LCCC
ENGLISH DAILY NEWS BULLETIN
January 11/09
Bible Reading of the
day.
Holy Gospel of Jesus Christ
according to Saint John 3,22-30. After this, Jesus and his disciples went into
the region of Judea, where he spent some time with them baptizing. John was also
baptizing in Aenon near Salim, because there was an abundance of water there,
and people came to be baptized, for John had not yet been imprisoned. Now a
dispute arose between the disciples of John and a Jew about ceremonial washings.
So they came to John and said to him, "Rabbi, the one who was with you across
the Jordan, to whom you testified, here he is baptizing and everyone is coming
to him." John answered and said, "No one can receive anything except what
has been given him from heaven. You yourselves can testify that I said
(that) I am not the Messiah, but that I was sent before him. The one who has the
bride is the bridegroom; the best man, who stands and listens for him, rejoices
greatly at the bridegroom's voice. So this joy of mine has been made complete.
He must increase; I must decrease."
Saint Augustine (354-430), Bishop of Hippo
(North Africa) and Doctor of the Church
Sermon 194, 11th sermon on the Nativity of the Lord/"This joy of mine has been
made complete"
Listen, children of light: you who have been adopted for the Kingdom of God;
listen, my dearest brethren; listen and exult for joy in the Lord, you just, for
«praise from the upright is fitting» (Ps 33,1). Listen to what you already know;
reflect on what you have heard; love what you believe; proclaim what you
love!...Christ is born, God from his Father, man through his mother. He was born
from his Father's immortality and his mother's virginity. From the Father
without the aid of a mother; from the mother without that of a father. From his
Father without time; from his mother without seed. According to his Father he is
the principle of life; according to his mother, the ending of death. According
to his Father he was born to determine the order of days; according to his
mother, to consecrate the day that is here. He sent John the Baptist before him,
causing him to be born when the days were beginning to decrease, while he
himself was born when the days began to grow in length, thus prefiguring John's
own words: «He must increase, I must decrease». For indeed, human life must grow
weaker in itself but stronger in Jesus Christ «so that those who live might no
longer live for themselves but for him who for their sake died and was raised»
(2Cor 5,15), and so that each one of us might repeat those words of the apostle
Paul: «Yet I live, no longer I, but Christ lives in me» (Gal 2,20).
Free
Opinions, Releases, letters & Special Reports
Will We Be Able to Bring Peace to
Gaza this Time?Dr. Walid Phares 10/01/09
The
responsibility to deliver-By
Ban Ki-moon 10/01/09
Latest News Reports From
Miscellaneous Sources for January 10/09
Hamas rejects international observers in Gaza-International
Herald Tribune
Abbas urges Israel to accept Gaza truce plan-guardian.co.uk
Israeli forces pound targets, draw
near Gaza City-AP
Lebanese Army, U.N. Find Weapons
Cache Near Israel Border-Naharnet
Mughniyeh's Posthumous Role in the Gaza Fighting-Naharnet
Williams Worried About Rocket Attack, U.N. Chief in Beirut on Jan. 16-Naharnet
Lebanese Fertility Expert: First British Baby Born Free of Cancer Gene-Naharnet
Larijani: Lebanon is the
Head of Resistance-Naharnet
Nassib Lahoud: Cabinet
Does Not Provide Israel With Free Assurances-Naharnet
Saniora: Lebanon is Not a
Post Box For Regional, International Messages-Naharnet
March 14 Questions Harmony
Between Military and Cabinet on Rocket Incident-Naharnet
PFLP-GC Set Up Missile
Platforms in Qossaya Directed toward Israel-Naharnet
Hizbullah Relocated
Positions … Next Battle to be Launched from Bekaa-Naharnet
Report: Hizbullah wary of another war with Israel-Ynetnews
Modeling Terrorist Group Behavior:
Hamas & Hezbollah-The
Terror Work
Will We Be Able to Bring Peace to Gaza this Time?FOXNews
Lebanese Army, UNIFIL unearth arms cache near Israeli border
(AFP)
Discussions at seminar on Gaza war fail to break new ground-Daily
Star
Hizbullah didn't launch rockets,
but didn't stop them either - analysts-(AFP)
Gaza war echoes much of Lebanon in 2006-Daily
Star
Lebanese media show united front on Gaza atrocities-Daily
Star
Beirut receives bids to run cellular grids for one year-Daily
Star
Israel tells Gazans to brace
for war escalation
By Ibrahim Barzak And Josef Federman, The Associated Press
GAZA CITY, Gaza Strip - Israeli forces pounded rocket-launching sites and
smuggling tunnels in the Gaza Strip on Saturday and planes dropped leaflets
warning of an escalation in attacks, as Palestinian militants fired at least 15
more rockets at Israel. Egypt hosted talks aimed at ending the violence. Flames
and smoke rose over Gaza City amid the heavy fighting. The Israeli threat to
launch a "new phase" in its two-week-old offensive that has already killed more
than 800 Palestinians came in defiance of international calls for a ceasefire.
Thirteen Israelis have died; nine were soldiers killed in Gaza and four,
including one soldier, were killed by rocket attacks on Israel.
"The IDF (Israeli Defence Forces) will escalate the operation in the Gaza
Strip," the leaflets said in Arabic.
"The IDF is not working against the people of Gaza but against Hamas and the
terrorists only. Stay safe by following our orders."
The leaflets urged Gaza residents not to help Hamas, the Islamic militant group
that rules Gaza and to stay away from its members. Israel launched the offensive
Dec. 27 to halt years of Palestinian rocket attacks on southern Israel. A week
later, ground troops moved in. The dropping of the leaflets appeared to be
partly a psychological tactic. Israeli defence officials say they are prepared
for a third stage of the offensive, in which ground troops would push much
further into Gaza but are still waiting for approval from the government. The
officials, speaking on condition of anonymity because they were discussing
classified information, said the army also has a fourth stage planned that calls
for a full reoccupation of Gaza and toppling of Hamas.
The Israeli military said more than 15 militants were killed in overnight
fighting. It said aircraft attacked more than 40 targets including 10
rocket-launching sites, weapons-storage facilities, smuggling tunnels, an
anti-aircraft missile launcher and gunmen. In the day's bloodiest incident, an
Israeli tank shell killed nine people in a garden outside a home in the northern
Gaza town Jebaliya, said Adham el-Hakim, administrator of Kamal Adwan hospital.
The Israeli military disputed the account, saying its forces did not carry out
attacks in that area Saturday.
Israel has come under international criticism for the rising number of civilian
casualties. Palestinian paramedics said the nine people killed in the garden
were from the same clan and included two children and two women. Residents
brought them to the hospital in a civilian car. They put them all in the trunk
because their bodies were mangled," Hakim said. Separately, a woman was killed
by tank fire in the nearby town Beit Lahiya. The Israeli army has repeatedly
accused Hamas of using civilians as human shields and launching attacks from
schools, mosques and homes. Earlier this week, an Israeli attack outside a UN
school killed nearly 40 people. Both Israel and Palestinian witnesses said
militants carried out an attack from the area moments earlier.
Palestinian medical officials say roughly one-half of the more than 800
Palestinians who have been killed were civilians.
Five Israeli soldiers were lightly wounded in Saturday's fighting. Israel and
Hamas ignored a UN resolution passed Thursday calling for an immediate and
durable ceasefire that would lead to the withdrawal of Israeli troops from Gaza.
Israel has dismissed the Security Council resolution as impractical, while
Hamas, whose government in Gaza is not recognized internationally, is angry it
was not consulted in the diplomatic efforts. In Cairo, Egypt, the Palestinian
Authority president urged both Israel and Hamas to agree to an Egypt-brokered
truce Saturday. After meeting Egyptian President Hosni Mubarak, Mahmoud Abbas
stressed there was no time to waste in ending the bloodshed in Gaza, home to 1.4
million people.
"If any party does not accept it (the truce), regrettably it will be the one
bearing the responsibility and if Israel doesn't want to accept, it will take
the responsibility of perpetuating a waterfall of blood," Abbas said. Hamas
officials from both Gaza and Syria are also in Cairo for separate talks with
Egyptian officials on a truce. Israeli officials visited Cairo earlier this
week. Hamas and Abbas's Fatah party, which dominates the West Bank of the Jordan
River, are fierce political rivals but the president still claims authority over
Gaza. Hamas violently took control of the Gaza Strip in 2007. In Damascus,
Syria-based Palestinian militant groups, including Hamas, on Saturday rejected
any deployment of international observers or troops in Gaza. A statement issued
by the groups after a meeting attended by Hamas political leader Khaled Mashaal
also rejected any security arrangement that "infringes on the right of
resistance against Israeli occupation."
Palestinian security officials said some of the heaviest fighting Saturday
occurred on the strategic coastal road north of Gaza City, home to 400,000
Palestinians. Israeli forces moved to within about 1.6 kilometres of the city
before pulling back slightly.
While Israel has largely taken control of the road, militants operate from
hidden positions in the area. The road is often used to fire rockets into Israel
or attack Israeli navy boats off the Mediterranean coast. At least 15 rockets
landed in Israel on Saturday, the army said. One rocket hit an apartment
building in the southern city Ashkelon, wounding three people, one of them
seriously. The offensive has caused extensive damage throughout Gaza. The United
Nations estimates two-thirds of Gaza's 1.4 million people are without
electricity and one-half don't have running water.
The Israeli military announced a three-hour halt to operations in Gaza on
Saturday to let besieged residents leave their homes and stock up supplies.
Medics use the lull to rescue casualties and aid groups also rush through food
distribution. But for the second straight day, there were reports of continued
fighting during the lulls.
Israel has called for the three-hour breaks in fighting for the last four days.
But aid groups say it isn't enough time to do their work.
Salam Kanaan of Save the Children said in previous lulls, the agency distributed
food to 9,500 people - far short of the 150,000 people it serves.
UN official Adnan Abu Hasna said the Palestinian refugee agency would distribute
aid to about 40,000 people, one-half of them holed up in UN schools that have
been transformed into shelters. All deliveries were coming from supplies already
in Gaza. UN officials said a halt on aid shipments into Gaza through
Israeli-controlled border crossings remains in effect. The ban was imposed
Thursday after a UN truck driver was shot and killed by Israel. It was unclear
when the deliveries will resume.
"As each day goes by and for each moment that the ceasefire demanded by the
Security Council is not observed, the crisis continues," said UN spokesman Chris
Gunness. UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon spoke with Israeli Prime Minister Ehud
Olmert by phone Friday and told the prime minister he was disappointed the
violence was continuing in disregard of the resolution, Ban's office said.
Israel says any ceasefire must include assurances Hamas will halt attacks and
end the smuggling of weapons into Gaza through the porous Egyptian border.
Hamas has said it won't accept any ceasefire deal that does not include the full
opening of Gaza's border crossings. The UN resolution emphasized the need to
open all crossings, which Israel and Egypt have kept sealed since Hamas
militants forcibly seized control of the territory 18 months ago.
Israeli leaders oppose that step because it would allow Hamas to strengthen its
hold on Gaza
Makari: Palestinian Arms Are
Syrian Tools
Naharnet/Deputy Speaker Farid Makari on Saturday described Palestinian arms
outside Lebanon's refugee camps as "Syrian tools" and urged government consensus
in issues of war and peace. Makari also told Voice of Lebanon radio station it
was important to speed up the implementation of what Lebanese leaders agreed on
regarding Palestinian arms outside the camps. He lauded the government's
decision to condemn the rocket attack on northern Israel and the Jewish state's
response. The cabinet also on Thursday rejected turning south Lebanon into a
platform for launching missiles. The government's stance should be followed "by
speeding up the implementation of what the Lebanese agreed on during the first
national dialogue in 2006 regarding Palestinian arms outside refugee camps
particularly that" such weapons "continue to be used as a tool by Syria," Makari
told VDL. He said Palestinian weapons that "receive instructions from Damascus
are not in the interest of stability in Lebanon." Makari also praised the
government's reiteration that it holds onto the implementation of U.N. Security
Council Resolution 1701 that ended the war between Israel and Hizbullah in the
summer of 2006. Consensus during Thursday's session should prevail in all
"issues related to Lebanon's security and stability and decisions of war and
peace," the deputy speaker added. Beirut, 10 Jan 09, 14:15
Raad: Hizbullah Ready to Face any Israeli Stupidity
Naharnet/
Tens of thousands of people took part in a Hizbullah-organized protest in the
southern Lebanese town of Nabatiyeh on Saturday against Israel's offensive in
the Gaza Strip. Demonstrators waved yellow Hizbullah flags and Palestinian flags
as they marched through the streets of Nabatiyeh, a stronghold of the Shiite.
Women wearing the Palestinian keffiyeh scarf over black chadors carried a sign
that read "July (2006) was a walk in the park," in reference to a threat made by
Hizbullah chief Sayyed Hassan Nasrallah in an address on Wednesday. "Death to
Israel! Death to America!" the protestors yelled as others held a banner that
read "Whatever happens, Gaza, the Katyushas (rockets) are waiting." "The Israeli
aggression and invasion of Gaza will reaffirm once again the hatred the people
of Arab and Muslim regions have for the American administration that allowed the
bloodshed and supported the Israeli enemy," said the head of Hizbullah's
parliamentary bloc, Mohammed Raad. "We are ready to face any (Israeli)
stupidity," he added. Since the Israeli offensive began on December 27, at least
821 Palestinians have been killed, including 235 children, 93 women, and 12
paramedics. Another 3,350 people have been wounded, overwhelming Gaza's
beleaguered medical facilities, already weakened by an Israeli blockade of the
territory in force since Hamas seized power in June 2007.(AFP-Naharnet) Beirut,
10 Jan 09, 19:06
Berri to Istanbul Next Week to Take Part in Gaza Conference
Parliament Speaker Nabih Berri will head to Turkey next week to take part in the
Asian Parliaments' conference for the support of Gaza. Arab Parliamentary Union
called for: - A unified stance on the Israeli attacks on the Gaza Strip -
Halting all sort of negotiations with Israel - Formation of a parliamentary
delegation to tour world decision-makers and urge them to force Israel into
ending its aggression on Gaza. NNA said Berri is likely to meet senior Turkish
officials while in Istanbul. Beirut, 10 Jan 09, 17:37
Israeli forces pound targets, draw near Gaza City
AP/GAZA CITY, Gaza Strip – Israeli forces pounded dozens of targets and edged
closer to Gaza City on Saturday while southern Israel was largely spared
militant rocket fire in one of its quietest nights in the two-week offensive
against Hamas.
The Israeli military said more than 15 militants were killed in heavy fighting
Saturday with its ground forces inside Gaza. Its aircraft attacked more than 40
targets throughout Gaza, striking 10 rocket-launching sites, weapons-storage
facilities, smuggling tunnels, an anti-aircraft missile launcher and gunmen.
Flames and smoke could be seen rising into the sky over Gaza City. Palestinian
hospital officials confirmed only four deaths, but fighting has hindered
paramedics from collecting bodies and treating the wounded. Eight people were
killed by Israeli tank fire Saturday in the town of Jebailiya, Palestinian
medical officials said. The dead appeared to be civilians, paramedics on the
scene said. The Israeli army said it was investigating the incident.
Palestinian medical officials say more than 800 people have been killed in
Israel's two-week offensive against Hamas militants in Gaza. Roughly half of the
dead are believed to have been civilians. The fighting raged after both Israel
and Hamas ignored a U.N. resolution calling for an immediate and durable
cease-fire that would lead to the withdrawal of Israeli troops from Gaza.
Israel has dismissed the Security Council resolution passed Thursday as
impractical, while Hamas, whose government in Gaza is not recognized
internationally, is angry it was not consulted about the diplomatic efforts.
Some of the heaviest fighting Saturday occurred on the strategic coastal road
north of Gaza City, Palestinian security officials said. Israeli forces moved to
within about 1 mile of the city before pulling back slightly.
While Israel has largely taken control of the road, militants continue to
operate from hidden positions in the area. The road is often used to fire
rockets into Israel or attack Israeli navy boats off the Mediterranean coast.
Israel launched the offensive on Dec. 27 to halt years of Palestinian rocket
attacks on southern Israel. A week later, ground troops moved in, with artillery
and tank fire that has contributed to a surge in civilian casualties.
Palestinian medical officials say more than 800 Palestinians have been killed,
roughly half of them civilians. Thirteen Israelis have been killed — four of
them by militant rockets, the rest in battle in Gaza. Five soldiers were lightly
wounded in Saturday's fighting.
In a possible sign of progress for the military, no rockets were fired into
Israel overnight, a sharp drop from the dozens of projectiles that were launched
in the early days of the offensive. Israeli military officials cautioned against
reading too much into the lull, and by Saturday morning, several rockets had
landed in Israel. Two struck the southern city of Ashkelon, lightly wounding two
people, authorities said. The offensive has caused extensive damage throughout
Gaza, fueling fears of an impending humanitarian crisis. The United Nations
estimates two-thirds of Gaza's 1.4 million people are without electricity, and
half don't have running water.
The Israeli military said it would halt the fire in Gaza for three hours on
Saturday to allow the territory's besieged residents to leave their homes and
stock up on supplies. Medics use the lull to rescue casualties in areas of
fighting, and aid groups also rush through food distribution.
It is the third time in recent days that Israel has suspended its offensive to
allow aid groups to work. But the groups say three hours isn't enough time.
Salam Kanaan of Save the Children said in previous lulls, for instance, the
agency distributed food to 9,500 people — far short of the 150,000 people it
serves.
U.N. official Adnan Abu Hasna said the Palestinian refugee agency would
distribute aid to about 40,000 people, half of them holed up in U.N. schools
that have been transformed into shelters. All deliveries were coming from
existing supplies already in Gaza. U.N. officials said a halt on aid shipments
into Gaza through Israeli-controlled border crossings remained in effect. The
ban was imposed Thursday after a U.N. truck driver was shot and killed by
Israel. It was unclear when the deliveries will resume.
"As each day goes by, and for each moment that the cease-fire demanded by the
Security Council is not observed, the crisis continues," said U.N. spokesman
Chris Gunness. In Israel's first official response to the U.N. resolution, Prime
Minister Ehud Olmert's office said more Hamas rockets fired Friday "only prove
that the U.N.'s decision is not practical and will not be kept in practice by
the Palestinian murder organizations."
Senior Cabinet ministers issued a statement saying the military offensive would
continue until rocket fire from the Hamas-ruled territory ends. Hamas, which
receives backing from Iran and Syria, has improved its capabilities to the point
that roughly one-eighth of Israel's 7 million citizens now live in rocket range.
U.N. Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon spoke with Olmert by phone and Friday and
told the prime minister that he was disappointed the violence was continuing in
disregard of the resolution, according to Ban's office. Hamas also dismissed the
resolution, and spokesmen expressed annoyance they were not consulted.
"Nobody consulted Hamas or talked to Hamas. Nobody put Hamas in the picture and
yet Hamas is required to accept it. This is unacceptable," Mohammed Nazzal, a
senior Hamas official based in Syria, told Al-Arabiya television. Israel says
any cease-fire must include assurances that Hamas will halt attacks and end the
smuggling of weapons into Gaza through the porous Egyptian border. Hamas has
said it won't accept any cease-fire deal that does not include the full opening
of Gaza's border crossings. The U.N. resolution emphasized the need to open all
crossings, which Israel and Egypt have kept sealed since Hamas militants
forcibly seized control of the territory 18 months ago. Israeli leaders oppose
that step because it would allow Hamas to strengthen its hold on Gaza.
The foreign minister in the Western-backed government of President Mahmoud Abbas,
which was driven out of Gaza by the rival Hamas in 2007, criticized both Israel
and Hamas for not accepting the demand for a halt to fighting.
"Both have responded to the resolution in the same way, in total disrespect,"
Riad Malki said at U.N. headquarters in New York. He said the Security Council
should enforce its resolution, perhaps by levying sanctions. The rising civilian
death toll has drawn heavy criticism of Israel from international aid groups and
triggered anger throughout the Islamic world and elsewhere. There have been
daily protests in the Middle East and in Europe, where there also has been a
rise in anti-Semitic attacks.
In Washington, Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice said it is difficult to
protect civilians in a place as densely populated as Gaza — an area just 25
miles long and roughly six miles wide. "It's also an area in which Hamas
participates in activities like human shields and using buildings that are not
designated as military buildings to hide their fighters," she told reporters.
Seven Hamas officials crossed into Egypt on Friday through the Gaza border
crossing at Rafah, on their way to Cairo for Egyptian-hosted negotiations on a
truce with Israel. The talks were expected to begin sometime Saturday following
the arrival of a Hamas delegation from Syria, including politburo members
Mohammed Nasr and Imad al-Alami.
**Barzak reported this story from Gaza City and Josef Federman from Jerusalem.
Report: Hizbullah wary of another war with Israel
Source affiliated with Shiite group says its supporters reacted negatively to
Thursday's rocket attack on north Israel, indicating they do not support fresh
aggression against Jewish state
Roee Nahmias Published: 01.09.09, 21:39 / Israel News
A source affiliated with Hizbullah told the London-based Arabic language
newspaper Asharq Al-Awsat Friday that while the Shiite group has placed its
forces on the highest alert level, it is not seeking another war with Israel.
Shiite Group
Nasrallah says Hizbullah ready to fight Israel / Roee Nahmias
'Lebanon war was just a walk in the park compared to what we have in store for
you,' Hizbullah leader says in speech Wednesday. Nasrallah also slams Mubarak
for refusing to open Rafah crossing
According to the report, as part of its heightened alert measures Hizbullah has
transferred its logistical and security headquarters from the Dahiya
neighborhood in south Beirut to the southern part of the country. In addition,
the group has ordered members of its technical units to return to Lebanon at
once.
The source said that despite these measures, the reactions among the Shiite
population in Lebanon following Thursday's rocket attack on northern Israel
indicated that they do not support a new military campaign against the Jewish
state.
Asharq Al-Awsat reported that Dahiya, a Hizbullah stronghold in Beirut that was
heavily bombarded by the Israeli Air Force during the Second Lebanon War, is
still in ruins. Only 20% of the structures that had been destroyed in the war
were rebuilt, and 80% of the neighborhood's displaced residents have yet to
return despite Hizbullah's promises, the newspaper added.
Therefore, a Hizbullah attack on Israel may be viewed by its supporters as a
reckless move and hurt its popularity in Lebanon. A new war may also affect
Iran's status in the country, which is of great importance to Hizbullah.
According to the source, Hizbullah would launch a war against Israel only if
Iran decides to enter a regional war of its own. He said that in case fighting
does erupt, it is likely to take place mainly in the Bekaa Valley, where most of
the Shiite militia's forces are concentrated, and not in south Lebanon, where
UNIFIL and Lebanese army forces are deployed.
The Asharq Al-Awsat report claimed that following the Second Lebanon War and the
implementation of UN Resolution 1701, which has restricted the movement of
Hizbullah terrorists in the area south of the Litani River, the group began
transferring some of its forces and weaponry to the area north of the river and
to the Bekaa Valley.
Modeling Terrorist Group Behavior: Hamas &
Hezbollah
The Terror Work
In my day job at the University of Maryland’s Laboratory for Computational
Cultural Dynamics I work with a team of computer scientists and socials
scientists to build models of terrorist group behavior. As the in-house
TerrorWonk my role is to “interpret” the results and see if they yield any
useful insights. I’ve co-authored papers on both Hezbollah and Hamas ( only the
abstract is posted online).
The models use a system called SOMA (Stochastic Opponent Modeling Agents) that
calculates probabilities of a group acting in a given way in a given situation.
Obviously, we hope that our models can achieve a high level of prediction
accuracy. But, regardless they can often reveal facets of an organization’s
behavior that were not previously evident. Just as military experts say, “Plans
are nothing, planning is everything,” I heard one speaker at a conference say,
“All models are wrong, but some are useful.”
Following are short summaries of the findings.
Hezbollah: The Model Holds
On hearing the news that rockets had been fired from Lebanon into Israel
yesterday morning, I was surprised as the single clearest rule about Hezbollah
behavior was that they do not like to target Israeli civilians during election
years – and Lebanon has parliamentary elections coming up in April. Hezbollah
even kept their rocket attacks down for 1998’s local elections. It turns out the
model held, Hezbollah quickly distanced itself from the rocket launch and did
not reply to Israeli counter-fire.
Extrapolating, this trend indicates how highly Hezbollah values its legal and
political standing in Lebanon and its recognition that this standing is damaged
when it is held responsible for provoking Israeli strikes. This provides a
working explanation as to why Hezbollah had not renewed hostilities with Israel
in the past few years – Lebanon’s presidential selection crisis, while not
exactly an election, had some similar dynamics.
Beyond some utility for predicting (on an annual basis) when Hezbollah might
launch rocket strikes, it provides real insight into Hezbollah and even a
possible counter-strategy. While Hamas’ rhetoric remains stridently anti-Israel,
the group is pressed by its need to satisfy its domestic constituency, the
Lebanese Shia, who are a bit tired of being the Muslim world’s spearhead against
Israel.
Military efforts against Hezbollah have not been effective, but these findings
raise two related questions: how popular is Hezbollah really among its
constituents and could political efforts against Hezbollah be successful at
marginalizing them. It is worth noting that Hezbollah receives something like
$100 million annually from Iran and the Lebanese Shia population is only about
1.5 million people, so these resources would buy a great deal of influence.
Other Lebanese Shia groups do not possess comparable resources.
Hamas: Anything but Resistance is Futile
The results of our Hamas model were very different. Strategic decisions to
reduce violence were not in evidence. The key driver appeared to be capability.
First, the likelihood of suicide bombings (the data set does not include rocket
attacks) increased after Hamas came into contact with Hezbollah in 1993, and
received training in suicide terror. The other factor, which increased the
likelihood of suicide attacks was Hamas’ provision of social services (which
would seem counter-intuitive – but as Matt Levitt shows, the social services
infrastructure is also a critical part of the terror network.)
Interestingly, when Hamas was participating in the Palestinian democratic
process they were also very likely to carry out suicide attacks on Israel.
However, the sample size was relatively small and capability seemed like a
likelier explanation.
Perhaps the most interesting finding was that certain attacks, such as
kidnappings and property attacks on Palestinians, tracked with internal
Palestinian conflict. Although it occurred after the data was collected, the
kidnapping of Gilad Shalit occurred during the Hamas-Fatah civil war. Another
round of Hamas-Fatah fighting is likely in the West Bank, so more of these kinds
of actions should be expected.
It could be argued that the 2006 war in Lebanon was a relative success –
Hezbollah has kept that border quiet since. The likelihood of a similar modus
vivendi with Hamas is Gaza seems less likely based on the model and also based
on Hamas rhetoric. In an interview given just days before Hamas began launching
rockets the deputy chief of Hamas’ Damascus wing stated:
[Your] question implies that the Tahdiah [truce] is a central issue behind [our]
decisions, consultations, and mediation attempts. However, the opposite is true…
[for us,] resistance is the main [element] in the relations between the
Palestinian people and the Zionist occupation.
Reducing Hamas’ desire to commit violence does not seem possible, it is
essential that Israeli strategy reduce their capability. In that regard, cutting
the Hamas supply lines of the tunnels between Gaza and Egypt (and attacking the
broader smuggling network) is critical.
Posted by Aaron Mannes at 1:43 PM
Will We Be Able to Bring Peace
to Gaza this Time?
By Walid Phares
Terror Expert/ FOX News Contributor
January 9th, 2009
It may be too early to discuss both a comprehensive solution for the future of a
Palestinian state and to anticipate an end to the global War on Terror at the
same time but here goes. In any discussion of peace in the Middle East it’s
important to remember the intentions of the Iranian and Syrian regimes and their
proxy, Hezbollah when we think about saving the civilian population of Gaza from
war, shielding the Israeli populations from rockets and avoiding an escalation
of violence that could engulf the entire region. The Iranian and Syrian regimes
and their ally Hezbollah will always oppose the peace process and try to sink
it.
In this case, the United Nations has a duty to seize Gaza and manage its peace
until an internationally recognized and responsible Palestinian state rises
again in that province.
So is there a plan to bring peace to the southern shores of the Levant? In an
interview with Al Jazeera, Israeli President Shimon Peres said his country will
stop military operations when the strikes by Hamas and its allies will come to
an end. Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas said his Palestinian Authority (PA)
is ready to assume responsibility for the sake of his people. Egyptian President
Hosni Mubarak and Jordan’s King Abdullah said their governments are ready to
solve the crisis in Gaza if the PA is part of it. The United States, the
European Union and the United Nations all affirmed that everything has to be
done to end the war in Gaza. Excellent.
If all the players listed above are ready to stop the violence, end the war and
save Palestinian and Israeli civilians from bloodshed, then the plan seems to be
clear: demilitarization and internationalization of Gaza.
Establishing a fully-fledged U.N. sponsored and managed security system in the
enclave has precedents across the planet: Bosnia, Kosovo, East Timor, and to
some extent in Lebanon and possibly in the near future, Darfur.
When an area slips under the control of a militia which is not bound by a peace
treaty, or operating under international law, and when a population comes under
fire from any party because of the military actions of such a militia, and until
a recognizable and recognized sovereign state becomes responsible for such an
enclave, the U.N. Security Council must step in and apply Chapter 7 of the
charter, that is to bring peace to civilian populations.
In this case, the United Nations has a duty to seize Gaza and manage its peace
until an internationally recognized and responsible Palestinian state rises
again in that province. How will this be accomplished?
1. The Security Council meets and declares Gaza as an area under U.N. emergency
management and vote, under Chapter 7, for a strong multinational force (MNF) to
enter the enclave in coordination with Israel and the Palestinian Authority.
2. The MNF should not include forces whose governments are in a state of war
with Israel or with the Palestinian Authority and must have diplomatic relations
with both, for the purpose of peace building.
3. The MNF proceeds with the disarming of Hamas and all other militias first.
Gaza should be demilitarized fully. Israeli forces would withdraw to the lines
of demarcation fully.
4. The MNF would reestablish police centers and remit them to a reformed and
transparent PA.
5. The MNF would protect the civilian population, in coordination with the PA
units.
6. The Arab League and the Organization of the Islamic Conference would provide
all needed expenses for the MNF and the PA security forces. A consortium of oil
producing governments from the Organization of Islamic Countries (OIC) would
grant Gaza’s U.N. sponsored local administration $10 billion or so to end the
economic crisis, fund new schools, hospitals and basic infrastructure.
7. The Arab League would commit to grant Gaza residents visas to visit all Arab
countries and work permits if they wish so.
8. Israel commits to allow Gaza workers to travel to the West Bank and vice
versa.
9. The final security and economic arrangements would be integrated in the final
status negotiations between the PA and Israel.
10. The PA and Israel would resume their direct negotiations for a peace
settlement.
This 10-point plan can, first and foremost, bring peace and security to the
Palestinian population in Gaza, the Israeli civilians in the surrounding areas,
and also engage the responsibility of the United Nations, the European Union,
the Arab League and the OIC in peace making.
Evidently, such a plan will never see the light of day as long as any party to
the conflict thinks they can only count on a military solution — and
particularly as long as Hamas is instructed by Tehran and Damascus to sink the
peace process. Sadly as long as democracy is not on the rise in Iran and Syria
we cannot predict the end of the War on Terror.
**Dr. Walid Phares is the coordinator of the Trans-Atlantic Legislative Group on
Counter-Terrorism based in Washington D.C. and Brussels and the director of the
Future Terrorism Project at the Foundation for the Defense of Democracies as
well as a visiting scholar at the European Foundation for Democracy.