LCCC
ENGLISH DAILY NEWS BULLETIN
February
26/2010
Bible Of the
Day
Luke 8/4-15: "When a great multitude came
together, and people from every city were coming to him, he spoke by a parable.
8:5 “The farmer went out to sow his seed. As he sowed, some fell along the road,
and it was trampled under foot, and the birds of the sky devoured it. 8:6 Other
seed fell on the rock, and as soon as it grew, it withered away, because it had
no moisture. 8:7 Other fell amid the thorns, and the thorns grew with it, and
choked it. 8:8 Other fell into the good ground, and grew, and brought forth
fruit one hundred times.” As he said these things, he called out, “He who has
ears to hear, let him hear!” 8:9 Then his disciples asked him, “What does this
parable mean?” 8:10 He said, “To you it is given to know the mysteries of the
Kingdom of God, but to the rest in parables; that ‘seeing they may not see, and
hearing they may not understand.’* 8:11 Now the parable is this: The seed is the
word of God. 8:12 Those along the road are those who hear, then the devil comes,
and takes away the word from their heart, that they may not believe and be
saved. 8:13 Those on the rock are they who, when they hear, receive the word
with joy; but these have no root, who believe for a while, then fall away in
time of temptation. 8:14 That which fell among the thorns, these are those who
have heard, and as they go on their way they are choked with cares, riches, and
pleasures of life, and bring no fruit to maturity. 8:15 That in the good ground,
these are such as in an honest and good heart, having heard the word, hold it
tightly, and bring forth fruit with patience.
Free Opinions, Releases, letters & Special
Reports
Is
Bellemare slowly preparing to bail out?/By
Michael Young/February
25/10
Resistance culture/Now Lebanon/February
25/10
The
Iranians are all over Iraq, and everywhere in between/By
David Ignatius/February
25/10
Latest News Reports From
Miscellaneous Sources for February 25/10
Assad Snaps Back at Clinton,
Ahmadinejad Says Region's Peoples, Including Lebanese, will Stand against
Israel/Naharnet
Iranian president in Syria to
discuss 'Zionist threats/Ynewnews
Peres: Hezbollah preventing Lebanon from
becoming Mideast Switzerland/Ynetnews
Peres: Armament of Syria, Iran doesn't frighten
Israel/Ynetnews
Iran: New Middle East won't include
Zionists/Ynetnews
Ethiopia accuses Lebanon of using plane crash
incident for “politics”/Ethiopian
News Journal
Lebanese army ignored warning
from Hizbollah/National
Peres
Rules out War with Hizbullah/Naharnet
Medvedev Calls for Full Implementation of 1701, Rejects Interference in Lebanese
Affairs/Naharnet
Chamoun:
Aoun, Jumblat Became Pillars of Syrian Regime/Naharnet
Syria Resents Hariri's
Remarks, Demands Explanation that Prompted Saudi Intervention/Naharnet
Plane Crash: Lebanon
Report Not Yet Done, Ethiopia to Receive Report Thursday/Naharnet
Jezzine Rages over FPM's
Aswad Anti-Municipal Remarks/Naharnet
Jwayya Concerned over
Continuing Spiral of Burning Homes, Cars/Naharnet
Kuwait's Zain Eyes
Expansion in Middle East, Including Lebanon/Naharnet
Ban Urges End to Israeli
Overflights, Withdrawal from Ghajar/Naharnet
Clinton Says Washington
Urging Syria to End Interference in Lebanon, Transfer of Arms to Hizbullah/Naharnet
Lebanon Seeking Death
Penalty for Alleged Spies for Israel/Naharnet
Baroud Supports Postponing
Municipal Elections in Case of Political Consensus on That Decision/Naharnet
Rayess Denies Jumblat Went
to Turkey Seeking Mediation for Damascus Trip/Naharnet
Syria turns down UN nuclear watchdog inspection/Ynetnews
Supreme Court weighs free speech against aid to
terrorists/Washington Post
Barak to UN: Hezbollah weapons aim to harm
Israeli civilians/Ha'aretz
Egypt not a target, Hezbollah says/UPI.com
Israel's Right To Self-Defense/Wall
Street Journal
Clear-eyed report spells out the risks/The
Australian
Iran, Syria back Iraq's Allawi for PM?/UPI.com
Clinton Reports Progress on Iran Sanctions/Voice
of America
Iranian Daily: Syria To Mediate Between Iran And
West On Nuclear Issue/MEMRI (blog)
Airline attacks Lebanon crash
comments/Independent Online
Prosecutor indicts 3 men with spying for Israel/Daily
Star
Hamas, Osbat al-Ansar hold Ain al-Hilweh
reconciliation talks/Daily Star
Committee demands boycott of Arab
League summit in Libya/Daily
Star
House
doomed prospects for lower voting age/Daily Star
Hariri
to receive families of plane-crash victims Tuesday/AFP
Lebanese
authorities seize counterfeit-drugs factory/Daily Star
Sleiman
to ink military cooperation deal in Russia/Daily Star
Former
UAE Interior Minister Sheikh Mubarak passes away/Daily Star
Harb
presses for quick fix to massive problems faced by NSSF/Daily Star
Hotel,
apartment use in Lebanon at record 2m nights/Daily Star
Palestinian principles committee launched in Beirut/Daily
Star
Manâ's
body found in car on Munsif-Jbeil highway/Daily
Star
ISFâ'sˆwarns citizens to be wary of Internet scam/Daily
Star
Syria
threatens to try Lebanese officials in absentia/Daily
Star
Police
arrest drug dealer on Dahr al-Baidar highway/Daily
Star
Top
Muslim clerics urge unity to mark Prophetâ's birthday/Daily
Star
Journalists's fund accepting applications for UN fellowship/Daily
Star
US
Embassy unveils new electronic process for visa applications/Daily Star
Syria and Iran defy
Clinton in show of unity
Khaled Yacoub Oweis
DAMASCUS
Thu Feb 25, 2010
DAMASCUS (Reuters) - Syria and Iran put on a show of unity and defied
Secretary of State Hillary Clinton on Thursday, dismissing her call on
Damascus to loosen its decades-long alliance with Tehran.
President Bashar al-Assad and his Iranian counterpart Mahmoud
Ahmadinejad signed a bilateral deal to remove travel visas and attended
a Muslim ceremony in the Syrian capital.
Ahmadinejad's visit came a day after Clinton said the United States was
asking Syria "to begin to move away from the relationship with Iran,"
and to stop supporting the Lebanese Shi'ite movement Hezbollah, which is
also backed by Iran.
"We must have understood Clinton wrong because of bad translation or our
limited understanding, so we signed the agreement to cancel the visas,"
Assad said.
"I find it strange that they (Americans) talk about Middle East
stability and peace and the other beautiful principles and call for two
countries to move away from each other," he added.
Ahmadinejad told a joint news conference: "Clinton said we should
maintain a distance. I say there is no distance between Iran and Syria."
He added: "We have the same goals, same interests and same enemies. Our
circle of cooperation is expanding day after day."
Support for Hezbollah forms the linchpin of the Syrian-Iranian alliance,
formed 30 years ago despite ideological differences between the ruling
hierarchy in the two countries.
Diplomats in Damascus said Syrian support for the group has been a main
sticking point in the rapprochement between Syria and the United States,
which started shortly after President Barack Obama took office in
January 2009.
NUCLEAR DISPUTE
Assad backed Iran in its nuclear dispute with the West and said Western
moves to exert pressure on Tehran constituted "neo-colonization."
The United States, along with other United Nations Security Council
members and Germany, is discussing possible fresh sanctions on Iran
because of suspicions it is seeking to build a nuclear weapon, which it
strongly denies.
Relations between Syria and Iran improved after the 1979 Iranian
revolution that brought Shi'ite clergy to power. Alone among Arab
countries, Syria, whose ruling hierarchy is secular, supported Iran
during the 1980-1988 Iraq-Iran war.
But their alliance is being tested by Syrian moves to seek a peace deal
with Israel and the possibility of an Israeli strike on Iran's nuclear
facilities.
Iran did not hide its displeasure at Syria's participation in a 2007
U.S.-supervised Middle East peace conference in Annapolis, Maryland that
it attended with Israel, prompting Syrian officials to emphasize that
Syria was a sovereign country and not a proxy of Iran.
Syrian officials have also made it clear that while Syria is against any
Israeli attack on Iran, Syria's struggle with Israel does not mean it
would be party to any hostilities between Tehran and the Jewish state.
Clinton told Senate members this week that Syria's ties with Iran were
"deeply troubling" to Washington and Syria must stop helping arm
Hezbollah, an accusation Syria denies.
She urged Syria to resume peace talks with Israel, saying Washington
would consider doing anything that could resolve the stalemate between
them. Indirect talks between the two, under Turkish mediation, broke
down two years ago.
Diplomats said U.S. envoy George Mitchell raised the issue of Syrian
backing for Hezbollah during a meeting with Assad last month. Obama has
since nominated an ambassador to Damascus after a five-year absence and
Undersecretary of State William Burns, the architect of a deal that
rehabilitated Libya's leader Muammar Gaddafi, visited Damascus this
month.
(Editing by Mark Trevelyan)
Peres: Chance of peace with Syria about to dissipate
By Haaretz Service 25/02/10
President Shimon Peres said Thursday that the chance of peace with Syria
is about to dissipate, in a speech during a national ceremony in Tel Hai.
"A peace deal with Syria could have been signed 30 years ago, as was
done with Egypt. It was not us who delayed a deal, it was the Syrians,"
said Peres. "Syria believed that time would stand by its side." "The
time has come to say the truth ? the problem in the Middle East is not
the Palestinian problem, the Palestinian problem will be solved in the
framework of the peace process with Israel. The central problem in the
Middle East is Iran's effort to control it. The central problem in the
Middle East is the insanity of Ahmadinejad.
"Assad needs to decide ? go with Iran on an axis of evil and terror or
make peace with Israel." The President also said that Hezbollah
threatens the fate of Lebanon and the peace in the region. "Nasrallah
and his group are the ones who waste money on purchasing missiles and
the ones who threaten Israel. They go against Lebanon's interests and
their actions reflect the Iranian ambition to control the Arabic
region." Peres blamed Iran for manipulating Hezbollah. "Iran and
Hezbollah use Israel as an excuse in order to hide the real goal, which
is Iranian hegemony over the Arab world in the Middle East," said Peres.
Peres called on Syrian and Lebanese leaders to return to negotiations as
soon as possible. "I came to once more extend a hand to peace. I came to
call on Syria and Lebanon to take the only road that leads to a new and
better future. The road to peace," the president said in his Tel Hai
speech.
"Iranian armament will not decide the fate of the region. Only dialogue
has the power to bring serenity to the region."
Ahmedinajad Envisions
Middle East "Free of Zionists"
by Hillel Fendel ?Arutz Sheva
At a press conference in Damascus on Wednesday, Iranian dictator Mahmoud
Ahmedinajad and his Syrian counterpart Bashar Assad took turns
threatening and taunting Israel. The former received more headlines,
with his remark about a “New Middle East free of Zionists." Assad said,
“We assume that we are facing an entity [Israel] that is ready to attack
us at any time. We are always ready for aggression, whether small or
large.” He said that he had discussed with his Iranian guest “Israel’s
crimes, and how to deal with [Israel] and help the resistance forces.”
Ahmedinajad, for his part, told the reporters, “The new Middle East [a
phrase originally made popular by President Shimon Peres who envisaged a
peaceful, prosperous region – ed.] will be a Middle East without
Zionists and without imperialists. With Allah’s help, this will happen.”
“We hope that they [Israel] will recognize the rights of the nations of
the region,” the Iranian president said, “but they must know that if
they continue their mistaken ways of the past, they will have no place
in our region… If the Zionists repeat their past mistakes, all the
nations of the region will stand against them and rip them up from their
roots.”
"No one can damage" the close Iranian-Syrian ties, Ahmadinajad said,
which will “become deeper and develop over the years… We are brothers.
We have mutual interests, as well as common goals and enemies.” On
Wednesday, U.S. Secretary of State Hillary Clinton downplayed last
month's decision by the Obama administration to return an ambassador to
Syria. Clinton told Congressmen that the U.S. demands that Syria sever
all ties with Iran.
Son of Hamas Leader was Top Spy for Israel
by Gil Ronen /Arutz Sheva
Mosab Hassan Yousef, son of jailed Hamas terrorist leader Sheikh Hassan
Yousef, operated undercover in the service of Israel's intelligence
agency for a decade. Yousef reveals this information in an upcoming
book, and in an interview with Israeli newspaper Haaretz to be published
this weekend.
According to the newspaper, the intelligence Yousef supplied led to the
arrests of several high-ranking terrorists including Ibrahim Hamid, a
Hamas terror commander in Judea and Samaria, as well as Fatah strongman
Marwan Barghouti and Hamas bomb-maker Abdullah Barghouti.
Mosab Hassan Yousef converted to Christianity and moved to the U.S. in
2007, where the book he co-wrote, Son of Hamas, is due to be published
shortly. He said that after he converted to Christianity, he decided he
had to escape and "live my life away from violence, because I couldn't
coexist with that situation as a Christian."
"He provided very important information [as did] hundreds of others
fighting against terror," MK Gideon Ezra (Kadima), formerly deputy chief
of the Israel Security Agency (Shin Bet), told BBC World Service.
Haaretz said that Yousef “was considered Shin Bet's most reliable source
in the Hamas leadership.”
"The amazing thing is that none of his actions were done for money,"
said his ISA handler, who is named in the book as "Captain Loai.”
Yousef's father, who has great influence within Hamas, was elected to
the Palestinian Legislative Council in January 2006 from his prison
cell.
Appalled by Torture
Yousef has said that from an early age he was appalled by the brutality
of the Hamas movement. "Hamas, they are using civilians' lives, they are
using children, they are using the suffering of people every day to
achieve their goals. And this is what I hate," he said.
In an interview with Fox News in 2008, Yousef said that when he was 18
years old, he was arrested and placed in an Israeli jail. “Hamas had
control of its members inside the jail and I saw their torture; [they
were] torturing people in a very, very bad way... Hamas leaders that we
see on TV now, and big leaders, [were] responsible for torturing their
own members. They didn't torture me, but that was a shock for me, to see
them torturing people: putting needles under their nails, burning their
bodies. And they killed lots of them... I was a witness for about a year
for this torture. So that was a huge change in my life.”"Islam is the
Problem"“The problem is not Hamas, the problem is not people. The root
of the problem is Islam itself as an idea,” he added. He said he saw no
chance for Israel and the PA to make peace.
Is Bellemare slowly preparing to bail out?
By Michael Young
Commentary by
Thursday, February 25, 2010
An interesting news item has appeared lately in several Arabic
newspapers, including the local Al-Liwaa. Reports, citing Lebanese
judicial sources, suggest that the prosecutor of the Special Tribunal
for Lebanon, Daniel Bellemare, will soon instruct his Beirut office to
issue legal orders to interview “Lebanese personalities,” whose
testimonies he can use to build up indictments. Bellemare will
supposedly ask the Lebanese to select 300 soldiers to implement the
summons orders.
The story has not been confirmed by Bellemare’s office, so it’s right to
be careful. However, the story makes rather more sense than all those
other leaks about the tribunal’s work, and this for several reasons: It
was always viewed as a distinct possibility by observers that Bellemare
might hold a round of interviews in the interim before issuing
indictments, if indeed indictments ever come. And an analysis of the
tribunal’s work indicates why such a course of action might be
necessary.
We can assume that Bellemare does not have enough to indict anyone
today, otherwise he would have already issued indictments. Nor does his
legal strategy appear to be a factor in the delay. Had Bellemare been
near to issuing indictments, it is highly doubtful that his chief
investigator, Naguib Kaldas, and the tribunal’s registrar, David
Tolbert, would have announced that they were leaving at the end of this
month.
If Bellemare does not have enough to indict, that means he is still
pursuing an investigation to gather the information required to draft
accusations that can hold up in court. There are essentially two sorts
of information the prosecutor must rely upon: old information that he
and his predecessors assembled during their years of work; and
information that Bellemare’s investigators must pull together starting
now. However, unless we missed something, there appears to be no police
investigation taking place today in Lebanon, or anywhere else for that
matter. The staff in the Beirut office has been drastically reduced,
with most investigators having either been released or living in The
Netherlands.
It follows from this that Bellemare and his team are relying on what
United Nations investigators collected previously, including
testimonies, telecommunications intercepts, forensic evidence, and so
on. But if the prosecutor still remains unable to build indictments on
the basis of that information five years after the assassination of
Rafik Hariri, it is probably a safe bet to argue that he desperately
needs new material. No one doubts that Bellemare knows who committed the
crime, and the particulars of how it was carried out. But that’s not
necessarily enough to indict, which requires testimony based on fresh
leads, arrests, and, most important, suspects willing to point the
finger at other suspects.
In that context, the reports that Bellemare intends to bring witnesses
in make more sense. Aside from the practical fact that such an
undertaking creates the impression that the prosecutor is doing
something amid growing doubts that the UN investigation has advanced
since 2006, it would serve three other crucial purposes.
First, it might allow Bellemare to supplement his apparently thin
testimony files, particularly when it comes to Lebanese participation in
the Hariri assassination. Still, it doesn’t seem especially probable
that the prosecutor will get much more out of such a process than he and
his predecessors did from questioning witnesses earlier, unless he plans
to question new witnesses. That seems to be the real point of the
exercise.
Which leads us to the second purpose. There are unconfirmed reports that
Bellemare has had trouble bringing in witnesses during the past year to
give testimony, because they have refused his summons. The story is that
the prosecutor asked the Lebanese authorities to assist him, but given
the nature of the parties he sought to question, the authorities replied
there was little they could do to help. If that is correct, a new round
of summons may just be a way of putting the Lebanese on the spot and
compelling them to take on their responsibilities in the investigation.
Which leads us to the third purpose. If the Lebanese do not bring in the
witnesses whom Bellemare asks them to bring in, or even some key figures
among them, this could provide the prosecutor with a pretext to announce
that he does not have enough in hand to bring indictments. The blame,
however, would fall on the Lebanese, not on Bellemare and the United
Nations. Lebanese officials should be aware of the prospect for such a
scenario, and probably are. Which is why you have to wonder whether the
judicial sources who leaked about Bellemare’s alleged scheme did so to
derail it – or to shift the onus onto his shoulders.
Whatever the answer, if Bellemare does call in new witnesses, this will
be more a maneuver on his part than anything else. At this late stage
the prosecutor knows very well who will offer testimony and who will
refuse to do so. And he knows this because he spent a year as
commissioner of the UN investigating team before becoming prosecutor. If
he forces the issue now, his primary objective would be to justify his
own failure.
In recent weeks, the former justice minister, Charles Rizk, has appeared
on television talk shows to discuss the Hariri investigation, which took
place largely during his days in office. Though Rizk expressed optimism
about the outcome of the investigation, that was merely a gloss over his
pointed criticism directed against the work of Bellemare and his
predecessor Serge Brammertz. Rizk’s main beef was that the two men had
placed the burden of detaining suspects, above all the four generals, on
the Lebanese judiciary, without having enough proof to validate this.Charles Rizk is both intelligent and experienced. His statements may
indicate that, somewhere, he is beginning to smell a rat, and doesn’t
want to be made the fall guy for the poor work of the UN commission. If
Bellemare is preparing to shift the blame onto the Lebanese for the
absence of indictments, Rizk perhaps decided to beat him to the punch.
You really have to wonder if the tribunal can still be effective in this
atmosphere.
*Michael Young is opinion editor of THE DAILY STAR.
Resistance culture
February 25, 2010
Now Lebanon/Hezbollah supporters during a rally to celebrate the
Resistance culture is apparently back in vogue. And with 2010 already
awash with rumors of a new conflict between Hezbollah and Israel, it is
a climate that is allowing Lebanon’s more hawkish leaders to give vent
to their fury. Hezbollah Secretary General Hassan Nasrallah set the tone
last week, when he warned Israel that any attack on Lebanese
infrastructure – he gave Beirut’s Rafik Hariri International airport as
an example – would be met with a mirrored response. You bomb our
airport, we’ll bomb yours.
Nasrallah’s thundering sermon, and the by-now famous antics of the
alleged Israeli hit squad in Dubai, inspired his No. 2 , Naim Qassem, to
launch a holier-than-thou sermon on Israel’s violations of international
law. This was more amusing than anything else, because of course
Hezbollah would never resort to using falsified documents on any of its
missions. Qassem segued neatly back into familiar territory by
reinforcing the Resistance credo, declaring that “what was taken by the
force of occupation can only be regained by the force of the
Resistance.” It’s a familiar tune.
Still, not to be outdone, the Change and Reform bloc has been
reinforcing its own credentials. On Wednesday, MP Fadi al-Aawar accused
Lebanese Forces leader Samir Geagea of not having “Resistance culture”.
Geagea’s shortcoming was, according to Aawar, exposed during his Monday
press conference when he had the nerve to suggest that that perhaps
Nasrallah’s bellicose warnings were unwise in the current climate and
that any conflict he provoked would threaten the entire country.
Geagea has always been a controversial figure. His war record is no
better or no worse than many of Lebanon’s senior politicians still in
office, and, as his supporters will tell you ad nauseam, whatever
“crimes” he was found guilty of, he has paid his debt to society. If any
ideals of the March 14 movement still remain intact, we have Geagea to
thank. On February 14, when many of his colleagues chose to talk of Arab
solidarity, his speech could be summed up in six words: the state the
state the state.
So bearing this in mind, we can hardly blame Geagea for not giving
Nasrallah a standing ovation. Anyone who believes in the concept of the
state would be appalled at such confrontational taunts delivered by a
man who holds no public office and whose last attempts at shaping
foreign policy led to the deaths of over 1,000 people, mostly civilians,
the displacement of over 1 million others and billions of dollars of
damage.
What Nasrallah, Qassem, Aawar and all those who promote Resistance
culture fail to see – or can see, but don’t care – is that today Lebanon
will never move forward while Hezbollah’s armed wing squares off against
Israel; that Lebanon will never achieve a sense of genuine statehood as
long as an armed militia, arguably the most effective fighting force in
the Middle East, operates outside the state of which it claims to be
part; and that Lebanon will never experience real peace as long as this
militia exists to implement a regional agenda set by Iran and managed by
Syria.
Israel is not Sweden. The Lebanese do not need to watch CNN to know how
ruthless it can be to ensure its own security. On Thursday, Israel
conducted more over flights in the South. These are violations of
international law, but Lebanon will never be able to mount a focused
defense of its own sovereign interests as long as the waters are muddied
by the Hezbollah factor.
Whether we like it or not, as long as Hezbollah is deployed along
Lebanon’s southern border, Israel will always be twitchy. It can claim
to the international community that its borders are targeted by a
non-state actor, and they would be right.
Bottom line: Hezbollah’s armed wing has no place in modern Lebanon. Nor,
for that matter, does Resistance culture.
Clinton Says Washington Urging Syria to End
Interference in Lebanon, Transfer of Arms to Hizbullah
Naharnet/U.S. Secretary of State Hillary Clinton said Wednesday the
United States is urging Syria to distance itself from Iran as well as to
stop arming Hizbullah and interfering in Lebanon.
In disclosing U.S. demands for engagement with Syria, Clinton was
blunter than ever about Washington's bid to drive a wedge between
Damascus and Tehran.
Clinton's remarks during a Senate budget debate come as Syria announced
that Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad will visit Damascus on
Thursday for talks with Syrian counterpart Bashar al-Assad. Speaking to
senators, Clinton presented a set of demands that Washington is making
to Syria now that a U.S. ambassador is returning to Damascus for the
first time in five years under President Barack Obama's policy of
engagement. She said William Burns, the number three diplomat at the
State Department, "had very intense, substantive talks in Damascus" when
he visited there last week. "And we've laid out for the Syrians the need
for greater cooperation with respect to Iraq, the end to interference in
Lebanon and the ... provision of weapons to Hizbullah, a resumption of
the Israeli-Syrian track...," she said. Clinton said Washington is also
asking Syria to "generally to begin to move away from the relationship
with Iran, which is so deeply troubling to the region as well as to the
United States." The United States accuses Syria and Iran of supporting
armed groups in the region, including Hizbullah and Hamas.
It also accuses Syria of turning a blind eye to militants crossing its
border into Iraq. Clinton also said she would study a senator's proposal
to consider ways to invite Syrian leader Assad and Israeli Prime
Minister Benjamin Netanyahu to the White House in a bid to break the
stalemate in talks between the two countries. "I certainly will look at
anything that might break the stalemate. I'm not sure that would be
acceptable or do-able to all the parties involved," Clinton told the
senator Arlen Specter. She repeated that the goal is to restart the
formerly Turkish-brokered talks that Syria suspended after Israel
launched its war on the Gaza Strip in December 2008. Obama last week
announced that Robert Ford will be the first U.S. ambassador to Damascus
since Washington recalled its envoy after Lebanon's former prime
minister Rafik Hariri was killed in February 2005 in a bombing widely
blamed on Syria. The move is part of the Obama administration's
year-long campaign to engage a former U.S. foe and energize its thwarted
push for a broad Arab-Israeli peace, particularly between Israel and the
Palestinians.(Naharnet-AFP) Beirut, 24 Feb 10, 19:34
Lebanon Seeking Death Penalty for Alleged Spies for Israel
A Lebanese military prosecutor has called for two men to be sentenced to
death for allegedly spying for Israel, a judicial source said.
A sentence of 15 years hard labor is being sought for a third person,
who is accused of having been in contact with Israel following the 2006
summer war between the Jewish state and Hizbullah. The source said the
names of the three could not be divulged. One of the two alleged spies
is a fugitive, and presumably living in Israel. The other was arrested
last June amid dozens of detentions, and the third person is also in
custody. The two alleged spies are suspected of having "given to the
enemy intelligence on Hizbullah positions." Last week, a retired member
of Lebanon's Internal Security Forces was sentenced to death for having
spied for Israel and for his involvement in the murder of two
Palestinian militant leaders. Mahmoud Qassem Rafeh, 63, was convicted of
"collaboration and espionage on behalf of the Israeli enemy," according
to the verdict handed down by a military tribunal. He was also convicted
of involvement in the 2006 car bomb murder in the southern coastal town
of Sidon of brothers Mahmoud and Nidal Mazjoub, members of the Islamic
Jihad group. More than 70 people were arrested in Lebanon in 2009 in a
crackdown on espionage rings, including a retired general and a
policeman. Lebanon and Israel remain in a state of war, and convicted
spies face life in prison with hard labor or the death penalty if found
guilty of contributing to Lebanese loss of life.(AFP) Beirut, 25 Feb 10,
07:09
Assad Snaps Back at Clinton, Ahmadinejad Says Region's Peoples,
Including Lebanese, will Stand against Israel
Naharnet/Syrian President Bashar Assad said Thursday that support for
the resistance was a 'moral and legal' duty and expressed 'surprise' at
U.S. Secretary of State Hillary Clinton's call for Syria to distance
itself from Iran. "We thank them (the Americans) for their advice,"
Assad said during a joint news conference with his Iranian counterpart
Mahmoud Ahmadinejad in Damascus. "I am surprised by their call to keep a
distance between the countries ... when they raise the issue of
stability and peace in the Middle East," Assad said. The region's people
should be ready for any Israeli attack, the Syrian president told
reporters. The Iranian president, in his turn, said Arab countries will
usher in a new Middle East "without Zionists and without colonialists."
He said that "if the Zionist regime wants to repeat its past mistakes,
this will constitute its demise and annihilation." Ahmadinejad said the
region's peoples, including the Lebanese, will stand against Israel. The
U.S. should pack up and leave the Middle East and stay out of regional
affairs, Iran's president added. Ahmadinejad's trip to Damascus follows
a string of U.S. efforts to break up Syria's 30-year alliance with
Tehran. Beirut, 25 Feb 10, 12:08
Peres Rules out War with Hizbullah
Naharnet/Israeli President Shimon Peres on Thursday ruled out war with
Hizbullah and accused the Shiite group of "preventing Lebanon from
becoming the Switzerland of the Middle East."
Speaking before high school students in the northern city of Hatzor
Haglilit, Peres also accused Hizbullah of preventing Lebanese unity.
"Hizbullah has changed from a religious movement into a military wing.
It has changed from a Lebanese organization into an Iranian agent," he
said. "Israel has upheld the U.N. resolution (1701) in its entirety, and
returned to Lebanon all of the territories belonging to it. Those who
have destroyed and continue to destroy and prevent union are Hizbullah,"
the Israeli president said. Referring to Iran, he expressed hope that "Hizbullah
would stop cherishing "the gods of missiles and begin praying to the god
of peace."
Beirut, 25 Feb 10, 14:27
Medvedev Calls for Full Implementation of 1701, Rejects Interference in
Lebanese Affairs
Naharnet/Russian President Dmitry Medvedev called on Thursday for the
full implementation of U.N. Security Council resolution 1701 and vowed
coordination with Lebanese authorities to fight terrorism. "I told the
Lebanese president that Russia always called for preserving Lebanon's
sovereignty. Interference in its internal affairs is unacceptable. The
Lebanese should themselves solve their problems," Medvedev said during a
joint press conference with his Lebanese counterpart Michel Suleiman in
Moscow. Moscow "calls for the full implementation of 1701 and UNIFIL's
jurisdiction in Lebanon," the Russian president said. "It is necessary
to reach comprehensive peace in the Middle East and set up a Palestinian
state."
He called for "fighting international terrorism" saying that Lebanon and
Russia have already faced such a danger. "We will continue to cooperate
to combat" terror, Medvedev said.
Suleiman, in his turn, described his trip to Moscow as "historic"
because it is the first official visit of a Lebanese head of state since
the independence.
Lebanon is abiding by the implementation of 1701 and is working on
forcing Israel to implement it, he told reporters. Suleiman said he
discussed with Medvedev continued Israeli violations of Lebanese
sovereignty and threats to Lebanon, its institutions and infrastructure.
"We agreed to consolidate cooperation and coordination between our
missions in world organizations after Lebanon was elected non-permanent
member in the Security Council," Suleiman said. The Lebanese and Russian
sides also discussed the signing of a military and technical cooperation
between the two countries "in an effort to achieve long-term
cooperation," the Lebanese president said. "It is a framework agreement
and is planned to be signed in the near future," said head of Russia's
military-technical cooperation agency, Mikhail Dmitriyev, according to
the ITAR-TASS news agency. However, there was no mention of past
promises by Russia to deliver 10 MiG-29 fighter jets as a gift for the
Lebanese military, an issue that had been discussed by the countries'
defense ministers in December. Under the plan, the fighter jets would be
modernized before delivery and the transport of the jets would be paid
for by the Russian defense ministry.(Naharnet-AFP) Beirut, 25 Feb 10,
15:00
Chamoun: Aoun, Jumblat Became Pillars of Syrian Regime
Naharnet/National Liberal Party leader Dori Chamoun on Thursday strongly
criticized both Druze leader Walid Jumblat and Free Patriotic Movement
chief Michel Aoun, calling them "pillars" of the Syrian government. Aoun
and Jumblat "have become pillars of the Syrian regime," Chamoun said in
an interview with the weekly Al-Masira magazine.
He believed Jumblat should quit representing the nation and called on
him to give up his Lebanese identity so long as he rejects the slogan
"Lebanon first."Chamoun also criticized Aoun's visit to the Shouf
Mountains, calling it a "failure." "Jumblat wanted through openness to
Aoun to create a balance with the Christians of March 14 forces,"
Chamoun thought.
He said Aoun considers himself "Saint Maroun the Second," adding that
the FPM leader sought to visit the Chamoun family cemetery "not in honr
of President Camille Chamoun, but is search of popularity." Beirut, 25
Feb 10, 14:13
Syria Resents Hariri's Remarks, Demands Explanation
that Prompted Saudi Intervention
Naharnet/A new crisis loomed between Prime Minister Saad Hariri and
Syrian President Bashar Assad after recent remarks made by Hariri in
which he compared Lebanese-Syrian relations with those that prevailed
during Saddam Hussein's era between Iraq and Kuwait. Hariri said Syria
had rejected diplomatic ties with Lebanon. "Syrian behavior was similar
to the one that existed between Iraq and Kuwait when former President
Saddam Hussein refused to recognize Kuwait," Hariri said in a recent
interview with the Italian newspaper Corriere della Sera. Syria has
reportedly expressed dismay about Hariri's remarks. Damascus'
criticism indicated the start of a confidence crisis, the first since
Hariri's visit to Syria last Dec. 19 ties frozen after the 2005
assassination of his father, ex-PM Rafik Hariri. Syria has had strained
ties with both France and the United States since Hariri's assassination
in a massive Beirut car bombing. Lebanon accused Syria of orchestrating
the attack, one of a string targeting its critics in Lebanon. Syria
repeatedly denied the charge but two months later withdrew its troops
from Lebanon, ending three decades of domination of its small neighbor.
Damascus is seeking clarification from Hariri which considered his
remarks "insult" to both Lebanon and Syria. The daily As-Safir on
Thursday quoted well-informed Lebanese sources as saying that what has
been expressed by the Syrian press came a day after a telephone
conversation between Assad and Hariri in which the Syrian president
admonished Hariri for his "verbal expressions that do not help to create
a new atmosphere in relations between the two countries."
The sources said high-level contacts between Saudi Arabia and Syria have
recently been undertaken in this regard.
They said Riyadh was in the picture of Hariri's decision to visit Syria
for a second time before end of February. However, no follow-up efforts
have been taken by the Lebanese side in this regard for unknown reasons,
As-Safir said. The Syrian newspaper Al-Watan had quoted high-ranking
Syrian sources as expressing dismay about Hariri's remarks published in
Corriere della Sera last Sunday.The Syrian sources said that history and
facts reveal that the late President Hafez al-Assad recognized Lebanon
since the seventies, "but no one in Lebanon requested diplomatic
relations with Syria in a formal or an informal way."They said the first
to demand diplomatic ties between the two countries was Bashar Assad
during a 2005 meeting of the Syrian-Lebanese Higher Council that was
attended by the then President Emile Lahoud, Speaker Nabih Berri and
former PM Omar Karami. Beirut, 25 Feb 10, 08:21
Jwayya Concerned over Continuing Spiral of Burning Homes, Cars
Naharnet/Unknown assailants on Thursday set ablaze a Toyota van that
belongs to Abbas Fahs in the southern village of Jwayya. Police arrived
at the scene and launched an investigation.
The house of Akram Nehmeh Fawwaz was also set on fire late Wednesday.
The attacks were part of a series of assaults against Jwayya houses and
shops for the past two months. Beirut, 25 Feb 10, 11:07
Jezzine Rages over FPM's Aswad Anti-Municipal
Remarks
Naharnet/Angry residents of Jezzine blocked overnight the main road to
their southern town with burning tires to protest remarks by Free
Patriotic Movement MP Ziad Aswad.
Local media said residents loyal to former MP Samir Azar set tires
ablaze outside the Municipal Palace building after having roamed the
streets in protest. Aswad had attacked Azar as well as head of the
Jezzine Municipality, accusing them of corruption and violating the law
by selling property that belongs to the town hall.
Aswad also pointed to the breaches committed at Jezzine hospital and
said he possessed documents that verify his claims. Beirut, 25 Feb 10,
13:02
Rayess Denies Jumblat Went to Turkey Seeking
Mediation for Damascus Trip
Naharnet/Progressive Socialist Party Media Officer Rami Rayess on
Wednesday denied that MP Walid Jumblat's visit to Turkey aims at seeking
a Turkish mediation for visiting Syria, adding that "the political
aspect of the Damascus visit has been accomplished pending the practical
aspect."Rayess called for making use of the Turkish dynamism on the
regional level as he stressed that "the date of Jumblat's visit to
Damascus would be officially announced." He reiterated PSP's "stance
that refuses to shift from centrism toward any new position."
As to Kamal Jumblat's 33rd assassination anniversary, Rayess clarified
that "Jumblat will state 'serious' remarks on this occasion." On the
other hand, Rayess stressed that PSP "is not against proportional
representation as an idea," warning against adopting it in the upcoming
municipal elections "where it could face some executive difficulties
such as equal Christian-Muslim powersharing in Beirut and the local
division among families in some towns." Beirut, 24 Feb 10, 18:33
The Iranians are all over Iraq, and everywhere in between
By David Ignatius /Daily Star
Commentary by
Thursday, February 25, 2010
Iran is conducting what US officials say is a broad covert-action
campaign to influence Iraq’s elections next month, pumping money and
other assistance to its allies. The best way to counter this assault,
American officials have decided, is by exposing it publicly.
The most direct criticism of Iran’s meddling has come from General Ray
Odierno, the commander of US forces in Iraq. In meetings with reporters
during a visit to Washington last week, he focused on the role played by
Ahmad Chalabi, an Iraqi who lobbied the Bush administration to invade
Iraq in 2003 and is now alleged to be working closely with the Iranian
Revolutionary Guard Corps (IRGC).
Odierno has also briefed top Iraqi leaders in Baghdad on US intelligence
reports about the Iranian campaign. A source provided me with an
unclassified summary of Odierno’s briefing, which included the following
allegations:
“Iran provides money, campaign materials, and political training to
various individual candidates and political parties [in Iraq].
“Iran interferes in Iraq’s political process, urging alliances that not
all Iraqi politicians favor, in an effort to consolidate power among
parties supported by Iran. For example … Ahmad Chalabi met with IRGC
Quds Force Commander Qassem Soleimani and Iranian Foreign Minister [Manouchehr]
Mottaki in late November to discuss” merger of two slates of Shiite
candidates backed by Iran. “Iran supports de-Baathification efforts
engineered by Ahmad Chalabi for the purpose eliminating potential
obstacles to Iranian influence. Chalabi is also interested in Iran’s
assistance in securing the office of prime minister.
“According to all-source intelligence, Ahmad Chalabi visited Iran at
least three times since last year. Additionally, he met with key Iranian
leaders in Iraq on at least five occasions.”
The decision to release this sort of intelligence information is
unusual, and it reflects concern across the United States government
about Iran’s push to shape the March 7 Iraqi balloting. The US has
“information operations” and other activities in Iraq to counter the
Iranians, but apparently it has not mounted a full-scale covert-action
campaign of its own, in part because of a desire not to manipulate a
democracy that America helped create.
“To covertly go after Iran, we’re too late,” says a top US official.
“What we can do is expose.”
Chalabi, reached by e-mail, denied Odierno’s allegations that he was
acting as an Iranian agent: “These accusations resurface every time we
take a course of action that is contrary to the political agenda of the
US … However, we forgive General Odierno because he captured Saddam
[Hussein].”
Iran’s operations in Iraq are directed by Soleimani, who is described by
people who have met him as a brilliant, soft-spoken Persian version of
John le Carre’s master spy, Karla. He is backed by his deputy for Iraq,
known as Abu Mehdi Mohandes, who US officials say was involved in the
bombing of the US embassy in Kuwait in 1983.
The Iranians allegedly are pumping $9 million a month in covert aid to
the Islamic Supreme Council of Iraq, a Shiite party that has the most
seats in the Iraqi Parliament, and $8 million a month to the militant
Shiite movement headed by Moqtada al-Sadr.
The current Iraqi prime minister, Nuri al-Maliki, is said to play a
delicate balancing game with Iran, opposing some of its moves and
acceding to others. According to US intelligence reports, a member of
Maliki’s staff personally hand-delivers sensitive documents from Tehran,
thereby avoiding electronic communications that might be intercepted.
For the Iranians, maintaining a compliant government in Baghdad is a
crucial matter of national security, especially for the generation that
survived the Iraq-Iran war of the 1980s. Tehran is still settling scores
for that conflict. According to US intelligence reports, the Iranians
two months ago circulated a list of 600 Iraqi officers who are targeted
for assassination because of their role in the Iraq-Iran war. Asked what
the US was doing to counter these killings, a commander responded: “We
notify people who are on the list.”
“The Iranians are everywhere, all over the place – overtly, covertly,
you name it,” says a White House official who closely monitors Iraq.
“They’re putting chips on red and black and whatever is in between.”
The best check against these Iranian machinations, US officials believe,
is the simple patriotism of the Iraqi people. Opinion polls show that
Iran is even more mistrusted by Iraqis than is America. Iranian meddling
has backfired in the past, officials say, and they are hoping that will
happen again when Iraqis go to the polls.
**Syndicated columnist David Ignatius is published regularly by THE
DAILY STAR.
Iranian
president in Syria to discuss 'Zionist threats'
Prior to his arrival in Damascus, Ahmadinejad says Iran, Syria 'at the forefront
of resistance to Zionist regime'
Dudi Cohen Published: 02.25.10, 09:53 / Israel News
Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad arrived in Damascus Thursday morning for
talks amid rising tensions between Israel and its Arab neighbors and US efforts
to break up Syria' alliance with Tehran. During his visit, Ahmadinejad is
expected to meet his Syrian counterpart Bashar Assad as well as officials from
the terror groups Hamas and Hezbollah.
Ahmadinejad said the talks will focus on "reaching new decisions on the possible
threats" from Israel, adding that Iran and Syria "stand at the forefront of the
resistance to the Zionist regime."
Speaking at the airport in Tehran before leaving for Syria, the Iranian leader
said, "The Zionist regime and its supporters in the region are quickly
approaching a dead end. The situation whereby the Zionists continually threaten
countries near occupied Palestine makes it necessary for Iran and Syria to reach
new decisions to deal with the possible threats from the Zionist regime."
Ahmadinejad's visit comes as the US announced the nomination of a career
diplomat to become the first US ambassador to Damascus since 2005 and lifted an
advisory on security concerns in Syria. Washington's overtures to Syria, Iran's
closest ally in the Arab world, coincide with rising US tension with Tehran.
About two weeks ago Ahmadinejad said during a telephone conversation with Assad
that Israel should be resisted and finished off if it launched military action
in the region.
"We have reliable information ... that the Zionist regime is after finding a way
to compensate for its ridiculous defeats from the people of Gaza and Lebanon's
Hezbollah," he told the Syrian leader. "If the Zionist regime should repeat its
mistakes and initiate a military operation, then it must be resisted with full
force to put an end to it once and for all," Ahmadinejad said.
Reuters and AP contributed to the report
Peres: Hezbollah preventing Lebanon from becoming Mideast Switzerland
Published: 02.25.10, 10:57 /
Israel News /President Shimon Peres said Hezbollah was "preventing Lebanon from
becoming the Switzerland of the Middle East". "Hezbollah has changed from a
religious movement into a military wing. It has changed from a Lebanese
organization into an Iranian agent. The State of Israel has upheld the UN
resolution in its entirety, and returned to Lebanon all of the territory
belonging to it. Those who have destroyed and continue to destroy and prevent
union are Hezbollah," Peres told high school students in the north. (Hagai Einav)
Iran: New Middle East won't include Zionists
In Damascus, Ahmadinejad says 'Zionist regime will be annihilated if it repeats
past mistakes'. Assad: Israeli threats aimed at boosting citizens' morale after
series of defeats
Roee Nahmias Published: 02.25.10, 12:21 / Israel News
Arab nations will usher in a new Middle East "without Zionists and without
colonialists," Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad said Thursday.
Ahmadinejad spoke Thursday during a trip to Syria. The trip follows a string of
US efforts to break up Syria's 30-year alliance with Tehran.
Opinion
The decisive factor / Ronen Bergman
Shoah memory will prompt Israel to strike Iran should all else fail
He said that "if the Zionist regime wants to repeat its past mistakes, this will
bring about its demise and annihilation."
Ahmadinejad said Iran, Syria, Iraq and Lebanon will stand against Israel.
Syrian President Bashar Assad addressed the recent Israeli threats, saying, "We
believe we are facing an entity that is capable of aggression at any point, and
we are preparing ourselves for any Israeli aggression, be it on a small or large
scale. "We must be prepared for any Israeli response, under any pretext," said
the Syrian leader. "Israel is directing its threats at Syria and the resistance
movement (terror groups). The threats are also aimed at boosting the Israeli
citizens' morale after a series of defeats." During the joint press conference
with Assad, Ahmadinejad said the bond between Damascus and Tehran is strong and
that "no one can damage it." "These ties will become deeper and develop over the
years. We are brothers. We have mutual interests, as well as common goals and
enemies," said the Iranian president, adding, "The world needs a new order.""The
Zionists and their protectors have reached a dead end. The Zionist entity will
eventually disappear; its existential philosophy has ended. The Zionist
conquerors have reached a dead end; all of their threats against the
Palestinians stem from their weakness. If the Zionists repeat their past
mistakes, all of the region's nations will uproot them," Ahmadinejad said.
"With Allah's help, the new Middle East will be a Middle East without Zionists
and imperialists. We hope they will recognize the rights of the region's
nations, but they must realize that if they continue along their wrongful path
they have no place in our region. Today the ties between the region's nations -
between Iran, Syria and the resistance movement - are very strong. We believe
that developments in the world will benefit Iran, Syria and the region's free
governments," he said. AP contributed to the report
Australia warns Israel over Dubai assassination
FM Stephen Smith makes it 'crystal clear' to Israeli ambassador that if Israel
sponsored use of Australian passports in Mabhouh killing 'Australia would not
regard that as the act of a friend'
Associated Press Published: 02.25.10, 08:21 / Israel News Australia warned
Israel on Thursday that if it was involved in the alleged use of three
fraudulent Australian passports in a Dubai assassination it would not be
considered the "act of a friend," the foreign minister said.
Foreign Minister Stephen Smith summoned Israel's ambassador and demanded his
cooperation in an investigation into the use of the passports in the killing of
a senior Hamas figure.
Jerusalem 'assassin': I wonder how they did it / Anat Shalev Philip Carr,
who carries British passport, recounts how he found out he was wanted in Dubai
for Hamas man's killing. 'It's a bit of a shock,' he tells Ynet. 'It's
surprising, but it's more interesting than annoying' Dubai authorities are
investigating the use of at least 26 possibly fraudulent passports in connection
with the Jan. 19 slaying of Mahmoud al-Mabhouh in a hotel room in Dubai, United
Arab Emirates.
"I made it crystal clear to the ambassador that if the results of that
investigation cause us to come to the conclusion that the abuse of the
Australian passports was in any way sponsored or condoned by Israeli officials,
then Australia would not regard that as the act of a friend," Smith told
reporters. Dubai's police chief, Lt. Gen. Dahi Khalfan Tamim, has said he was
nearly "100 percent" certain that Israel's Mossad secret service masterminded
the killing. Hamas also has blamed Israel and vowed revenge.
Israeli officials have a policy of not commenting on allegations about any of
its spy agency's activities. 'Central role in smuggling weapons'
Smith told Parliament that Dubai authorities confirmed to Australian officials
Tuesday that they were investigating the use of three Australian passports in
connection with the slaying, and that a preliminary investigation suggests they
were fraudulently duplicated or altered. "At this stage, Australian officials
have no information to suggest that the three Australian passport holders were
involved in any way, other than as victims of passport or identity fraud," Smith
said. Smith said he met with United Arab Emirates Foreign Minister Sheikh
Abdullah on Wednesday, and with Israel's Ambassador to Australia, Ambassador
Yuval Rotem, on Thursday morning, to reinforce Australia's full cooperation and
the seriousness of the matter.
Dubai police have outlined a 19-hour operation to kill al-Mabhouh, including
clockwork precision and disguises such as fake beards, wigs and tourist garb.
Israel says al-Mabhouh played a central role in smuggling weapons from Iran to
Gaza militants. The suspects using foreign passports are 12 Britons, six Irish,
four French, three Australian and one German. At least seven of the 26 passports
share names with people living in Israel, reinforcing widespread suspicion about
Mossad involvement and bringing sharp complaints from European ambassadors about
how the expertly altered passports were obtained.
Ethiopia accuses Lebanon of using plane crash incident for “politics”
Written by Administrator
Thursday, 25 February 2010 08:05
Addis Ababa - Ethiopia on Wednesday accused Lebanon of using the last month’s
plane crash investigation process for “politics”.
The Ethiopian Minister of Transport Diriba Kuma told journalists in Addis Ababa
that the Lebanese government was giving unreliable information to the media
regarding the Ethiopian Airlines plane crash on 25 January 2010 after take off
from Beirut where the 90 people on board including 24 Ethiopians, died.
Kuma urged the Lebanese authorities to stop giving such “unreliable” information
to the media regarding the plane crash investigation process.
“Though the investigation process is still underway, but the Lebanese officials
continue to give unreliable and contradictory reports to the media,” said Kuma.
He indicated that Ethiopia had asked the president of the International Civil
Aviation Organization and its secretary to intervene in these affairs.
According to him, the Ethiopian Ministry of Foreign Affairs in collaboration
with its partners continues to counter media statements being made by the
Lebanese officials.
“The organization promises to interfere in the matter and normalize the current
situation,” said Kuma. There are media reports from Beirut saying that the
preliminary investigation is showing that the plane crash was by “pilot error”.
However, Kuma told journalists that the preliminary investigation is not yet
made public, and it is expected to be released soon.
He also indicated that there was an incident during the investigation process
where the Lebanese officials were involved in hiding, and not to include useful
information for the investigation process. “Ethiopia strongly opposes the on
going move by Lebanon to use the investigation process for political affairs,”
added Kuma. There is as yet no reaction from the Lebanese authorities on the
comments made by the Ethiopian government.
Lebanese army ignored warning from Hizbollah
Mitchell Prothero, Foreign Correspondent
Last Updated: February 24. 2010 11:52PM UAE / February 24. 2010 7:52PM GMT
BEIRUT // The 2008 incident in which a Hizbollah fighter opened fire on a
Lebanese army helicopter in south Lebanon, killing the pilot, could have been
avoided if the army command had passed on repeated warnings from the resistance
group, according to officials from both the military and Hizbollah.
“Hizbollah sent repeated messages to the LAF high command warning them not to
use that area of south Lebanon for training because it was close to a sensitive
command centre used by the group,” according to one high-ranking Lebanese
officer, who under Lebanese law cannot allow his name to be used. “After three
warnings were ignored – the people who received the information did not act to
get it into the hands of the officers who needed to know that area was off
limits – a completely avoidable incident tragically took the life of an army
officer.”
The shooting occurred in August 2008 while the helicopter was practicing
take-offs and landings on uneven terrain, a specialised skill that pilots need
to develop through practise in rural areas. As the aircraft touched down in a
field outside of Tallet Sojor, a known Hizbollah stronghold, a 19-year-old
fighter heard the sound of the helicopter and later testified he also heard what
he thought were other Hizbollah positions opening fire as well.
Mustafa Hassan Moqaddam, now 20, testified last week that he left his post to
see a helicopter attempting to land. He said the helicopter was not painted in
Lebanese Armed Forces colours and that a glinting sun prevented him from seeing
a small Lebanese flag in its tail.
As Hizbollah fighters in the area had been recently put on high alert, he then
opened fire from about 300 metres away, shooting Capt Samir Hanna, the pilot,
twice, immediately killing him. Several Hizbollah military-wing commanders
contacted by The National corroborated to exacting detail both the testimony
given at the tribunal and the army officer’s claim that the army command had
been given ample warning to find another site for the training and that the
warnings were ignored.
“We told them three times in two weeks that we had installations in the area and
a few days after each warning, they would do it again,” said one commander, who
asked to be identified as Abu Hasan, as he did not have permission from
Hizbollah’s top command to speak to the media.
He cited the nature of the charges against Mr Moqaddam and the unwillingness of
the military to take any responsibility for the incident as his motivation to
break the group’s stringent rules against talking to the media about security
incidents.
“The boy [Mr Moqaddam] was doing exactly what he had been taught to do,” the
commander added. “The resistance in that area was on high alert because there
was reason to believe an Israeli operation could be planned. He saw a
helicopter, he thought he heard gunfire and he did his job. But now he must face
trial while the officers who didn’t do their jobs and warn the pilots remain
free.”
The army official agreed with the assessment of the Hizbollah commander.
“They’re trying this boy to cover their own mistake,” he said. “Who killed Capt
Hanna? The boy who did his job or the officers who didn’t do theirs?”
The officer also confirmed that the military intelligence office in South
Lebanon, which liaises with both Hizbollah and the United Nations peacekeeping
force along the border, had received three warnings before the fourth, fatal,
incident, just as the Hizbollah sources contended.
Multiple attempts to reach the defence ministry, the army high command, Prime
Minister Saad Hariri and President Michel Suleiman for comment were ignored or
unsuccessful.
Another military intelligence officer who has since retired, Col Adnan Gheith,
told the local media shortly after the incident that he had personally been told
by Hizbollah operatives that the area in question was a “closed military zone”,
which in Hizbollah parlance means not even the Lebanese army may enter it
without permission.
Taimur Goksel, who worked with the UN in southern Lebanon for nearly 30 years
and frequently co-ordinated the movements of UN peacekeepers with Hizbollah and
the LAF, described the claims made by both Hizbollah and the outraged military
officers as “more than plausible”.
“I spent more than 4,000 hours flying over southern Lebanon in helicopters and
every minute of it was terrifying because I just knew the ground below me was
filled with young, heavily armed, excitable men with various levels of
training,” he said. “So we spent major efforts making sure everyone was informed
of each other’s movements.”
Mr Goksel said that miscommunication between the LAF and Hizbollah, who more or
less tolerate each other’s presence in south Lebanon with varying degrees of
co-operation, is a constant problem for numerous reasons. “The Lebanese army is
institutionally weak but specific officers can personally be very good co-ordinating
with Hizbollah,” he said.
“The problem is that Hizbollah does not like to make its top commanders easily
reachable. So if we were moving around, I’d inform the army, and it would be
their job to tell Hizbollah, but we always followed up with our own channels
just to make sure.”
The army officer also blamed the army’s lack of proper communications equipment.
“We aren’t sophisticated enough on the subtle things, like secure communications
lines. Hizbollah has a secure fibre optic network connecting all its major
bases. We have telephones. During the [2008] siege of Nahr Bared [refugee camp],
we realised that most of our guys were using mobile phones to plan military
operations.”
Mr Goksel agrees, arguing that even if given the proper information, a Lebanese
soldier might face a choice between relaying the important information over an
unsecure line, almost certainly monitored by the Israelis, and doing nothing at
all. “Imagine a young officer learns that Hizbollah says to stay away from a
field because they have intelligence that Israel might attack it,” he said. “If
that officer only has a telephone that everyone knows the Israelis closely
monitor, he’d be committing treason to call his headquarters in Beirut to warn
them that Hizbollah thinks an Israeli attack could be coming and to get rid of
the choppers. Imagine that choice?”
mprothero@thenational.ae