicate
subjects. Add splashy full-page color photos and witty tabloid-style headlines,
and you have an alluring product.
“Our project is basically anti-imperialism,” said Khaled Saghieh, Al Akhbar’s
mild and cerebral managing editor, who abandoned a Ph.D. in political science at
the University of Massachusetts, Amherst, to help start the paper. That
insurrectionary theme, he said, links the paper’s resistance to neoliberal
economic policies and its support for Hezbollah’s fight against Israel. There
are plenty of disagreements with Hezbollah, whose members regularly call to
complain about articles — though not in any official capacity. But the Shiite
group’s leaders appear to recognize the importance of maintaining alliances
across Lebanon’s complex sectarian and political landscape.
Al Akhbar has sometimes criticized Hezbollah in print (though mildly), and Mr.
Saghieh himself — who writes a regular column — has written excoriating
critiques of Hezbollah’s chief Christian ally, the party of Michel Aoun, a
former general.
The paper suffers from many of the same flaws as the mainstream Arab press: too
much reliance on single sources, and news pages that often show a loose mingling
of fact, rumor and opinion.
Still, it is refreshingly free of the slavish headlines that are so common
across the Middle East: the king’s visit to the airport, the president’s trip to
the mosque. Even the pan-Arab press, largely owned by Saudi Arabia, is seriously
constrained in what it can say. Lebanon has long had the most freewheeling news
media in the region, but its outlets are often vehicles for their owners,
usually political bosses or businessmen with a sectarian ax to grind. Reporters
are often pawns in this game: Rafik Hariri, the billionaire former prime
minister who was assassinated in 2005, used to send around envelopes of cash to
his favorites.
Al Akhbar wanted to break free of that formula. Its founding editor, a revered
left-wing journalist named Joseph Samaha, found a London-based investment banker
to underwrite the venture in 2006 while promising not to interfere with
editorial content. Mr. Samaha envisioned a paper with a strong political
commitment but no attachments to any particular party, and a refusal to be
constrained by anyone.
“We are going to show that you can make a profitable paper without bowing to any
government,” said Hassan Khalil, the banker, who is the paper’s chief owner, in
a telephone call from London. “We wanted to make something new: a truly
independent newspaper.” The paper broke even last year, Mr. Khalil said.
The handful of other owners include members of the staff. The paper receives no
support from Iran, Syria or Hezbollah, Mr. Khalil said, despite accusations from
its ideological foes that began even before the paper started printing.
Al Akhbar’s print circulation is dismally low, 10,000 to 15,000, though
comparable to circulations at Lebanon’s other leading papers. The industry is
fading here, as everywhere. But Al Akhbar’s Web site is by far the most popular
of any Lebanese newspaper’s, and its editors see a broader audience for their
product. They are starting an English-language version, set for introduction
early next year.
Critics say the paper’s protestations of editorial freedom ring a little hollow,
given that it operates under the tacit protection of Hezbollah, Lebanon’s most
potent military force. It was reporters on the other side of the political
fence, many Lebanese say, who took the greatest risks for their views in recent
years, and paid the price. Samir Kassir and Gebran Tueni, critics of Syria and
Hezbollah who worked for the older and more pro-American newspaper An Nahar,
were both killed by car bombs in 2005.
But there is a youthful energy and conviction at Al Akhbar that is lacking at
many other papers. The offices, on the sixth floor of a West Beirut office
building, above a supermarket, have more of the feel of a college newspaper than
a major daily. The staff members are mostly in their 20s and 30s, and seem to
see the place as a kind of alternative family. There are pictures everywhere of
Mr. Samaha, whose death from a heart attack in 2007 — less than six months after
the paper’s founding — was a serious blow.
“Joseph was our father, our friend, our drinking partner,” said Omar Nashabe,
editor of Al Akhbar’s crusading Justice page.
Like several of the editors, Mr. Nashabe is fully conversant with American
culture; he earned a Ph.D. in criminal justice from the State University of New
York, Albany, before joining the paper. He is responsible for some of the
paper’s most socially liberal columns, and talks excitedly about the need for
new laws to defend foreign laborers and women’s sexual rights. He brushes off
the angry letters and phone calls he gets from social conservatives, including
some in Hezbollah.
But no one apologizes for Al Akhbar’s vehement support for “the resistance,” as
Hezbollah’s armed forces are known here. A portrait of Imad Mughniyeh, the
legendary Hezbollah commando who was assassinated in 2008, hangs in the office
of Mr. Amine, the chairman of the board.
“Our Che,” Mr. Amine says, as he leads a visitor into his office and proudly
displays the portrait. After Mr. Mughniyeh was killed in Damascus, Syria, Al
Akhbar published an amazing scoop: a personal interview with Mr. Mughniyeh, done
months earlier and written by Mr. Amine, who was a personal friend.
If Mr. Saghieh and Mr. Nashabe are the paper’s Western-friendly faces, Mr. Amine
is its hard-line bulldog, a grizzled Marxist whose columns are widely viewed as
telegraphs from the Hezbollah leadership (or parts of it). He offers his
visitors tea, then reels off some of his own fondest hopes: to replace the
oppressive governments of the Arab world, redraw the colonial-era borders,
remove Israel from the map and send the Jews back to Europe — they would be more
comfortable, after all, in a capitalist environment.
“I hope I haven’t provoked you,” he says at last, somehow managing to avoid a
smirk.
Accused spy says Israel paid their Syrian agent for nuclear
information
29.12.10/Haaretz
According to Egyptian media, the official's information led to Israel's alleged
bombing of a Syrian nuclear reactor in 2007.
An Egyptian charged with spying for Israel told authorities that his Syrian
counterpart was paid 1.5 million dollars to provide Israel with information on
Syrian nuclear activities, Egyptian media reported Wednesday. The Syrian
intelligence official, named as Saleh Al-Nijm, provided Israel with information
on the whereabouts of an alleged Syrian nuclear reactor which probably led to
the bombing of the facility in 2007, according to Egyptian state media reports.
According to the EgyNews website, Tareq Abdelrazeq told authorities that he met
with al-Nijm several times in Damascus and that they collaborated on providing
information to the Mossad.For his part, Abdelrazeq allegedly received 37,000
dollars from Israel in payment for his activities, Egyptian officials said.
Syria denies that the bombed structure was a nuclear reactor.
Meanwhile, Israel has not officially said it was behind the 2007 attack, but a
U.S. government cable released by WikiLeaks earlier this month named Israel as
responsible.
The cable, written in 2008 by then secretary of state Condoleeza Rice, stated
that "on September 6, 2007, Israel destroyed the nuclear reactor built by Syria
secretly."
Abdelrazeq also allegedly told prosecutors that no other Egyptians had
collaborated with him in providing Israel information.
Egyptian authorities announced the arrest of Abdelrazeq earlier this month,
accusing him of spying for Israel and attempting to recruit spies in Syria and
Lebanon for the Mossad.
Egypt's Emergency State Security court is expected to hear the case on January
15.
The prosecutor's office also accused two Israelis of working alongside
Abdelrazeq and forming a spy ring in Egypt. The prosecutor did not name the
suspects, only saying they were "fugitives" and had not yet been arrested.
Jouzo: Sfeir's place in our hearts remains the same
By The Daily Star /Wednesday, December 29, 2010
BEIRUT: Mount Lebanon Mufti Mohammad Ali Jouzo said Tuesday he stood by the
Maronite patriarch’s side to preserve Lebanon’s best interests. Jouzo added that
his recent criticism of Patriarch Nasrallah Butros Sfeir aimed at serving the
country’s interests rather than raising sectarian tensions. “The patriarch’s
place in our hearts remains the same. We regard him as a major national
guarantee and our reproaches will not jeopardize our relations,” Jouzo said.
Jouzo criticized Sunday “political Maronism” in the wake of Sfeir’s statement
that “qualifications were equally important to demographics,” a reference to the
decreasing number of Lebanese Christians versus their Muslims compatriots. He
said such statements harmed the “feelings of the rest of the Lebanese,” and
added that quality no longer exists in Lebanon neither among Christians nor
Muslims. – The Daily Star
Saudi-Syrian bid to solve crisis picks up steam
King Abdullah, Assad discuss Lebanese situation in extended phone conversation
By Mirella Hodeib /Daily Star staff
Wednesday, December 29, 2010
BEIRUT: Talks led by Saudi Arabia and Syria to solve Lebanon’s months-long
stalemate gained momentum Tuesday, two days after the Syrian president and the
Saudi monarch held an extensive telephone conversation on the matter.
Bashar Assad and King Abdullah bin Abdel-Aziz thoroughly discussed the situation
in Lebanon during a lengthy telephone conversation Sunday, an Arab diplomatic
source told The Daily Star. “The Syrian side is very confident and comfortable
with the outcome of recent talks with the Saudis,” said the source.
Lebanon’s two main powerbrokers launched an initiative in July to contain
mounting tensions in Lebanon over the indictment to be issued by the Special
Tribunal for Lebanon (STL), which is probing the assassination of former Prime
Minister Rafik Hariri. The UN-backed court is widely expected to point the
finger at Hizbullah, sparking fears of violence erupting in the volatile
country.
Riyadh and Damascus are said to be negotiating a package deal to end the
Lebanese crisis acceptable to the country’s rival March 8 and March 14 factions.
After a slowdown due to Abdullah’s hospitalization, the Syrian-Saudi bid has
received a boost in the past few days.
The slain statesman’s son, Prime Minister Saad Hariri, is currently on a visit
to New York where he paid a visit to the Saudi monarch, who is recovering there
after undergoing back surgeries earlier this month. King Abdullah was expected
to brief Hariri about the progress of talks with Syria.
Former Prime Minister Omar Karami said Hariri’s visit to New York could indicate
that a Syrian-Saudi agreement has been concluded. Karami said Hariri might have
left to the US to be informed of the Syrian-Saudi brokered agreement to end
Lebanon’s crisis over the disputed issue of the STL.
The Arab diplomatic source explained that Saudi-Syrian efforts aim to address a
wide array of issues including the STL and its impending indictment, as well as
arrest warrants issued by Syria against Lebanese and Syrians in the lawsuit
filed by the former head of Lebanon’s General Security apparatus Jamil al-Sayyed.
The source also spoke about the Saudi-Syrian dialogue addressing a possible
government change, with Hariri remaining premier and an overhaul of the
country’s security and judicial hierarchies.
Syria and Saudi Arabia are also apparently heavily relying on an expected visit
around January 12 to Washington by French President Nicholas Sarkozy. Assad had
discussed Lebanon during talks with Sarkozy earlier in December.
The positive impression conveyed by the Arab diplomat echoed remarks made by the
Syrian president to his Monday visitors. Assad was quoted as saying the
Saudi-Syrian endeavor has reached its final stages, adding that King Abdullah’s
illness has delayed its announcement.
Assad was also quoted as saying that succeeding in preventing the drastic
repercussions of the STL indictment was similar to the collapse of the May 17,
1983, peace deal between Lebanon and Israel.
Hizbullah has slammed the Netherlands-based court an “Israeli project” aimed at
targeting the resistance and blatantly rejected any cooperation with the STL.
The party’s Secretary General Sayyed Hassan Nasrallah said a settlement to the
Lebanese crisis ought to be attained before the court issues an indictment.
Hariri’s adviser Mohammad Shatah told MTV that there would be “plenty of time”
to contest the indictment after it is released. “The indictment can be
challenged if relevant and clear-cut evidence is submitted.”
Shatah said Saudi-Syrian efforts will not compromise justice, adding that talks
focused on “finding a unified stance among the Lebanese, guarantying the
functioning of the government, and maintaining the level Lebanese-Syrian ties
have reached.”
Beirut MP Nuhad al-Mashnouq of Hariri’s Future Movement visited Damascus Monday
and held talks with the Syrian president’s top adviser Bouthaina Shaaban. The
visit is considered the first known face-to-face meeting between a member of the
Future Movement and a Syrian official.
Hizbullah, meanwhile, said the party welcomed all initiatives aimed at solving
Lebanon’s political impasse. “[Hizbullah] extends a hand to all initiatives
aimed at helping this country whether Saudi-Syrian or Turkish-Iranian to reach a
solution before the indictment is issued,” said Hizbullah’s politburo member
Mahmoud Qomati.
In an implicit reference to comments made by Hariri to pan-Arab daily Ash-Sharq
al-Awsat in September, the Hizbullah official slammed attempts to overlook the
issue of the so-called “false witnesses.” “Some have admitted that false
witnesses have harmed Lebanese-Syrian ties but they insist on paralyzing the
country and the government so the false witnesses are not uncovered,” said
Qomati.
The Cabinet has been stalled over the problematic issue of “false witnesses,”
which the Hizbullah-led March 8 alliance accuses of misleading the probe into
the assassination of Rafik Hariri and calls for their trial by the country’s
highest court, the Judicial Council. But the March 14 coalition fears that the
investigation of “false witnesses” by the Judicial Council, rather than by the
regular judiciary, would eventually block the work of the tribunal.
Meanwhile, Lebanese Forces head Samir Geagea said the Syrian-Saudi bid was
“currently on holiday.” “We are currently facing an internal problem and we
should solve it on our own through dialogue otherwise it will never be solved,”
he added.