LCCC
ENGLISH DAILY NEWS BULLETIN
March 13/2010
Bible Of the
Day
Matthew 9/27-34: "As Jesus passed by from there, two blind men followed him,
calling out and saying, “Have mercy on us, son of David!” 9:28 When he had come
into the house, the blind men came to him. Jesus said to them, “Do you believe
that I am able to do this?” They told him, “Yes, Lord.” 9:29 Then he touched
their eyes, saying, “According to your faith be it done to you.” 9:30 Their eyes
were opened. Jesus strictly commanded them, saying, “See that no one knows about
this.” 9:31 But they went out and spread abroad his fame in all that land. 9:32
As they went out, behold, a mute man who was demon possessed was brought to him.
9:33 When the demon was cast out, the mute man spoke. The multitudes marveled,
saying, “Nothing like this has ever been seen in Israel!” 9:34 But the Pharisees
said, “By the prince of the demons, he casts out demons.”
Free Opinions, Releases, letters & Special
Reports
How to Make Defeatism Look
Good: Let's Give Up and Cheer the Islamists/By Barry Rubin/March
12, 2010
Antione Choueiri's legacy lives on/Daily Star/March
12/10
Washington is the indispensible partner for a settlement/By
Ziad Asali/March
12/10
Turkey and Armenia must speak privately/By
Vartan Oskanian/March
12/10
Sweden Recognizes Assyrian, Greek
and Armenian Genocide/AINA/March
12/10
Latest News Reports From
Miscellaneous Sources for March 12/10
U.S.-Syrian Dialogue: Senate to
Hear Ford's Testimony, Feltman and Shapiro in Damascus this Month/Naharnet
Syria:
Border Demarcation Bilateral Issue, No Palestinian Bases on Border with Lebanon/Naharnet
Suleiman Will Not Attend Arab Summit in Libya/Naharnet
Syria requests not be mentioned in
Resolution 1701 reports/Now Lebanon
Rifi says political campaign has
been launched against him/Now
Lebanon
Scientists predict large Lebanon
earthquake looming/Daily Star
Biden calls for Hizbullah
disarmament during Tel Aviv University talk/Daily
Star
Biden Says U.S. to Keep on
Supporting Lebanon Institutions, 1701 Implementation to Disarm
Hizbullah/Naharnet
Cabinet
Forms Committee Tasked with Submitting Ideas on Appointments Mechanism/Naharnet
Lebanese Tycoon, Choueiri, Buried in Hometown/Naharnet
Lebanese man becomes first to sue former Syrian
jailers/AFP
Berri
Describes as 'Very Dangerous' the Alleged Signing of Saniora Government of
Security Agreement with U.S. Embassy/Naharnet
Russian Ambassador: Time
for Lebanese to Take Reins of Government/Naharnet
Magistrate lists charges in Ain al-Remmaneh case/Daily Star
Ministers to set rules for filling
key posts/Daily Star
Lebanese industrialists disregarding ministry controls/Daily Star
Bank Audi report highlights
detrimental impact of global crisis on Jordan's economy/Daily Star
Ex-minister Daher calls National Dialogue 'illegitimate/Daily Star
EU
Official in Beirut to Discuss Prospects for Peace/Naharnet
Man Arrested in North
Lebanon for Sister's 'Honor Killing/Naharnet
Police Arrest 44 in Night
Raids/Naharnet
Jumblat Surprised at
Different Damascus Visit Dates Circulated by Media/Naharnet
Maqdah Rejects Abbas'
Offer to Move Out of Lebanon/Naharnet
Murr: No Army Protection
for Tribunal/Naharnet
Judiciary Calls for Death
Penalty against Abu Madi's Suspected Killer/Naharnet
Syria
requests not be mentioned in Resolution 1701 reports
Now Lebanon/March 12, 2010
Syrian Ambassador to the UN Bashar al-Jaafari delivered a letter to UN Secretary
General Ban Ki-moon and the Security Council requesting not to mention Damascus
in any report issued on the implementation of UN Security Council Resolution
1701, As-Safir newspaper reported Friday. In Ban’s 12th report on the
implementation of Resolution 1701, he stated that neither the Lebanese
government nor UNIFIL reported any violations of arms smuggling into Lebanon,
however, added the Lebanese cabinet admitted that its border can be porous.
Damascus said that reports there was arms smuggling via Syria are “claims and
lies,” adding the report helps Israel justify and carry on its aggressions.
Syria called on Ban to condemn Israeli violations of Lebanon’s airspace, urging
the UN chief to take the necessary measures to stop them.
The letter also said the delineation of the Lebanese-Syrian borders “is a
bilateral issue that is in the process of being settled.”
Syria denied Ban’s statements that there are Palestinian military bases along
the Lebanese-Syrian border, saying that these are only present on Lebanese
territory.
Damascus defended its position in the region, saying it supported the Lebanese
government in exercising its authority over its territory. “Syria also highly
contributed to enhancing the Lebanese army’s capabilities and to ensuring
Lebanon’s security and stability, since [the situation] reflects on Syria and
the region.”
Lebanese-Syrian relations have drastically improved since December 2009 when
Lebanese Prime Minister Saad Hariri visited Damascus to meet with Syrian
President Bashar al-Assad, said the letter. “The coming weeks and months will
[be a period of] continuous efforts [to improve relations] between both
countries.”
-NOW Lebanon
U.S.-Syrian Dialogue: Senate to Hear Ford's
Testimony, Feltman and Shapiro in Damascus this Month
Naharnet/The U.S. Senate Committee on Foreign Relations is scheduled to hold a
hearing early next week to approve or reject the appointment of Robert Ford as
Washington's ambassador to Damascus, As Safir daily reported Friday. The
newspaper said that the move would come amid a third visit to the Syrian capital
by U.S. Assistant Secretary of State for Near Eastern Affairs Jeffrey Feltman
and senior White House official Daniel Shapiro end of March. The committee's
communications director, Frederick Jones, told As Safir that setting Tuesday as
a date for the nomination of the new ambassador comes within the "natural
course" and is not an urgent issue. He stressed that the committee chairman,
John Kerry, "believes that it is important to have diplomatic representation in
Syria." Kerry, who will preside over Tuesday's hearing, held a meeting with
Syria's ambassador to Washington Imad Mustafa last week. As Safir also quoted
sources in the U.S. capital as saying that preparations are underway for a visit
to Damascus by Feltman and Shapiro as part of efforts to continue dialogue with
the Assad regime on regional issues. Several sources in Damascus also said the
two U.S. officials will visit Syria end of March as part of "continued dialogue
between Damascus and Washington over bilateral ties and regional issues."
Beirut, 12 Mar 10, 08:06
Syria: Border Demarcation Bilateral Issue, No Palestinian Bases on Border with
Lebanon
Naharnet/Syria has again protested against the inclusion of Damascus in U.N.
chief Ban Ki-moon's reports on the implementation of Security Council resolution
1701 without taking into consideration the Syrian point of view. Syria's
ambassador to Washington Bashar al-Jaafari sent a letter to Ban criticizing
accusations of arms smuggling to Lebanon from Syria without hearing Damascus'
point of view. The letter also criticized Ban for referring to the improvement
of Lebanese-Syrian ties after PM Saad Hariri's visit to Damascus. Instead the
U.N. chief should focus on daily violations of Lebanese airspace by Israeli
fighter jets, the letter said. Jaafari has already sent two similar letters to
Ban and members of the Security Council. In the third letter, he reiterated that
demarcation of the border between Lebanon and Syria is a bilateral issue.
The ambassador also denied the presence of armed Palestinian bases on the
Lebanese-Syrian border saying the bases are only present on Lebanese
territories.
He said Syrian-Lebanese ties witnessed a historic leap forward last December
when Hariri "made an important visit to Damascus" during which the two sides
discussed ways to improve ties in all fields. The Syrian letter came on the eve
of a Security Council session to discuss Ban's latest report on the
implementation of resolution 1701. U.N. Special Coordinator for Lebanon Michael
Williams will brief the Council on the report on Friday. Beirut, 12 Mar 10,
08:52
Suleiman Will Not Attend Arab Summit in Libya
Naharnet/Information Minister Tareq Mitri has unveiled that President Michel
Suleiman will not attend the Arab summit in Libya end of this month following
demands by the Shiite community to boycott the meeting. Sources from Speaker
Nabih Berri's Development and Liberation bloc told An Nahar daily that
"Lebanon's participation in the summit is a very dangerous issue and would
worsen the situation in the country." Shiites have been demanding Lebanese
authorities to boycott the summit over the disappearance of Imam Moussa al-Sadr.
In 1978, the Shiite religious leader flew to Tripoli for a week of talks with
Libyan officials. He was never seen or heard from again. Meanwhile, Arab League
chief Amr Moussa told An Nahar that he hasn't been asked to deliver any
invitation to Lebanon to participate in the summit. It is the responsibility of
the host country to do so, he said. "When I last visited Beirut, I agreed with
officials that Lebanese representation at the summit should be (at the level of)
responsibility and that the government would decide on the level." Moussa is
expected to visit Beirut on March 18 to attend USEK's celebration of the
establishment of the Arab League. Beirut, 12 Mar 10, 09:17
EU Official in Beirut to Discuss Prospects for Peace
Naharnet/EU High Representative for Foreign Policy Catherine Ashton will visit
Beirut March 16 as part of a four-day regional tour, press reports said. They
said Ashton is to discuss with Lebanese officials prospects for Mideast peace as
well as Lebanese-European relations. Beirut, 12 Mar 10, 12:08
Man Arrested in North Lebanon for Sister's 'Honor Killing'
Naharnet/A Lebanese man has been arrested in northern Lebanon for killing his
sister earlier this week in what authorities described as an honor killing, a
security official said on Friday.
"The 24-year-old victim was single and apparently had a boyfriend," the security
official told AFP. "(Her brother) admitted shooting her twice in the head to
cleanse the family honor."
The woman was only identified by her initials, as was her 28-year-old brother.
Her body was discovered on Tuesday on the main road of the village of Hakr al-Daheri,
in the northern Akkar region. "This kind of crime is not common in Lebanon but
we have a few every year," the official said. Lebanese law stipulates
extenuating circumstances for so-called honor killings, in which male relatives
kill female kin they suspect of illicit behavior with men. In 2007, Lebanon's
top Shiite Muslim cleric Mohammed Hussein Fadlallah issued a fatwa, or religious
edict, banning honor killings as repulsive acts that contradict Islamic law.
Beirut, 12 Mar 10, 13:06
Maqdah Rejects Abbas' Offer to Move Out of Lebanon
Naharnet/Head of the Palestinian Armed Struggle in Lebanon Mounir al-Maqdah
rejected an offer by Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas to transfer him to any
destination of his choice, pan-Arab daily Asharq al-Awsat said Friday. Abbas had
ordered new appointments within the leadership of Fatah in Lebanon. While Abbas
has offered Maqdah to choose his country of residence and any post outside
Lebanon, he appointed Fatah's commander in Lebanon Sultan Abul Aynayn as his
advisor for Palestinian refugee affairs, al-Hayat newspaper has reported.
It said Abul Aynayn is likely to be based in Amman, Jordan. Fatah's military
commander in Lebanon Sobhi Abu Arab, who maintained his post, said Maqdah was
denied promotion due to a mistake he made during the fighting that broke out on
February 15 between members of the Fatah faction and Osbat al-Ansar militants at
Ain el-Hilweh camp. Abu Arab said that Maqdah was biased in favor of Osbat al-Ansar
and had differences with Abul Aynayn. Beirut, 12 Mar 10, 10:46
Murr: No Army Protection for Tribunal
Naharnet/Defense Minister Elias Murr denied that a security force has been at
the disposal of the Special Tribunal for Lebanon. "There has been no legal
request in this regard,' Murr said in remarks published Friday by the daily Al-Akhbar.
Unconfirmed reports had said that the STL plans to request the Lebanese
government to assign a 300-strong Lebanese army force to be ready when the
orders of summons are issued by STL President Daniel Bellemare against a number
of Lebanese personalities. The daily Al-Liwaa, which had carried the report,
said Bellemare will refer the orders of summons to the STL Beirut office. It had
quoted Lebanese judicial sources as saying that the move comes as part of the
completion of the probe into the crime in preparation for issuing the charge
sheet, which may be delayed pending finalization of investigation. Beirut, 12
Mar 10, 10:01
State Department: Torture and Extralegal Intimidation of Journalists
The Lebanese government has continued to deny the use of torture, although
authorities acknowledged violent abuse sometimes occurred during preliminary
investigations at police stations or military installations, the State
Department said."Such abuse occurred despite national laws preventing judges
from accepting confessions extracted under duress," the annual report by the
State Department on human rights practices said. On freedom of speech and of the
press, the report said "political violence and extralegal intimidation in recent
years have led to self-censorship among journalists." In 2008, several
journalists "reported receiving threats from political parties, politicians,
fellow journalists, and opposition militia figures who generally threatened
violence against them and their families if they did not cease writing articles
on sensitive political issues," the report said. In its annual survey of human
rights in 194 countries, the State Department noted that in November 2008 more
than 15 supporters of the SSNP attacked Future News TV reporter Omar Harqous
with sticks in Beirut's Hamra Street, injuring him in the head, neck, and chest.
The report reiterated that prison conditions were poor and did not meet minimum
international standards. "Prisons were overcrowded and sanitary conditions,
particularly in women's prisons, were very poor," it said. In a positive
development, the State Department said there were no reports of political
prisoners or detainees.
On freedom of movement, the report noted that "government forces were unable to
enforce the law in the predominantly Hizbullah-controlled Beirut southern
suburbs and did not typically enter Palestinian refugee camps." Beirut, 12 Mar
10, 09:57
Rifi says political campaign has been launched against him
Now Lebanon/March 12, 2010
Cooperation agreements between countries and systems have never been and will
never be tackled in the form of administrative memorandums that are discussed in
councils and ministries and exposed to the media, said Internal Security Forces
Director General Major General Achraf Rifi in an interview in An-Nahar published
on Friday.
This comes in reference to reports about a supposed security cooperation
agreement between the US and the ISF, following a US request for information on
Lebanon’s cellular phone networks. The request led to March 8 coalition figures,
including Loyalty to the Resistance bloc MP Hassan Fadlallah and Speaker Nabih
Berri, criticizing former Prime Minister Fouad Siniora’s cabinet for allegedly
signing the agreement with the US Embassy. “The US and European companies who
have installed the systems have access to the maps anyway,” he said.
Rifi added that a political campaign is being launched against him on the issue.
“I do not have the right to send anyone else but ISF members to training,” he
said, in reference to As-Safir’s report on Thursday that one of the supposed
agreement’s clauses state that the Lebanese government should confirm that all
ISF members who receive training are not affiliated with any organization listed
by the US as terrorist. Rifi also questioned who has an interest in diverting
attention by “engaging in futile domestic disputes” rather than focusing on
Israeli espionage networks and means of dismantling them.-NOW Lebanon
Sweden Recognizes Assyrian,
Greek and Armenian Genocide
3-12-2010
http://www.aina.org/news/20100311192620.htm
Stockholm (AINA) --- In adopted a resolution adopted
today, the Swedish parliament (the Riksdagen) referered to the World War I-era
killings of 2.75 million Armenians, Assyrians (also known as Chaldeans and
Syriacs) and Pontic Greeks by the Ottomans as a genocide. Turkey is regarded
legally and politically as the successor state of the Ottoman Empire but
vehemently rejects calling the killing genocide according to the U.N. definition
adopted in 1948, insisting that those killed were victims of war and uprising.
The genocide claimed the lives of 750,000 Assyrians (75%), 500,000 Greeks and
1.5 million Armenians.
The resolution passed by a single vote after some members of Prime Minister
Fredrik Reinfeldt's ruling centre-right coalition broke ranks and voted with the
red-green opposition.
Swedish Foreign Minister Carl Bildt is cited by Swedish radio news saying that
he regretted the Parliament's decision and feared it could "be used" by reform
critics in Turkey and that it "will unfortunately not have a positive effect on
the ongoing normalization process between Turkey and Armenia."
In contrast the Left Party's foreign policy spokesperson Hans Linde told The
Local newspaper on Thursday that the time had come for Sweden to take a stand on
the issue. "First, to learn from history and stop it from repeating and second,
to encourage the development of democracy in Turkey, which includes dealing with
its own history. The third reason," added Linde, "is to redress the wrongs
committed against the victims and their relatives."
The Washington Post cites Gulan Avci saying that, "after 95 years it is time for
people who have suffered so long to obtain redress." Gulan Avci is a Liberal
Party lawmaker who broke with her party's line and voted to recognize the
resolution. Avci is a Kurdish immigrant from Turkey.
The uniqueness of Sweden's genocide adoption is that it refers also to Assyrians
and Pontic Greeks. Their suffering during the World War I has been mostly
forgotten for decades, but in December 2007 the International Association of
Genocide Scholars (IAGS) did vote overwhelmingly and recognized the genocides of
the Assyrian and Greek populations of the Ottoman Empire between 1914 and 1923.
For the Assyrians organizations in Sweden, the recognition of the genocide,
called Seyfo in Assyrian, is a milestone in their effort for political
acknowledgment. More than 80,000 Assyrians live in Sweden, and they closely
followed the debate in the parliament.
As expected, Turkey condemned the decision of the Swedish Parliament. A strong
condemnation was voiced in a press release from the Prime Minister's office.
Turkey recalled its ambassador to Sweden for consultations and said Prime
Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan has cancelled his planned visit to Sweden on the
17th of this month.
Last week a U.S. a congressional committee approved a similar resolution that
would send the measure to the full House of Representatives. Minutes after the
vote, Turkey withdrew its ambassador to the U.S. Also last year, Turkey also
recalled its ambassador to Canada after Prime Minister Stephen Harper referred
to the killings as genocide.
By Abdulmesih BarAbrahem
Copyright (C) 2010, Assyrian International News Agency. All Rights Reserved.
Terms of Use.
http://www.persecution.org/suffering/newssummpopup.php?newscode=11903&PHPSESSID=f0e88144c4e3ebaa1b9443357a5f0ce0
500 Christians Slaughtered
Where is the worldwide outrage for such an atrocity?
How could the murder of a six-week-old child be revenge for anything?
On 7 March 2010, in the middle of the night, Muslims murdered 500 Christian
women and children in the village of Dogo Nahawa, near the city of Jos. The
Muslims massacred children as young as six weeks old.
Muslim extremists invaded the village at 2 a.m. local time and slaughtered
Christians with machetes. In some cases, the Muslims wiped out entire families.
Of those murdered, 380 were buried in a mass grave. The police have arrested 93
people and recovered guns, knives and other types of weapons from the suspects.
The security officials knew what was happening but did not intervene.
The Reverend Chuwang Avou, General Secretary of the Christian Association of
Nigeria in Plateau State said Christians from the village called him as soon as
the Muslims started their attack. He immediately alerted the security officials.
The security officials went to the village, where they witnessed Muslims were
killing Christians, but didn’t intervene to stop the massacre. When other
Christians from surrounding villages attempted to intervene, the security forces
stopped them by stating they couldn’t enter the village until 6 a.m. The Muslims
carried out the massacre until 5:30 a.m. and then left the village.
Reverend Avou, said, “Christians are intimidated. We need assistance from
outside Nigeria because we don’t have confidence in this country. We have lost
confidence in the security forces in our country . . . . Military people,
especially the army, are taking sides. We want the United Nation to come to our
aid.”
Jonah John Jang, the Governor of Plateau State, where the attack took place,
confirmed the failure of the military to stop the killing. According to the
Nigerian newspaper, This Day, on March 6, at 9 p.m., the governor reported the
possibility of the attack to Major-General Maina Saleh, the commanding officer
of the military in the area. But the military failed to take actions despite the
warning by the governor.
According to Governor Jang, the massacre “could have been avoided, if they acted
on my report.”
Scientists predict large
Lebanon earthquake looming
Sidon shake registering 3.8 on Richter Scale this week just latest earth
movement
By Patrick Galey /Daily Star staff
Friday, March 12, 2010
BEIRUT: Although it probably passed you by, Lebanon was one of many countries to
experience an earthquake this week.
A quake registering 3.8 on the Richter Scale hit 50 kilometers off the coast of
Sidon at just after 2:30 Tuesday morning. No damage was reported and, according
to Ata Elias, assistant professor at the American University of Beirut’s (AUB)
Department of Geology, it was in no way related to recent larger tremors. “The
earthquake that happened off the coast of Sidon was very small,” he told
students at AUB Thursday. Already in 2010, huge earthquakes have killed
thousands of people and caused billions of dollars worth of damage in Haiti,
Chile and most recently Turkey. Elias was keen to point out these tremors were
not part of a wider trend of earth movements:
“These have nothing to do with our faults. There are on very different faults
and not related,” he said.
But that’s where the good news ended. The eastern Mediterranean basin lies next
to the boundary between African and Arabian tectonic plates, forming one of the
most volatile seismic regions on earth.
“The Mediterranean has lots of earthquakes … especially the eastern
Mediterranean because this area is surrounded by major faults,” Elias said.
Lebanon is particularly vulnerable to tremors; it is bisected by the Yammouneh
fault and Mount Lebanon Thrust fault lines, which produce hundreds of minute
shocks a year.
“Earthquakes happen everywhere and everyday in Lebanon,” Elias said.
Most of these are too small for concern – around 1,000 times weaker than the
last major quake to strike Lebanon, in 1759 at a magnitude of 7.4, which killed
tens of thousands of people. In 1956, the 5.7M Chim earthquake caused loss of
life and significant material damage.
Scientists believe that a colossal quake occurred off the coast of Lebanon in
551, producing a tsunami that razed Beirut to the ground.
Elias and Abdel-Rahman, professor and chairperson at AUB’s Department of
Geology, warned that another earthquake of this magnitude could occur any day.
“The Yammouneh fault produces major earthquakes about every 1,000 years; the
Mount Lebanon Thrust every 1,500 to 1,750 years. But we can have earthquakes
before and after these dates and that’s the only scientific account we can give
of a possibility of earthquakes in the area,” Elias said.
“In other words, if we learn that there was a large magnitude earthquake [in
551], we are expecting one with a similar magnitude around now,” Rahman added.
“Obviously we cannot do to much predicting. We still cannot predict to any
reasonable degree when an earthquake will happen.” Elias said that the current
lull in major earthquakes in Lebanon was not uncommon, nor did it mean the
area’s seismic activity had ceased. “The fact that today we are not witnessing
major earthquakes is not unusual, but it tells us that maybe the stress is
loading … and a major earthquake will happen. Maybe we are close to the end of a
seismic cycle,” he said.
It is a danger humans in Lebanon have faced since the first inhabitants of the
Fertile Crescent – even the architects at Baalbek’s Temple of Bacchus designed
its keystone to withstand seismic activity – and Elias said it was each
homeowner’s responsibility to ensure modern buildings could stand up to future
jolts.
“It’s up to everyone among us to check whether their house is well built or
not,” he said. He added that Lebanon’s seven seismic activity monitor centers
made it one of the best placed countries in the region to come up with viable
methods of reducing earthquake-induced damage.
Lebanese man becomes first to sue former Syrian 'jailers'
By Agence France Presse (AFP)
Friday, March 12, 2010
BEIRUT: A Lebanese man has filed an unprecedented lawsuit against five Syrians,
including four officers, that he said kidnapped, tortured and jailed him in
Syria, his lawyer told AFP on Thursday. Elias Tanios was kidnapped from Lebanon
by Syrian soldiers in 1992 and taken to Syria where he was held in jail until
his release in 2000, Sleiman Labbous said. “Two days ago he filed a suit in a
Beirut court against four officers responsible for his detention and his torture
during his years in jail,” the lawyer said. Tanios, a former member of the
Lebanese security services, also filed a suit against a Syrian man, who also
holds Lebanese nationality, who allegedly “denounced him.” The attorney refused
to give a motive for the arrest and detention of his client but insisted that he
was “innocent.” The suit is the first of its kind to be filed against Syrian
authorities by a Lebanese once held in Syria – which ruled Lebanon politically
and military for nearly three decades until April 2005. Syria rounded up
hundreds of Lebanese during its occupation of Lebanon, holding them in detention
either in Lebanese or in Syrian jails. Hundreds of Lebanese who went missing
during that time are still believed to be held in Syrian prisons. Families of
the missing have been pressing the Syrian authorities to free them or to report
on their fates. Families have been demanding for years their release, as well as
a probe into the fate of hundreds of their kin who went missing during Syria’s
domination of Lebanon. In October 2008, Lebanon and Syria established their
first ever diplomatic ties after decades of strained relations between the two
neighbors. The defendants named in the lawsuit include Jameh Jameh, a Syrian
officer who was in charge of an infamous detention and torture center in Beirut
in the 1990s, the lawyer said. Also named was Barakat al-Ash, who ran the
Saydnaya prison, one of Syria’s largest jails, as well as officers Dib Zeitouni,
Kamal Youssef, and Ghassan Alloush who allegedly denounced Tanios to the Syrian
authorities. – AFP
Magistrate lists charges in Ain al-Remmaneh case
Khamis demands death penalty for killer in bloody incident
By The Daily Star
Friday, March 12, 2010
BEIRUT: Mount Lebanon Investigative Magistrate Fawzi Khamis issued Thursday a
list of charges regarding the bloody Ain al-Remmaneh incident.
On October 6, 2009, 31-year-old Georges Abu Madi was killed and four others were
wounded when violence erupted between young men from the mainly Shiite district
of Shiyyah and men from the nearby Christian area of Ain al-Remmaneh.
The incident sparked fears of further outbreaks of sectarian violence similar to
the events of May 7, 2008, when bloody clashes broke out between pro-government
and opposition gunmen in West Beirut and the Chouf region.
Khamis demanded that the death penalty be given to Ali Yassin for deliberately
killing Abu Madi by stabbing him in the chest and for attempting to kill others.
The magistrate also demanded life imprisonment with forced labor for Ali al-Sayyed
Hussein, Samih Hammoud, Ali Bilal, Kamal al-Shafawi, Ahmad Eissa, Ibrahim Yassin,
Yahya Yahya, Hassan Jaber, and Abass Zahwi for attempted murder. The men were
all found to have participated in beating Abu Madi and a number of his friends.
Khamis also accused the detainees of participating in a “riot, gatherings on
public roads, undermining national unity and instigating sectarian tensions.”
Khamis said the charges revealed that on the day of Abu Madi’s killing, the
accused had agreed to go from Beirut’s southern suburbs to Ain al-Remmaneh
simply to create trouble to avenge one of their friends being humiliated in the
area a week earlier.
With knives, sticks and daggers in their possession, the accused went to the
area on five motorcycles. After reaching Gallery Kanaan on Haneen Street, they
found Abu Madi standing near his house with a number of individuals. The men
then battered Abu Madi, Selim Boulos, Jean Al-Haber, Mazen Mitri, George Mansour,
Boulos Abdel-Ahad, and Jean Habib. During the fighting, Abu Madi was stabbed in
the chest and died.
Yassin later confessed to stabbing Abu Madi, saying he’d bragged about it to his
friends.
Different Lebanese political factions condemned the incident in the wake of the
crime.
Hizbullah and the Amal Movement, the two parties that hold sway in Beirut’s
southern suburbs, issued a joint statement condemning the “painful” incident and
urging security forces and judicial authorities to disclose the details of the
event. “All parties should bear their national responsibilities, preserve
coexistence and work in favor of the country’s best interests,” the statement
said.
The statement also criticized all those “seeking” to provoke sectarian strife,
adding that “impulsive attitudes” do not serve Lebanon’s interests. “The
incident was personal rather than politically or religiously motivated,” it
said.
A few days after the incident, the pan-Arab Al-Hayat newspaper published remarks
by MPs quoting Parliament Speaker Nabih Berri as saying that the group that
entered Ain al-Remmaneh “came from [the southern suburb of] Bourj al-Barajneh to
drink and gamble.” Berri told his visitors that “the incident was a personal one
but this does not justify what happened, particularly since the victim was an
innocent bystander,” the paper added. – The Daily Star
Antione
Choueiri's legacy lives on
Friday, March 12, 2010
Editorial/Daily Star
The passing of Antoine Choueiri this week is being marked in Lebanon and the
region, as people use words such as “mogul” to refer to his legacy in the
advertising industry, and “president” to refer to his legacy in the realm of
sports.
A man of many hats, Choueiri might not have pleased everyone, but the bottom
line is this: During the Civil War, which is remembered directly by fewer and
fewer people, there came a point where he almost single-handedly lifted the
country’s advertising industry, with a knock-on effect in related sectors.
In our part of the world, the media has two main sources of income. One is the
government, while the other is “political money,” which has a variety of
manifestations. Neither is particularly responsive to the media industries as
such; the concern of states and powerful figures is one of “get my message out”
and damn the consequences.
By contrast, Choueiri played a distinctive role. He wasn’t an advertising man
per se; he didn’t spend his days polishing the image of clients. Instead, he was
the real estate agent who dealt in selling column inches of advertisements. He
was a broker between ad agencies and the media, and more importantly, he used
his own money to develop the industry and let it discover new opportunities.
He was a master of networking before the term became widely used. He and the
country benefited from his connections to international associations and bodies
active in media and advertising. He put his money where his mouth was: he funded
conferences and brought people together, which lifted the profile of Lebanon’s
advertising firms. Lebanon’s media surged after the war, and Choueiri was
central in this process. And, he was equally pivotal in making Dubai’s
advertising sector what it is today.
Choueiri might have had his biases and wasn’t a reflection of Gandhian purity.
But, he was as close to the concept of professionalism, and his work was as
close to being market-driven, as you can possibly get in this part of the world.
He was a ruthless businessman, but the industry demanded it. He was also a
risk-taker who pushed the envelope. As an individual, he was a salesman par
excellence. As time went on, as a businessman, he came to function, invisibly,
as the banker of the advertising industry.
Rafik Hariri might not have pleased everyone, but his name came to be associated
with the very word Lebanon, because of his local reconstruction achievements and
massive external clout. The same goes for Antoine Choueiri and Lebanon’s
advertising agencies, which means a true giant has passed from the scene. He was
a mogul, and a president, but more importantly, he was a builder.
Lebanese
Tycoon, Choueiri, Buried in Hometown
/Naharnet/The body of millionaire Antoine Choueiri was buried Thursday in his
hometown of Bsharri in north Lebanon. The funeral service for the 69-year-old
businessman was held at St. Georges Cathedral in downtown Beirut before midday
Thursday. Choueiri's funeral was attended by a huge number of relatives, friends
as well as government and media officials. Choueiri, a prominent Lebanese
businessman and media magnate, died on Tuesday after a long battle with illness.
He had been rushed to the intensive care unit at Hotel Dieu Hospital in
Ashrafieh about 20 days ago. During the 38 years he spent in the business world,
Choueiri was the main advertising representative of several Arab media
corporations such as An-Nahar and As-Safir Lebanese dailies, Lebanese
Broadcasting Corporation International TV, Al-Jazeera pan-Arab TV, al-Hayat
London-based pan-Arab daily, and Dubai Media Incorporated. Choueiri was
responsible for managing advertising sales for some of the largest broadcasters
in the region such as LBC, MBC and Dubai TV. His prevailing influence in the
world of television prompted the formation of the GCC Association of Advertisers
3 years ago. Members of the GCC Association of Advertisers include Emirates
Airlines, Unilever and McDonalds. All of the members are said to spend over $100
million a year on advertising in the region. The Choueiri Group is a privately
held company initially formed by Antoine Choueiri in Paris after civil war
erupted in Lebanon in the 1970's. The first regional firm launched by the
Choueiri Group was in Saudi Arabia, where Antoine Choueiri built on his
reputation and his expertise until he was ready to launch in Lebanon and in the
UAE, in what has become the most expansive media network in the region. The
Group is involved in managing and marketing the advertising space of more than
30 TV and radio stations, print title and billboard signs in the GCC. On the
other hand, Choueiri was renowned for his passion and support for Lebanese
basketball. He was the chairman of Sagesse Club for a long period during which
the club was able to reap many local and international championships, including
8 Lebanese League Championships, 3 Lebanese Basketball Cups, 2 Arab Clubs
Championships, and 3 Asian Basketball Club Championships. Beirut, 11 Mar 10,
13:01
Russian Ambassador: Time for Lebanese to Take Reins of Government
Naharnet/"It is time for Lebanese to take the reins of the government
themselves," Russian Ambassador to Lebanon Sergei Poukin said. He stressed the
importance of dialogue in Lebanon "to discuss the most acute issues which still
exist on the table."While pointing out that Lebanon is an independent country,
Poukin rejected any foreign meddling in Lebanese affairs.
Beirut, 11 Mar 10, 12:15
Berri Describes as 'Very Dangerous' the Alleged Signing of
Saniora Government of Security Agreement with U.S. Embassy
Naharnet/Speaker Nabih Berri on Thursday stressed that the Media and
Communications Parliamentary Committee will persistently follow up on the issue
of the alleged security agreement with the U.S. Embassy. In an interview with
al-Manar TV network, Berri warned that if it appears that the ex-PM Fouad
Saniora government had earlier signed the agreement, "then the issue will be
very dangerous and it will lead to consequences."On the other hand, Berri urged
finding a mechanism for administrative appointments to ensure balance.
Beirut, 11 Mar 10, 21:55
Biden
calls for Hizbullah disarmament during Tel Aviv University talk
Us VP URGES immediate restart to Palestinian-Israeli peace talks after row
Compiled by Daily Star staff /Friday, March 12, 2010
US Vice President Joe Biden stressed Thursday during a speech in Israel that his
country would pursue its efforts to fully implement UN Security Council
Resolution 1701 to stop arms flow to Hizbullah and strip the party of its
weapons, while also calling for Israeli-Palestinian peace talks to start without
delay.
“Weapons constituting danger equally against Israeli and Lebanese civilians,”
Biden said during a lecture at Tel Aviv University on Thursday.
Biden also slammed Iran’s leadership for funding and arming Hizbullah as well as
seeking nuclear weapons.
“There is no doubt that the major danger in the region is Iran, whose leadership
defies the international community in its attempts to acquire nuclear weapons,”
Biden said.
“During the past 10 years, Iran became more dangerous and is building thousands
of centrifuges while supporting and funding Hizbullah,” he added.
Tackling American-Syrian bilateral ties, Biden said the US was promoting
bilateral ties with Damascus and that it had reassigned a new ambassador to
Syria.
“However, we will keep our eyes open to Syrian acts that could threaten security
in Israel and the region while hoping for improved ties between Syria and
Israel,” Biden added.
Speaking of the Israeli-Palestinian peace talks, Biden called parties to start
talks without delay in spite of demands by Palestinians that Israel first cancel
a settlement project announced this week.
On Tuesday, Israel announced its plans to build 1,600 settler homes in an area
of the occupied West Bank near occupied Jerusalem.
The announcement, which was made during Biden’s visit, cast a shadow over
American efforts to relaunch Middle East peacemaking.
“The most important thing is for these talks to go forward and go forward
promptly and go forward in good faith,” Biden said in a speech at Tel Aviv
University. “We can’t delay because when progress is postponed, extremists
exploit our differences.”
The settlement announcement embarrassed Biden, who said it undermined peace
efforts, and infuriated the West Bank-based Palestinian leadership, which had
agreed to a US proposal for indirect talks under pressure from Washington and
Arab allies.
Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas told Arab League Secretary General Amr
Moussa on Wednesday he had decided not to enter the talks for now. The Arab
League had endorsed a four-month framework for the US-mediated negotiations.
In a telephone conversation with Biden before the Tel Aviv address, Abbas
“reiterated to him that Israel must annul the settlement project in Jerusalem so
that indirect talks will not be obstructed,” Abbas aide Nabil Abu Rdainah told
Reuters.
Palestinian officials had no immediate comment on Biden’s Tel Aviv speech.
US officials expressed confidence that despite the flare-up, the indirect
negotiations could begin as early as next week, when US Middle East envoy George
Mitchell is scheduled to return to the region.
The vice president later travelled to Jordan for talks with King Abdullah to
discuss the peace process.
In his address, Biden gave no sign Washington would press Israel to cancel the
project as the Palestinians have demanded; and Israeli officials made clear it
would not do so.
Instead, he termed “significant” assurances from Prime Minister Benjamin
Netanyahu that building at the site, a religious settlement, would not start for
years.
With no construction scheduled for now, Biden said, negotiators would have time
to “resolve this and other outstanding issues.” He stressed that indirect talks
should lead to direct negotiations on key issues of Palestinian statehood.
In a statement, Netanyahu said he had voiced his displeasure to his interior
minister, a leader of the ultraorthdox, nationalist Shas party, over the timing
of the announcement of the project.
Israel’s Labour Party, meanwhile, hinted that it may quit the ruling coalition
over the decision to build the settler homes, Agriculture Minister Shalom Simhon
warned on Thursday.
“Members of the Labour Party have more and more difficulty in taking part in a
coalition government that they joined with the purpose of relaunching the peace
process with the Palestinians,” Simhon told army radio. “A grave error has been
committed [by Israel] and there is a price to pay,” he added.
Biden’s speech was widely seen in Israel as an attempt by the White House to
counter-balance the address to the Muslim world that President Barack Obama
delivered back in June in Cairo.
Many Israelis view Obama with suspicion, and Biden reaffirmed in his speech a
United States commitment to Israel’s security and what he called Washington’s
determination to ensure that Iran does not obtain nuclear weapons.
On the Israeli-Palestinian diplomatic front, Mitchell, who has been trying to
broker for a year a resumption of talks, was expected to return to Israel and
the West Bank next week.
Abbas had demanded a full settlement freeze in the West Bank and occupied East
Jerusalem, areas captured by Israel in a 1967 war, before any resumption of the
two-decade old peace process.
Israel considers all of occupied Jerusalem its capital, a claim that the
international community rejects. Palestinians want occupied East Jerusalem to be
the capital of the state they hope to establish in the West Bank and Gaza Strip.
“Jerusalem is the capital of Israel and construction there will be carried out
like in Tel Aviv or any other city – in every part of Jerusalem according to
the plans,” Israeli Cabinet Secretary Zvi Hauser told Israel Radio. The
Palestinians say the settlements, considered illegal by major world powers, will
deny them a viable state. Under US pressure, Israel announced in November a
decision to restrain building in its West Bank settlements for 10 months but
said the restrictions would not include occupied East Jerusalem.
The international community, meanwhile, continued to slam the Israeli plans to
build new settlement homes. China, Turkey, and Spain denounced the plan on
Thursday.
Lebanese President Michel Sleiman said the Israeli cabinet’s decision to build
new settlements proved that Israel had rejected the prospect of partaking in the
peace process.
“The policy of running forward to escape international pressure reveals with no
doubt that Israel is not ready or willing to start serious peace negotiations
with the Palestinians in order to establish a basis for a comprehensive and just
peace in the Middle East,” Sleiman said.
Foreign Minister Miguel Angel Moratinos of Spain, which represents the European
Union presidency, expressed concern over the announcement of the new settlements
to Israeli counterpart Avigdor Lieberman.
“I expressed my real deep concern, hoping that this settlement activity will be
ended, and there will be no more announcement, no more expansion work.”
Turkey, for its part, said that the plan raised “serious doubts” on Israel’s
commitment to peace. – AFP, with Elias Sakr
Biden
Says U.S. to Keep on Supporting Lebanon Institutions, 1701 Implementation to
Disarm Hizbullah
Naharnet/U.S. Vice President Joe Biden on Thursday stressed the persistence of
Washington in supporting Lebanon's institutions and working on the
implementation of U.N. Security Council Resolution 1701 "to stop the flow of
arms to Hizbullah." Speaking at Tel Aviv University, Biden said that Hizbullah's
weapons represent a threat to both "Israel and Lebanese civilians." The vice
president described Iran as the greatest threat to the region due to its alleged
nuclear program and sponsoring of Hizbullah.
On the other hand, Biden confirmed that Washington will send a new ambassador to
Syria to enhance diplomatic relations. However, he called for keeping an eye on
Damascus' acts that may jeopardize "the security of Israel and the region."
Biden implored Israelis and Palestinians to move beyond a diplomatic spat that
has marred his trip to the region, urging the sides to waste no time in
resolving their decades-old conflict despite daunting obstacles. Biden used
conciliatory language as he wrapped up a three-day visit to the area in an
apparent attempt to get past the uproar sparked by an Israeli plan for new
settlement construction in disputed east Jerusalem. The Israeli announcement --
seen as a slap in the face to Biden -- drew a sharp condemnation from the vice
president as well as a Palestinian threat to withdraw from U.S.-mediated peace
talks before they even begin. The 22-nation Arab League, which gave Abbas the
backing to resume talks with Israel, has recommended withdrawing support for
indirect talks in the wake of the Israeli settlement plan. Biden's speech
appeared aimed at not letting the row with Israel derail the Obama
administration's latest drive for Mideast peace. However, the vice president's
effusive praise for the Jewish state — saying the U.S. has "no better friend"
than Israel — could disappoint those who had hoped he would talk tougher in the
wake of the new settlement plan. Biden said the sides must get down to the
business of making peace.
"To end this historic conflict, both sides must be historically bold," Biden
said. "If each waits stubbornly ... this will go on for an eternity."
In his speech, Biden outlined the contours of what the U.S. believes should be a
final settlement. He said a Palestinian state must be based on the pre-1967
borders, with some modifications and strong guarantees for Israel's security.
Biden listed what he believes to be reminders of Israel's security concerns: The
strength of Hizbullah guerrillas to Israel's north in Lebanon, the Hamas
presence in Gaza, the continued captivity of an Israeli soldier in Gaza, and
"ongoing Palestinian incitement against Israel."(Naharnet-AP) Beirut, 11 Mar 10,
17:44
Cabinet Forms Committee Tasked with Submitting Ideas on Appointments Mechanism
Naharnet/The Cabinet on Thursday formed a committee tasked with submitting ideas
for the criterions and mechanism of administrative nominations and appointments.
The committee is headed by PM Saad Hariri and consisted of the ministers Elias
Murr, Jean Ogassapian, Mohammed Fneish, Jebran Bassil and Wael Abu Faour.
It is expected to submit its report to the cabinet by the end of this month.
"The committee will convene Monday under Minister Elias Murr at the defense
ministry," Information Minister Tareq Mitri announced after cabinet's
extraordinary session. Mitri revealed that the "transparent" mechanism will
guarantee the integrity of the candidates, equal Christian-Muslim powersharing,
and increasing the rate of women's presence in public administrations. On
Wednesday, a Cabinet meeting failed to approve administrative appointments.
Cabinet, however, approved a proposal by the Higher Judicial Council to name two
active members among its ranks and appoint one additional member to the Justice
Council.
"There were no appointments," Mirti told reporters. "There were some
reservations but discussions did not take a long time."
Those who expressed reservations were ministers Elias Murr, Jebran Bassil,
Charbel Nahhas, Abraham Dedeyan, Adnan Sayyed Hussein and Mona Ofeish.
Nevertheless, Council approved the nominations.
Beirut, 11 Mar 10, 22:21
Human Rights Watch
Sectarian Killings in Nigeria Continue
Investigations, Prosecutions Needed to Help Break Cycle of Violence
“They came with guns, ammunition, and machetes,” a 25-year-old student said.
“One group surrounded our village and started shooting. I saw many villagers -
women, children, and some men - hacked to death. I lost one of my daughters, who
was 7 years old.”
The recent massacre in a mainly Christian village near Jos left at least 200
dead. Two months earlier, 150 Muslims from another village were massacred in a
tragically similar fashion. More than 13,500 people in Nigeria, 3,000 of them in
and around Jos, have died in sectarian clashes since the end of military rule in
1999.
Nigeria is deeply divided along ethnic and religious lines. Human Rights Watch
research shows that profound levels of poverty, the failure to investigate and
prosecute those responsible for the violence, and discriminatory government
policies fuel tension and underlie the cycles of violence. The government
policies deny government jobs and scholarships to people who can’t trace their
ancestry to a certain area. "This kind of terrible violence has left thousands
dead in the past decade, but no one has been held accountable," said Corinne
Dufka, senior West Africa researcher. "It's time to draw a line in the sand
How to Make Defeatism Look
Good: Let's Give Up and Cheer the Islamists/By Barry Rubin/March
12, 2010
http://www.gloria-center.org/gloria/2010/03/how-to-make-defeatism
I'm not going to bash or rant about a Newsweek article
about Turkey by Owen Matthews-shocking and dangerous as it is--but rather talk
about what is wrong and inaccurate about it. That article is part of a new wave
of defeatism sweeping the West, though it still remains subordinate to the more
ostensibly attractive idea that there is no real conflict or at least one easy
to fix by Western concessions.
Here's the title: "The Army Is Beaten: Why the U.S. should hail the Islamists."
Yes, we should thank the Islamists for taking over Turkey. But wait a minute!
The ruling AK party says it isn't Islamist. Indeed, I have been viciously
attacked by them in the Turkish media for saying so. Up until now the
line--including that from the regime itself--has been that we shouldn't be
afraid of them because they are really just democrats. But now some are willing
to face the truth and still sugarcoat it.
Matthews writes:
"The political logic should be simple. The arrest of a shadowy group of generals
for allegedly plotting a bloody coup should be a victory for justice. The end of
military meddling in politics should be a victory for democracy. And greater
democracy should make a country more liberal and more pro-European."
Each of these sentences makes a false assumption and must be examined a bit.
Sentence one: Arresting military officers is only a victory for justice if they
are guilty. Why does the author assume they are guilty? In fact, the claims are
ludicrous. That a group of officers created a 5000 page plan for a coup that
involved attacking mosques and massive attacks on civilians. It is one of a
series of such accusations for which no real evidence has been presented, in
which a widely disparate group of people have been arrested as alleged
conspirators when their sole connection is that they are critics of the
government.
This is ridiculously gullible. It's like the famous sentence by a newsweekly
magazine that even if the Hitler diaries were forgeries (they were) that would
tell us a great deal about the history of the time. If in fact the arrests were
trumped-up to tame the army so that the current regime can impose a dictatorship
in practice it was not a victory for justice but for injustice. Iran, Syria,
Hamas, Hizballah, and Islamists in general lie a lot (and a lot more than
democratic government) so why should they be taken at their word, especially
when any serious examination of evidence shows the truth.
Sentence two: Of course, in general, keeping the army out of politics is a
victory for democracy, but that ignores the specific history of Turkey. The army
has viewed itself and been accepted there as the guardian of democracy. This
history is certainly imperfect but when the country has been sliding into
anarchy in the past or fallen into the hand of those who threatened to destroy
the republic, the army has stepped in briefly, gotten civilians to reorganize
things on a stable basis, and quickly gone back into the barracks.
The Turkish army is not like those of the Third World which hunger for power,
destroy democracy, and unleash corrupt and repressive regimes. On the other
hand, this article--and many others--show ignorance about the actual shifts in
Turkey.
For example, there is no awareness that the regime is seizing control of the
media; that the party leader (which means the prime minister for the ruling
party) simply picks candidates for parliament as he pleases; that the reforms
have strengthened the prime minister's power and not parliamentary democracy;
and that women are being forced out of high positions. Merely weakening the army
doesn't mean more democracy when in almost every other respect there is less.
Sentence three: If indeed-as is the case-the regime is systematically cracking
down on the free media and imposing its control over all the institutions. This
is not leading to greater but to less democracy. There should be a lot more
reporting on what's happening within the country instead of just repeating the
regime's claims.
Indeed, the author states:
"And with the last major obstacle to the ruling AK Party's power gone, Turkey's
conservative prime minister, Recep Tayyip Erdogan, will be free to implement his
vision of a more Islamic Turkey. More democracy, then, doesn't necessarily lead
to more liberalism, either."
The assumption here is that this is what the Turkish people want. Yet it should
be noted there are some big problems for that claim. Turkey's electoral system
is so weighted that the AK has received near-monopoly control on the basis of a
vote that in most parliamentary democracies would have produced a coalition
government.
Moreover, many or most Turks who voted for the AK weren't doing so because they
wanted Islamism-as public opinion surveys clearly show--but because they thought
(mistakenly, even according to this author) that it was a mildly conservative
party.
And finally, the AK is seizing control over institutions so as to be sure that
it will never lose another election. It is destroying Turkish democracy, a point
made rather obvious by a long list of such actions over non-military
institutions like the civil service, courts, and media. The author-and many
others-are simply taking the regime's word for it and ignoring what the
government is actually doing.
The author concludes by saying: "It's also clear that Turkey under the AK Party
will remain a Western ally, and NATO will remain Ankara's most important
strategic partner."
Then, this unusually candid if wrong author explains:
"How do we know? The AK Party says so, and it has no real options. There's no
rival alliance, not with Iran, the Arab world, or Russia, which could possibly
rival the clout Turkey has, with the second-largest Army in NATO."
Of course, Turkey has options. And here is the option the regime has chosen: To
keep as much as possible the Western alliances while the content of its policy
favors radical Islamist forces.
Incidentally, this "no option" argument is the root of a huge amount of
confusion in the Middle East. Supposedly, Iran has "no option" but to become
moderate; Syria has "no option" but to dump Iran; the Palestinian Authority has
"no option" but to make peace. Yet over and over again the local forces find an
option that they are quite happy to pursue other than the one laid out for them
by Western observers. They have their own view of the world, ideology, and goals
(often the goal of the regime being to amass wealth and stay in power).
And one of the key factors in this process is that--rightly or wrongly--they
think they are winning so why should they change course or make compromises? And
certain other ideas are calculated into their list of options: soon Iran has
nuclear weapons. And the divine being is on their side. And the West is weak,
stupid, cowardly, and easily fooled.
Turkey is one of the main places they think they are winning, according to Syria
and Iran.
Now of course, the Turkish government doesn't have to say: America stinks and
we're pulling out of NATO. It can keep the benefits of these relationships,
having their cake and eating it, too. But in practice Turkey is moving closer to
Iran and Syria, with the leaders of both of these two countries openly pointing
out that fact. The question is what does it mean for Turkey to be a Western ally
in a practical sense? If it supports Iran, Syria, Hizballah, and Hamas, just how
does Ankara function as a Western ally? It's meaningless.
So, the article concludes, "The world would be wise to side with the AK Party,
not seek a return of the discredited generals." I'm not sure why the generals
are supposed to be discredited by ludicrous accusations orchestrated by an
anti-American (in practice) government which needs to destroy them. Rather, it
is the current regime in Turkey that should be discredited.
Still, it's a pretty neat trick when a regime repressing Turkish democracy and
increasingly siding with the enemies of the West can convince people in the West
that this is a good thing.
Incidentally, the New York Times has only a slightly more nuanced editorial than
the Matthews article. Among other things, it take at face value that the story
about the military planning a coup was broken by a small "independent" newspaper
in Turkey. Actually, that publication is a front from the regime and is most
unreliable--a point one might expect the Times to have discovered. The story was
part of the regime's strategy, not some journalitic scoop.
As the theme song to the television show "MASH" put it:
"The game of life is hard to play,
I'm going to lose it anyway,
The losin' card I'll someday lay;
So this is all I have to say...
"That suicide is painless...
And I can take or leave it if I please."
The Western world should reject playing that particular card as its strategy.
*Barry Rubin is director of the Global Research in International Affairs
(GLORIA) Center and editor of the Middle East Review of International Affairs (MERIA)
Journal. His latest books are The Israel-Arab Reader (seventh edition), with
Walter Laqueur (Viking-Penguin); the paperback edition of The Truth About Syria
(Palgrave-Macmillan); A Chronological History of Terrorism, with Judy Colp
Rubin, (Sharpe); and The Long War for Freedom: The Arab Struggle for Democracy
in the Middle East (Wiley). To read and subscribe to MERIA, GLORIA articles, or
to order books, go to http://www.gloria-center.org.